News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Guy Kawasaki: What I learned from Steve Jobs by vertr on Sunday October 09, 2011 @12:39AM (#3089677)
This is a repost. I once respected Kawasaki, however he has turned into a huge social media spammer and baiter.
Re:Guy Kawasaki: What I learned from Steve Jobs by SODaniel on Sunday October 09, 2011 @01:32AM (#3089759)
Guy is a very insightful person, fallen victim to the 'The more people that hear me, the more I matter' theorem.
Re:Guy Kawasaki: What I learned from Steve Jobs by slardat01 on Sunday October 09, 2011 @05:58AM (#3090142)
Can you give a little background for someone who's not as familiar with GK?
[deleted]
Re:Guy Kawasaki: What I learned from Steve Jobs by SODaniel on Sunday October 09, 2011 @02:49AM (#3089873)
How can it not matter. Once a person that wrote from the heart about matter concerning maybe a few, maybe very few, once fallen victim to his own greatness that person will seek out subjects that appeal to the masses no matter the depth of his own insight.

I think it matters deeply.

Re:Guy Kawasaki: What I learned from Steve Jobs by palish on Sunday October 09, 2011 @02:59AM (#3089890)
Mm... Good point.

Is that happening here, you think?

I tend to play Devil's advocate; and right now, people are demonizing Guy. But if he's genuinely full of fluff, then it'd be justified.

Re:Guy Kawasaki: What I learned from Steve Jobs by vertr on Sunday October 09, 2011 @02:35AM (#3089853)
Sounds like an appeal to authority to me.
[deleted]
Re:Guy Kawasaki: What I learned from Steve Jobs by vertr on Sunday October 09, 2011 @03:05AM (#3089898)
I'm talking about your comment: "He was right back then, and he's still right today. Not many people can claim that."

There is no argument there other than, 'he's right because he's right.'

[deleted]
Re:Guy Kawasaki: What I learned from Steve Jobs by rumpelstiltskin on Sunday October 09, 2011 @03:25AM (#3089920)
He's not saying Guy is wrong. He's saying you're gonna have to come up with a more cogent argument than "He was right back then, and he's still right today". Basically, the burden of proof is on you since you made the original claim.
Re:Guy Kawasaki: What I learned from Steve Jobs by palish on Sunday October 09, 2011 @03:27AM (#3089922)
Kay, you win.
Re:Guy Kawasaki: What I learned from Steve Jobs by Goladus on Sunday October 09, 2011 @09:51AM (#3090444)
The first post was killed for some unknown reason. Are Kawasaki articles banned from Hacker News?

Also, the ad hominem seems out of place. Is he wrong or uninteresting in this case?

Re:Guy Kawasaki: What I learned from Steve Jobs by mhartl on Sunday October 09, 2011 @01:32PM (#3090841)
I think the first post may have been deleted because it had "[good!]" in the title and got flagged. It would have been easier to remove the "[good!]", but it's likely that it got killed automatically before an admin could edit it.
Re:Guy Kawasaki: What I learned from Steve Jobs by chl on Sunday October 09, 2011 @12:59PM (#3090769)
Is there a way to find out whether a story was killed (besides noticing a sudden drop in the ranking)?
Re:Guy Kawasaki: What I learned from Steve Jobs by Goladus on Sunday October 09, 2011 @01:30PM (#3090833)
In this case, the only way I know is that I had the comments page of the old thread loaded. When I refreshed the page, [dead] appeared in the title and replying was disabled. Now, I'm unable to find it, so I'm not sure, and the comments that were there are not here.
Re:Guy Kawasaki: What I learned from Steve Jobs by chl on Sunday October 09, 2011 @01:43PM (#3090865)
Ah! HN doesn't display [dead] when you're the submitter of the story. Now I only wonder _why_ it was killed ...

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3088810

Re:Guy Kawasaki: What I learned from Steve Jobs by vertr on Sunday October 09, 2011 @12:05PM (#3090669)
It would be ad hominem if I were trying to prove the claims of this article incorrect by critiquing him personally, but I clearly wasn't trying to disprove the claims of the article.

Citing wikipedia: "Gratuitous verbal abuse or "name-calling" itself is not an ad hominem or a logical fallacy.[8][13][14][15][16] In order to become a fallacy, the insult would need to be given as a reason for believing some conclusion. An example would be, "X is idiotically ignorant [of politics], so why should we listen to him now?""

Also, "Is he wrong or uninteresting in this case?" is a false dilemma.

Re:Guy Kawasaki: What I learned from Steve Jobs by Goladus on Sunday October 09, 2011 @01:31PM (#3090839)
You are correct. Absent any attempt to address points actually made, it cannot be ad hominem.