I think it matters deeply.
Is that happening here, you think?
I tend to play Devil's advocate; and right now, people are demonizing Guy. But if he's genuinely full of fluff, then it'd be justified.
There is no argument there other than, 'he's right because he's right.'
Also, the ad hominem seems out of place. Is he wrong or uninteresting in this case?
Citing wikipedia: "Gratuitous verbal abuse or "name-calling" itself is not an ad hominem or a logical fallacy.[8][13][14][15][16] In order to become a fallacy, the insult would need to be given as a reason for believing some conclusion. An example would be, "X is idiotically ignorant [of politics], so why should we listen to him now?""
Also, "Is he wrong or uninteresting in this case?" is a false dilemma.