Re:Guy Kawasaki: What I learned from Steve Jobs
by mhartl on Sunday October 09, 2011 @01:32PM
(#3090841)
I think the first post may have been deleted because it had "[good!]" in the title and got flagged. It would have been easier to remove the "[good!]", but it's likely that it got killed automatically before an admin could edit it.
Re:Guy Kawasaki: What I learned from Steve Jobs
by chl on Sunday October 09, 2011 @12:59PM
(#3090769)
Is there a way to find out whether a story was killed (besides noticing a sudden drop in the ranking)?
Re:Guy Kawasaki: What I learned from Steve Jobs
by Goladus on Sunday October 09, 2011 @01:30PM
(#3090833)
In this case, the only way I know is that I had the comments page of the old thread loaded. When I refreshed the page, [dead] appeared in the title and replying was disabled. Now, I'm unable to find it, so I'm not sure, and the comments that were there are not here.
Re:Guy Kawasaki: What I learned from Steve Jobs
by chl on Sunday October 09, 2011 @01:43PM
(#3090865)
Ah! HN doesn't display [dead] when you're the submitter of the story. Now I only wonder _why_ it was killed ...
Re:Guy Kawasaki: What I learned from Steve Jobs
by vertr on Sunday October 09, 2011 @12:05PM
(#3090669)
It would be ad hominem if I were trying to prove the claims of this article incorrect by critiquing him personally, but I clearly wasn't trying to disprove the claims of the article.
Citing wikipedia: "Gratuitous verbal abuse or "name-calling" itself is not an ad hominem or a logical fallacy.[8][13][14][15][16] In order to become a fallacy, the insult would need to be given as a reason for believing some conclusion. An example would be, "X is idiotically ignorant [of politics], so why should we listen to him now?""
Also, "Is he wrong or uninteresting in this case?" is a false dilemma.
Also, the ad hominem seems out of place. Is he wrong or uninteresting in this case?