News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: I gamified a habit tracker to fight procrastination by medimikka on Saturday April 02, 2022 @07:00AM (#30887269)
Here's a habit I have gotten into: not paying $9/month for someone's code, in perpetuity, if the data are locked behind that payment.

And, for all that is holy, please stop trying to convince me to pay by using lines like "for less than two cups of coffee." Where I come from, that's as much as a family of four has for dinner, many days. It's what 85% of the world and 65% of the US have per day for non-mandatory spending. It's pretty damn privileged to worry about gamifying habit tracking and justifying it with $4.50 coffees.

Re:Show HN: I gamified a habit tracker to fight procrastination by marclou on Saturday April 02, 2022 @07:21AM (#30887360)
You can choose to pay for the game after the free trial is over but the Habit Tracker is (and will always be) 100% free.

Thanks for your feedback :)

Re:Show HN: I gamified a habit tracker to fight procrastination by jeanlucas on Saturday April 02, 2022 @09:26AM (#30888091)
Ah, that is unclear. Looks like you have only 7 days to decide to pay.
Re:Show HN: I gamified a habit tracker to fight procrastination by marclou on Sunday April 03, 2022 @03:45AM (#30895200)
Did you think you would have to pay to use the Habit Tracker after 7 days?
Re:Show HN: I gamified a habit tracker to fight procrastination by toshk on Saturday April 02, 2022 @09:10AM (#30887981)
Looks like a great product!!! Well done.
Re:Show HN: I gamified a habit tracker to fight procrastination by marclou on Sunday April 03, 2022 @03:44AM (#30895196)
Thanks, it means a lot :)
Re:Show HN: I gamified a habit tracker to fight procrastination by maps7 on Saturday April 02, 2022 @11:42AM (#30889053)
Well then I have a great solution for you: don't pay for it. You're not in the market for this app. It's akin to crying because you can't afford an expensive car.
Re:Show HN: I gamified a habit tracker to fight procrastination by JanSt on Saturday April 02, 2022 @07:23AM (#30887370)
Do you offer your work for free? It‘s a fair comparison for EU+US market in my eyes.

For EU customers data export has to be possible

Re:Show HN: I gamified a habit tracker to fight procrastination by number6 on Saturday April 02, 2022 @07:38AM (#30887442)
Yes, thus this advise is free: And no one should spend 4.50 on coffee. It's a bad habit - spending it on absolving oneself from procrastination is even worse. Better spend $10 on "Getting things done" and reread it every month or so.
Re:Show HN: I gamified a habit tracker to fight procrastination by ljm on Saturday April 02, 2022 @08:53AM (#30887854)
Different things work for different people and oftentimes the difficult part of habit forming is the accountability piece. If you're great at holding yourself accountable then maybe re-reading Getting Things Done every month will work for you, or you can just change things through sheer willpower. If you need something else to help keep yourself accountable then maybe $9 a month for an app that tries to make it into a game will work, or maybe another subscription would help because the payment makes it feel like you've put more skin in the game. Maybe you can afford $80 an hour for a weekly session with a professional coach!

One thing is for sure, beng judgmental about how people go about improving themselves is a sure-fire way to kill their motivation. To that extent, I don't think your post constitutes good advice and it wouldn't be worth much even if you did charge for it.

Re:Show HN: I gamified a habit tracker to fight procrastination by number6 on Saturday April 02, 2022 @09:52AM (#30888288)
> One thing is for sure, beng judgmental about how people go about improving themselves is a sure-fire way to kill their motivation

Key concept here: motivation. Motivation is not your friend. Motivation is getting you hooked and leaves you cold turkey. Become independent of motivation. Don't allow motivation to be your scapegoat or you master.

Put $9 a month into a jar and do whatever you want with it if you need it as motivation.

> If you're great at holding yourself accountable then maybe re-reading Getting Things Done every month will work for you, or you can just change things through sheer willpower

If you aren't or you don't have a lot of willpower, then you are lost to the grace of your motivation?

My next free advice: work on your willpower and self accountability. You brush your teeth every day, don't you? Why? Because you hold yourself accountabel. You don't need motivation for this, right? To simple an example? Yes, you are right. We all, myself included, fall apart on the big challenge. Why? Because they are challenging - and it is ok. Stand up and fail better. You aren't a quitter - how many hours of Eldenring are on your clock? Isn't it a damn frustrating game? Yes, until you fail better. Sometimes failing better needs time, research and/or training.

Ok if you want to spend the money on ops game, more power to you, as long as it helps you to fail better, I give you that.

To conclude: go cold turkey on motivation, learn to hold yourself accountable, improve on willpower and avoid its drains, be kind to yourself. You will fail in all of the above but you have to fail better everytime, thus be kind to yourself, its hard and its hard for all of us. Even when you're thinking it's easy for somebody else, it's not he is just doing it longer.

Thanks for reading my blogpost.

Re:Show HN: I gamified a habit tracker to fight procrastination by ljm on Saturday April 02, 2022 @10:05AM (#30888378)
This is a pretty remarkable satire of your typical shelf help book, I give you that.
Re:Show HN: I gamified a habit tracker to fight procrastination by number6 on Saturday April 02, 2022 @10:20AM (#30888479)
Thanks, not sure if I got a whole book in me, but if I am on par maybe I should charge
Re:Show HN: I gamified a habit tracker to fight procrastination by alar44 on Saturday April 02, 2022 @11:10AM (#30888798)
I'm going to buy an extra coffee today just for you.
Re:Show HN: I gamified a habit tracker to fight procrastination by number6 on Sunday April 03, 2022 @09:15AM (#30896660)
Was it worth it?
Re:Show HN: I gamified a habit tracker to fight procrastination by alar44 on Sunday April 03, 2022 @05:53PM (#30901089)
Yes as it takes me approximately 5 minutes to earn that money.
Re:Show HN: I gamified a habit tracker to fight procrastination by number6 on Monday April 04, 2022 @01:58PM (#30909865)
5 Minutes? That's quite quick. It sure seems like you are proud of you ability to earn money this fast.
Re:Show HN: I gamified a habit tracker to fight procrastination by riedel on Saturday April 02, 2022 @08:20AM (#30887668)
And for Italians it should rather cost 2EUR/months jsut with smaller font size, for Germans it would rather be 6EUR , however you will need to accept cash.
Re:Show HN: I gamified a habit tracker to fight procrastination by ge96 on Saturday April 02, 2022 @11:02AM (#30888750)
There is this site I found a while back, wip.chat it's like a social-media/shared to-do list but you have to pay $20/mo to use it. Maybe there's mechanics on dropping money on something that makes you stick to it. I did not sign up for wip ha.
Re:Show HN: I gamified a habit tracker to fight procrastination by marckohlbrugge on Monday April 04, 2022 @03:50AM (#30904246)
Maker of WIP here. Yes, many members note that having to pay $20 motivates them to be more consistent in using the tool which in turn helps them be consistently productive.

It also helps pay my bills so I continue improving the service :)

Re:Show HN: I gamified a habit tracker to fight procrastination by collegeburner on Saturday April 02, 2022 @10:05AM (#30888381)
I guess he is probably targeting America and Europe where people have disposable income then. Nothing wrong with that. And there's a free tier.
Re:Show HN: I gamified a habit tracker to fight procrastination by marclou on Sunday April 03, 2022 @03:48AM (#30895214)
I'm going to copy your message and paste it everywhere - it summarizes it pretty well^^
[dead]
Re:Show HN: I gamified a habit tracker to fight procrastination by katet on Saturday April 02, 2022 @11:11AM (#30888802)
Wow, I'm impressed how grumpy one can seem in a few short sentences. Take an upvote for that alone.

GP has a certain - admittedly orthogonal - point. At what point does "just two coffees per month" translate into "too many coffees traded for services"?

If it's relevant, a fairly high-end black coffee made from medium-roasted in-house coffee beans - which I strongly enjoy - costs me $1.70 in my local economy.

So this costs me 5x coffees, or a work-week of coffee. And I'm a pretty well-paid foreigner living in a strange land.

If I were to take a charitable reading of the GP - with no expertise in economics on my side - I'd say they were pointing out that you are potentially losing a 65+% of your market for whom $9 is not "a couple of coffees".

That's not an indictment - maybe you don't care! Maybe 100x customers @ $9 = $900/month and the service pays for itself.

I am a big fan of what I think is Purchasing Power Parity (PPP) / Pay What You Can (PWYC), even though I see it pretty rarely.

I guess it depends on whether you want to provide your product/service to as many people it can benefit at once, versus the minimum number of people who can support your costs with a profit.

Neither position is inherently "wrong"/"privileged", they just seem to have different incentives and/or target markets.

The voice of a potential target market that is being excluded seems valuable to me - even if the revenue increase might be negligible per-user, perhaps it's worth considering the volume of potential users in that market :shrug:

(To re-iterate that I'm trying not to pick a side here: maybe it's not - maybe the business model is to target affluent consumers. That doesn't make criticism of the exclusionary nature of this approach "privileged", however, in my view. YMMV)

(Edit: minor emphasis)

Re:Show HN: I gamified a habit tracker to fight procrastination by aerosmile on Saturday April 02, 2022 @01:35PM (#30890021)
If I'll be accused of being grumpy for calling out some couch quarterback for bringing irrelevant arguments to squash down some developer's hopes and dreams, then so be it. You have to be really full of yourself to criticize someone's launch on HN so harshly. This community is famous for sharing kind feedback, with a few notable exceptions that now live in infamy (eg: Dropbox). A good question to ask yourself would be - "how did my Show HN post compare to this one?" If you haven't made one yet, then be extra kind and humble.
Re:Show HN: I gamified a habit tracker to fight procrastination by turtlebits on Saturday April 02, 2022 @12:47PM (#30889605)
This is akin to having a hissy fit over marketing speak. It's like seeing a red car in a commercial but don't like red cars. Doesn't mean the product isn't targeting you. Just ignore it.
Re:Show HN: I gamified a habit tracker to fight procrastination by hall0ween on Saturday April 02, 2022 @10:35AM (#30888595)
I respectfully disagree as I found the comment (1) insightful that upon terminating a subscription the data is no longer accessible, (2) that $9/month could be seen as a lot to many people [honestly did not cross my mind, I guess that’s a priviledge of mine] - it’s the same argument as “$9/mo is too expensive for me” using different words and (3) it did not come off as overly negative, especially compared to some comment sections on controversial topics.

> uses sloppy reasoning, and tells us a lot more about yourself than about the topic you’re commenting on.

An example of being overly negative in one’s comments.

Re:Show HN: I gamified a habit tracker to fight procrastination by rosndo on Saturday April 02, 2022 @11:59AM (#30889171)
> (1) insightful that upon terminating a subscription the data is no longer accessible

This doesn’t seem to be true.

> (2) that $9/month could be seen as a lot to many people

This is a fairly worthless piece of information in this context. Do we really need a “check your privilege!” comment every time we discuss a product?

> (3) it did not come off as overly negative, especially compared to some comment sections on controversial topics

Complaining about privilege in this context seems overly negative.