> Although Bateman's principle served as a cornerstone for the study of sexual selection for many decades, it has recently been subject to criticism. Attempts to reproduce Bateman's experiments in 2012 and 2013 were unable to support his conclusions. Some scientists have criticized Bateman's experimental and statistical methods, or pointed out conflicting evidence, while others have defended the veracity of the principle and cited evidence in support of it.
Seems like a very convincing conjecture otherwise, though.
I'm having trouble to understand how this can be true. It seems like every human should have equal numbers of male and female ancestors, e.g. by induction on how many generations back you look.
Taking an average human generation time of 25 years, you would theoretically have 2^30 = roughly a billion ancestors 30 generations back, or 750 years ago. But the population of the Earth in 1300 was... maybe 400 million. (e.g. https://www.census.gov/data/tables/time-series/demo/internat... for world population estimates)
And your ancestors in 1300 aren't drawn from the entire population of the world; they're drawn from a tightly restricted subset of that.
And if you think that's ridiculous, imagine how many ancestors you'd have thirty-one generations back!
This is fairly intuitive result when you consider gestation time - imagine a scenario where there are more male than female in a given moment for a given species. At most each female got fertilized once, so the number of distinct male parents is less than or equal to the number of females. If there are more females than males, the you get the same situation (less distinct male parents). This result is simply because a male parent can fertilize multiple females quickly, while gestation period limit the females.
This dynamic has led to sexual selection mostly affecting the males of the species, which means that this is where the competition happens. The move from polygamy to monogamy in human culture has allowed more males to reproduce and reduced this effect (although it still exists, and is significant).
1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bateman%27s_principle
2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reproductive_success#Humans