This is fairly intuitive result when you consider gestation time - imagine a scenario where there are more male than female in a given moment for a given species. At most each female got fertilized once, so the number of distinct male parents is less than or equal to the number of females. If there are more females than males, the you get the same situation (less distinct male parents). This result is simply because a male parent can fertilize multiple females quickly, while gestation period limit the females.
This dynamic has led to sexual selection mostly affecting the males of the species, which means that this is where the competition happens. The move from polygamy to monogamy in human culture has allowed more males to reproduce and reduced this effect (although it still exists, and is significant).
1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bateman%27s_principle
2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reproductive_success#Humans
> Although Bateman's principle served as a cornerstone for the study of sexual selection for many decades, it has recently been subject to criticism. Attempts to reproduce Bateman's experiments in 2012 and 2013 were unable to support his conclusions. Some scientists have criticized Bateman's experimental and statistical methods, or pointed out conflicting evidence, while others have defended the veracity of the principle and cited evidence in support of it.
Seems like a very convincing conjecture otherwise, though.
I'm having trouble to understand how this can be true. It seems like every human should have equal numbers of male and female ancestors, e.g. by induction on how many generations back you look.
Taking an average human generation time of 25 years, you would theoretically have 2^30 = roughly a billion ancestors 30 generations back, or 750 years ago. But the population of the Earth in 1300 was... maybe 400 million. (e.g. https://www.census.gov/data/tables/time-series/demo/internat... for world population estimates)
And your ancestors in 1300 aren't drawn from the entire population of the world; they're drawn from a tightly restricted subset of that.
And if you think that's ridiculous, imagine how many ancestors you'd have thirty-one generations back!
Females are super careful about picking a mate because they spend months making an egg. They have a sunk cost. And females are relatively more caring about young because it is cheaper than making a new egg.
This access control forces males to evolve to be pleasing and provide some proof of quality. And this proof of quality can create more of a sunk cost for the male. They stick around and protect the young because it is easier to do that than find another female, impress them, build a nest etc.
Also, sex is very very obvious in terms of primary sexual characteristics. We have literally evolved to focus on those things. But outside of reproduction it is far less obvious in biology. On an individual level it is better to think of sex as an output rather than an input. Things don't happen because of the sex variables state, rather sexual characteristics are a consequence of other processes.
>Females are super careful about picking a mate because they spend months making an egg.
The prevailing science was that females - assuming we are talking about humans - don’t make eggs rather are born with a finite number that reduces over their life time.
Only in the last couple years has the science begun to be questioned with the possibility that women do in fact make new eggs during adulthood. However, as far as I know that is still an open ended question being studied, whereas you offer some very specific facts about the required energy to produce eggs, which would suggest that in fact studies have not only confirmed women do actually make new eggs during their lifetime but there is further understanding about that process.
Could you link any studies about women producing new eggs “every couple months” and the energy required that you reference?
Humans are social animals with a wide variety of cultural values, in most cultures throughout history it won’t be a viable option for a man to go around impregnating multiple women every year and likely result in becoming a social outcast in civilized societies or outright killed in others.
Most cultures tend to be monogamous, courting and marriage being fairly common and also dowries were and are real thing -where a man pays a cost for each daughter to be married - not to mention co-evolution of societal norms that have also resulted in laws in some societies requiring child support until a child is 18. Whatever the natural biological costs, humans seem to have created different social norms and laws that have there own costs tending to curb the behavior you describe.
The same is true of humans. If a males want their kids to survive to reproductive age then looking after their mum and the kids during infancy is the best strategy. And the best strategy for the mum is to use what power she has to encourage that. That may not be entirely a reflection of biology now, but it certainly was in the past. And it is no accident that humans find certain traits attractive in a mate.
But the difference in cost absolutely does still exist. Single parent households where the mum is left holding the baby are not exactly unusual. And the health burden of carrying a child and birthing is 100% on the women.
Of all things we know and think we know, we still don't know this? That's a miracle.
[0] https://thehighbook.netlify.app/muller's-ratchet (first half)
If there's a evo geneticist around, one thing I'm wondering is whether some of these traits might have evolved as a heck from the male side. E.g., if I have mutations that increase selectivness of the females against everyone but me, passing those mutations would bias later generations to select for my gene line. I'm not sure whether this is feasible or likely, but it's an example of evolutionary benefit without any real benefit if possible
I know many people, male and female, who would be considered prime mating material opting out of having children because they do not want to spend the resources they would have to to raise children.
If I know anything about nature, it's that it's a brute-force optimizer for biological fitness. Every possible combination of traits could feasibly be tested on these scales.
> [...] and there are - or used to be, sadly - enough species for every linear combination of both possibilities.
Extinction is sad, but there's still plenty enough species to make this statement true.
> If I know anything about nature, it's that it's a brute-force optimizer for biological fitness. Every possible combination of traits could feasibly be tested on these scales.
Not quite. Eg there's basically no wheel in nature, despite the structure itself being quite simple. That's mostly because it's hard to evolve in small steps.
Agreed, but V-ATPase is worth mentioning as it has a rotor and is very highly conserved. I guess it all depends on scale.
Fair enough. I do find it interesting that even in plants that have N different sexes, their life cycles are still often dimorphic.
Maybe the most fundamental abstraction really is the difference between a 1 and a 0.
> In plant biology, Vavilovian mimicry (also crop mimicry or weed mimicry[1][a]) is a form of mimicry in plants where a weed evolves to share one or more characteristics with a domesticated plant through generations of artificial selection.[2] It is named after Nikolai Vavilov, a prominent Russian plant geneticist.[2] Selection against the weed may occur by killing a young or adult weed, separating its seeds from those of the crop (winnowing), or both. This has been done manually since Neolithic times, and in more recent years by agricultural machinery.
> Vavilovian mimicry is a good illustration of unintentional selection by humans. Although the human selective agents might be conscious of their impact on the local weed gene pool, such effects go against the goals of those growing crops. Weeders do not want to select for weeds that are increasingly similar to the cultivated plant, yet the only other option is to let the weeds grow and compete with crops for sunlight and nutrients. Similar situations include antibiotic resistance and, also in agricultural crops, herbicide resistance. Having acquired many desirable qualities by being subjected to similar selective pressures, Vavilovian mimics may eventually be domesticated themselves. Vavilov called these weeds-become-crops secondary crops.
Nature and nurture. Gattica-level eugenics, at the end of the day, only affect the DNA. And eugenics will never save someone from the adage "Hard times make strong men. Strong men make good times. Good times make weak men. Weak men make hard times."
Eg western militaries don't seem to be worse at fighting than militaries from poor countries?
It works in the other direction as well, especially if competition involves expending many resources on a single female. Only attractive females attract many competitors.
> It’s already applied in business [Founders (competing), investors (curating)] [...]
Wouldn't the even more basic dynamic in business been between company and customers? (And of course also between company and suppliers including workers who supply labour (or investors who supply capital, as you mention)?)
Now a population of mixed male-type and hermaphoditic-type individuals by definition can only skew male-type (in the sense that the average individual over the entire population somewhat prefers fathering over mothering). But each offspring has one male and one female parent; i.e. the population of parents does not skew in either direction. Run the math and you'll find that, counting hermaphodites as 1/2 in each category, there are more offspring per female-type than per male-type: those hermaphodites who prefer mothering are now the sexually fittest individuals in the group. And much like in the case with males above, a genetic preference towards mothering will catch on among the hermaphoditic population and begin skewing a subpopulation ever more female-like.
Eventually the male-type and female-type sexes fully diverge from each other, and the initial population of hermaphodites get out competed by the sexual specialists and fall solely into the fossil record.
Why has biological gendering evolved to lead to this dynamic? Is it to enable one sex to vary wildly evolutionarily to respond to wildly changing conditions, while the other maintains the stability of the species? Is it because of what we’ve seen in human governments where division of power keeps one dominant bad leader from sinking the whole species? We saw GANs lead to tremendous boosts in creativity in machine learning algorithms. What if we apply these two-role algorithms (competing side and curating side) into machine learning and see where it takes us with agent systems for example? It’s already applied in business [Founders (competing), investors (curating)] and education [students and universities].