News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by johnyzee on Monday March 28, 2022 @10:45AM (#30830997)
Just like the banning of Russian TV channels, this is another step towards the same totalitarianism that the West prides itself on being in opposition to. Scary how it happened so fast, and without any public debate.
Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by wklauss on Monday March 28, 2022 @11:11AM (#30831316)
Russian TV channels have not been banned. Two propaganda channels have. Might look like semantics, but it's not. The fact that Russia 1 or NTV have not been banned is important.

In Germany they have very strict laws against the use of extremist symbolism, for pretty obvious reasons. Not only the swastika. The black standard of the islamic state or the hammer and sickle are also covered, for example. There are contexts in which they are allowed, obviously (art, education, research...) but this seems to fall in line with the usual cases.

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by brianwawok on Monday March 28, 2022 @11:00AM (#30831163)
Do you find the current Ukraine a morale grey area? What's the argument? Maybe Ukraine had it coming? They didn't deserve their freedom anyway?
Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by hef19898 on Monday March 28, 2022 @11:21AM (#30831439)
I do and I don't. First, it is an unprovoked invasion of sovereign state. As such it is unlawful, morale bankrupt and totally unacceptable. It is also utterly stupid on more levels than can be possibly covered here.

It is kind of a grey area when it come to the West in general. The West invaded Afganistan, Iraq, Syria, Lybia, intervened in the Balkans. We in the West had Vietnam and Cuba, we had Algeria and all those little known wars in Africa. All of those were framed in ways not to different from what Russia is trying in Ukraine. Now, taking in refugees is seen as a sign of how great we are. When we refugees from other countries and regions in Europe it was called refugee crisis and ended up with people living in shitty camps and illegal push backs (the guy leading FRONTEX organizing those is still in charge despite indisputable proof). Europe is treating Ukrainian refugees way different from non-Ukrainians fleeing from the same war, not to mention those refugees stuck in Belarus. Western intervention in Ukraine is more than justified, once it is over and we have some time the West should do some much needed soul searching so. Not that I think that's gonna happen.

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by contravariant on Monday March 28, 2022 @11:14AM (#30831351)
You can disagree with an opinion while still supporting someone's right to speak it.
Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by scrollaway on Monday March 28, 2022 @11:24AM (#30831489)
In my short life, I've supported the right of many people to say shit I disagree with. Even pretty awful, disgusting shit at that.

How come I'm able to draw the line at "supporting an unjustified genocidal war, the invasion and killing of my neighbours, and the destruction of their homes"?

How come I'm able to see the difference between "freedom of having and speaking opinions that are contrary to the mainstream's", and "freedom to want to murder innocents"?

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by powerapple on Monday March 28, 2022 @11:23AM (#30831461)
I believe the war is engineered by the US, the only country benefits so much from this war, the US actually had intelligence about the war before anyone else, even called for it before it actually happened. So far, US's plan is working, Russia will be a lot weaker and Europe is very dependent on US, a lot money to be made on energy and weapon sales.

Probably US will try to use the same strategy with China if this works well against Russia. That's my personal prediction. Once Russia is weaken, US will move immediately on China.

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by wklauss on Monday March 28, 2022 @01:05PM (#30832771)
How do you explain Putin's speech at the beginning of the conflict, claiming a return to previous imperial Russia borders? Or the fact that a quick celebratory article explaining Russians, Belarusians and Ukranians where united again was published by mistake and then quickly deleted by Russia's main news agency? Is Putin a US agent in this scenario?
Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by powerapple on Monday March 28, 2022 @03:18PM (#30834433)
My mine reasoning is that:

1) on YouTube, there are many talks from American scholars, officials and intelligence talked about Ukraine, and predicted this conflict, even before the invasion, US insists that (although NATO doesn't want Ukraine) Ukraine has right to join NATO. US has trained Ukraine to be the frontline to fight Russia, knowing Russia would take action in response to NATO's plan;

2) US and UK are not worried the war would affect them directly, they are pushing to continue this conflict to bleed Russia economy and military, while other European countries who have a lot to lose want this conflict to end;

3) This war is not really about Russia and Ukraine, it is a war between Russia and US. To US's advantage, it is a proxy war where US does not need to participate directly. I believe US is more than happy to have this war than a direct conflict (which would result casualties and push back by voters);

4) Because this is mainly a US-Russia conflict, only US and Russia can stop this. US has shown no interests of deescalating the situation, instead, US has been using this as an opportunity to criticizing China, taking advantages of the situation. So far, US has not called for negotiation at all.

In response to your question, here is what Putin said:"It is not our plan to occupy the Ukrainian territory." (https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-02-24/full-tran...)

I think Putin's stupid to do this, look at history of war, US's 20 years in Afghanistan, 20 years in Iraq, how can you invade a country? Maybe his plan was to get rid of Zelensky quickly.

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by mindslight on Monday March 28, 2022 @03:45PM (#30834726)
That skips over the major details of Russia choosing to openly invade another sovereign country, and engaging in barbaric all out destruction of civilian targets while doing so.

I agree the West's hot-cold meddling does not paint a rosy picture, and if we were just discussing covert actions in the Donbas/Crimea, your narrative could make sense. But once we're talking about open war, the relativism drops away and the aggressor becomes very clear - many Russian troops are occupying Ukrainian territory, while no Ukrainian troops are occupying Russian territory.

As far as US deescalation - what exactly do you think there is for the US to give? Ukraine's right of free association is not the US's to give away.

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by powerapple on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @01:27AM (#30839068)
I totally agree Putin has to take the responsibility for this action, which is very stupid. In legal terms, definitely Russia bear the responsibility of starting the war. I think this is what the west is best at, always right on legality.

Ukraine is at loss, Russia will be weaker, it is a good strategy for the US, Europe will spend more money (but they are rich). The developing world is going to suffer with the food price and energy prices. Developing world is going to bear the cost of the war and sanctions.

From US the point of view, not deescalation is the best option. You know what US could give? Just tell Ukraine that NATO is not the best option for it, could be behind doors, I am sure US does this all the time. Unfortunately Ukraine was not discouraged, rather encouraged to pursue a dead end.

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by johnyzee on Monday March 28, 2022 @11:45AM (#30831731)
It seems as if you don't even know the Russian side. Which speaks to the effectiveness of the suppression of information and propaganda in the 'free world' which we unironically label ourselves. Ukraine's NATO membership is bound to be viewed as a threat by Russia. Regardless of whether you think this justifies the invasion, it can't simply be written off as 'nazism', a childish oversimplification of the issue.

(And if the above made you think I support Russia, or the war, you might be brainwashed).

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by timeon on Monday March 28, 2022 @12:02PM (#30831937)
> It seems as if you don't even know the Russian side.

Most people know this. But Ukraine was not even able to join NATO because of disputed territories. So in case of Ukraine argument about NATO threat is pretty naive.

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by scrollaway on Monday March 28, 2022 @12:01PM (#30831923)
> if the above made you think I support Russia, or the war, you might be brainwashed

Yeah, well, you say that but you're here continuously defending them, and you're bringing up weak arguments. Upthread you've also said you "read RT daily", and maybe that has something to do with it.

FWIW, I'm extremely familiar with the Russian side of the argument. Not everyone is because not everyone is interested in digging into geopolitical issues that don't concern them directly beyond reading the news over breakfast cereal or vaguely scrolling a couple of retweets. This doesn't imply they're "brainwashed" or that we "suppress information"; I had no trouble at all finding all of Putin's idiotic arguments since 0224.

Of course, you can play right into his hands and "discuss NATO" or some shit, as if there is ANY justification to the war crimes and atrocities being committed every day. Civilians being explicitly targeted, hospitals and shelters being bombed, chemical weapons being used, and so on.

"Yes but you see, NATO" is justifying the unjustifiable.

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by johnyzee on Monday March 28, 2022 @01:31PM (#30833124)
> you say that but ... you "read RT daily"

I really hope you recognize the problem in what you are implying.

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by sofixa on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @09:52AM (#30842523)
> It seems as if you don't even know the Russian side

The Russian side doesn't matter. They're invading in a brutal manner a sovereign country for the interests of an authoritarian leader and his clique. It doesn't matter why he thinks this is the best course of action ( it isn't, whatever he hoped to achieve was unachievable from day 1), he's flat out wrong and doing a morally abhorrent thing. All of the excuses Russia has provided for the invasion are very flimsy at best, but usually outrageous ( like that Ukraine isn't a real country and has no national identity).

Russia has multiple NATO neighbours ( Baltics, Poland). Occupying Ukraine will add a few more ( Hungary, Slovakia, Romania). Even if we take Putin's "geopolitical concerns" at face value, and we shouldn't because Russia has done nothing but lie, it doesn't make sense.

But again, it doesn't matter why the crazy old person is bombing maternity hospitals, the important part is that he is, he deserves all the pushback possible and he should be punished for that.

The comparisons to the Nazis are in the playbook only - delusions of grandeur and nationalism, dismissal of other peoples, X isn't a real country, etc.

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by marcosdumay on Monday March 28, 2022 @11:41AM (#30831680)
Yeah, here it is. Took 15 minutes for that comment about censorship to get an answer equating it with Russia support.

The Internet is fast.

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by mindslight on Monday March 28, 2022 @01:10PM (#30832838)
And yet based on further comments trotting out the NATO canard, the inference was correct. While there are certainly abstract free speech arguments to be made about Germany (and larger Europe), and despite being a proponent of the ideal of frees speech, I'm not particularly eager to advocate for it in the context of Europe during wartime.
Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by marcosdumay on Monday March 28, 2022 @03:07PM (#30834328)
Hum... I'm not sure you meant misrepresent the OP's ideas and painting him as a genocide apologist was the "right thing to do" or that banning the symbol is ok.

And if you meant that banning the symbol is ok, it does not immediately follow that discussion about the censorship (it is still censorship, even if it's ok) should be banned.

Anyway, in a huge thread, there appeared a single answer about NATO. So if you want to go tag something, that answer is a good one.

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by john_moscow on Monday March 28, 2022 @11:20AM (#30831427)
Ukraine is a victim of an aging dictator that lost his marbles. A dictator that accomplished his goals within Russia without any opposition, got bored, and decided to play a rather bloody chess game geopolitically.

That said, it started with Putin gradually eliminating opposition, controlling mainstream media and blocking non-mainstream ones, beating down all organizations that had organized people working together and expressing alternative opinion (religious organizations, trucker unions, heritage funds).

The West is currently about 1-1.5 decades behind. We are silencing fringe voices instead of reasoning with them. We are canceling dissidents instead of tolerating them. We let a handful of people with their own interests decide what is "information" and what is "misinformation". If we let this process continue, it will inevitably follow the Russian curve.

The mechanics here is very simple: once you create a position of power that decides what is right and what is wrong, the person occupying this position will seek more rights and wrongs simply to justify their existence. And others will join that cause for the sake of promotion/influence. Such structures only fall in a larger turmoil (bankruptcy of a company, fall of the government, etc) that inevitably brings a lot of destruction.

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by moistly on Monday March 28, 2022 @01:51PM (#30833389)
I am so tired hearing “we have to listen to fringe voices” because oh my lord so many of those fringe voices are anti-democratic, accelerationists, theists, and/or greedy misanthropes.

Banning “Z” is banning support for a mafioso political system that is not only anti-democracy, but also actively murdering an internationally-recognized democratic nation… again.

Fringe voices need to give their heads a shake and sit this one out.

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by john_moscow on Monday March 28, 2022 @10:39PM (#30838126)
Coincidentally, Russia's history for censorship starts with banning the popular-back-then neo-nazi party[0]. 20 years later, you get a prison sentence for questioning the "special military operation in the Ukraine".

But no, this time is different. I'm so tired listening to the bad guys, let the good guys shut them up... /s

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_National_Unity

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by moistly on Tuesday March 29, 2022 @01:50PM (#30846041)
I repeat: Banning “Z” is banning support for a mafioso political system that is not only anti-democracy, but also actively murdering an internationally-recognized democratic nation… again.

Don’t support the mafia, you goof.

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by scrollaway on Monday March 28, 2022 @11:20AM (#30831416)
And for some extra context, this is the sort of material you see every day on Russian TV nowadays:

https://twitter.com/maria_avdv/status/1506283895771348994

> State Russian TV show in prime time discusses possible nuclear strike on Europe, Russian invasion of Poland and Lithuania and corridor to Kaliningrad, threatens Germany and Baltic states.

Yeah, tell you what, I'm very ok with banning Russian propaganda. There will be plenty of time to worry about slippery slopes if we're actually alive by the end of this.

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by johnyzee on Monday March 28, 2022 @11:40AM (#30831671)
I follow RT daily (gasp!) and that is not true at all. Try it, you might be surprised.
Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by scrollaway on Monday March 28, 2022 @11:44AM (#30831720)
What isn't true? The video I linked you, that was aired on Russian TV prime time, and confirmed by multiple sources? Am I missing something?

And what would I be surprised at exactly? I'm getting a 403 when I load RT because RT banned my country from reading it. I used to read it once in a while FYI, just to get a sense of the types of articles they'd publish.

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by johnyzee on Monday March 28, 2022 @11:55AM (#30831854)
> State Russian TV show in prime time discusses possible nuclear strike on Europe

They might 'discuss' it, as does every news channel. They certainly don't endorse it. It's this kind of spin that passes for reporting.

Do you really not have a problem with your ISP deciding for you that you cannot read rt.com? How is it not 'autocratic'?

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by scrollaway on Monday March 28, 2022 @12:04PM (#30831961)
> How is it not 'autocratic'?

For one thing, if it's my ISP deciding, then it has nothing to do with autocracy because it's a private company doing so?

Second, they haven't.

Third, you're lost - this thread is about two Russian TV channels being banned. The RT thread is elsewhere.

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by iisaev on Monday March 28, 2022 @11:58AM (#30831881)
Yes it is. _If_ NATO joins the war, upgrading it from local conflict to worldwide one.
Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by nh23423fefe on Monday March 28, 2022 @10:58AM (#30831147)
Just asserting similarity isn't convincing at all.
Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by PaulHoule on Monday March 28, 2022 @10:46AM (#30831008)
I dunno.

I've wondered if I can paint a "Z" on somebody's car and then people will trash it. Maybe it happens only in Ukraine.

There's a lot of precedent for this in Germany. A Berliner went to jail circa 2000 for training his dog to make the Hitler salute. Rumor has it that the Nazis persecuted people for the same thing but the opposite reason.

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by soco on Monday March 28, 2022 @11:23AM (#30831472)
I think there would be very easy ways to find out if there were vandals or his own writing and his own convictions. Do we know of any errors or mistrials regarding missatributed nazi symbols which are - by the way - banned since decades in Germany? I don't. So you can draw a Z in the dirt of the neighbor's car if you want to test the idea (and happen to live in Germany, which I don't believe), otherwise your relativization is just what it is: a fallacy only serving one side.
Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by weberer on Monday March 28, 2022 @11:12AM (#30831330)
It happened in Scotland too with Count Dankula.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_Meechan

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by AustinDev on Monday March 28, 2022 @10:56AM (#30831124)
What if his dog was just trying to shake? This is so bizarre.
Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by PaulHoule on Monday March 28, 2022 @11:01AM (#30831172)
That Berliner was known for his Nazi sympathy and he got arrested after he demonstrated the dog's saluting to a cop.
Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by AustinDev on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @10:50AM (#30855983)
Oh, I didn't know that context. That's awful.
Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by lm28469 on Monday March 28, 2022 @11:48AM (#30831767)
Yeah we should be careful, next thing you know they'll ask you to get a license to drive a car and they'll inject you vaccines at birth, imagine that ah, what kind of totalitarian hellscape that would be.

They banned Putin's personal propaganda channels and a hate symbol used by people supporting an actual totalitarian regime who's currently invading a country and slaughtering civilians, don't get confused on who's wrong here.

And don't forget that the US freedom of speech is an anomaly, not the norm, both in term of application and in term of ideals

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by HotHotLava on Monday March 28, 2022 @11:14AM (#30831356)
There isn't really a slope here, this completely in line with earlier applications of the same law. For example the IS flag and various Nazi symbols are also banned. This is part of the tradition of "wehrhafte Demokratie" (defensive democracy) that was established after the bad experiences from the Weimar republic with anti-democratic forces abusing the democratic structures.

Keep in mind that Germany is not the US, and human dignity is actually placed above freedom of speech in the German constitution.

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by manuelabeledo on Monday March 28, 2022 @11:00AM (#30831158)
People tend to forget that we are waging a war - an information war. And the first thing you do when you are at war is denying your opponent of any advantages.

But regardless of current events, this could fit in the paradox of tolerance. Should we tolerate the intolerant, i.e. Russian apologists? History hasn't been very kind with the proponents of absolute freedom of discourse.

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by matheusmoreira on Monday March 28, 2022 @11:24AM (#30831488)
> Should we tolerate the intolerant

Yes. Tolerance is absolute, it must be capable of withstanding anything without compromising. Otherwise it is not tolerance, it is selective intolerance.

A truly tolerant free speech society should be able to tolerate even literal nazi discourse without crumbling. What happens in practice is people get tired of debating, decide they're right and start excluding others.

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by lm28469 on Monday March 28, 2022 @11:51AM (#30831809)
Well that's your definition. I'd recommend reading about the history of Europe and its philosophers, you'd discover many version of freedom, freedom of speech, tolerance, &c.

Contrary to what Americans believe these things aren't written in stone by a Divine hand and are products of a long process

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by matheusmoreira on Monday March 28, 2022 @11:54AM (#30831835)
I'm not american. My country has even more restrictive freedom of speech laws than germany and they were inspired by the european ideas you mentioned. When in doubt, judges in my country will literally cite european law to support their decisions.
Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by manuelabeledo on Monday March 28, 2022 @01:33PM (#30833154)
> A truly tolerant free speech society should be able to tolerate even literal nazi discourse without crumbling. What happens in practice is people get tired of debating, decide they're right and start excluding others.

It’s funny how it looks like you are almost sympathizing with nazis. By definition, nazis seek to exclude and maybe exterminate, everyone they don’t agree with, so tolerating them means giving them the right to preach their methods. That’s pretty much the core of Popper’s paradox of tolerance:

“Unlimited tolerance must lead to the disappearance of tolerance. If we extend unlimited tolerance even to those who are intolerant, if we are not prepared to defend a tolerant society against the onslaught of the intolerant, then the tolerant will be destroyed, and tolerance with them.—In this formulation, I do not imply, for instance, that we should always suppress the utterance of intolerant philosophies; as long as we can counter them by rational argument and keep them in check by public opinion, suppression would certainly be most unwise. But we should claim the right to suppress them if necessary even by force; for it may easily turn out that they are not prepared to meet us on the level of rational argument, but begin by denouncing all argument; they may forbid their followers to listen to rational argument, because it is deceptive, and teach them to answer arguments by the use of their fists or pistols. We should therefore claim, in the name of tolerance, the right not to tolerate the intolerant.”

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by matheusmoreira on Monday March 28, 2022 @05:58PM (#30836133)
> It’s funny how it looks like you are almost sympathizing with nazis.

Not really.

> By definition, nazis seek to exclude and maybe exterminate, everyone they don’t agree with, so tolerating them means giving them the right to preach their methods.

If society can't tolerate their preaching and remain democratic, what does it say about society? About humans and their rationality?

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by manuelabeledo on Monday March 28, 2022 @06:04PM (#30836191)
> If society can't tolerate their preaching and remain democratic, what does it say about society? About humans and their rationality?

You could just look back and see by yourself. We don't need to hypothesise about "what could happen", because it already has. Popper himself based his explanation of the paradox of tolerance in the rise of Nazi Germany.

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by matheusmoreira on Monday March 28, 2022 @07:24PM (#30836824)
So we're supposed to impose truths on everyone whether they like it or not and exclude those who don't accept them? Do you realize that this is not tolerance but authoritarianism?
Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by manuelabeledo on Monday March 28, 2022 @07:52PM (#30836997)
We are supposed to not accept authoritarianism.
Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by x86_64Ubuntu on Monday March 28, 2022 @11:05AM (#30831217)
Nazi symbols have been effectively banned in Germany for decades[1] without the oft referenced slippery slope coming into play.

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strafgesetzbuch_section_86a

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by polski-g on Monday March 28, 2022 @12:49PM (#30832538)
The slippery slope is literally the title of this post: now Z's are banned.
Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by indemnity on Monday March 28, 2022 @02:07PM (#30833590)
Given the fascist war loving nature of Russia today, I don’t see the slippery slope.

Do you know the definition of slippery slope?

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by mindslight on Monday March 28, 2022 @11:11AM (#30831314)
Germany has banned the swastika, a symbol of a past war, for a long time. Why wouldn't this also include banning the zwastika, a symbol of a presently occurring genocide?

Even as a libertarian, it's really hard to take overly simplistic freedom-invoking arguments in good faith when they appear to lack any context.

Re:Using the “Z” symbol could lead to prosecution in two Ger... by shmerl on Monday March 28, 2022 @11:10AM (#30831297)
Yeah, modern Goebbelses wouldn't approve.