The same is said about every innovation or invention ever. If you have knowledge about why it is infeasible, then your references are welcome. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30802349
From https://www.mining-technology.com/projects/zero-carbon-lithi... “A pilot plant to demonstrate DLE from the project became operational in April 2021 while the first battery-quality lithium hydroxide was produced from the pilot operations in September 2021.”. They are doing it and obviously believe it is commercially viable to do so.
From https://geo40.com/geolithium/ “We have successfully recovered lithium from low, moderate and high-grade brine types covering Europe, the Americas and New Zealand at laboratory scale. We will move to pilot stage in 2022.”. I am more sceptical about the economics of this (some government funding, possibly for positive discrimination, and no obvious commercial investors). “Lithium bearing geothermal fluid is allowed contact with Geo40’s proprietary GeoSeive compound. The GeoSieve is then regenerated to release the lithium”, and reused.
> Lithium will be a huge cost even in LFP batteries as you can't take it out.
The figure I have heard is ~5% of the battery cost is related to the cost of Lithium. The cost of the raw Lithium compounds is not a dominant factor in the cost of most Lithium batteries, for example see https://pdf.sciencedirectassets.com/271367/1-s2.0-S037877531... I did some googling to find something recent that could compare the raw costs of materials, but they usually only break it down to the cost of the cathode material rather than individual metal compounds. https://www.crugroup.com/knowledge-and-insights/spotlights/n... imply that Nickel and Cobalt costs dominate currently.
No one is going to want to drive on sodium batteries, which are merely good, rather than good enough. We're talking about the weight of a Tesla with the range of a Leaf, as a best case scenario.
As for lithium, there are absolutely enormous amounts of it in highly available form, in the parts of the world where brine evaporated relatively recently. The Great Basin has a lot of those.
When you say lithium extraction is difficult to do profitably, this is just a way of saying the supply/demand curve yields cheap lithium in 2022.
We're in no danger of supply issues at the right price, no one who wants to buy some lithium is coming up short, and no such future is at all likely in this century.
People said the same about LFP and Sodium is getting pretty close to that on a system level. You have to consider the whole pack and its price.
The reality is that there are literally millions that could run with sodium and be a practical product.
And the extra volume required is actually not that big a problem in many vehicles.
> When you say lithium extraction is difficult to do profitably, this is just a way of saying the supply/demand curve yields cheap lithium in 2022.
No actually lithium is getting more and more expensive and demand is growing at insane rates while getting new mines in production is really hard. So the price will likely continue to go up.
> We're in no danger of supply issues at the right price, no one who wants to buy some lithium is coming up short, and no such future is at all likely in this century.
Price go up until some people that had plans will reconsider those plans.
Do many people care about the weight of their car? I would bet most people couldn’t tell you what their car weighs with any accuracy (me, for one).
People happily drive giant heavy trucks (like an F150) for much shorter distances than the range of a Leaf.
Or weight matters for some other reason? Shipping?
More mass also means collisions are higher energy, so crash and pedestrian safety become an issue at lower speeds.
The tradeoffs have to justify the extra weight, so money saved on batteries has to exceed money spent on stronger frames, etc. I think Tesla is playing at the edges, so it's probably safe to say inefficient (heavier) batteries aren't going to be feasible.
As I pointed out, Sodium could get reasonably to LFP. So just as we moved from NMC to LFP, we will move from LFP to Sodium. That doesn't mean NMC or LFP will go away.
All of the above are needed.
1: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41560-017-0014-y?from=artic...
The host has decades of experience in lithium and has interviews with many of those lithium companies. He is certainty opinionated but he is informed.
On battery in general, and partly on lithium: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCIFn7ONIJHyC-lMnb7Fm_jw/vid...
Many others but information is kind of all over the place.
But I'm not in that industry, more a general interest in batteries.
Email in my profile: https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=simonebrunozzi
Thanks!
If you want to look at realistic lithium extraction in the US, look at Thacker Pass. That is much closer to being an actual reality.
Nobody has yet made Geothermal Brines a reality and nobody has even really managed commercial DLE.
The reality is all lithium in the world today comes from conventional brine project that use natural evaporation or it comes from Spodumene rock. We will scale those things first in order to increase lithium production.
Lithium industry is difficult, its very hard for these operations to be profitable. And the California is specially difficult.
But this is very much a very, very real problem. Lithium will be a huge cost even in LFP batteries as you can't take it out. We already know that not enough new lithium mines are coming online for coming demand. And high oil price made it even worse.
We do actually seriously need to move to other types of battery chemistries as well. The most promising by far is Sodium batteries and CATL (big dog of batteries) is commercializing it. It has far, far less supply issues and it will be dense enough to make standard cars practical.
There are lots of other ideas but the reality is, its absurdly hard to get even a tiny innovation in the cathode into actual cars and takes 5+ years. Doing it with a totally new chemistry is even more difficult.