News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Evaluation of science advice during the Covid-19 pandemic... by deng on Saturday March 26, 2022 @07:16AM (#30810872)
Well, this is a peer reviewed paper, arguing quite coherently that the handling of the pandemic in Sweden did not follow scientific methods, and they have a ton of references to back up that opinion. If you are aware of similar papers arguing against this opinion, please provide links.
Re:Evaluation of science advice during the Covid-19 pandemic... by bjeds on Saturday March 26, 2022 @07:32AM (#30810955)
Expect that this Hacker News thread will be overrun by Swedish patriots who will, with tooth and nail, argue for Swedish exceptionalism and downvote all criticism. War is Peace and all that.

I am ashamed how my country handled this pandemic and I'm ashamed that my fellow citizens are more interested in managing the public image of Sweden rather than learning from obvious mistakes.

I am therefore thankful that Nature published this. It has been debated since early 2020, but the narrative of Swedish exceptionalism is so strong, especially on the Internet, that I wouldn't be surprised if this will tried to be burried.

I have lost friends due to this, not because people have died of Covid but because foreign nationals, who moved to Sweden to work on some of the famous tech companies, have realized how poorly Sweden handled the pandemic. They have now moved to other countries instead.

Re:Evaluation of science advice during the Covid-19 pandemic... by Tade0 on Saturday March 26, 2022 @08:42AM (#30811345)
> the narrative of Swedish exceptionalism is so strong, especially on the Internet, that I wouldn't be surprised if this will tried to be burried.

I always thought this was an American thing, but turns out just about every nation has this to some extent.

Re:Evaluation of science advice during the Covid-19 pandemic... by emj on Saturday March 26, 2022 @10:28AM (#30812092)
I've never met a group of people who did not see themselves as special, this view is common in all countries I've lived in. I wonder if someone has tried to measure it objectively.
Re:Evaluation of science advice during the Covid-19 pandemic... by shalmanese on Saturday March 26, 2022 @04:02PM (#30814870)
> I always thought this was an American thing, but turns out just about every nation has this to some extent.

There's a deep irony in this sentence.

Re:Evaluation of science advice during the Covid-19 pandemic... by robrorcroptrer on Saturday March 26, 2022 @08:51AM (#30811386)
I am a Swede and I think most of my peers are delusional fans of our institutions and leaders. The leaders tries to cover up everything, and holds no accountability. People are such fans of Anders Tegnell - the man who uses an extreme amount of words to say almost nothing, in addition to almost never admitting to failure or being wrong. They go hand in hand with the politicians on this part.
Re:Evaluation of science advice during the Covid-19 pandemic... by emn13 on Saturday March 26, 2022 @10:40AM (#30812225)
I seem to remember that he did publicly admit certain policies were poor in retrospect - a bit of googling e.g. finds this, just months after the start of the pandemic: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-52903717
Re:Evaluation of science advice during the Covid-19 pandemic... by legulere on Saturday March 26, 2022 @05:02PM (#30815344)
It’s a bit like reverse Jantelagen. You're not to think Sweden isn’t better than the rest.
Re:Evaluation of science advice during the Covid-19 pandemic... by gus_massa on Saturday March 26, 2022 @08:55AM (#30811407)
> this is a peer reviewed paper

Note that this paper is published in "Nature Humanities and Social Sciences Communications" journal, not in the plain "Nature" journal that is a totally different journal published by the same editorial. I'd also thrust more a pare published in one of the many journals of Nature that has something about medicine or biology in the title, because the reviewers and editors are more specialized in this subject. https://www.nature.com/siteindex

Re:Evaluation of science advice during the Covid-19 pandemic... by deng on Saturday March 26, 2022 @09:09AM (#30811501)
I didn't say it's plain "Nature", as I'm perfectly aware that a paper of that length and subject would never be published there.

It's still peer reviewed, and I'm still waiting for the links to papers which say that Sweden did an exceptional job.

Re:Evaluation of science advice during the Covid-19 pandemic... by alkonaut on Saturday March 26, 2022 @10:27AM (#30812082)
Science and policy are only weakly related. Especially when it comes to things like acting out of caution (assuming the worst given scientific knowledge) and how to weigh personal freedoms and so on.

The discussion of the science of childrens psychological health for example was curiously absent in countries that argued that science demanded swift lockdowns. Is a life-year in lockdown for a school aged child as “lost” as a year shorter lifespan for an elderly person? Or less? Or more?

These are ethical and political questions more than they are scientific.

These ethical problems and differences in how they are handled are present even absent a pandemic. Who’s given intensive care over a certain age for example is likely very different in the US and Sweden. That’s not because the medical facts differ or doctors in either end act on bad science or in bad faith. Medicine isn’t just science, it’s ethics, politics, economics too.

Re:Evaluation of science advice during the Covid-19 pandemic... by refurb on Saturday March 26, 2022 @08:14AM (#30811194)
Which science? The science that said masks aren’t needed, then needed and any mask will do, then no, clothe masks don’t work, then oh, it should have been N95 masks all along?
Re:Evaluation of science advice during the Covid-19 pandemic... by saiya-jin on Saturday March 26, 2022 @08:23AM (#30811247)
The science remains the same, until we learn new facts and adjust our knowledge. The political pressures and decisions that shaped public decisions and speeches are a different thing, please don't conflate those.
Re:Evaluation of science advice during the Covid-19 pandemic... by funstuff007 on Saturday March 26, 2022 @08:26AM (#30811268)
science, absolute truth, lived experience, and public health policies are often times disjoint sets.
Re:Evaluation of science advice during the Covid-19 pandemic... by geysersam on Saturday March 26, 2022 @08:55AM (#30811411)
Succinct way of putting it
Re:Evaluation of science advice during the Covid-19 pandemic... by LadyCailin on Saturday March 26, 2022 @08:27AM (#30811281)
Yes, that science. The one that looks at available data and reassesses, rather than taking a potentially incorrect stance and sticking with it for no reason other than to save face.
Re:Evaluation of science advice during the Covid-19 pandemic... by yucky on Saturday March 26, 2022 @08:37AM (#30811327)
"The science" never made a reassessment on masks though, we didn't learn anything new about how masks work and how effective cloth vs N95 etc. All of the posturing on masks was political. So "Trust the science" really became "trust our politicians bro".
Re:Evaluation of science advice during the Covid-19 pandemic... by brianshaler on Saturday March 26, 2022 @09:38AM (#30811679)
Sure, there was and is political posturing with regard to pandemic countermeasures.

The reassessments haven't been about learning how masks work but about how a particular virus spreads and the efficacy of various types of masks in various settings between parties of varying contagion levels. The advice also has to be grounded in practicality given current circumstances (supply constraints, rate of asymptomatic spread among vaccinated populations, etc)

Re:Evaluation of science advice during the Covid-19 pandemic... by refurb on Saturday March 26, 2022 @08:31AM (#30811300)
False. Science may be consistent, but governments don’t enact science they enact policy that involves trade offs and risk taking.

That’s why “you don’t need a mask” was just a lie to conserve masks for healthcare workers.

Is that following the science?

Re:Evaluation of science advice during the Covid-19 pandemic... by geysersam on Saturday March 26, 2022 @09:04AM (#30811474)
I don't think it was a deliberate lie.

Many conventional wisdoms we're overturned during these last couple of years. Saving mask for the health care services might have been a reasonable thing to do 20 years ago. But today with Chinese extreme mass production it is entirely feasible in rich states to equip their populations with sofisticated face masks and test for virus infection with anti-gen tests several times every week.

It's a new world.