News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering questions anonymously

https://www.throwapp.com/

Hello HN community,

For the past year we’ve been working on this disruptive new thing. It’s about people, community, communication and truth.

Throw is the new space for asking and answering questions anonymously. We believe that in today’s world (both online and offline) content in communication exchanges is strongly influenced by the personas, profiles and façades people maintain/upkeep/safeguard socially, ideologically and on relationships.

From the way people post on Instagram the life they want others to believe they have, or the way people behave on thanksgiving with family, or at work, or with friends; on every social setting and interaction to some degree acting and behaving according to that setting and the people they interact with. These dynamics influence the content itself, as people don’t just respond to a question like computers do. What ends up happening is that the responder comes up with the answer by blending the possibly objective answer with feelings, setting, desires, commitments, ideologies, fears, insecurities, etc (social pressure or social agenda).

Something is missing between social media and the traditional Q&A…

Throw addresses this by creating a space free from this social agenda. Thus focusing strictly on the content exchanged and providing a safe, comfortable and unbiased space where people can ask and answer anything freely with no bias, fears or strings attached.

Not only may Throw be used for personal and private questions and answers. But the power of crowdsourcing allows for a great variety of use cases like market research, validation of content and ideas, trivia, and much more. Serious matters and also just for fun…

It’s a query marketplace which means that “throwers” (people who ask questions) pay a fee proportional to the answers they need and in turn “catchers” (who catch them and respond) get compensated. This way we guarantee every user gets as many responses as he/she needs.

As for dealing with anonymity, we have built a sophisticated moderation protocol to neutralize and quickly ban people that contribute negatively as it is a priority people feel safe and comfortable in this community.

We have worked very hard to create a delightful product and are currently very close to rolling out our app to the market.

If this is something that may be of your interest or you’d like to be one of the first to test it out, you may keep an eye for our launch and other news by subscribing to our waitlist. https://www.throwapp.com

Also, if you have questions there is additional information in the FAQs section on our web page that could be of help.

If you still haven't looked at our explainer video I encourage you to see it as it's quite fun and describes pretty well what we are doing. https://youtu.be/3f9RcVVpkNA

Finally, we really appreciate any feedback we can get (of any kind). So if there's anything you like, don't like, or any other thought about Throw, we'd love to hear about it! You may post a comment below or through the contact section on the web page.

Be curious and dare to know!

Thank you!

( 47 comments | 16 points | on HN )
Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by cpfohl on Friday March 25, 2022 @10:52AM (#30802874)
Hey there, this is actually feedback on your domain name. It probably wasn't cheap, but it doesn't pass my '10 year old' test.

"The 10 year old test" is an imaginary test where I inhabit the mind of a 10 year old for a little bit trying to find inappropriate or gross jokes to make about the name. In your case "Throw App" and "Throw Up" are extremely similar. Even more so if you have certain non-native accents.

I think the name 'Throw' is totally fine, I'd just avoid using it next to 'app' if I were you.

Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by luisamodio on Friday March 25, 2022 @11:07AM (#30803060)
Thanks for the thoughtful and useful feedback!

You’re right and we probably will update the domain down the road.

Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by auroralimon on Friday March 25, 2022 @10:53AM (#30802885)
The several times I have seen this tried, it usually devolves down to a bunch school students asking sex questions and other students posting outrageous (and often incorrect and harmful) answers. Best of luck, though.
Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by psyc on Friday March 25, 2022 @11:14AM (#30803150)
And half of that will be fetishists baiting others into furnishing wank material. And half of the responses are really other fetishists posing so the whole thing is really a role-play that superficially looks like Q and A.
Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by luisamodio on Friday March 25, 2022 @11:14AM (#30803144)
Thanks for the feedback!

This is probably the biggest challenge we faced we decided to create Throw.

We have addressed the problem face on and believe we have developed a robust solution to outrun this kind of behaviors.

Our moderation (filtering out and reward) algorithm very quickly promotes or demotes users based on the quality of their content.

And it is the community itself (with supervision of our team) that drive the tone.

Also thanks for the wishes!

Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by dymk on Friday March 25, 2022 @11:20AM (#30803216)
What’s the rubric being used to assess quality?
Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by luisamodio on Friday March 25, 2022 @12:03PM (#30803830)
Fundamentally, if the response was useful or not to the person who asked it.

The platform is prepared positive and negative tags that strongly influence each user’s score (sort of like karma).

So what we value mostly is the effort taken to satisfy and meet the query’s needs.

As for trash and offensive content you’d simply hit the report button, an investigation will immediately take course, you’ll be reimbursed that answer and the offender drastically punished if not permanently banned as there is minimal tolerance for this.

Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by dazamarquez on Friday March 25, 2022 @11:08AM (#30803080)
1) why would I use this site instead of Reddit/4chan/StackExchange/Quora/any specialized Q&A board, that are free? 2) How do I make sure the answers I paid for are correct and/or worth my bucks? 3) How is this going to deal with plagiarism? Once you put money into the equation, what prevents a random answerer from copy-pasting swathes of text from wikipedia or one of the aforementioned websites?
Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by luisamodio on Friday March 25, 2022 @11:57AM (#30803716)
Hi!

1) The main differences (both for the person that’s asking and the person that’s answering) are:

- Agile & guaranteed number of responses (no need to be a HOT question/topic) - Compensation model - Flexible media types (ask and answer in text, audio (voice), video, poll, and more. - Full anonymity (no social bias and/or no profile/façade to upkeep) - Robust moderation protocol - Gamified and engaging user experience - Target a profiled audience

As for incentives if you’re answering (there’s 3):

- Sake of entertainment and curiosity - To help others - Cash

2) As for unrelated (gibberish/trash) and offensive answers, all you need to do is click an immediately visible “report” button that will trigger an investigation immediately. That answer will be reimbursed and the responder drastically punished if not banned (as tolerance for this is very limited).

3) Plagiarism is not a main area of concern to be honest, in the end if a quote from someone famous or a fragment from Wikipedia are a great answer for someone that’s fine. What mainly drives the score algorithm is how useful the answer was to the person that asked the question, where it came from, not so much.

Thanks so much for asking!

Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by corobo on Friday March 25, 2022 @10:53AM (#30802895)
I think the FAQ is missing a bit of info. Nothing deal-breaker-y, but the biggest questions don't actually get answered!

The ones about how much each answer pays and the minimum threshold, the answers essentially say "you get paid an amount per answer" and "you can pay out above a threshold" without actually saying what the numbers are. It's a little recursive :P

I guess my main question is: Ballpark figures of course, not holding you to a quote, how much per answer? We talking pennies or dollars?

Threshold then comes in to play as (for example) if it's pennies per answer and the payout threshold is $100 it will probably not pay out for anyone but those that figure out how to game the system or get reeeally involved and treat it as a job ala Mechanical Turk

I'm also getting a vague reminder of Aardvark[1] (RIP, cheers Google) if it'd help to see how something similar worked :)

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aardvark_(search_engine)

Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by luisamodio on Friday March 25, 2022 @12:39PM (#30804283)
Good question!

So the way this was designed, is so that the unit (answer) cost is fairly cheap (below the dollar), so that volume is incentivized.

In turn, the payout amount which is a fraction of that per unit cost was calculated to be an attractive enough figure. Such that if you don’t do this ala Mechanical Turk you get some decent extra cash out of it and if you do get very involved you can even make a salary out of it.

However, there is a dynamic algorithm that takes into account several factors primarily consistency on the quality of the answers that directly impacts each users final compensation.

Thus promoting a virtuous cycle of better content.

Thanks so much for asking and hope this makes sense!

Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by corobo on Saturday March 26, 2022 @02:58PM (#30814330)
Thank you for the response

Look forward to seeing your progression! Best of luck! :)

Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by luisamodio on Saturday March 26, 2022 @04:13PM (#30814973)
Thank you for your comments and wishes! :)
Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by benplumley on Friday March 25, 2022 @11:22AM (#30803254)
Thanks for reminding me about Aardvark, I used to use it a lot and haven't really seen anything like it since.
Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by corobo on Saturday March 26, 2022 @03:00PM (#30814348)
I used to make a load of IRC bots back when they shut it down, I wanted to make a replacement for it

I was worried Google would squash my finances forever with a patent lawsuit haha

Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by phailhaus on Friday March 25, 2022 @10:33AM (#30802633)
Is payout to the catchers commensurate with the quality of the answers? What happens to answers that are just wrong? What are some examples of questions that you think throwers would actually pay money to get anonymous answers for, instead of going to Reddit?
Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by luisamodio on Friday March 25, 2022 @12:14PM (#30803950)
Hello!

To your first question, yes! The compensation paid is a dynamic fee determined by the score (karma of a kind) a user has.

There was a previous question on this page asking what determines quality. And fundamentally it is the fulfillment/satisfaction of the needs of the person who asked.

So people who give better answers on a consistent basis will earn more than people who don’t. This creates a virtuous cycle.

As for answers that are either trash or offensive, there is an extremely-viusal “report” button on every answer that if hit immediately triggers an investigation. If found true, you’ll get refunded for that answer and the offender will be drastically punished if not banned as there is minimal tolerance for this.

Finally, some examples are: -Sourcing ideas -Depression, anxiety, and loneliness advise -Love life & relationship advise -Embarrassing situations advise -Parenting advise -Feedback on content before posting on social media (content creators or public figures for example…) -Product / service feedback Market research -Difficult life situation advise -Important decisions advise -Curious questions -Random questions -Sourcing memes or jokes -Trivia

And honestly many more, it’s up to peoples creativity as the platform provides much flexibility.

Hope this helps and thank you so much for asking!

Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by phailhaus on Friday March 25, 2022 @04:58PM (#30806986)
> And fundamentally it is the fulfillment/satisfaction of the needs of the person who asked.

Do you mean that the thrower gets to decide which answers are "quality" and deserve a payout?

> If found true, you’ll get refunded for that answer

This seems to imply that throwers will be automatically charged for any catchers before they've decided it's useful, which sounds like a huge problem.

Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by luisamodio on Friday March 25, 2022 @05:48PM (#30807348)
The thrower gets to asses if the answer was a good one, or a bad one or just mediocre. This has no effect on deserving a payout as long as there was a genuine effort to respond the question. It does however influence the scoring (karma) system with which the catcher is directly compensated.

The general rule is that answers that are subject to refund are answers that fall into 2 categories 1) it’s gibberish/trash/unrelated content (for example someone that repeatedly copy-pastes the same paragraph with no relation to the question hoping to earn money), and 2) offensive content (anywhere from trolling, racism, misogyny, etc).

As for your second claim, yes, you pay regardless if you find it useful (unless of course it’s any of the two categories I previously mentioned).

And the reason for this is because getting a large pool of diverse and unbiased data puts you on a better informed position and may open your eyes to angles you wouldn’t have considered otherwise. Regardless if you dislike them or disagree with them.

You’re not always going to hear what you want to hear…

Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by phailhaus on Sunday March 27, 2022 @08:47PM (#30825750)
If a catcher spams your service with thousands of just-barely-relevant replies, they'll always get paid? Is there any karma level at which the catcher flat out is not paid?
Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by manx on Friday March 25, 2022 @02:22PM (#30805493)
Who does the investigation, e.g. if an answer is offensive?
Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by luisamodio on Friday March 25, 2022 @02:53PM (#30805785)
Simplified, the way this works is the question and the answer get packaged inside a new question that is asked to a number of people just as if it were a normal question with a yes or no poll.

“Is the response to this question offensive?”

(Yes it is offensive / no it is not offensive)

So, in short, a crowdsourced jury!

Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by manx on Friday March 25, 2022 @05:18PM (#30807145)
Great Idea to reuse the q/a system for that! Is there also a payout for those who answer that question? Is it a yes/no question with majority decision?
Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by luisamodio on Friday March 25, 2022 @05:31PM (#30807247)
Yes correct!
Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by Freak_NL on Friday March 25, 2022 @10:59AM (#30802974)
Or if they want anonymous instead of pseudonymous, 4chan?
Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by luisamodio on Sunday March 27, 2022 @12:30AM (#30817722)
100% anonymous. And actually it’s nothing like 4chan.
Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by mtlynch on Friday March 25, 2022 @11:18AM (#30803192)
Looks interesting, but a waitlist signup is off-topic for Show HN[0]:

>Show HN is for something you've made that other people can play with. HN users can try it out, give you feedback, and ask questions in the thread.

>Off topic: blog posts, sign-up pages, newsletters, lists, and other reading material. Those can't be tried out, so can't be Show HNs. Make a regular submission instead.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/showhn.html

Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by manx on Friday March 25, 2022 @02:20PM (#30805474)
Maybe we need a new section "Wait HN". Or are there better places to post these?
Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by nindalf on Friday March 25, 2022 @11:24AM (#30803284)
Dang pls.
Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by encryptluks2 on Friday March 25, 2022 @10:53AM (#30802894)
I think it is hilarious that it says you ask questions anonymously and then front and center, they want your email address to join their waitlist. No thanks, clearly not meant to be anonymous after all. Besides, wouldn't it be better to showcase something once it is ready than asking for an email to join a waitlist? Reminds me of truth.social.
Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by luisamodio on Friday March 25, 2022 @11:29AM (#30803343)
Email is only for launch purposes.

In the end, nor email nor any other attribute that ties to your identity will be shown or used within the platform.

It’s fair to be skeptical.

Maybe we’ll change your opinion when you see it in action.

Thanks for commenting still.

Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by manx on Friday March 25, 2022 @10:30AM (#30802602)
This kind of idea is actually a great use case vor virtual currencies and a market, because the given AND received value can come from a human. I once wanted to build something similar for project feedback only, but the core idea is the same.

A potential problem I see with simple question/answer systems like this is, are questions about truth. Paying to get more answers only forms a majority opinion, not truth. Collaboratively working on an argument graph could be useful in this situation.

Did you do anything to prevent sybil attacks in your voting system?

Btw, Show HN is meant for projects you can already try, not just for waiting lists.

I still signed up and want to see how it works :)

Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by luisamodio on Friday March 25, 2022 @11:04AM (#30803024)
Hello!

You do have a point about majority of opinion not necessarily being the truth.

The way we see this is, when someone looks for feedback or needs to make a decision, having a diverse pool of unbiased information increases the chances of having a better understanding of the truth. Thus potentially making a petter decision.

As for Sybil attacks, it will be virtually impossible to influence and target a particular question as each user is not open to choose which question to match. Throw does the thrower/catchers matching using a dynamic algorithm with many variables to determine the best matches. So we are expecting certain users to try to use several accounts to try to go around the system and we’re prepared for that.

I really appreciate your candid feedback and am really hoping you love it once it’s out there!

Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by gyulai on Friday March 25, 2022 @10:44AM (#30802768)
One way I could see this going wrong is if it gets overrun by market researchers. "How much would you pay for a healthy softdrink?" makes for an insanely boring user experience. It would drive away people who could answer more interesting questions in a high-quality fashion. That in turn would drive away anyone wanting to ask a question who isn't a marketer.
Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by luisamodio on Friday March 25, 2022 @11:25AM (#30803297)
Hello!

If that we’re to happen it would be partly true that only product or market people would be interested and it would become a noche platform say “Perksy” which does precisely what you describe.

We do believe it is very unlikely for this to happen as we purposely decided not to launch in a niche or with an audience of this sort.

So yes, there will likely be some marketers that use this for market research but it will be very unlikely they drive the content in the community.

We really appreciate the feedback!

Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by Majestic121 on Friday March 25, 2022 @11:07AM (#30803064)
The graphic style of the website makes it look extremely corporate/soul-less, which is the opposite of what I was expecting from the headline.

If you're targeting market research it might be on purpose, but I know that personally it was an instant turn-off.

Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by luisamodio on Friday March 25, 2022 @11:17AM (#30803179)
We’re not targeting market research in particular, it is just one of the use cases.

Thanks for the feedback! We will surely keep this in mind!

Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by dymk on Friday March 25, 2022 @11:19AM (#30803206)
What kind of questions do you see people asking on this app, such that they’d only post anonymously? How about for answers?
Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by luisamodio on Friday March 25, 2022 @12:18PM (#30804010)
Some examples are:

-Sourcing ideas -Depression, anxiety, and loneliness advise -Love life & relationship advise -Embarrassing situations advise -Parenting advise -Feedback on content before posting on social media (content creators or public figures for example…) -Product / service feedback Market research -Difficult life situation advise -Important decisions advise -Curious questions -Random questions -Sourcing memes or jokes -Trivia

And honestly many more, it’s up to peoples creativity as the platform provides much flexibility.

Hope this helps and thank you so much for asking!

Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by jitl on Friday March 25, 2022 @10:30AM (#30802607)
I tried to sign up and got “Something went wrong submitting the form”
Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by luisamodio on Friday March 25, 2022 @10:47AM (#30802813)
Hello and thank you for your interest! May I ask you on which browser this happened? It is the second time I’ve heard it but the form works well everywhere I test it. I’d love to fix the bug that seems to be on a specific browser… Also, you may try another browser for now and it should work. Thanks again!
Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by jitl on Friday March 25, 2022 @11:50AM (#30803617)
iOS 15.3.1 Safari, iPhone 12 Pro Max. I use typical content blocker settings w/ OneBlocker
Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by drcongo on Friday March 25, 2022 @10:45AM (#30802781)
Same. I think it might be because tracker blockers are blocking all the tracking this anonymous site seems to be doing.
Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by mdb31 on Friday March 25, 2022 @10:44AM (#30802755)
Same here, failed with Firefox 98 and uBlock. But, worked OK with Edge 99 and no plugins, so...
Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by luisamodio on Friday March 25, 2022 @10:48AM (#30802827)
Thanks for the feedback I’ll fix this ASAP.
Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by ghostoftiber on Friday March 25, 2022 @11:04AM (#30803020)
OK so it's 4chan with extra steps? :)
Re:Show HN: Throw – The new space for asking and answering q... by luisamodio on Sunday March 27, 2022 @12:32AM (#30817733)
Not at all like 4chan. For a start it’s not a forum. And in every other aspect also lot like 4chan.