News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I became the world's most prolific DJ, using code by marssaxman on Thursday March 24, 2022 @01:38PM (#30793049)
The point is that applying copyright law to music leads to absurd outcomes. It is a bad idea, and ought to be abolished.
Re:I became the world's most prolific DJ, using code by Kye on Thursday March 24, 2022 @02:09PM (#30793468)
What do you imagine would change if musicians couldn't protect their work?

As a musician, I think what would happen is the companies that abuse copyright now would keep abusing musicians, except now they can just take any song they like without compensating the person who made it.

Re:I became the world's most prolific DJ, using code by ARandumGuy on Thursday March 24, 2022 @03:17PM (#30794204)
Broadly speaking, there are 3 main copyrights that apply to a given piece of music: the recording, the overall composition, and the melody. The first two are pretty uncontroversial [1]. You can't distribute my recording without my permission, and you can't make money off of a cover version without compensating me.

The melody copyright is where things get really hazy. It's hard to determine when a melody infringes on another melody. What if the notes are the same, but the timing is different? What if the notes aren't exactly the same, but are pretty similar? What if the main melodic ideas are really common in a given genre or style? How do you determine if there was actual copying, or if two musicians just came up with the same idea independently? What if the melody just isn't an important part of the style of a given work? What if the melody is almost the same, but used in a completely different musical context?

There isn't an objective set of criteria that can determine if a melody infringes on another melody, without being too narrow or too broad. And since there's no good criteria, the only way to litigate this is to have better lawyers then the other guy, which rarely works out well for independent artists.

[1] At least, uncontroversial at a high level. The details get messy really quickly.

Re:I became the world's most prolific DJ, using code by msla on Thursday March 24, 2022 @04:27PM (#30794943)
Can chord progressions be copyrighted?

https://www.buzzfeed.com/reggieugwu/what-the-law-says-about-...

> Copyrighted elements of a musical composition can include melody, chord progression, rhythm, and lyrics — anything that reflects a "minimal spark" of creativity and originality.

https://ask.audio/articles/5-common-beliefs-about-song-copyr...

> Song Titles and Chord Progressions are not copyright protected

> This is true.

[snip]

> Ditto for chord progressions. There must be hundreds of songs that were hits in the ’50s and early ’60s that followed the familiar “ice cream changes” progression of I-vi-IV-V7. Thin “In The Still Of The Night” (another song that shares its title with others), “Donna”, “Silhouettes”, “This Boy” just for starters. Also the chords from the “Pachelbel Canon in D” have been used numerous times. Think “A Whiter Shade Of Pale.”

Does lack of enforcement make something legal?

https://moviecultists.com/can-chord-progressions-be-copyrigh...

> "If a single chord progression were elaborate enough and unconventional enough, it could be protected."

How many possible chord progressions are there?

Re:I became the world's most prolific DJ, using code by Kye on Thursday March 24, 2022 @03:23PM (#30794265)
There is definitely a sizable and vocal contingent of people who want all copyright on music abolished and only consider performance a valid way to make a living as a musician. When they don't specify, like above, that's generally the meaning. I've been chastised for selling albums enough to know it's not isolated enough to ignore.
Re:I became the world's most prolific DJ, using code by throwaway675309 on Thursday March 24, 2022 @03:56PM (#30794626)
Does the same apply to other mediums? What if I generate all possible 64x64 images? (Extend that to every resolution in theory)
Re:I became the world's most prolific DJ, using code by logicchop on Thursday March 24, 2022 @08:15PM (#30797260)
One row of that, two colors, has 18,446,744,073,709,551,616 permutations. Now do it for 63 more rows. Now write that to disk.
Re:I became the world's most prolific DJ, using code by alar44 on Thursday March 24, 2022 @09:35PM (#30797763)
You can't. Even the total number of chess positions can't be stored on disk, and that's only 8x8x32.
Re:I became the world's most prolific DJ, using code by ahaferburg on Friday March 25, 2022 @07:25AM (#30800781)
8x8x32=2048. Maybe you're talking about something else?
Re:I became the world's most prolific DJ, using code by Kye on Friday March 25, 2022 @01:11PM (#30804727)
Probably a misunderstanding of the word position in this context.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shannon_number

Re:I became the world's most prolific DJ, using code by alar44 on Friday March 25, 2022 @08:08PM (#30808153)
I mean dimensionally. 8x8 board with 32 pieces. So 8x8^32 or something like that.