The problem isn't that people have momentary false beliefs (fan death can be disproven with a bit of evidence gathering) but that there appears to be no correction mechanism. If you never see a dude turn into a cat, and if sacrificing people doesn't make you rich (worked for Jeff! ... Sorry couldn't help myself) then why do you think it works?
I'm not sure the answer is intellectual. It's quite possible people have some sort of psychological desire to believe things they know deep inside aren't true. Perhaps it's some sort of group belonging that must be satisfied ("yes, he walked on water!") by professing belief in what everyone can see is false.
I do not see what neat things “sacrificing cat person” will bring.
I have no belief in the supernatural, paranormal, or any hocus pocus. I don't believe in ghosts. But, conversely, I've had an experience that I've a hard time explaining as anything but a ghost. My dad lived in a house that once was used as a pheasantry, but no pheasants lived on the land for ~100 years. At night, though, I and many other folks would hear pheasants coming from inside the conservatory, where the pheasants used to be hung after slaughter. On many investigations, no source of the noise was ever discovered.
The only way I can harmonize the two is to just avoid thinking about it. If asked if I believe in ghosts, I say no. If asked if I've ever experienced a ghost, I recall this experience.
I don't mean this as some spooky tale or suggestion that anything mystical is possible, just one account of the weird ways evidence and beliefs work.
The shopkeeper wasn't prepared to demonstrate the good things his pouch of talismans were doing for him, but he certainly preferred to believe that his day would go better with them in hand. Who wouldn't? What an easy way to ward off misfortune.
It's like a belief in Myers-Briggs personality types, too, in that it's easily bolstered by a confirmation bias and, arguably, can serve a broader function in metaphor. The same of course can be said for much religious dogma and many faith-oriented parables. I think most people would agree that the world would be a better place if more people behaved as Christians believe Jesus did.
I don't believe that an excess of something called black bile, which relates to autumn, Earth, etc. makes me feel melancholy, but I have, numerous times, described my girlfriend as 'sanguine' to people who've not met her, and then, when I was rightly mocked for saying that instead of something more colloquial, proceeded to attempt to justify my word choice with an approximate characterization of her based on a humorist framework.
Perhaps this is just a product of insufferable douchiness and self-satisfaction, and is little more than analogizing, but that's kind of all beliefs are, anyway.
https://pacificheatingcooling.com/2018/12/27/carbon-monoxide...
There is so much going on in Africa, and what story makes it onto HN front page? The one that confirms our beliefs. (This is an issue common to the portrayal of many 'outside' groups.)
Pregnancy and childbirth is another area that's ripe with (literal) "old wives' tales". I read both Japanese and English advice on the topic, and it was both hilarious and disturbing to see completely contradictory recommendations like "eat healthy food, avoid sushi and caffeine at all costs" and "eat healthy food, like sushi and green tea". Another good example is co-sleeping, which the rest of the world considers obvious but in the US is considered outrageously dangerous, mostly because some studies found that adults who are {morbidly obese, drunk, on drugs} occasionally squash their babies.
(In my family we do practice co-sleeping, but without any alcohol involved; and my wife never had sushi during pregnancy because listeria are rare but really bad for the fetus.)
Your kidneys work, if you aren't thirsty (barring certain medical conditions) you don't need to drink water.
There's no such thing as "dehydration without being thirsty" on a routine basis. You'll develop a pretty powerful thirst at 2% water depletion, and for most healthy adults you need to see 4% or more for negative effects.
https://health.clevelandclinic.org/drink-up-dehydration-is-a...
In practice, I don't think anyone really does this: thirst, urine/sweat, and weight are very easy to measure, and the obvious next step would be pulse or blood pressure.
But I'm aware there are various issues with CGM's (a friend has one, which may act as an insulin pump as well, and complains that the needle needs to be moved around every so often as the attachment site stops giving accurate readings). The cost/benefit probably isn't there, if an elderly person cannot control their own hydration they probably also aren't able to adequately care for a CGM or similar monitor. If it was something you could implant into the body and poll wirelessly it might have some value.
I think you could get 99% of the way there with a reminder at 10am, 2pm, and 6pm to have a glass of water. With a few exceptions (e.g., heart failure), there's no real harm in moderately overdoing it--you'll just pee it out.
I was slowly turning into lyophilized me, fortunately I could give up at the 9th hole and went to immediately drink 2 liters of water.
But apparently younger me was convinced that story came from her and not from the schoolyard rumor mill.
It's like the thing about getting arrested for turning on the lights inside a moving car. No, you won't get arrested, but the reflection on the windshield can be annoying, and getting distracted by kids going ham on flicking the lights on and off is obviously dangerous.
See also, school "permanent records".
As a kid, I always wanted to go swimming (swimming pool or sea) as soon as I finished eating. My parents told me not to because of the cramps. "You must wait an hour before swimming".
It wasn't about throwing up and as an adult I finally understand it: they wanted to have a chat at the table after eating, take it slowly, maybe they were a bit drowsy. What they didn't want to do was to look after kids doing potentially dangerous activities such as swimming. So that hour of waiting? A period of grace for them to enjoy their meal and maybe rest for a short while.
Ask me how I know :)
Interior lamp
10.20 (1) A commercial passenger vehicle shall be equipped with a
lamp or lamps within the vehicle so arranged to illuminate
the aisle of the vehicle to the rear of the driver.
(2) A person driving a commercial pass enger vehicle having a
seating capacity including the driver of more than 12 occupants
shall insure that the light or lights referred to in subsection
(1) are illuminated at all times that passengers are being
carried between sunset and sunrise.On the other hand, how long does it take to know that your kids haven't gotten food poisoning from the food that would be served near a swimming pool?
Even if I believed that, I wouldn't, say, avoid jumping out of a burning ship into the water just because I just had a meal.
Is the scientific method perfect? No, of course not; as long as humans are involved, nothing will ever be perfect. But to paraphrase Wigner, science is and has always been "unreasonably effective" at getting things right, far more than any other way humans have looked at the universe, and as such is the best we've got to understand it.
My culture is very efficient at solving some problems, barely equipped to solve others. That's true of everyone. Some holidays or traditions are quaint, even silly, others make me envious. Some ideas are mutually exclusive, but others complement each other.
For the [oil field fires](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kuwaiti_oil_fires) the real story is stranger than I had recalled. Apparently the Hungarians mounted a MiG engine onto a tank and used it to power the water cannon. I had recalled the tank (high thermal mass rather than expensive heat shielding), but not that the water was jet powered.
Folks from Texas just thrown explosives on the fire until it blown it out.
There was some other nation who lifted in a long pipe over the fire, forcing the oil to go in the pipe which obviously kept burning at the top of the tube. And then they suddenly tipped the pipe to the side. The oil was still flowing of course, but when they got the timing right they could remove the oil stream fast enough from the heat that it got extinguished. That looked like a very ingenious solution from the lower-tech side of the spectrum.
> ... but not that the water was jet powered.
I found this video[1]. It sounds like it's not really that the water was jet powered. They were blowing out the fire with the oxygen-depleted exhaust of the jet engines and they mixed water into the exhaust to further enhance the process with the cooling effect. Or at least that's what the guy in the red helmet next to the machine says in Hungarian.
https://second.wiki/wiki/aerosollc3b6schfahrzeug
But it was never used for its intended role:
> When the vehicle was completed, however, the fires had already been put out by Hungarian turbo fire engines. The vehicle was used experimentally and showed good results. Even so, it was no longer used.
At least that one. Sounds like they had others that were smaller that were used instead?
Obviously the earth is not flat, or... is it? I suggest you take a look at all the flat earthers arguments, they can explain a surprising amount of things. I particularly like the one that explains gravity using a variation on the Einstein elevator thought experiment. I know it is all wrong, but try to let go of your preconceived ideas and look at their arguments for what they are.
What is good about flat earth is that it is a safe and well "documented" exercise in epistemology. Arguments are relatively easy to disprove even with minimal scientific knowledge, and besides ridicule, it is a harmless belief. I mean, flat earth doesn't suggest that you should kill people or anything like that.
Maybe "they" did fake a pandemic to slip mind-control chips into the vaccine. Maybe "they" are plotting to take control more overtly, more violently. Maybe "they" aren't even human, they just appear human. Maybe "they" are among us, hiding within a certain religious or ethnic group.
Me too... except for the jinx. If someone says "This project is going great" it strikes terror deep in my soul.
When you take into consideration that there's a literal CO2 spewing furnace underneath your room that you can't easily turn on or off, the introduction of electrical fans into the picture becomes the next obvious thing to watch for.
How is that in any way obvious? I don't see any connection, like at all. The furnace does not vent into the room.
[0] https://img.koreatimes.co.kr/upload/newsV2/images/202104/301...
So, would that not normally happen without a fan? If a room is that small, and that pooorly ventilated, how does a fan make the co2 concentrate in a more dangerous way?
But you'd never deliberately cause harm to someone over such a conviction, so it's not urgent.
You might want to self-scan for convictions that are likely to cause you inadvertent harm.
That can be lazily evaluated; in any situation in which you're making some critical decision where the wrong one could cause harm, check those convictions that are inputs to it.
Take conversion therapy for example. My understanding is that many, if not most, proponents of sexuality-focused conversion therapy truly believe that it is not only not harmful, but in fact directly beneficial to its subjects, for a variety of (mostly religious) reasons. I suspect the agony felt by the people subjected to such things is seen not as so much as harm by the people promoting it, but more as the pinch felt from a vaccine shot: a momentary sting in service of an eternal afterlife of painless happiness and purity.
Of course there's tons of predatory money to be made in the business of religion, and it's likely that most of today's religious bigwigs dgaf about anyone's eternal salvation, but that's due to a separate set of convictions.
Sometimes it can be.
Sometimes there are tradeoffs.
If it was as simple as "don't do the thing you hate", nobody would ever get cold in the first place, regardless of it makes them sick.
So it matters whether the sickness effect is negligible or not.
Nope. I guarantee people would like skiing more if you were possible at ~70 degrees. Snowmobiles can be fun, but they'd be more fun without the twenty extra layers of clothing you need to put on. Warming yourself by a fire can be nice, but it's the warming that's enjoyable. Being cold sucks.
Again, being cold leads to hypothermia. Just wear a coat, it's not that big of a deal.
Things like magnetic bangles, crystals and other stuff does appear in the west. I can't say how prevalent. Anecdotally it wasn't common amongst western researchers I've known, at least not outwardly.
Less fringe, but also less magical: the notion that a wild animal will abandon their young if a human touches them. It doesn't really make a lot of sense, but only on a second thought.
Not sure if you're referring to the fact that it's not well understood, but that doesn't make it less real.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fan_death#South_Korean_governm...
> The Korea Consumer Protection Board (KCPB), a South Korean government-funded public agency, issued a consumer safety alert in 2006 warning that "asphyxiation from electric fans and air conditioners" was among South Korea's five most common summer accidents or injuries, according to data they collected. The KCPB published the following:
>> If bodies are exposed to electric fans or air conditioners for too long, it causes [the] bodies to lose water and [causes] hypothermia. If directly in contact with [air current from] a fan, this could lead to death from [an] increase of carbon dioxide saturation concentration and decrease of oxygen concentration. The risks are higher for the elderly and patients with respiratory problems. From 2003 [to] 2005, a total of 20 cases were reported through the CISS involving asphyxiations caused by leaving electric fans and air conditioners on while sleeping. To prevent asphyxiation, timers should be set, wind direction should be rotated, and doors should be left open.
Maybe you should explain what you think the problem is with PMS, because I don't get it. It seems to me that the scientific consensus is to acknowledge the existence of something called PMS. What it encompasses (e.g. including "mood swings" or not) and whether it's a medical problem is, however, debated.
Numbers are an example. Numbers are a strictly metaphysical set of categories and rules, and they can relate to physicality, but there is no physical evidence for the idea of "seven", for example. Logic is another example. Cities are another example.
Ok, cities might need a little explaining to show what I mean, because you say "A city is physical!" and I say yes, but it's also metaphysical. I'll reduce it from city to a mayor to explain more clearly. Does the mayor exist? If you walk into the city office, you can meet with the mayor. So the mayor is real. However, if you go to the bar with the mayor and he starts talking about his car insurance or his marriage after a couple of drinks, you're no longer talking to the mayor. You're talking to Steve, who acts as the mayor during the day, but is also a person with a private life. Now, if Steve dies that night on his way home from the bar, does the mayor cease to exist? Well, in a way, yes, but in a few days, a new mayor will be appointed and in the meantime there will be an "acting mayor". So is the mayor real?
We could say the same for a city. It has physical boundaries, and if you don't pay your water bill "to the city", then the "city will turn off your water". Is it some entity called "city" who comes to your house and turns the valve? No. It is a member of the city's "body" that comes and turns off your water. So is the city "real"?
Marriage is another example. A couple that is married acts differently than a couple who is not married, and if the marriage ends, that can have drastic, real effects on the people in the marriage. So is marriage "real"?
But what you’ve done is none empirically assert numbers are “this”. Cities are “this”. No non-empirical claims have the same weight as empirical science. It’s not that empirical science should talk about things it does not yet know, rather we shouldn’t make claims like yours. We should only go as far empirical science says if you want to match empirical science’s reliability, and it doesn’t say numbers are metaphysical categories.
The 'disproven' part was also deliberately parenthetical and only indirectly linked to religion, with the used notions of proof and veracity both subject to the aforementioned concession.
Forgive my defensive parsing here, but it's important to me that I don't present myself as someone who feels he 'knows the truth'. My intent was to say that I don't.
I was just trying to point out to you that you might be open-minded regarding what evidence you are willing to consider, but just he point that you consider evidence as a way of establishing truth is a presupposition that can, and should be examined.
Anybody can come up with a definition but the usefulness of doing so is based on whether the definition is self-contradictory or not and whether there are useful rules of deriving more abstract things out of them. 1 + 2 = 3.
Fortunately abstract things like numbers can be made semi-concrete by representing them in a physical medium such as pen and paper or computer-memory. Then we can observe how they behave and verify event by observation the soundness of our rules for manipulating them. 1 + 2 seems to always be 3.
It's easy to point to western religions as examples of this kind of thing, but I think there are plenty of other unverifiable (or even effectively disproven) but deeply felt beliefs that proliferate among both the right and the left, some of which are deeply dangerous and only gaining momentum.