News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by cm2187 on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:05PM (#30756671)
As JP Morgan said, a person always has two reasons for doing something: a good reason and the real reason.

I think the sympathy for Ukrainians is a bit of a pretext. It's not just a pretext, there is clearly a lot of sympathy in Europe for Ukraine, not the least because of the geographical and cultural proximity, and we all know ukrainians personally. But the real reason for Europe to be tough on Russia is because Russia is now directly threatening EU countries (Baltic states, Poland, etc). And I do not understand how we can justify financing what has become a direct enemy.

Which is why an equivalence with Yemen or any other conflict, no matter how violent it is, isn't really convincing.

Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by aksss on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:21PM (#30756974)
I think we need to acknowledge that no “red line” implied by NATO’s mutual defense pact has been crossed yet (to my knowledge). I think there are instincts and interests champing at the bit for any pretext to engage with Russia using the lives of their neighbors kids to do so, but for now, I think it’s wise to keep that impulse in check and talk about what the red line really is in a practical sense.
Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by cm2187 on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:35PM (#30757198)
Naturally, and I think Putin will stay clear of that red line.

But there are many other means to be tough with Russia without triggering an all-out war. Not giving him money or trading with him is a start. Providing an unlimited supply of weapons, intelligence and humanitarian aid to Ukraine is another.

We should also be mindful that staying clear of a direct confrontation with Russia doesn't mean Russia should be allowed to set up all sorts of arbitrary red lines in term of what they claim constitutes an act of war. Providing planes to Ukraine for instance isn't an act of war by any standard. Biden's veto on the transfer of the Migs was really an act of weakness that will call for Putin to define more red lines. I heard general McMaster recently mentioning Russian pilots were shooting at US troops in Korea and Vietnam.

Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by plandis on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:00PM (#30756591)
This person is a troll. For example here is one of their previous posts: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30681090

“Ask HN: Ukrainians, why don’t you surrender?”

Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by c0nducktr on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:02PM (#30756627)
That's not trolling, it's just not a popular opinion.
Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by tuyguntn on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:16PM (#30756864)
Kudos to you!

I don't get how people behave when you try to look from other people's perspective and share your opinion, if it doesn't match with their opinion, you immediately marked as "brainwashed", "troll", "stupid conservative" and so on.

Why on Earth we gave up diversity of opinions and started thinking only one side is always right.

* US can ban mass media - stopping propoganda. any other country banning media - violation of freedom of speech * US invades a country, destroys economy for another 50 years - fighting for human rights. any other country, aggressor * CIA tortures - that's fine, we need to get terrorists. any other country - human right violations. * US says something - right! any other person - ohh brainwashed, troll, as if we don't have a brain and we don't compare actions of governments

Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by ummonk on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:03PM (#30756648)
Not an appropriate question for HN though. Not that it makes a difference to their comment here, which is entirely reasonable.
Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by DocTomoe on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:36PM (#30757207)
Advocatus diaboli: WHY is it not an "appropriate" question for NH, and who decides what is appropriate?
Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by ummonk on Monday March 21, 2022 @06:54PM (#30760808)
I think the guidelines are pretty straightforward - pure politics is inappropriate for HN, but if it's some phenomenon of interest to hackers then it's okay: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

As to who decides, I believe it's a combination of user flagging and moderation by a few HN mods.

Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by hackerfromthefu on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:19PM (#30756921)
The theme of their posts seems consistent with what a russian psy-op would be. Probably a paid inciter/troll.
Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by tuyguntn on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:28PM (#30757094)
First of all, I am not a Russian, not paid by Russia and 100% chance I can't prove it to you that I am not a troll, so I don't care, that's clear. What I can tell you is, I don't trust USA with its politicans like

* George Bush

* Hillary Clinton (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mlz3-OzcExI happy for destroying a nation)

* Joe Biden (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=927i2HAgxms telling how he suggested bombing Belgrade)

* Colin Powell (famous lier, who lied to invade another country) and many more stupid politicians.

I don't trust Putin as well, but that's not main issue here, my concern is ordinary people, like you and me are dying! for what? they even don't know. Imagine you wake tomorrow with bombs are dropped in your neighborhood, would you care about what Biden or Putin is talking about? No, you will try to save your family, because they are civilians like you and me. My guess is, this war is because of geopolitical games (not my expertise, just thinking out loud), not because we deeply care about Ukrainian people or Russians, we just care about our pockets, and selfish imperialism. If they don't obey us, let the regime change!

Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by gre on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:33PM (#30757168)
Is it hard to imagine there are people who want Putin to win as fast as possible so that fewer lives are lost and nuclear war is prevented? Ukraine should have stayed neutral wrt NATO, and at any time Zelensky can end his war, but he won't.
Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by tuyguntn on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:44PM (#30757306)
this is exactly my point, thanks for pointing it out better than me! I don't care who wins at this moment, I vote for stopping war, not only in Ukraine, but in all other countries. If war stops tomorrow either with Russian win or EU win I am happy for both

We are human species, we haven't chose Earth, why millions should get killed for the ambitious of very small subset of humans

Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by numpad0 on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:29PM (#30757112)
Considering that Russia is literally shelling civilians with intent and sending captive civilians to gulags, I think their options boil down to:

a) die, or,

b) fight to death with so-so chances of survival.

It is not a choice between:

x) to live under Russian rule(impossible as Russians don’t tolerate life)

x) or die(possible but not a choice).

As such, recommending a surrender is just trolling. Blame Russians for that!

Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by tuyguntn on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:10PM (#30756746)
Let me copy/paste my question here and check if it was trolling or legitimate question:

Question sounds pathetic, sorry for that, couldn't find better words, but mostly civilians are suffering in this war, why don't you ask Zelensky to surrender and stop this war?

Here is my rationale:

* every single day of war costing more civilian lives from Ukrainian side

* every attack is destroying Ukraine

* every weapon sent by West as a "help" is going to increase resistance, which in turn makes war to last longer.

* don't expect intervention from West, otherwise we might see nuclear bomb thrown to somewhere

* we can ask same question to Putin, why don't you stop the war, but he started war, so he is not going to stop it unless agreement is reached

Let's talk about different cases of power balance:

1. Russia has more power: that means eventually Ukraine will be capitulated

2. Ukraine has more power: Ukraine will win this war, assuming it won't attack Russia, whole Ukraine will be in ruins, lots of lives lost, but in Russia side no civilians are killed, economy will recover, people will say Putin was to blame, now he died, include us to EU

3. equal power balance: war indefinitely

4. Someone from government kills Putin: Then they can say, look we killed him, we are not responsible, so lift the sanctions, similar situation to Option 2 will happen

Option 2 is unlikely at this moment, even if it happens, Ukraine won't win economically, look at what happened in Libya, Syria their economies didn't recover after war.

Stop the war, don't expect Putin is going to stop this war, don't fuel war with weapons.

Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by wffurr on Monday March 21, 2022 @12:53PM (#30756476)
Begs the question, why didn't the world wean off oil and supporting then-repressive regimes 50 years ago. I despair for the species sometimes.
Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by AlanSE on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:19PM (#30756924)
As a young adult during the Bush years, I felt strongly that we needed to take aggressive action to replace foreign oil dependence with new energy sources (renewables, nuclear, whatever, sign me up). Politically, I saw both a nationalistic reason for it, as well as the obvious environmental reasons. Paul Friedman's "Real Men Tax Gas" seemed like the right angle that cut across the ENTIRE political spectrum. Really, who can disagree with this?

But I could offer a concession, at the time, that the solutions were not off-the-shelf available.

Now? The bottom has fell out of the "we can't" argument. Solar just kept going down in price along with batteries. Anyone defending coal power is hardly doing so on the price argument. A solar-based economy is not familiar, no. We will have to build infrastructure that turns on and off daily and seasonally in response to electricity supply-and-demand balance. There are large engineering changes needed... but no cultural ones.

There's no day like today. The energy transition will benefit our friends and crush our enemies.

Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by getcrunk on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:12PM (#30756790)
Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by qaq on Monday March 21, 2022 @12:59PM (#30756575)
What is the cost of 8 million refuges in EU? (since you are focusing on cost) Russia is not the only oil and gas supplier
Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by DocTomoe on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:39PM (#30757243)
Differently from earlier refugee waves, the Ukraininan one may well be a net positive for host countries. I keep hearing stories by refugee helpers that these people want to work, to the point where they refuse host locations if there is no infrastructure (and no jobs) nearby.
Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by parkingrift on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:06PM (#30756679)
What you are suggesting here is equivalent to blowing up a bridge and then suggesting that there are other ways to cross a river.

Yes, there are other oil and gas suppliers. No, Germany and the EU cannot just suddenly switch.

Fools for relying on Russian energy in the first place.

Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by aksss on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:30PM (#30757132)
“Fools for relying on Russian energy in the first place.”

This is a tough one. Yes, but at same time there was and still is a long term benefit to normalizing Russia’s identity as a “Western” power. That’s a long haul project and Germany/EU wasn’t wrong to engage economically with them, mutually, to that end.

Given the history of Germany/Russia in particular, this mutual dependence is arguably working exactly as it was intended - cooling impulses.

Arguably an error to become strategically dependent upon a resource pool you’re not capable of securing for yourself when the chips are down but hasn’t that ever been Germany’s post-industrial challenge? Much to the world’s relief, I might add.

Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by parkingrift on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:54PM (#30757435)
>This is a tough one. Yes, but at same time there was and still is a long term benefit to normalizing Russia’s identity as a “Western” power. That’s a long haul project and Germany/EU wasn’t wrong to engage economically with them, mutually, to that end.

Engaging economically is one thing, dependence on Russian energy is another. It was absolutely insane post-2014 to have an energy strategy with such a profound dependency on Russia. One US President warned Europe and Germany of such a dependence, and they quite literally laughed at him to his face.

At minimum Germany and the EU could have taken measures to ensure optionality in the event that Russia did as Russia has historically done.

>Given the history of Germany/Russia in particular, this mutual dependence is arguably working exactly as it was intended - cooling impulses.

It does not appear (to me) that Russia has cooled their impulses at all.

Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by aksss on Tuesday March 22, 2022 @02:32AM (#30763259)
I mean in relation to each other, Germany and Russia.
Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by qaq on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:09PM (#30756718)
They can't suddenly switch 100% they can start shifting oil fairly quickly.
Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by parkingrift on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:30PM (#30757122)
It depends on your definition of "fairly quickly." Within months to years, yes. Within weeks, no.
Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by qaq on Monday March 21, 2022 @02:15PM (#30757688)
Within months they can switch economically meaningful amount
Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by FDSGSG on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:04PM (#30756652)
Even a child can understand why Europeans care about a war in Europe but not about a war in the middle east.
Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by deeviant on Monday March 21, 2022 @12:57PM (#30756539)
Oh, whataboutism. Neat?
Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by unvs on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:10PM (#30756747)
Exactly! Whataboutism or even the fallacy of relative privation seems to be just everywhere these days. I don't understand the appeal of it. Someone is trying to do something good, is it really neccessary to shoot it down just because there are OTHER bad things that need attention? Such a strange way of moving the spotlight to themselves, in pretending to shine a light on bigger problems.
Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by tuyguntn on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:09PM (#30756725)
Oh when you expose crime, it is freedom of speech, diversity of opinions right? But when others expose double standards of West (usually politicians) and crime, it is whataboutism right?
Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by FDSGSG on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:12PM (#30756792)
Nobody is exposing double standards here. It's simply not hypocrisy to care about the war in Europe, and not care about Saudis killing Yemenis somewhere far away.

This is very obviously not a double standard, as the first one directly affects Europeans in a way which the second one does not.

Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by tuyguntn on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:21PM (#30756962)
what you are suggesting is we should not fight for basic human rights and give everyone equal opportunity to live (they haven't chose to be born, so why not give them at least a chance to live), instead we should fight for people who are like us? close to us? And we don't give shit to other people dying?

Imagine, Germany bans Russian oil, does it make you a happy if they buy oil from Saudi? For me its same, both sides are killing innocent people, why make a switch then?

Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by FDSGSG on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:21PM (#30756981)
It's not the same for me. I live in Europe, not the Middle East. Very simple.

No matter how evil the Saudis are, their bullshit does not affect me in the same way that Russian actions do.

Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by tuyguntn on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:32PM (#30757153)
> It's not the same for me. I live in Europe, not the Middle East. Very simple.

That's the reason why Ukraine war happened. We don't care, unless it is happening in our neighborhood! Now it is too late.

Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by g7r on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:20PM (#30756936)
This isn't a whataboutism, this is a case law.
Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by internet_user on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:03PM (#30756639)
when is hypocrisy also whataboutism?

when is it simply hypocrisy?

hard questions.

Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by FDSGSG on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:13PM (#30756808)
How is it hypocritical for Europeans to care about a war in Europe but not about a war in the Middle East?

War in Ukraine directly affects European security and pushes millions of refugees into Europe. The Yemeni conflict obviously does not directly affect Europeans.

Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by ummonk on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:05PM (#30756675)
Especially when Saudi oil would be used to substitute for Russian oil. It's not really moral to buy Saudi oil instead given that the Saudi conduct of warfare in Yemen is worse than the Russian conduct of warfare in Ukraine.
Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by tuyguntn on Monday March 21, 2022 @12:53PM (#30756456)
instead of banning Russian oil, I would first start with banning sending weapons to Ukraine and demand 240 hours non-stop negotiations to stop the war sooner. 10 days of not leaving anywhere unless consensus has been reached
Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by choeger on Monday March 21, 2022 @12:56PM (#30756521)
There won't be consensus. This war started over one party having lots of demands and not even recognizing the other party as sovereign and the other party just wanting to be left in peace. How the fuck should a compromise look like here?

It's like being robbed at gunpoint and negotiating a deal with the robber about how much you might keep.

Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by tuyguntn on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:07PM (#30756702)
> This war started over one party having lots of demands and not even recognizing the other party as sovereign

Can you name the party?

if you say Russia, put yourself on their shoes and answer the question, if you see NATO expanding to your borders together with the country ruled by people like Geroge Bush, Hillary Clinton (see how she is happy for destroying whole nation and their government: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mlz3-OzcExI), Joe Biden (I was suggesting we bomb Belgrade: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vei_18YcC6E) and Colin Powell who blatantly lied about bio weapons and illegally invaded another country, would you believe their word and allow them to expand to Ukraine? Country fighting for free speech who put Julian Assange on jail because he exposed US crime?

I wouldn't believe, I don't agree with Putin on starting war, but I also believe, he didn't wake up with migraine and decided to start a war, no he was pushed to this war

Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by choeger on Wednesday March 30, 2022 @01:59AM (#30851911)
That's completely and utterly bonkers. First of all, Russia has nuclear weapons. No one is ever going to invade Moscow as long as that is the case. Full stop.

Second, even if there were no nuclear weapons in play, NATO ain't the USA and UK alone. Most NATO states had more or less castrated their military to the point that even successful conventional defense depends cooperation with all other members. That's over since 2014 and even more so since 2022. Putin woke the sleeping giant. Germany alone will more than match Russia's conventional military in the future. Putin created his own opponent. Before that, NATO was structurally incapable of attacking Russia conventionally without a year long buildup of forces.

And finally, if it comes to the thread of a color revolution: Putin has had all the chances to both develop close and lasting ties to the EU and make his own people happy. He had the money and the tools. All he would have needed to do was to stop running the country like a mafia clan. He could have gone down in history as the great Russian reformer but now he will go down as its grave digger.

Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by ummonk on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:09PM (#30756727)
This war started in 2014 when a foreign funded protest was created to overthrow a democratically elected (albeit corrupt) government. This government then responded to local demands for autonomy in minority provinces by attacking them with neo-Nazi militia for the past 8 years.
Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by choeger on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:32PM (#30757159)
That's just retroactive rewriting of history. These "local demands for autonomy" where a violent, foreign funded, uprising. It was about to be crushed by the legitimate Ukrainian military which was in turn crushed by the Russian army. The Neonazi militias occured afterwards and filled the power vacuum left by Ukrainian army.
Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by FDSGSG on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:20PM (#30756938)
Do you genuinely believe that the top levels of Russian government care about the people of DPR and LPR?

If you do, then you're a fool.

If you don't, then you're a liar.

Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by qaq on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:02PM (#30756614)
Consensus on we believe your nation should not exist? Ukraine already once found the consensus of give up worlds 3d largest nuclear arsenal in exchange for security guarantees. It worked out great.
Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by internet_user on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:11PM (#30756758)
regarding the security guarantees, it appears that memorandum was not legally binding, and provides no real guarantees, as per the US themselves, and pre-2014.

"Regardless, the United States publicly maintains that "the Memorandum is not legally binding", calling it a "political commitment"."[0]

"not legally binding", below.

"Media Statement by the U.S. Embassy in Minsk April 12, 2013 Repeated assertions by the government of Belarus that U.S. sanctions violate the 1994 Budapest Memorandum on Security Assurances are unfounded. Although the Memorandum is not legally binding, we take these political commitments seriously and do not believe any U.S. sanctions, whether imposed because of human rights or non-proliferation concerns, are inconsistent with our commitments to Belarus under the Memorandum or undermine them. Rather, sanctions are aimed at securing the human rights of Belarusians and combating the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction and other illicit activities, not at gaining any advantage for the United States."[1]

[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budapest_Memorandum_on_Securit...

[1]https://web.archive.org/web/20140419030507/http://minsk.usem...

Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by qaq on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:15PM (#30756838)
Good Honest deal you got em.
Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by internet_user on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:18PM (#30756905)
Whats with snark?

seems that guarantees weren't worth the paper written on, in the first place, but everyone keeps on talking about them as if they were ironclad somehow.

The sad truth is there was no real guarantees at all, just an empty promise to make it politically feasible for the Ukrainian politicians to sign.

Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by qaq on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:26PM (#30757052)
Sorry dealing with a lot of stress related to what is happening.
Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by kolbusa on Monday March 21, 2022 @12:59PM (#30756579)
You have Russia actively trying to overtake Ukraine and yet somehow lack of military support for Ukraine should help negotiations? That seems to be true only if you want Russia to prevail. How can you force the sides to negotiate? There’s very little leverage.
Re:3,599,040,600 € wired by Germany to Russia since the inva... by internet_user on Monday March 21, 2022 @01:13PM (#30756793)
wouldn't that bias the conflict strongly in favour of russia, who would simply continue the invasion during the 240 hours?