News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by zmgsabst on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @02:56PM (#30702568)
This analysis even admits that there’s an object required for the “glare” to exist.

This analysis doesn’t reject an actual object being tracked: it confirms it and describes it as one that causes IR glare!

Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by stouset on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @03:07PM (#30702704)
Exactly. Zero of the GPs objections are inconsistent with this explanation. The carrier group tracked an unknown object and scrambled fighters to investigate. The pilots may have visually observed the object, but it would have been too far away to really ascertain any visual detail. Instead they relied on infrared sensors which… suffered from glare, and so rendered incorrect visuals for the object. Its strange shape and rotational behavior are now explained.

What remains is still an unidentified flying object, but one whose behavior is reasonably mundane and doesn't require advanced technology to explain.

Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by adriand on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @04:36PM (#30703738)
We also need to be really honest about what we want this to be, and how that desire influences what we believe about it. I personally want this to be an alien spacecraft, because that's super interesting and exciting. I think the same is true of lots of other people. Unfortunately, there are much more mundane explanations which fit the evidence much better.
Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by birdyrooster on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @05:10PM (#30704136)
Why do you want it to be alien spacecraft? Are you some sort of glutton for punishment?
Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by RobertMiller on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @09:13PM (#30706328)
If we're not dead already, how bad could they be?
Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by bentobean on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @11:46PM (#30707441)
I, for one, welcome our new alien overlords.
Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by astrange on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @08:59PM (#30706231)
The investors in Tom DeLonge's aliens startup would probably like to make a profit.
Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by sterlind on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @05:27PM (#30704325)
if the aliens don't annihilate us, maybe they'd be willing to teach us some physics?
Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by mark-r on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @05:34PM (#30704400)
If there really are aliens out there, wouldn't you like to have some proof of it?
Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by JaimeThompson on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @06:39PM (#30705049)
Given how horribly interactions between more technologically advanced and lesser technologically advanced societies seem to harm the lesser ones I'm not sure it would turn out well for humanity.
Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by depingus on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @08:36PM (#30706063)
A civilization capable of interstellar space travel has probably overcome "The Great Filter". I like to think there's a decent chance they're enlightened; instead of conquerors. But even if they are here to conquer, we may be better off for it. I mean, it doesn't really look like humanity is going to make it past the filter on their own.
Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by earthboundkid on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @09:23PM (#30706406)
Any civilization sophisticated enough to make a boat that can cross the Atlantic Ocean has got to have its stuff together or else they would have just mutinied on the journey over, right?
Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by depingus on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @11:47PM (#30707453)
Any civilization just sophisticated enough to make a boat that can cross the Atlantic Ocean... does not yet have the technology necessary to destroy themselves. Hence, the great filter.
Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by sswaner on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @10:32PM (#30706972)
To play on earthboundkid’s comment, some “enlightened” explorers traveled in advanced craft from the Old World to the New World. They brought genocide and near total devastation on every society they encountered. 1492. Columbus. But the literal and figurative descendants of those aliens put up a statue of him in New York and called him a hero.
Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by depingus on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @11:55PM (#30707496)
I don't know why you would call the conquistadors "enlightened". I'm talking about a civilization that's developed planet ending technology...and yet managed to not end their planet.
Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by beeboop on Thursday March 17, 2022 @08:25AM (#30710355)
so far
Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by aksss on Thursday March 17, 2022 @12:24AM (#30707660)
Well, what he did was pretty damn amazing and consequential, even if not all the consequences were positive or amazing. It was inevitable that the New World would eventually be contacted by the Old World, whether by Asia or Europe or perhaps Africa, and inevitable that when that happened, the isolated peoples of the new world would be devastated by pathogens they’d never been exposed to. Anyway, I see no issue making a statue to the guy. I kinda like statues in principle. At the end of the day that’s all they are. The world was bigger than the Americas, and still is.
Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by krapp on Thursday March 17, 2022 @12:43AM (#30707745)
>It was inevitable that the New World would eventually be contacted by the Old World, whether by Asia or Europe or perhaps Africa, and inevitable that when that happened, the isolated peoples of the new world would be devastated by pathogens they’d never been exposed to.

It's not the pathogens people object to, so much as the slavery and genocide. Particularly, celebrating the originator and perpetrator of those crimes on the land where they were perpetrated.

By all means, write about Christopher Columbus in the history books (after Leif Erikson, who unlike Columbus actually set foot in America) but let's stop normalizing erecting statues to villains.

Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by 10u152 on Thursday March 17, 2022 @07:08AM (#30709775)
Have you read the plaque on the statue ? Do you know the text? You can put up a statue to say someone did something meaningful or historical, not that they were a good or noble person.
Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by krapp on Thursday March 17, 2022 @07:55AM (#30710120)
>You can put up a statue to say someone did something meaningful or historical, not that they were a good or noble person.

Yes, but we don't. We don't create statues of Christopher Columbus to place his actions in their proper historical context, or to memorialize his victims, any more than we do the Holocaust with statues of Hitler. We erect statues of Columbus because until relatively recently the entirely Eurocentric narrative about him considered him a heroic figure, and the subjugation of indigenous peoples a righteous and noble cause.

Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by aksss on Thursday March 17, 2022 @02:07PM (#30714150)
You abuse the pronoun “we” - I consider him a heroic figure, highly flawed, plus - for better and worse - symbolic of the opening of the new world, totally acknowledging the negative impacts. ..And have zero problem with statues of the guy.

I think that’s more the norm with people, if they even think about Columbus at all.

The problem with contemporary dialogue is the refusal to allow for grey zones, for nuanced and balanced viewpoints. Who is this “we” that you project upon? Do you consider that this presumption and projection may by symptomatic of a neuroticism unique to a overly loud illiberal subculture in the US? I do, it’s all that gives me faith in the survival of the greater whole.

Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by krapp on Thursday March 17, 2022 @03:18PM (#30714873)
>Do you consider that this presumption and projection may by symptomatic of a neuroticism unique to a overly loud illiberal subculture in the US?

No. I consider that not everyone in the US is completely culturally detached from the legacy of colonialism, and that some people have perfectly valid reasons to object to statues of people like Columbus.

You seem to understand the negative impacts of colonialism on an intellectual level, as a simple fact of history, but you also seem perplexed as to why anyone would care. Perhaps you should consider why someone would object to a statue of Columbus. Engage with the nuance you're referring to, by not dismissing those with views other than yours as being carriers of a social disease. Examine your own views and ask yourself why you consider it valid to keep a Columbus statue up to celebrate some of his accomplishments, but not to remove it as a statement of opposition to his other accomplishments.

Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by mkr-hn on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @09:06PM (#30706279)
This was basically the plot of Falling Skies. The invaders justified the invasion with humanity's own history.
Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by blenderdt on Thursday March 17, 2022 @07:28AM (#30709902)
Indeed. It could be something simple as a gas bubble.

It is now understood that all those weird stories about the Bermuda Triangle are caused by gas. But still people want to believe in other, more exciting stories because that is what we want it to be.

Edit: even the gas theory of the Bermuda Triangle is just that: a theory. The best explanation is probably nothing much is going on there.

Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by shadowgovt on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @03:20PM (#30702829)
And in the realm of mundane objects that may create very strange radar and visual patterns, we have our choice.

Space Data Corporation was operating as early as 1997. Their product is radio communications provided by balloon. IIUC, normally those balloons are tethered, but if a tether snapped and one got away and was caught in a high-altitude crosswind, you'd have a mostly-metal object catching sunlight and throwing it in weird ways as it tumbled.

Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by bostonsre on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @03:33PM (#30702958)
This analysis is saying it's likely 10 miles away, that doesn't track with the other evidence, does it?
Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by stouset on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @03:41PM (#30703068)
What other evidence is this inconsistent with?
Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by colordrops on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @03:53PM (#30703220)
RADAR and visual confirmation.
Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by stouset on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @04:06PM (#30703371)
I’d be floored if the radar data didn’t back this up. A carrier group would have scrambled fighters well before anything unidentified got within a hundred miles, much less ten.

Visual confirmation I don’t find remotely compelling. Besides the notorious general unreliability of human observers, humans simply cannot distinguish between small, nearby objects traveling slowly and large, far objects traveling quickly without additional contextual clues (e.g., a tiny plane-shaped object in the sky is probably the latter). Factor in that they were validating their observations against a sensor displaying a misleading image—in other words, providing incorrect contextual clues—and I think it’s not hard to call into question the accuracy of any visual claims.

Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by bostonsre on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @06:47PM (#30705120)
It was picked up on radar over several different days and a training mission was scrubbed so that they could go investigate what they saw on radar.

You don't think humans could get better at judging distance of objects with practice? It seems like if any humans on earth could reliably do it, it would be seasoned fighter pilots that have thousands of hours of experience doing that exact thing.

Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by stouset on Thursday March 17, 2022 @12:48AM (#30707769)
We fundamentally don't have the hardware capable of doing it. So we use context clues and intuition. And both of those can easily be misleading.
Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by thereddaikon on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @04:03PM (#30703339)
I didn't think the radar track was at the same time was it? I thought the Tico's tracked it with the SPY-1 and they sent F-18s to investigate who then tracked it with the FLIR and visually.

Without a reference point you are unlikely to be able to guess the distance of an aircraft, especially an unknown one.

Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by scoopertrooper on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @05:01PM (#30704055)
Got a source on that?

I feel like people just want to believe. But this is a pretty satisfying explanation.

Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by cronix on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @05:36PM (#30704426)
Here's a 60 Minutes piece discussing it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZBtMbBPzqHY

Here's a 4 hour interview with the pilot, David Fravor, on Lex Fridman's show where he goes into much more detail than you'll probably read elsewhere: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aB8zcAttP1E

This wasn't just a single radar. It was an AEGIS system compromised of multiple ships with state of the art radars, multiple plane radars, and visual confirmation by several pilots. They were tracking it for multiple days.

Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by scoopertrooper on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @07:53PM (#30705711)
I think part of the problem here is that there are multiple incidents being conflated. For instance, people are saying that the pilots visually confirmed the incident with their own eyes, but (according to the article) that would not have been possible given the distance between the plane and the object.

Is there a source to indicate that in the specific incident being covered by this article, that there is any evidence beyond the video itself?

Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by native_samples on Thursday March 17, 2022 @06:16AM (#30709469)
There are actually lots of different UAP incidents. In some there are supposedly objects that get really close to carriers, which are tracked by many different radar systems etc. The gimbal video one wasn't one of those, IIUC, it was just what you see in the video.
Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by nl on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @10:26PM (#30706917)
I don't believe there was visual confirmation of this incident.

There was a separate incident where there was a visual sighting and people are conflating the two.

Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by NyxWulf on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @02:58PM (#30702593)
So the claim is...these highly trained pilots and the other sensor systems didn't realize that objects cause IR glare, but this guy did. Case closed.
Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by stouset on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @03:12PM (#30702750)
I'm quite confident that most people here are going to find a calm, measured, and thorough explanation of the observed phenomenon more credible than a snarky and instinctive dismissal that doesn't even bother to address a single one of the clearly demonstrated points in the analysis.
Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by thesuitonym on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @04:11PM (#30703422)
It's not the pilots job to theorize on whether the object is glare or not, just to describe what he's seeing. This is one plausible explanation, not THE explanation. There is still a UFO there, the video is just saying it probably doesn't look like what we see on screen.

If you're unwilling to even entertain that this might be a possibility because you want to believe... I guess do what you want.

Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by sudosysgen on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @04:33PM (#30703689)
Yes. This happened multiple times. There was an incident where the tree-blade bokeh of a NVD was mistaken for a UFO once, for example.
Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by tablespoon on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @03:59PM (#30703305)
> So the claim is...these highly trained pilots and the other sensor systems didn't realize that objects cause IR glare, but this guy did. Case closed.

And frankly the "this guy" appears to be someone with no expertise and who is strongly biased towards particular investigatory outcomes:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mick_West:

> Mick West is a British science writer, skeptical investigator, and retired video game programmer. He is the creator of the websites Contrail Science and Metabunk, and he investigates and debunks pseudoscientific claims and conspiracy theories such as chemtrails and UFOs.

Not to say he isn't right in this case, but I'm equality unenthusiastic about "skeptics" like that as I am about conspiracy theorists.

Edit: on second thought, I'm somewhat more unenthusiastic "skeptics" like that. Conspiracy theorists can at least be entertaining sometimes, while "skeptics" tend to just bore you with self-assured arrogance while they take pot shots at low-hanging fruit.

Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by glenstein on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @08:20PM (#30705940)
>Not to say he isn't right in this case, but I'm equality unenthusiastic about "skeptics" like that as I am about conspiracy theorists.

My working theory for what creates the lowest common denominator of internet comments, is that you have to believe whatever is necessary to believe to keep the conversation going.

If a skeptic debunks something by appeals to mundane facts relating to camera angles and physics principles, that closes the conversation. And for internet comment sections that is a problem. But, if them being right means they are arrogant, then we can talk about how arrogant they are, the nothing gets turned back into a something and the conversation can keep going.

Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by tablespoon on Thursday March 17, 2022 @09:36AM (#30711000)
The problem with both conspiracy theorists and non-expert "skeptics" is they both approach a phenomenon with their results already decided. It's just the conspiracy theorist has decided it's must be a conspiracy, and the "skeptic" has decided it must be some mundane thing with camera angles, and they both produce explanations to confirm their biases. They (especially the "skeptic") are just performing their identities.

And note the quotes around "skeptic," I'm not talking about people with real expertise in some area who show some crazy theory to be implausible or impossible.

Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by d35007 on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @06:10PM (#30704773)
> Conspiracy theorists can at least be entertaining sometimes, while "skeptics" tend to just bore you with self-assured arrogance while they take pot shots at low-hanging fruit.

I don't know about skeptics in general, but I found Mr. West's video to be pretty entertaining. He built some pretty impressive-looking simulations to support his claims.

I think conspiracy theories can be interesting and entertaining, but a lot of their theorists are kinda pathetic.

Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by msla on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @04:21PM (#30703535)
> Conspiracy theorists can at least be entertaining sometimes

Right up until they're sure that there's a child molestation ring in the basement of a pizza parlor that doesn't have a basement, and someone goes and shoots up the place because the conspiracy theory was so damn entertaining.

Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by tablespoon on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @05:54PM (#30704619)
That's exactly why I said "sometimes." It might have been more precise to mean occasionally, but the clear intended meaning was that it was a minority of the time.
Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by Talanes on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @06:56PM (#30705211)
> Not to say he isn't right in this case, but I'm equality unenthusiastic about "skeptics" like that as I am about conspiracy theorists.

Yeah, it can be interesting to hear a dubunking from someone with an actual background in the field, but someone who's whole schtick is debunking is just as motivated to prove things wrong as the conspiracy theorists are to prove things right.

Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by mkr-hn on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @09:16PM (#30706351)
>> "Conspiracy theorists can at least be entertaining sometimes"

Very true. We got some of the best TV in history in the form of the Stargate franchise from goofy '90s conspiracies.

Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by rasz on Thursday March 17, 2022 @01:14AM (#30707896)
The object might of existed for a millisecond. Test of a new stealth tech - quick directional laser burst to temporarily damage/blind IR camera. After that Jet was flying in circles trying to track its own camera glitch.
Re:Famous Navy UFO video was camera glare, evidence suggests by dcow on Thursday March 17, 2022 @01:18AM (#30707922)
That’s not how glare works.