News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by sebmellen on Monday March 14, 2022 @10:40AM (#30672984)
This looks good! I'm definitely behind efforts like this, especially regenerative CO₂ sequestration. Two questions:

1. What are the trade-offs you make (if any)? Are the trees in any way less robust or "healthy" than "natural" trees?

2. How do your trees compare to Empress trees, which can supposedly capture 103 tons of carbon per acre per year [0]?

[0]: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2019-08-02/we-alread...

Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by maddiehalla on Monday March 14, 2022 @11:23AM (#30673487)
Good questions! 1. We are still studying tradeoffs. Given the biochemical mechanism (how we change the trees), we are essentially increasing the amount of energy going to growth and not changing any fundamental ratios between lignin and cellulose. Think of this as similar to when humans go into ketosis :) We have seen some evidence of increased temperature resistance and wilt resistance but not enough data yet to come to any conclusions. 2. Empress trees grow very fast but there is not much of a market for their wood because it is very light. this means it is harder to get landowners to plant these trees. Poplar trees are commonly planted for environmental services like cleaning up of abandon mine lands and loblolly pines which are commonly used for saw timber. The varieties of trees we start with have been studied in the field for decades and we have access to that field trial data to start with.
Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by tempestn on Monday March 14, 2022 @06:32PM (#30679360)
It sounds like this might allow these trees to out-compete others. Is there risk that over time they could take over and reduce diversity, or cause other unintended consequences in the long term?
Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by biomcgary on Monday March 14, 2022 @02:24PM (#30676070)
I burn wood pellets to heat my house. Wood pellets are a convenient, relatively high density energy storage system. Pellets are also carbon neutral (other than the supply chain, which, in the US, tends to be regional rather than global). I'm concerned that the metal uptake might be problematic. I assume you are engineering trees with various combinations of properties. . .
Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by maddiehalla on Monday March 14, 2022 @04:03PM (#30677484)
We would not use any trees with metal for pellets. Because the landowners we work with grow the trees for over 25 years the type of wood produced is better for saw timber or timber that is used in building materials. it wouldn't be pellet grade wood.
Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by webmaven on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @05:08PM (#30691737)
> We would not use any trees with metal for pellets. Because the landowners we work with grow the trees for over 25 years the type of wood produced is better for saw timber or timber that is used in building materials. it wouldn't be pellet grade wood.

This may be a bit nitpicky, but one of the things sawmills produce is sawdust. What are the downstream effects of sawdust with higher metal content?

Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by Fiahil on Monday March 14, 2022 @04:02PM (#30677473)
> Empress trees grow very fast but there is not much of a market for their wood because it is very light.

"Market" for wood is measured in decades, not months. The trees we are harvesting today are the result of a "market" selection made by our fathers and grand-fathers (typically, oak in western Europe).

Saying that Empress trees is out of fashion today because their wood is too light, might be true, but it's not the answer you should be giving. So, either you have the ability to see 40 years into the future, or you simply don't know and don't assume it won't be likeable for the next generation.

Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by maddiehalla on Monday March 14, 2022 @04:05PM (#30677514)
In the conversations we have had with landowners, they are much more interested in planting Loblolly pine or poplar, which are naturalized and / or native than Empress. I think Empress trees are very cool but hybrid poplar and loblolly pine are better suited for the types of sites we are planting seedlings on.
Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by Fiahil on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @05:05AM (#30683123)
Don't listen to what people want or like. As I said, tree selection is not for one's lifetime : it's a gift for the next generation.

If you're approaching landowners by telling them they can turn a profit in X years, you are doing it wrong. If your motivation is greed, then you set yourself up for failure, first because price forecast 25 years in the future are absolutely idiotic and meaningless (as we have seen in the past two years), then because trees are very complex organisms that take a very long time to grow. By modifying their genome you expose them to potential rejection by their peers and more things that you will discover in two decades. And also getting bared from planting them in Europe.

So, get your marketing straight : no more profit, and grow what you want. Take those carbon credits home, that's the most profitable thing you can do.

Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by ncmncm on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @02:15PM (#30688869)
Not listening to the people you want to have do things is a super great way to get nothing to happen.
Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by danuker on Wednesday March 16, 2022 @05:53AM (#30696947)
Or to stop being asked about it.
Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by rob74 on Monday March 14, 2022 @11:00AM (#30673219)
I'm not in any way related to this startup, but in my experience trees that grow faster have lower-quality (weaker, less durable, but lighter) wood than slower-growing ones - this also includes the "empress tree". To quote Wikipedia, "Paulownia grown on plantations generally has widely spaced growth rings, meaning that it is soft and of little value". So "developing" trees that "grow faster, capture more carbon, and produce more durable wood" will be an interesting challenge...
Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by maddiehalla on Monday March 14, 2022 @04:07PM (#30677536)
I think I mentioned this in my other comment but durability and grow rate increase are two different traits we are working on at Living Carbon. I agree it's near impossible to address both in one trait.
Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by coryrc on Monday March 14, 2022 @11:38AM (#30673691)
I'd buy it by nobody stocks it nearby!
Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by pstuart on Monday March 14, 2022 @10:58AM (#30673198)
I've long been intrigued by Paulownia (empress). Nice to see others share the same thought.

Unfortunately its strength in this area is a weakness for adoption because its so highly invasive: http://www.ecosystemgardening.com/paulownia-princess-tree-on...

Bamboo might be another option. While it can be invasive I think it's much more manageable.

Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by sp332 on Monday March 14, 2022 @11:13AM (#30673375)
I think any plant with a 50% advantage in biomass per year will effectively be invasive, including the ones from this project.
Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by pstuart on Monday March 14, 2022 @11:20AM (#30673454)
Agreed. But at least with bamboo it appears to be much easier to constrain.
Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by AtlasBarfed on Tuesday March 15, 2022 @04:31AM (#30682902)
I thought there were non-invasive or less-invasive empress subtrees.

I know there is one that spreads quickly and uncontrollably, but other varieties don't

Re:Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture an... by sp332 on Monday March 14, 2022 @10:50AM (#30673097)
For one thing, Empress flowers smell very strongly and most people don't like the scent.