Re:Modern movies teach us awful lessons [video]
by mysterydip on Saturday March 12, 2022 @06:45AM
(#30650727)
Don't many people have just a stereo setup still (myself included)? Why would a newer standard be backwards-hostile like that?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Modern movies teach us awful lessons [video]
by willcipriano on Saturday March 12, 2022 @06:53AM
(#30650759)
As a counterpoint, I have both 5.1 via ARC and Dolby Atmos system hooked up via eARC and dialogue is still quiet in some modern releases. Older movies sound great though.
Re:Modern movies teach us awful lessons [video]
by cvuls on Saturday March 12, 2022 @07:06AM
(#30650819)
this will be because more recent movies will be utilising high dynamic ranges for audio, worked around by compressing/limiting but in doing so, you lose quality.
trade-offs for everything.
there was a time when stereo was seen as unnecessary faff, too.
edit: movies are mixed for theatres and no longer are the home releases adjusted to suit.
Re:Modern movies teach us awful lessons [video]
by RobertMiller on Saturday March 12, 2022 @11:05AM
(#30652274)
In many cases, people ostensibly using stereo sound may as well be using mono sound. Stereo speakers built into a TV that's 20 feet away, or watching a video on their smartphone without headphones; technically these people are using stereo sound but with the speakers so close to each other relative to the listener, it might as well be mono.
I think if you want to make widely accessible audio content, you should be taking this into account. Make it intelligible in mono first, then worry about the rest.