News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bad behavior is almost always good politics (2021) by lazide on Monday March 07, 2022 @11:36AM (#30589900)
Well, it's irrelevant for 'normal' folks until the inevitable wars crush them under the tank treads of the ones doing the power manipulation (and/or they get laid off, or can't pay the bills with their ever inflating currency, or crushed under unrealistic workloads and burn out...).

In a society, it's never actually irrelevant for anyone. 'No man is an island' and all. Even someone who checked out so completely they moved into a cabin into the woods can get hit by errant bombs or shot by invading soldiers.

What I've learned over the years is that most people prefer to focus on the fun thing right in front of them rather than the larger mechanics of the environment they are in. That fundamentally makes them easier to manipulate for those trying to get control of the larger mechanics for their own benefit.

Sometimes, you get folks doing that where most everyone's benefits and their benefit aligns.

Often, especially if people aren't paying attention or there is a broken system that incentivizes it (which is typical) you get people whose idea of 'benefit' is pathological for others.

Figuring out how this all works, AND being able to influence the overall mechanics and systems so evil folks don't get into power is very difficult and often thankless. Most people can't handle it, so most people check out.

Bad actors like to encourage this, as it makes their life easier.

Re:Bad behavior is almost always good politics (2021) by mrtksn on Monday March 07, 2022 @12:36PM (#30590811)
I don't think that I suggested not to focus on larger things.

My argument is actually about focusing on the larger and important things instead of being a device in the fight of the political class.

Oh and understanding how society works is definitely of great value, what I find great waste of human life and resources is to participate in the fight of sociopaths who try to interfere with the workings of the society to skew it in their favour.

Re:Bad behavior is almost always good politics (2021) by lazide on Monday March 07, 2022 @12:58PM (#30591077)
How do you propose to keep an eye on and participate in steering the larger things without ‘participating in the fight of sociopaths’?

Even if somehow you have no sociopaths on ‘your side’ (whichever it is), fighting a sociopath by definition requires participation?

Re:Bad behavior is almost always good politics (2021) by mrtksn on Monday March 07, 2022 @01:10PM (#30591237)
Steering large things doesn't need to be about fight of sociopaths. Having a governmental system with checks and balances also helps with keeping the sociopaths inefficient, by the time they assume any significant power they run out of energy, people catch up with the situation.

Nothing of these are original problems, some societies managed to build quite robust machines where sociopaths can't really cause huge damage.

Re:Bad behavior is almost always good politics (2021) by lazide on Monday March 07, 2022 @02:07PM (#30591969)
I’ve never seen or heard of any society that has pulled it off for long. Where you see it even in the short term, that is more likely due to extreme effort put forward on a day to day basis by people both in the machine and outside it.

If you care to put forward some examples, I’m happy to try to provide more concrete information on what I mean.

It’s easy to write off leaders as sociopaths - but very few seem to check the boxes, if you pull yourself out of the politics.

More often often you see someone acting with a set of incentives and a problem that you don’t understand, making a decision you don’t agree with. Which sucks. Add on top that the extreme pressure, visibility, power, and wealth can cause some unique looking (but all too common) pathologies at those levels, and it gets even easier to us vs them them.

Someone can’t make hard decisions if their heart bleeds (for real) for every bad situation. No group will survive long with no one able to make hard decisions leading it.

No matter what anyone does, if the group size is large enough bad situations will happen no matter how good a system is, or how perfect anyone attempts to make it. For anyone to be able to be effective at that level, they have to be able to make decisions somewhat free of emotional affect, and to be good, they need to do that without completely losing it. Which is incredibly difficult.

It’s easier to just go ‘meh’, make the decision that’s better for them right now and move on.

And being an experienced leader - emotional contagion/forcing empathy as a manipulation tool is super common, and commonly used to try to ‘should’ someone into making a decision that is terrible for everyone.

We all do it (hopefully positively) - give a smile (regardless of how we’re actually feeling) to the boss, or try to relay how terrible it feels to them when a family emergency happens, etc. hoping they’ll empathize and treat us nicer.

And good bosses do, but also know how to draw the line if someone is abusing it.

A sociopath (by definition) acts anti-socially, and they won’t be at the head of any social group for long, if ever.