Re:What's the problem with old but excellent Mac apps?
by ohCh6zos on Saturday March 05, 2022 @06:51PM
(#30573272)
1password was an amazing app and now it's an electron app that frequently doesn't work for me, if you want another example.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:What's the problem with old but excellent Mac apps?
by smoldesu on Saturday March 05, 2022 @07:30PM
(#30573582)
It also runs on Linux and Windows now with only a single codebase. They're not doing this for no reason; it may well just not make economic sense to develop native Mac apps anymore.
Re:What's the problem with old but excellent Mac apps?
by PeterisP on Saturday March 05, 2022 @09:57PM
(#30574606)
That's the key problem, the conflict of interest as separate native apps are much better for users but a single cross-platform app (often web/Electron based) is much better for the developer due to cost, compatibility and maintenance issues.
So the endgame is probably resigning to having lousy non-native software until/unless there once more comes a time with a single dominant/monopoly platform where people just make a single native app for everyone.
Re:What's the problem with old but excellent Mac apps?
by smoldesu on Saturday March 05, 2022 @10:09PM
(#30574672)
That's the problem from your point of view. For me, a lousy cross-platform app is a direct upgrade from "no app at all", so I don't anticipate that very many software engineers are going to spend their time designing a bespoke version of their app for >20% of their target audience, even if the experience on that one platform is better. If we lived in a perfect world, every app would have a Qt, GTK3, GTK4, SwiftUI, Winforms and Fluent Xaml version that makes everyone happy. Somewhere you've got to draw the line though.
Re:What's the problem with old but excellent Mac apps?
by blub on Sunday March 06, 2022 @02:43AM
(#30575781)
Meaning that Linux is nowadays not just continuing to have low UX standards, but is dragging down standards across the all OSes :)
Re:What's the problem with old but excellent Mac apps?
by smoldesu on Tuesday March 08, 2022 @05:55PM
(#30608459)
Linux has native GUI toolkits. If those lazy developers didn't just sit around all day developing Electron clients that worked, we could have a SwiftUI, Catalyst, WinForms, GTK and Qt version that everyone can hate! What a waste of developer resources, amirite?
Re:What's the problem with old but excellent Mac apps?
by iudqnolq on Sunday March 06, 2022 @01:35AM
(#30575533)
I've had a totally different experience as a Linux 1password user.
I went from a shitty cli and a laggy browser extension to an excellent native feeling 1password app that is fully integrated into my desktop environment. I don't notice any lag, in fact it feels snappier than the native windows version on my handful of years older laptop.
Unlike many other apps I use (Spotify, vscode, intellij, Firefox) I don't notice any difference in system load when it's running too.
Re:What's the problem with old but excellent Mac apps?
by bombcar on Saturday March 05, 2022 @07:47PM
(#30573736)
As they grow into corporate windows focused someone else can come and make a dedicated non-cloud Mac app.
Call it 2factorpass or soemthing.
Re:What's the problem with old but excellent Mac apps?
by kalleboo on Saturday March 05, 2022 @08:54PM
(#30574222)
Apple has been busy improving the functionality of iCloud Keychain, including stuff like adding a better UI than Keychain Access, compromised password alerts, 2FA token support, etc.