News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Learning the hard way: Moving from NYC to Palo Alto and b... by tptacek on Thursday September 29, 2011 @01:03PM (#3053294)
I know you can't reasonably say what % you offered (you're still apparently a going concern), but know that people on HN are pretty accustomed to b-school types and their notions of what "significant equity" are.

Again though, the top line here is, we're in the middle of a tech bubble, there are a lot of venture-backed companies, most of them are going to fail, tech comp packages have never ever been higher, competition is fierce, aggressive, and protracted. There has never been a worse time to assume you've got talent locked up.

I'm sympathetic to the idea that someone who isn't 100% sold shouldn't represent themselves as 100% sold. BUT. Oftentimes, we don't demand of others the frank answers we don't want to hear. How many serious sit-down conversations did you have with your potential partner about his commitment level? Your post is "Red flag!" "Red Flag!" "Warning sign!". Well, did you react to any of those flags?

If you didn't: I appreciate the idea of writing a post about the warning signs you've learned people should be looking for. However, if you ignored warning signs that the guy wasn't committed, it becomes harder to sympathize with the idea of a blog post designed to slag one guy for not signing on with your company.

If you did react to the warning signs and diligently qualified and re-qualified this guy and he kept coming back saying "absolutely I am one hundred fifty percent behind you": I agree you got shafted a bit, but again remind you that tech people mostly don't give a shit. A guy who can execute on the level you're saying you needed can simply write his own ticket. The game theory suggests that you have little to gain by lashing out.

((I'm having a really procrastinate-y morning, which comes from knowing I'm working super late tonight, so sorry I'm being so noisy. At least you're not on the logo design thread I'm howling at.*)

Re:Learning the hard way: Moving from NYC to Palo Alto and b... by joshwprinceton on Thursday September 29, 2011 @01:14PM (#3053335)
a) I'm not a b-school guy, so it's legit significant equity. b) Understood on the competitive space front c) Repeatedly, repeatedly had those conversations with him. He NEVER said he wasn't going to start, and I continuously had him reaffirm that. d) I was somewhat pot-committed at the point that the red flags really started popping up...
Re:Learning the hard way: Moving from NYC to Palo Alto and b... by durga on Thursday September 29, 2011 @04:36PM (#3054180)
I like the lessons. Good to keep in mind while hiring.

Having said that, this might also be a good moment to reflect. How can you make yourself a more attractive founder/company to work with? [You meet a girl, she's hot, she sees you for a bit and then moves on. I wouldn't waste such a nice opportunity for self-reflection. Maybe you need to lose weight or enjoy outings more so the next hot girl sticks..]

Re:Learning the hard way: Moving from NYC to Palo Alto and b... by chopsueyar on Thursday September 29, 2011 @09:42PM (#3055174)
...or give her more coke?
Re:Learning the hard way: Moving from NYC to Palo Alto and b... by borski on Thursday September 29, 2011 @09:35PM (#3055160)
tptacek, I like you, but in this particular case Josh really wasn't in the wrong. Definitely not a 'b school' kid; I went to high school with him (so I'm biased) but I can vouch for the fact that he got royally fucked over.
Re:Learning the hard way: Moving from NYC to Palo Alto and b... by tptacek on Thursday September 29, 2011 @10:33PM (#3055342)
I like you too, and I agree that what happened looks unfortunate and is not Josh's fault.