News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by johnnyanmac on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @03:21PM (#30532518)
Historically, Epic's aquisitions are given freedom to do whatever they were doing beforehand, so I wouldn't be worried. Quixel now just gives out tons of free materials and assets, Sketchfab is untouched, Artstation forums don't behave any differently, Hypersense's tech was likely leveraged and used in Metahuman.

People concerned over the "Exclusivity deals" on the game store end aren't looking at the "Developer" acquisitions which have rarely lead to the kinds of ends that, say, Google's Aquisitions have.

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by superkuh on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @04:22PM (#30533364)
Tell it to "Rocket League" or look at what happened to PUBG when they used Epic's engine. Epic only makes those things "free", it only buys popular software, because it's goal is getting more people locked into it's walled garden Epic store. It is not because they are nice. As soon as they believe they have a critical mass of Epic store users you can damn well bet they'll treat Quixel, Sketchfab, and Artstation forums just like the Rocket League linux client the minute there's any more profit to be squeezed out.
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by stonith on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @04:42PM (#30533585)
> look at what happened to PUBG when they used Epic's engine

They made a lot of money.

> it only buys popular software, because it's goal is getting more people locked into it's walled garden Epic store.

The rev stream is royalties from engine use since the free tiers are locked to UE, not EGS.

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by smileybarry on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @05:28PM (#30534152)
>> look at what happened to PUBG when they used Epic's engine

> They made a lot of money.

They reportedly worked with Epic Games on technical support for PUBG features, and Epic Games may've ended up using some of them in their own Battle Royale mode:

> Notably, Epic Games updated their in-development title Fortnite, a sandbox-based survival game that included the ability to construct fortifications, to include a battle royale mode that retained the fortification aspects. Known as Fortnite Battle Royale, Epic later released it as a standalone free-to-play game in September 2017. Shortly after its release, Bluehole expressed concerns about the game, acknowledging that while they cannot claim ownership of the battle royale genre, they feared that since they had been working with Epic for technical support of the Unreal engine, that they may have had a heads-up on planned features they wanted to bring to Battlegrounds and could release it first.

Quote: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PUBG:_Battlegrounds#Epic_Games...

Article: https://www.pcgamer.com/pubg-exec-clarifies-objection-to-for...

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by stonith on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @06:52PM (#30535196)
I'm well aware of the lawsuit. It went nowhere.

[1] https://www.theverge.com/2018/6/27/17509114/pubg-fortnite-la...

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by mrguyorama on Thursday March 03, 2022 @11:43AM (#30543309)
Aren't PUBG the ones who tried to sue people for using a frying pan as a melee weapon in game? Years after valve had it in TF2?

There lawsuits seem a bit empty

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by jsmith45 on Monday March 07, 2022 @11:59AM (#30590231)
Super Mario RPG did frying pan as a melee weapon back in 1996. Sure it was character locked, a single player game in a totally different genre, etc, but it still means frying pans ere an established video game melee weapon long before before TF2, much less PUBG.
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by HeavyStorm on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @08:02PM (#30535765)
Saying someone copied your work and broke the law doesn't mean that that they did. That's why we have tribunals.

Personally, I'm all against what they did with Fortnite and PUBG - they didn't broke any laws, but the surely reworked Fortnite into PUBG,instead of creating their own thing (it is now). But that's a long shot from saying they committed a crime or that their acquisitions turn up bad.

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by toastal on Thursday March 03, 2022 @12:44AM (#30537595)
Rocket League lost Linux support shortly after. Any company cutting off previous Linux support is not a good one.
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by johnnyanmac on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @08:05PM (#30535777)
>As soon as they believe they have a critical mass of Epic store users you can damn well bet they'll treat Quixel, Sketchfab, and Artstation forums

Maybe. But Unity is technically still used in more games and is being just as aggressive in acquisitions between Parsec, Syncsketch, Ziva, and even Weta Digital. It's definitely not going to be a battle won by outspending the competition.

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by MattRix on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @09:57PM (#30536578)
Tim Sweeney has been pretty crystal clear about his feelings disliking walled gardens and monopolies for at least a decade, since well before the Epic Games Store or Fortnite existed. He is very much a tech guy, not some super savvy cutthroat business guy (as is pretty clear when you look at their battle with apple, which made absolutely no financial sense)
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by activitypea on Thursday March 03, 2022 @04:39AM (#30539017)
This is a good counterargument only if you believe Tim Sweeney will outlive Epic Games. I don't think he will, and I have no reason to believe that Tim's successor will have his mindset or his values.
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by hamburglar on Thursday March 03, 2022 @12:52PM (#30544227)
Do you think bandcamp leadership will live forever if it remains a “lifestyle business”?
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by tpxl on Thursday March 03, 2022 @04:50AM (#30539082)
He dislikes monopolies and yet uses monopolies on distribution to expand the market share of Epic Games Store?
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by raxxorrax on Thursday March 03, 2022 @06:18AM (#30539582)
Can I get a refund for it? I had it on Steam but don't really play it anymore. Is such a service degradation a reason for a refund even if I had a lot of fun and countless hours in it? I don't need the money, but I heavily dislike such practices and want them to at least feel that.
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by ehnto on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @07:51PM (#30535660)
But being a market, Bandcamp's user's are actually artists and listeners, so Bandcamp having freedom to do what they want doesn't mean they can suddenly start giving all their music out for free, unless they change to a Spotify style model of listens = payout.

I wouldn't be surprised if the acquisition is to provide royalty free music to the games industry via Unreal Engine, as was the case for Quixel, but none of this is really good news for artists trying to make money unless Bandcamp plans to pay the artists out of their own pocket for a royalty free side.

All of that is speculation of course, we'll see where it goes. It's just a weird acquisition if it's not for integration I feel.

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by johnnyanmac on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @08:00PM (#30535742)
"none of this is really good news for artists trying to make money unless Bandcamp plans to pay the artists out of their own pocket for a royalty free side."

To be honest, I wouldn't be surprised if that's Epic's endgoal. But the music industry is a gargantuan behemoth with paper thin profit margins, and Epic is already struggling enough battling the mobile market (a much more lucrative market where the fight makes sense).

I can't see any significant push like that happening for a decade+. This and the harmonix aquisition are probably just the foot in the door needed for those plans should they want to push one day.

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by cinntaile on Thursday March 03, 2022 @05:20AM (#30539269)
They might focus on streamers, they have quite a bit of issues using music. Their recorded streams tend to have large portions of the stream without sound and it definitely needs fixing. The music industry fees are simply too high for them to pay.
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by DoctorOW on Thursday March 03, 2022 @03:13AM (#30538467)
> none of this is really good news for artists trying to make money unless Bandcamp plans to pay the artists out of their own pocket for a royalty free side

I don't see why that's the case? Just give Bandcamp artists the tools to set their own royalty structure (In the same way they price their own songs) and integrate this marketplace into Unreal or wherever else. Self published artists get a source of revenue typically reserved for labels and Bandcamp gets the cut instead of someone else.

Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by ehnto on Thursday March 03, 2022 @09:04AM (#30541126)
That's a fair point. My original assumption was that royalties wouldn't flow back to artists in a meaningful way but bandcamp has been a big advocate of fairness toward artists so that's really a fair take on my behalf.
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by jamal-kumar on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @04:24PM (#30533380)
It's a company that's been successful, while also mired in a variety of legal problems and scandals, often related to how their games are so deliberately addictive.... I don't doubt what you say about their good intentions, I just honestly worry more about any fallout from that kind of business practice leading to an acquisition.
Re:Epic Games acquires Bandcamp by HeavyStorm on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @07:50PM (#30535655)
Never heard of legal Epic having legal problems because of addictive games. Can you elaborate?