Not a single thing about the writing process, or how to frame your ideas, or anything like that.
I know that's not how grants are always awarded, but as a junior faculty member it's hard to know what to make of that, when a university-sponsored workshop is structured around those issues.
It's difficult for me to wrap my head around this all most of the time, to convey to an outsider what bothers me so much about the whole thing, or to even articulate it to myself. I can make comparisons to certain things (Theranos, cryptocurrencies, or economic bubbles) but it's very abstract and fuzzy and imperfect. So much of it seems empty to me, or false.
One really key thing for me was to reach out to senior colleagues in the same area (definitely not just at the same university) to get multiple examples of what successful grant applications look like. There's a bunch of text in the grant call, but the panel are going to be senior in-area academics who may know what a good application looks like, but won't necessarily be able to articulate all the rules.
Everyone I know finds writing proposals hard. So much of writing papers is being careful about citing prior work and not over-claiming for your results, but for grant proposals we are basically forced to make big claims about things that we have not done. However, it's worth noting that no one on the panels or at the grant agencies see research proposals as binding promises to do certain work: they mostly all want you to follow the science and change course if you spot something better.
Part of it's perfectly rational: faced with two competently written but not directly comparable proposals, knowing that one of the proposers is less of a mystery than the other is additional information about their ability to deliver, and part of it's humans being humans.
Ironically I'd see much of crypto and other investment bubbles as the opposite cognitive bias (who cares about the gaps in our knowledge, this number is going up faster than that number?)
HN maybe isn't the best forum to explain all of this but I'm quite jaded at this point with academics.
I don't want to come across as too negative either, as implying nothing works or there is no progress or something like that, but there's a huge disconnect between what I see personally in scientific circles in actuality vs the nominal narrative in terms of how ideas are taken up, how consensus is reached, what happens to accurate but dissenting perspectives, and how credit accrues. Some of it is common to our time, but some of it I think is amplified or something in the academic community.
I also realize at some level my experiences are not universal, but that there are a lot of people who feel the same (apparently) maybe just underscores my point.
When someone like Peter Higgs is saying he wouldn't be employable today (https://www.theguardian.com/science/2013/dec/06/peter-higgs-...), scientific institutions should be paying closer attention and doing something about it.
Landed said grant on first submission.
I didn't keep track of most of my cohort from that program, but the ones I have had been fairly successful. Mostly, I think the benefit was structured time and an available "red team" to read it (one contract research organization I've worked with had one of these, and it was an amazing experience) etc.
Established groups definitely get a bit of a pass with "Well, surely Professor So-and-So will sort this out" that an early career person won't. And environment does come into play in terms of whether or not a university has the ability to manage a grant, and yes, large universities basically get an auto-pass there, but it's something people talk about.
But I will say that even for established people at large universities, you do have to stick the content. A ton of recent cycles have been dominated by "Hey, we do COVID research now!" from groups that never did infectious disease research before, and a lot of those got clobbered in review.
But I also do my best to teach my students about the "soft factors" of academia - there are a lot, and they are, by and large, hidden.
Your last point isn't lost either - I occasionally get a little bitter when I translate funding rounds on Hacker News into grant-equivalents.
Sounds a bit like any job:
* Cross train in other departments
* Demonstrate your functionality/team’s functionality to other groups through talks, white papers, ‘internal consulting
* You do well when your boss does well, make your boss look good
* Buzzwords and trends make the world go round
"Communicate all your ideas using narrative form. Embed your ideas in motifs, illustrate them with visual icons. Explain their worth by using existing context."
The reason buzzwords and zeitgeist terminology works is because they're a shorthand to understanding a topic, and a linker to existing context.
It's important to consciously understand how that works though.
I don't know about the academic side, but for corporate grants this part:
> sprinkle a bit of fad-ish topics into your research if even if it's a stretch to do so.
Does work, but only if the core thing you're tackling isn't as meritorious as what the reviewer is used to seeing. So, for example, one grant I wrote for a hardcore AI startup that had huge data engineering issues on a shoestring budget. Former Stanford, Google, etc folks. I didn't need to pull in anything. I just straight wrote the claim (retrospective grant applications are called claims) and we got a big cheque. Most of the work was meticulously going through their pull requests and estimating hours that were research vs traditional software development.
As an aside, I make around $5k per day with this type of work because I get pulled into the most technical claims and I'm very good at it, but I don't enjoy it as much as software development so I only take stuff that I think needs my help.
Compared to, say if I was a paper clip salesman. What makes money and what loses is far more obvious. In addition, if the plan lost money, its immediately obvious and can be stopped
I used to think that academia was up to merit, during my teaching days
The only and I mean only reason I ever got a grant is because I called the asshole and asked him to craft it
for me
You get extra credit points if you're active in visiting other universities and giving talks on the annual job circuit. You tend to do well if you advisors are well-connected. You have to sprinkle a bit of fad-ish topics into your research if even if it's a stretch to do so.
I suppose that it has always been so. And now looking back, I don't find huge fault in that you should be able to connect your research with larger ideas. Or that people in richer environments with more information are generally more successful.
But having tried to be on the faculty track before, from a middle-tier university, I never knew these things. Or the professors I was around never told me those unofficial factors. And I thought it very unfair that the judges allowed those factors to creep into their consideration without making it clear to everyone that those were important. If giving talks in person is important, tell people at least.
I naively (I guess) thought that the strength of what you wrote in the application/grant document dominated. Maybe it does for some fields or if reviewers are diligent about understanding the blinders they wear and their availability bias.
Well, anyway, I left the field all the same. No regrets, but I wish these fields would improve their explicit processes about it.
I do note with some amusement now in industry, that basically I am able to approve spending of $500k for certain things with approximately a 30 minute conversation with leadership (with appropriate justification and documentation)...