While I generally agree with the alarm raised by this article, I find it does itself a disservice by exaggerating and citing to Americans with, charitably, a passing understanding of Canadian law and government.
If people would like a dispassionate/neutral reading of the legal obligations imposed by the invocation of the Emergencies Act, I can recommend:
- a summary by Osler, a prestigious Canadian law firm [1]
- the order itself [2]
- the regulations themselves [3]
They are bad enough on their own without embellishment.
For additional context, I have never voted for the Liberal party. Federally, I have donated to and voted for Conservative and Green candidates my entire life. My current MP (a Green MP), voted against the Emergencies Act. I approved of that vote. But it is just absolutely bizarre to me to see people comparing Trudeau to Hitler, Stalin and Mao, as is done in the punk6529 Twitter thread that is embedded in this article. There is plenty to criticize without undermining yourself by using these stupidly emotive comparisons.
[1]: https://www.osler.com/en/blogs/risk/february-2022/new-emerge...
[2]: https://www.gazette.gc.ca/rp-pr/p2/2022/2022-02-15-x1/html/s...
[3]: https://www.gazette.gc.ca/rp-pr/p2/2022/2022-02-15-x1/html/s...
In addition this interview by en ex-CSIS (Canadian spycops agency) employee suggests that the funding is getting to the organizers by some means other than those which go directly through payment processors. It would be interesting if these measures were also actually ineffective. I was a bit skeptical of her claim that bitcoin ATMs in Ottawa were a likely source though:
https://thebigstorypodcast.ca/2022/02/15/trying-to-follow-th...
Past explanations of why we have that rule:
https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comme...
https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
Trudeau, on the other hand, recently won re-election in what is generally accepted to have been a free and fair election and which was, in large part, a referendum on his handling of the coronavirus. This is relevant because his invocation of the Emergencies Act is related to protests about how he has handled coronavirus.
Even so, his invocation of the Emergencies Act was successful only because, in a minority parliament, he convinced another party to support him. Additionally, Doug Ford, a provincial premier of a third, different, party requested him to invoke it.
That's just... not dictatorial, totalitarian or mass murder-y to me. And again, I say this as someone who does not like Trudeau, does not generally like the Liberal party, and has never supported them.
I think this emergency act stuff is very bad, but Canada's response to Covid has been head and shoulders better than the USA and the death counts show it. I'm happy, as an American, to live up here where human life is valued.
(And even if they do, 30 days is still a really long time not to have access to money, aside from whatever cash you happened to have on you at the time.)
“Although not impossible that someone who gave $20 be captured and have their bank account frozen, I find that scenario…you know I think it would be in rare circumstances.”
https://www.ctvnews.ca/politics/banks-begin-unfreezing-accou...
[0] https://mobile.twitter.com/ezralevant/status/149485205614596...
I understand why Freeland would not want to outright say "we want the permanent power to freeze funds with no recourse" - but that's the only conclusion I could reach based on that clip.
Keep in mind, the government had the power to seize/freeze assets, before this Emergency Act, as long as they had a court order. However, that low bar seemed to be too high a hurdle so the Liberals want to make this permanent.
Further, the government always had the power to freeze the destination accounts as long as they were at a Canadian bank and had a court order. This is the only distinction.
At the end of the video that you linked, she explicitly says that some of the emergency powers (suspending insurance for commercial vehicles involved in blockades) should not be available to governments in ordinary times.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Section_1_of_the_Canadian_Char...
Label any protest you don't like an "illegal protest". Then as long as there's less than one such protest every 30 days, it's not "permanent"... Yet it is.
Honking a horn carries very little penalty but is massively annoying if done in front of the PM's house. Parking your truck infront of a border crossing is similarly not very penalized, yet killing 25% of the trade between two countries is very damaging to the gov't.
The real reason we never saw these measures before is because of how brutally effective they are while being entirely non-violent.
As of this post, 36,116 and not millions of people died of COVID in Canada, and the removal of vaccine mandates / mask mandates are inline with the recommendations of the Chief Public Health Officer. The people were pretty much protesting to get Trudeau to follow the medical recommendations of the Health Officer.
In most countries where masks and vaccine mandates have been eliminated, infections have gone down. Denmark's peak was the last day of restrictions.
While that is a lot, it's far fewer from the number of people who have died from COVID.
It seems like you're over-dosing on misinformation.
This is true. They have frozen the bank accounts of hundreds and you cannot do anything about it. You never got due process, there is no redress from the courts because you dont have a bank account to hire a lawyer.
[0] https://twitter.com/markstrahl/status/1495472037438967808
Perhaps this is why freezing an account generally requires a court order, my guess is that no judge would approve based on the current jurisprudence and facts of the case.
https://twitter.com/ikwilson/status/1495841230315560962
Sorry but you are the one in the echo chamber.
I accept my ban.
I said this about Mark Strahl, my MP, so no I didn't make the same "attack", sorry. As of now this story seems fabricated so I'll keep trying to hold my MP accountable.
Here is the information directly from the RCMP, who say directly that they did not at any time provide a list of donors to banks: https://blockade.rcmp.ca/news-nouvelles/ncr-rcn211130-s-d-en...
Moreover, a reply to his tweet is a statement from the police that says they provided a list of truck drivers and “influencers”, not donors, to the bank. https://twitter.com/rcmpgrcpolice/status/1495813180983021575...
The text of the invocation allows for freezing of anything more than $25 which is a fact, not a tweet.
If you want to believe an org that bombs people and blames it on farmers go right ahead.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_controversies_involv...
Is this actually true? According to [0] "The Declaration expires after 30 days unless an extension is confirmed within specific timelines by both the House of Commons and the Senate.". I don't see how this would grant the government permanent powers unless the Emergencies Act gets renewed in perpetuity.
[0] https://www.canada.ca/en/department-justice/news/2022/02/can...