News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dutch antitrust authority fines Apple for fifth time by ocdtrekkie on Monday February 21, 2022 @04:31PM (#30420874)
Just a simple math question: Is keeping the in-app purchasing regime from collapsing worth more than $50 million to them? Yep.

Even if the Dutch revenue isn't that much, once one country succeeds the rest will follow that model. Apple and Google are just going to delay as much as possible, and when their delay tactics no longer work, eat the fines until they're higher than the profits.

Re:Dutch antitrust authority fines Apple for fifth time by iruoy on Monday February 21, 2022 @05:15PM (#30421367)
Just paying the fine doesn't allow them to keep the status quo.

This is a nice article [1] about what the ACM is asking for and why Apple is making an effort to comply.

Also, this lawsuit is for dating apps specifically, but should pave the way for other categories to follow right?

[1] https://www.theverge.com/2022/2/14/22917514/apple-netherland...

Re:Dutch antitrust authority fines Apple for fifth time by ummonk on Monday February 21, 2022 @06:00PM (#30421871)
> Even if the Dutch revenue isn't that much, once one country succeeds the rest will follow that model.

The point of contention here isn’t about the Netherlands, but about whether the Dutch ruling will apply de facto globally. Apple wants to ensure it doesn’t, by requiring Netherlands-specific apps if enabling third party payment processors. The ACM wants it to apply globally.

Re:Dutch antitrust authority fines Apple for fifth time by ocdtrekkie on Monday February 21, 2022 @06:40PM (#30422235)
Not necessarily: Apple could permit an app developer to allow third party payments in the same app, but only if the user was in the Netherlands. That's not a difficult code path to manage.

The issue here is Apple is trying to frustrate any attempts to circumvent their payment processing: By both still demanding 27% fees, and also requiring they publish a separate app (likely requiring users to uninstall the main app and install the new one), Apple is trying to make it so onerous and painful to use third party payments that nobody will actually do so in practice.

Re:Dutch antitrust authority fines Apple for fifth time by Someone on Monday February 21, 2022 @07:14PM (#30422519)
> By both still demanding 27% fees

In the court case that led to this, the court required Apple to support third party payment processors, but rejected the claim that their 30% cut was outrageous.

The EU also has regulations limiting how much payment services such as Mastercard can charge. https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/IP_13_...: “caps are set at 0.2% of the value of the transaction for debit cards and 0.3% for credit cards“

Given that, I don’t see how the same court could say a 3% margin for third party payment services is unfair.

Requiring a new app, on the other hand, is the trouble area. It means losing App Store reviews, and, probably more importantly, means users can’t seamlessly upgrade to a version that supports a third party payment service.

Also, if you retire the old app, you likely will lose subscribers. If you keep it around, you’ll likely see few users move to the new app.

Re:Dutch antitrust authority fines Apple for fifth time by ummonk on Monday February 21, 2022 @07:22PM (#30422586)
> Also, if you retire the old app, you likely will lose subscribers. If you keep it around, you’ll likely see few users move to the new app.

I think the apps here would be front ends to the same dating network.

Re:Dutch antitrust authority fines Apple for fifth time by Someone on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @02:12AM (#30424878)
They would, but the app developer wants all their users to move to the new payment service (e.g. so that the developer gets to know more about its users)

That calls for making it as easy as possible to migrate. Downloading a new app and deleting the old one is harder for users than using the iOS auto-update mechanism, so developers would prefer to have the ability to update their app with one that offers a subscription through a new payment service.

Developers can force users of the old app by retiring it, but they can’t force them to download the new one. Chances are some users will think “what do I get out of this app?” and not download the new one. That’s the “losing subscribers” part.

Re:Dutch antitrust authority fines Apple for fifth time by TheCoelacanth on Monday February 21, 2022 @10:47PM (#30423796)
It's not the 3% cut for payments. It's the 27% cut for doing nothing.
Re:Dutch antitrust authority fines Apple for fifth time by Someone on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @02:29AM (#30424985)
I know, but in this case, from what I read, the antitrust authority said something about that in its original ruling, too, but a follow-up court case concerning that ruling scrapped that part of it, implicitly saying the 30% cut is not problematic/the antitrust authority didn’t argue well enough that it is (IANAL, and I don’t think the full history is online, so corrections welcome)

Because of that, I can see why Apple isn’t giving up the golden goose at the moment.

Re:Dutch antitrust authority fines Apple for fifth time by mr_toad on Monday February 21, 2022 @09:58PM (#30423566)
> likely requiring users to uninstall the main app and install the new one

This. Most users won’t bother, so they’ll default to using Apple as a payment processor. Everyone knows the power of defaults.

Re:Dutch antitrust authority fines Apple for fifth time by withinboredom on Monday February 21, 2022 @04:45PM (#30421039)
I somehow doubt IAP revenue with dating apps in the Netherlands >= 5 million EUR a week.
Re:Dutch antitrust authority fines Apple for fifth time by ocdtrekkie on Monday February 21, 2022 @04:52PM (#30421114)
The issue is the global revenue: If any country can get them to forego 30% profits, the rest will follow in short order.
Re:Dutch antitrust authority fines Apple for fifth time by withinboredom on Monday February 21, 2022 @04:59PM (#30421182)
I thought the issue was in regards to laws surrounding dating apps and not generalized? FWIW, here, some NL specific apps just accept a direct bank transfer without any IAP, right in the app. Apple reviewers don't seem to care.
Re:Dutch antitrust authority fines Apple for fifth time by ummonk on Monday February 21, 2022 @06:03PM (#30421912)
After the ruling, Apple has been requiring the dating app companies to create NL specific apps if they wish to use third party payment processors. They’re getting fined for this.
Re:Dutch antitrust authority fines Apple for fifth time by yreg on Monday February 21, 2022 @05:43PM (#30421711)
Perhaps they could kick dating apps out of the Dutch App Store.
Re:Dutch antitrust authority fines Apple for fifth time by tremon on Monday February 21, 2022 @07:14PM (#30422525)
Perhaps they could have, if only they would have allowed third-party app stores.

But doing this now, while this case is ongoing, will very quickly earn them a contempt of court badge,