News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: YouTube and how my wife lost 7 years of work by rectang on Saturday February 19, 2022 @06:08PM (#30401397)
Lots of commenters rushing to chastise the user for not taking pro-active steps to preserve content, since your Google account (or any cloud account once a provider decides you've violated their Terms of Service) may go "poof".

Wouldn't it be nice if the platforms themselves helped out with this, instead of luring their users into a false sense of security?

Re:Tell HN: YouTube and how my wife lost 7 years of work by sli on Saturday February 19, 2022 @06:31PM (#30401580)
Both of those things are true simultaneously. YouTube and other Google products are advised against for long term storage because Google's acting this way is entirely unacceptable. Until the latter can be fixed, the only real hedge a person has is to simply not rely entirely on Google for anything. That's just the reality of it.

Blame never rests on the user, either way. Google will always have far more power than the user.

Re:Tell HN: YouTube and how my wife lost 7 years of work by Ekaros on Saturday February 19, 2022 @06:09PM (#30401419)
It would. I hope people here work towards their companies regularly warning their customers that any content stored on their services can be gone any day without any warning.
Re:Tell HN: YouTube and how my wife lost 7 years of work by feupan on Saturday February 19, 2022 @09:42PM (#30402744)
Not that I'm justifying it, but isn't that part of every single ToS of web services?

"Your account may be terminated at any time"

No business owner wants to print that in large letters above every upload form: "Thanks for uploading, your content may be deleted at any time, keep a copy."

What we need though is some accountability especially from large companies and for real users.

How long can we go before we start treating online stuff like real stuff? Why is my car protected from theft but my data isn't?

Re:Tell HN: YouTube and how my wife lost 7 years of work by Ekaros on Sunday February 20, 2022 @05:29AM (#30404699)
Clearly many users here want it. Maybe even with these pop-on level forced notification boxes. And thus I recommend they fully start pushing such big red warning letters in the services they work with.

And size should have nothing to do with it. I believe treating most SaaS providers the same.

Re:Tell HN: YouTube and how my wife lost 7 years of work by rectang on Saturday February 19, 2022 @06:50PM (#30401702)
How about if durable archival was an upsell alongside upload?
Re:Tell HN: YouTube and how my wife lost 7 years of work by ocdtrekkie on Saturday February 19, 2022 @07:17PM (#30401870)
So the issue is Google often takes down accounts with illegal content using the same process as here. Imagine the very real scenario that Google found CSAM on an account: They aren't going to let you access it or download it again for any amount of money.

And that's the problem here: With no humans in the process, YouTube treats ordinary users and predators exactly the same way, because ultimately, algorithms are stupid and don't make good moderators.

Re:Tell HN: YouTube and how my wife lost 7 years of work by rectang on Saturday February 19, 2022 @07:37PM (#30402000)
> YouTube treats ordinary users and predators exactly the same way

Does it have to be that way? There are various reasons for banning an account.

If the content is actually CSAM, then I imagine a provider's hands are tied under US law at least. But algorithmically flagged CSAM has a confidence percentage associated with it. A provider is not legally obligated to deny you archival access to video of a kid's pool party given a false positive flag by a scanning algo.

Then there are lots of other reasons that an account may end up banned where archival access doesn't necessarily have to be problematic. For example, there's no reason to take away access to completely original COVID denialist videos, even if the platform decides that it's not going to allow them to be shared.

Re:Tell HN: YouTube and how my wife lost 7 years of work by alienbeast on Saturday February 19, 2022 @11:40PM (#30403261)
Solution: A button that says "Click here to pay $5 for a human to review your situation."
Re:Tell HN: YouTube and how my wife lost 7 years of work by Tozen on Sunday February 20, 2022 @07:23PM (#30410593)
Good idea. Not sure why YouTube/Google doesn't do it. As you would think there is good money in it and better user relations. Possibly they like the authoritarian algorithm approach, and feel they are making enough money, so don't need to bother with alternatives or "lowly user" issues.
Re:Tell HN: YouTube and how my wife lost 7 years of work by charcircuit on Saturday February 19, 2022 @11:38PM (#30403257)
YouTube can undelete accounts. All of their old videos are still there.
Re:Tell HN: YouTube and how my wife lost 7 years of work by Ekaros on Saturday February 19, 2022 @06:58PM (#30401768)
I wonder how that would work, after certain amount of data or time period. For reasonable cost ship a tape archive or similar to customer?
Re:Tell HN: YouTube and how my wife lost 7 years of work by rectang on Saturday February 19, 2022 @07:09PM (#30401825)
For most services (certainly for Google) the cost of long-term storage isn't the main issue — it's the cost of supporting an appeals process when you have to deal with bad actors and legal complexities. We have to overcome the economics and legalities and make it feasible to provide download of the archived materials even after an account gets banned.

Brainstorming an interface, I can imaging "archive your original source materials" as an upsell alongside the YouTube upload, with an option to archive the actual video file as well. This would actually be enabled if you were to subscribe to the archival service, which would be paid in advance. Perhaps we can argue that such files should be considered private materials rather than redistributed works, so not subject to copyright takedowns.

Re:Tell HN: YouTube and how my wife lost 7 years of work by Aunche on Saturday February 19, 2022 @06:31PM (#30401579)
YouTube isn't a cloud storage service, let alone one a paid one. I'm not really sure what you'd expect them to do. If they lost access to their free Google drive I'd be more sympathetic.
Re:Tell HN: YouTube and how my wife lost 7 years of work by fouc on Saturday February 19, 2022 @07:10PM (#30401828)
It kind of is. If it looks like a duck and walks like a duck, then we can effectively treat it like a duck, even if it denies it in the legalese.