News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by micromacrofoot on Thursday February 17, 2022 @11:20AM (#30374795)
If the US wants meaningful housing reform they need to severely limit corporate real estate investment.
Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by rhino369 on Thursday February 17, 2022 @11:23AM (#30374840)
First we need to realize that rising home "value" just means rising prices. Our policy is to essentially make housing more expensive since pre-existing home owners benefit.
Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by micromacrofoot on Thursday February 17, 2022 @11:44AM (#30375196)
Sure, I don't think individual homeowners are the enemy... it's the large investors that treat housing stock like gold to lock away in a safe. Some large investors don't even operate as landlords (which is another industry that could use a cap), they'll buy new units in managed buildings and keep them vacant.
Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by chrisseaton on Thursday February 17, 2022 @12:36PM (#30376049)
> First we need to realize that rising home "value" just means rising prices.

Genuine value of a property often raises.

For example access to a new train station.

Access to a school that starts performing better.

Features that people want where the supply is going down.

Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by rootusrootus on Thursday February 17, 2022 @11:28AM (#30374918)
It's also probably too late to really do anything about it, other than try to slow it down. A price crash would help people who want to buy their first home, but it would bring also fair amount of economic devastation along for the ride.
Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by brink on Thursday February 17, 2022 @11:33AM (#30374996)
Unaffordable homes _is_ economic devastation. How are new generations supposed to prosper when they cannot afford a place to live?
Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by swagasaurus-rex on Thursday February 17, 2022 @11:49AM (#30375286)
It's like saying affordable healthcare is economic devastation because insurance companies and hospitals will lose profits.

It's completely ignoring the massive wealth drain on the average American. There's an enormous opportunity cost.

Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by fancifalmanima on Thursday February 17, 2022 @12:58PM (#30376344)
Don't something like 65% of Americans own their homes? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Home-ownership_in_the_United_S...

Realistically, we're in a place where significant prices increases (which has happened, obviously ) and a significant price drop would both have a significant economic impact. Both groups (home owners, and renters) are large. And while a chunk of people that own homes are investors, there are a ton of people that own their home and pretty much depend on selling and capturing the equity in the future for either their next house or retirement. Many of those people are just middle class folks, well into the fat part of the bell curve. Obviously on the flip side, more expensive homes makes it more difficult for new homeowners to buy in, and break out of the renting cycle, build equity, build wealth, etc, etc, and that's also bad. Just wanted to point out the flip side of it.

Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by rootusrootus on Thursday February 17, 2022 @02:05PM (#30377189)
Are you going to reset the mortgages for all the Americans who already own their home? Give them rebates if they've already paid it off?

I get that this seems like an unpopular observation on HN. But still, any significant price reset on real estate in the US would cause a LOT of people to lose a huge amount of their net worth. And if they recently bought their first home, they will then be massively underwater with all of the negatives that brings.

It's pretty easy to say that only investors are going to lose, without appreciating that you're advocating for destroying more than half the population in order to provide a better future for the remainder. Think of a better plan.

Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by onion2k on Thursday February 17, 2022 @11:42AM (#30375164)
A price crash would help people who want to buy their first home...

It absolutely wouldn't because first time buyers would still be competing with investors, except the investors would be able to buy properties in cash with no need to spend time arranging mortgages, and with guarantees that they won't need to drop out of the sale because it'd happen so fast, which would be very appealing to sellers. Plus, investors would still be able to outbid private buyers no matter even if prices are lower. Everything about selling a house favors selling to an investor (apart from morality maybe).

At this point a house price crash without legislation to block corporate investment in housing stock would likely see a massive shift of ownership from individuals to corporations.

Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by chordalkeyboard on Thursday February 17, 2022 @11:31AM (#30374958)
not really, a price correction would just reset prices to where they belong.
Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by adamsmith143 on Thursday February 17, 2022 @11:59AM (#30375444)
And put countless people into upside down mortgages as well as give investors/corporations an even bigger incentive to grab properties at a premium discount.
Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by ethagknight on Thursday February 17, 2022 @11:23AM (#30374841)
Homestead tax abatements are common. Owner-occupant's primary residence gets a big RE tax break, second homes and investment properties pay full freight. That works pretty well.
Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by gregwebs on Thursday February 17, 2022 @11:33AM (#30374986)
My homestead deduction is a few hundred dollars a year while I pay thousands on property taxes every month. Rental properties are still eligible for all kinds of tax write-offs. I think the bigger issue is that the government is there to support the mortgage of those buying multiple properties. The low mortgage rate relative to high inflation rate is the underlying financial that makes the housing market a very attractive investment right now. Taking away government subsidies for low mortgage rates for investors would radically alter the market.
Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by abofh on Thursday February 17, 2022 @11:54AM (#30375368)
This, when I lived in my apartment, I'd save 300$/year on 10k of property taxes. When I rented it, I got a 30k/yr deduction for depreciation - between that and rent, it basically pays for itself right out of the gate as long as I have the income to use the deductions.
Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by wing-_-nuts on Thursday February 17, 2022 @04:51PM (#30379174)
Don't you have to pay back that depreciation when you sell unless you enter some kind of complicated 1030 agreement?
Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by _rtld_global_ro on Thursday February 17, 2022 @05:30PM (#30379569)
You can use 1031 exchange to avoid that.
Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by micromacrofoot on Thursday February 17, 2022 @11:39AM (#30375108)
I live in one of these areas and I can tell you that it's not working well enough. Investment properties still dominate the market. New buildings go up with vacant investment units. Investors pay cash over asking price for existing housing.
Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by iancmceachern on Thursday February 17, 2022 @11:30AM (#30374950)
And I've heard this on HN before - we cannot simultaneously have affordable housing and look at housing as an investment.
Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by micromacrofoot on Thursday February 17, 2022 @11:54AM (#30375372)
Can't housing still be an investment for owner-occupants while investment companies are disincentivized from buying every available property in competitive housing markets?

By limiting investors you'd likely slow down an individual's appreciation on housing as an investment, but I can't imagine it would disappear entirely.

Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by ska on Thursday February 17, 2022 @12:10PM (#30375641)
> Can't housing still be an investment for owner-occupants while investment companies are disincentivized from buying every available property in competitive housing markets?

Not really effectively. There are two big problems.

The most fundamental is: If you have a good return on your house (outstrips inflation by a decent amount) and wages stay flat (actually it's been worse than that recently) - who do you think is going to be your buyer 20,30 years on?

The other: You can't effectively keep rich people and institutions out if the ROI is good enough. If their money doesn't have a better place to go, it will end up here some how.

Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by bpodgursky on Thursday February 17, 2022 @11:28AM (#30374915)
No, we just need to build more housing.
Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by deepnotderp on Thursday February 17, 2022 @12:11PM (#30375659)
1. Those who own houses as an investment have an incentive to block new housing construction. So ending RE as an investment helps accelerate laxer zoning laws.

2. There’s a limit to how much housing can be built in an area, but no limit to the leveraged purchasing power of an investor.

If you look at high density property markets around the world such as several Asian cities and NYC, I think it’s clear that more construction alone can’t stop price increases due to speculation.

Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by bpodgursky on Thursday February 17, 2022 @01:43PM (#30376912)
Tokyo has in fact stopped price increases by building a ton.

NYC is a good example of my original point; NYC barely builds any housing in a proportion to their existing housing stock, and they aren't even that dense outside of Manhattan!

Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by mperham on Thursday February 17, 2022 @11:32AM (#30374973)
And that means federal reform to municipal zoning codes, which are the primary driver of suburban sprawl. It should be legal to replace any single family home with a quadplex.

Oregon did it at the state level in 2019 with HB2001.

Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by staticman2 on Thursday February 17, 2022 @11:35AM (#30375029)
The federal government lacks the authority to regulate zoning, an amendment to the constitution would be required, and a constitutional amendment would be virtually impossible to pass.
Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by mperham on Thursday February 17, 2022 @11:37AM (#30375083)
That's easy to fix. The feds just say "You won't get $20 billion in infrastructure grants unless you do X" and suddenly zoning reform is on the table. Like so:

https://www.usatoday.com/in-depth/news/nation/2021/04/14/zon...

Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by nathanaldensr on Thursday February 17, 2022 @11:57AM (#30375406)
Your definition of "easy" is interesting.
Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by colpabar on Thursday February 17, 2022 @11:31AM (#30374955)
We do need more housing, but what’s stopping these same investors from buying it all up?
Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by zwieback on Thursday February 17, 2022 @11:33AM (#30375000)
They are only buying it up because prices are rising so fast. More housing would mean more stable home prices, which makes the sector less attractive to investors.
Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by mikeg8 on Thursday February 17, 2022 @11:37AM (#30375084)
No, they’re buying them up because rates are so low it costs them little to borrow/buy.
Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by bpodgursky on Thursday February 17, 2022 @11:50AM (#30375301)
They wouldn't be buying houses if houses weren't an appreciating asset. Let's change that.
Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by cannonpalms on Thursday February 17, 2022 @12:54PM (#30376297)
Just to be clear, we shouldn't throw the baby out with the bathwater. Houses can and should be appreciating assets. However, their rate of return shouldn't be as astronomical as they are at present. In inflationary environments, money will always flock to real estate. That shouldn't change.

The goal of increasing supply is to lower returns to such a point that they remain attractive to first-time buyers but are suboptimal for the institutional investor.

Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by bpodgursky on Thursday February 17, 2022 @01:44PM (#30376926)
Why should houses be an appreciating asset?

Cars are an expensive depreciating asset, and the car economy works just fine.

Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by oldsecondhand on Thursday February 17, 2022 @01:08PM (#30376480)
You still haven't given a reason why they should be appreciating assets.
Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by mperham on Thursday February 17, 2022 @11:35AM (#30375040)
Supply and demand. Keep building. It works for Tokyo.
Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by deepnotderp on Thursday February 17, 2022 @12:16PM (#30375747)
Tokyo had a massive real estate bubble driven by speculation. It’s also seen weak population growth in the recent past, so it’s unclear whether it can be generalized.
Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by renewiltord on Thursday February 17, 2022 @08:50PM (#30381246)
That's the thing, we just keep building and selling to them, and then we take that money and build more. Eventually they'll run out but the state is never going to run out since it can just make more money.
Re:Investors bought a record share of U.S. homes in 2021 by micromacrofoot on Thursday February 17, 2022 @11:37AM (#30375088)
You can try to solve a problem on more than one front. Zoning is a huge and fractured problem that will take decades and decades to solve at scale, if it happens at all. We need to be trying more than one thing.