But yeah, "it violates HTTP!" is hardly the best argument against "frictionless sharing" :)
JavaScript in modern web apps has made the distinction between GET and other HTTP methods irrelevant to users. Simply changing these "frictionless sharing" apps to use POST instead of GET doesn't address anyone's concerns.
That said, at least FB requires you to approve this. Ads have been doing this kind of thing for a while now, and i'm not sure how I feel about it (I recently was browsing for pictures on art.com and didn't end up buying anything, but for the next month everywhere I went on the web was showing me the exact pictures I had been browsing).
The author points to something that we're going to loose (or perhaps that we already lost). Now, ads are the only nasty thing that break the guaranty of side-effect-free GET requests. And this is the only thing that matters for geeks and non geeks.
A human-oriented rant would say: "When you visit a page, you don't have to worry about other parties knowing it because it's guaranteed that way. This is about to change. Act now." As far as I'm concerned, it means the same thing. This is HN, not TechCrunch..
I'm not sure if you only mean "your friends" when you say "other parties", but there are plenty of people that already know when you visit a site (ad-tracking).
Besides, "it violates http get" is still a horrible argument.
Well said! I'm not against frictionless sharing myself (different can of worms, not for this thread) but I'm glad to see another person look at this objectively.
Any site that uses SOAP violates HTTP (use POST also for GET-style requests). Any site that has delete links (as opposed to buttons) violate HTTP (barring onclick ajax action, that is). The big mega bucketload of sites violating HTTP this way (GET having severe side effects) is the very reason offline browsing and prefetching never took off much. Every site that uses comet very much violates HTTP.
This is no "message to the future to Mark Zuckerberg". It's just using the available tools for the job to their limits.
Note, I'm just as much against the whole frictionless sharing thing as most people here. But the moment we allow geek nonsense like this to overtake the real arguments is the moment the world will stop taking it seriously. This is what happened to the net neutrality debate ("net neutrality"? who made up that term? how will i ever make my mom care about that?), let's not let it happen here.