News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by lolinder on Sunday February 13, 2022 @12:51PM (#30323735)
This comment and its top reply are dead on:

https://old.reddit.com/r/cscareerquestions/comments/sm54ri/a...

No job is going to get you away from unreasonable people with unreasonable expectations, and most trades introduce a bunch of other unpleasant things that you'd have to deal with.

It's all tradeoffs. Someone may legitimately prefer the stresses of a trade to the stresses of working in software, and that's great for them. But it's not an objectively easier path: if it were, plumbers would be much less expensive.

Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by bartread on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:04PM (#30323908)
I agree. I work in tech and, outside of work, I'm refurbishing my house. I'm enjoying the refurbishment but would I do a trade as a full time job? Hell no.

Crawling around in my loft sistering joists is satisfying work but also, if it were to become the kind of thing I did over a long period of time, would 100% wreck my knees.

And that's just one downside. There are plenty more: e.g., all the ancillary guff you have to do (same as you have with contracting really), and then dealing with the general public and having people phone you at all hours of the day and night looking for estimates and quotes. No thanks.

Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by ElKrist on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:33PM (#30324215)
I share your view about making estimates and quotes.

I get contractors to my house to help me renovate. It's just standard practice to get multiple tradesmen (>=3) to make a quote for the same job. I do that whenever the job is above $5000. I assume they must have a lot of other clients who do the same for lower thresholds too. I don't know the margins in each trade but I guess at least half of the quote is costs?

For the transport, the time on-site, the time to make a quote (depends a lot on the job).. I believe they each spend at least half a day on this. Then you add various time-consuming items like phone calls, people canceling appointments, people changing their minds about what they want, time to chase unpaid invoices, dealing with other tradesmen on some projects... All of this for a 1/3 chance of getting the job ?

Clearly some tradesmen are doing very well, but let's not pretend it's easy. As a contractor in software, I realized quickly I could and would only bill on a time-based approach. I've gone through the hassle of making a quote for a project with a lot of uncertainties and spanning over multiple months. At the end the client played with my weakness of being still quite young. He was older and much more experienced in legal & contract matters so he kept adding items pretending my contract was not fulfilled otherwise.. I ended up OK but would never go back to that anymore

Now I only have to negotiate once or twice a year (with my latest and ongoing client it's been multiple years so even better) when tradesmen have to do that multiple times a week

Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by otachack on Monday February 14, 2022 @11:32AM (#30333993)
Ditto on the contract experience you had where you gave a rough project-wide estimate. I had the exact same position. I didn't end up finishing the contract because the client refused to fulfill their end of the first, and only, contract.

If I ever get another contract I'll be doing it your way: time-based via a settled hourly rate.

Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by jaclaz on Monday February 14, 2022 @06:53AM (#30330926)
>I don't know the margins in each trade but I guess at least half of the quote is costs?

Costs are likely more 80-85% in building/construction, margins are thin.

Electricians/plumbers may have something more, but not much.

Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by user3939382 on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:12PM (#30323982)
Get yourself a pair of these https://www.amazon.com/dp/B001P30BQE/

I use them all the time. Cable management under desks, tile work, electrical. I wonder how I went so long without them.

Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by bartread on Monday February 14, 2022 @06:31PM (#30340059)
Thanks for the recommendation. Believe it or not I have a pair of exactly those but unfortunately I hate them because they rub my knees nearly raw when worn for prolonged periods. In the end I've bought an old skool rubber kneeler, which seems to work better, but of course you have to continually move it around, which isn't always convenient (or even possible).
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by SenHeng on Monday February 14, 2022 @05:11AM (#30330276)
I've done the same time. Spent nights and weekends remodeling my home over 5 years. It was never 'finished', and the quality was never as good as the bits that I did hire out. The entire time I felt like I was living in a construction site.

When I got my 2nd home, I hired pros. The pros tell me they want their kids in my job.

Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by letitbeirie on Monday February 14, 2022 @07:03AM (#30331000)
Most things "simple living" - working with your hands, living off the land, camping, etc. - are only enjoyable if they're optional.
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by brightball on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:29PM (#30324168)
Yep. I got burned out at one point and got my real estate license. I was going to go into commercial real estate and build a residential website in my spare time.

Good grief what a scheme that entire field is. If I wanted access to residential MLS data I was going to have to be a residential realtor. To be a residential realtor you have to work for a broker who will charge you monthly for the pleasure. You have to put the name of the brokerage on any site that uses the data even if you pay for it yourself. You also have to pay for each MLS you want to access.

If you want to start your own brokerage you have to get a brokerage license. To do that you have to have your real estate license for 3 years and take the brokerage class. There’s nothing you actually have to do during that 3 years other than maintain your license.

Seeing the profession from the inside was eye opening and I’ve been extremely happy getting to enjoy being in an unlicensed profession ever since.

Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by scythe on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:35PM (#30324232)
The National Association of Realtors donated $44M to political candidates last year, the second-largest contributor overall.

https://www.opensecrets.org/federal-lobbying/top-spenders

Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by 01100011 on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:20PM (#30324085)
An old, cynical engineer I once worked with left me with two indelible quotes:

- If it was fun they'd charge money at the door.

- If you can't write it down you can't do it.

You can argue about the accuracy of those ideas, but more or less I've found them to be true.

Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by openknot on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:30PM (#30324182)
>- If it was fun they'd charge money at the door.

I'm not sure if 'fun' is the right descriptor, but certain fields of work with relatively high prestige and supply of applicants but relatively low credential requirements (in comparison to credentialed professions like law or medicine) pay little or almost charge money.

Examples include journalism (very low paying, limited jobs in North America), museum curation (requiring many years of low-paid, unpaid internship; most people can't afford it), and many creative fields (e.g. graphic designers are, in my view, paid very low comparative to the skill and creativity they bring; creative writers often have to pay to submit to a literary journal; and video game developers are notoriously overworked/underpaid, compared to other types of software developers).

Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by ReactiveJelly on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:25PM (#30324124)
> If it was fun they'd charge money at the door.

I've told people that at my work and had it said back to me later.

"If it was fun, it wouldn't be work." Also, I leave after 40 hours each week because there will never be a day when the work ends early. If we run out of work, it's because the company is sinking.

Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by sneakymichael on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:28PM (#30324157)
"If you can't write it down you can't do it." - elaborate?
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by itronitron on Sunday February 13, 2022 @03:31PM (#30325335)
I think this might have two, maybe more meanings. The first is that if the person asking you to do something won't put it in writing, then it's probably not legal and therefore you can't do it. The second is that if you haven't thought through something well enough to write it down (the problem and the solution) then you haven't thought about it long enough to have found a solution.
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by ByThyGrace on Sunday February 13, 2022 @03:37PM (#30325405)
Maybe it means that the ability to spell out the entirety of the work process is an indication of the ability to fulfill the task.
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by JKCalhoun on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:27PM (#30324155)
Stresses of a trade? Never "plumbed" professionally, so I can't speak from experience. But from other non-software jobs I have had, I know it was easy to "leave work at work".

Software development followed me home, lived in my brain 24/7. It also caused a good deal of stress I was unaware of at the time.

Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by s1artibartfast on Sunday February 13, 2022 @03:43PM (#30325471)
I think the ease of leaving work at work is probably a better proxy for age and commitment to your job. If you know it is a short term job or career, it is easy to leave there.

If you need the job, you start to care. Even with manual labor, there are problems that didn't get solved that need to be worked out before 7 AM tomorrow. I would say it is even harder to leave it at work. If a pipe breaks, and water is pouring out, sleeping on it isnt an option

Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by psbp on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:03PM (#30323888)
The levels of stress aren't that much different, but there's something more practical about the stresses of labor jobs that make them a bit more manageable in my experience. Only in software jobs have I had persistent, constant stress that never seems to let up and consumes my weekends. It's a skill to manage it, but it's definitely part of the job.
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by rakamotog on Sunday February 13, 2022 @12:59PM (#30323841)
I opened comments to reply the same comment from Reddit. Grass always feels greener on the other side.
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by nelblu on Sunday February 13, 2022 @03:15PM (#30325171)
100% this. I have been renovating my house for the past few months, room by room. It is fun on some days and not so much on other days. It can even be stressful when you can't figure out certain corners, or end up with leaks etc. I have contemplated started renovation as a side business, but having spoken to independent contractors I have figured it isn't all that much lucrative. There are even assholes who won't pay you at all.
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by mrwnmonm on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:12PM (#30323990)
What about teaching? Or becoming a Youtuber?
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by tonyedgecombe on Monday February 14, 2022 @06:53AM (#30330933)
I did a maths degree with the Open University. Most of the students are adults and sometimes it seemed half were programmers wanting to become teachers and the other half were teachers wanting to become programmers.
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by kd0amg on Sunday February 13, 2022 @02:06PM (#30324547)
Teaching isn't likely to get you away from unreasonable people with unreasonable expectations.
[dead]
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by hodgesrm on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:06PM (#30323919)
Hey! What's wrong with BMWs? We have two of them. Both diesels. The gas mileage is slightly below amazing. (Though my lawyer says you should always buy them used, never new. He's very good on life advice in general.)
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by nixgeek on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:21PM (#30324093)
They’re incredible, in slow traffic I have no issue fitting into a space which is only 12” bigger than the BMW is in length terms, and everyone around me is impressed, particularly the driver behind, they often gesture congratulations about these feats

In all seriousness though after a few years driving a Tesla it is a stark contrast, the BMW’s are actually well-manufactured, very quiet in the cabin, tactile controls instead of touchscreens. I’d forgotten what a good car behaved and looked like instead of an early-adopter plastic-fantastic interior and technology stack. Really do think with “Big Auto” starting to figure out bEV and things like F-150 Lightning, BMW iX and more coming to the market, Tesla is not looking like a solid safe equity to be holding in a 5 year time horizon.

Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by civilized on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:24PM (#30324114)
You're making a surprisingly persuasive case. Maybe it's time for me to become an asshole too.
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by blowfish721 on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:13PM (#30324001)
BMW’s are great cars, used to have one. But somehow their turn signals never seem to work.
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by civilized on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:17PM (#30324041)
The wheel and the gas work super well though. Maybe too well.
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by tonyedgecombe on Monday February 14, 2022 @06:41AM (#30330860)
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by granshaw on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:41PM (#30324287)
Not sure if that was a sarcastic reply but if not You’re missing the point - which was that these fools will often be better paid and more well off than you :)
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by Tijdreiziger on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:01PM (#30323862)
That's why I don't own a car. :P
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by Simon_O_Rourke on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:13PM (#30323997)
It had to be said because it's largely correct!

https://www.financialexpress.com/auto/car-news/psychopaths-d...

Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by tonyedgecombe on Monday February 14, 2022 @06:51AM (#30330917)
I know it's anecdotal but I found that I turned into an arsehole when I owned a german car.

The cars are generally quiet and comfortable, they insulate you from the outside world. The dealership will treat you better than the typical garage because they can afford to. Your work colleagues will fawn over it even though they think you are a bit of a knob. You will get more attention from the opposite sex because they think you have more money. I even read that estate agents find selling houses with a german car in the drive easier.

From that it's easy to slip into thinking you are a very important person and that the plebs should just get out of your way.

Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by artemonster on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:05PM (#30323913)
I like how in our progressive society it is absolutely frowned upon to invoke any association between observable societal statistics and, say, race/gender, but its okay to bash BMW/audi drivers. So, user civilized, why is it okay for you to generalize? And why exactly you were sorry? (I am aware that this is a tangent discussion to the original post, but it may be an interesting one)
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by openknot on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:36PM (#30324244)
The comedic term is "punching up" [0]. It's generally more acceptable to make jokes about the (presumably) wealthy owners of BMWs and Audis, versus "punching down" by making fun of people who comparatively face more disadvantages.

[0] Urban Dictionary: https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Punch%20Up

Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by brnaftr361 on Sunday February 13, 2022 @02:17PM (#30324647)
If we use the punching metaphor, in either case one is committing an act of "violence", which I think most people would acede is negative at least in the large scheme of things.
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by openknot on Sunday February 13, 2022 @02:37PM (#30324828)
Violence has different definitions, according to the Oxford English Dictionary [0].

One is: "1. a. The deliberate exercise of physical force against a person, property, etc.; physically violent behaviour or treatment; (Law) the unlawful exercise of physical force, intimidation by the exhibition of such force." Another definition is: "4. Vehemence or intensity of emotion, behaviour, or language; extreme fervour; passion."

That the first definition is inherently negative is a separate philosophical discussion (as quick counter-examples where violence may not be negative, consider the violence of a fencing or martial arts match). However, it is clear that "punching up" in this case refers to definition four. I believe that most would agree that intensity of emotion or language is not inherently or necessarily a negative behaviour.

[0] Current quoted version is paywalled, but older 1989 edition for reference (may have differences from the quoted version): https://www.oed.com/oed2/00277885

Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by grogenaut on Sunday February 13, 2022 @02:15PM (#30324624)
I can afford a BMW, I've chosen not to buy one. In 08, I technically bought one in a Mini. But it was better MPG (very good for the time), fun, and cute. My buddy has a fast BMW, 2x the price. He got real mad when he drove the mini when he realized that the grand tour guys are right, hot hatches are pretty fun. He was blowing through $1500 in tires every year or so as well. I told him he got the bmw cause he's a dbag and a defense lawyer. He agreed that he is a dbag and he needed to show off as a lawyer. Every one of my friends who has a BMW would agree they care about appearences and are a bit of a dbag, I have about 10 from college/highschool/the neighborhood. So I'd be making fun of myself or my friends.

Personally I want multiple fun to drive vehicles. But I'd also rather have a CNC mill sharing space a motorcycle in the garage instead of a car I'm wiping with a diaper for the same price.

It's also quite common and a source of fun in many communities to make fun of the other brand. Many of these jokes are great at summarizing why people buy a thing. Ford vs Chevy. It can also get bit annoying and detract from what would otherwise be a useful conversation. "Fix Or Repair Daily" isn't very helpful. However "yamaha bike owners ask which valve head shims to buy, bmw owners ask which dealer is the most reputable" is a good description of the mindset for those respective brands, and the what the owners are looking for. Case in point, many BMWs only have an oil low sensor. How low? drain it and measure the volume, no dip stick. This carried over to my mini (bmw made), when the low oil light came on it was at .75 of 4 quarts, basically empty and damaging itself, and the dipstick is almost unreadable except in bright sunlight, but it's sure stylish.

Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by pwython on Sunday February 13, 2022 @03:39PM (#30325424)
Wow. You're all over the place with this comment dude.

> "Every one of my friends who has a BMW would agree they care about appearences and are a bit of a dbag, I have about 10..."

I would seriously reconsider who is the dbag among your 10 BMW friends. The people that care about what car someone drives are the ones venting about their buddies spending money on tires and quarts of oil online. Unless I missed the part where they made fun of your self-described "cute" Mini Cooper. Some people like quick cars, or cars that look nice.

Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by grogenaut on Sunday February 13, 2022 @03:59PM (#30325625)
Almost of these comments are from my friend about the his own driving habits with the car. It's his money he can blow through tires if he wants. He's the one calling himself a dbag. I think he's got redeeming qualities and some insecurities, it's why he's still a friend.
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by pwython on Sunday February 13, 2022 @04:08PM (#30325699)
So it's 1 friend and not 10 that are self-proclaimed dbags. Well I guess add me to that list.

- BMW M4 dbag owner who drives like a normal person.

Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by grogenaut on Sunday February 13, 2022 @04:51PM (#30326026)
Me to one of the others when looking at college photos: "is that an affliction shirt"... Them "yeah I was kinda a dbag post college till I got married". me "wait is that a wristband, were you watching UFC pay per view"... them "actually, yes".

Do you need me to enumerate all of them for you? :)

Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by brnaftr361 on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:35PM (#30324233)
I do think that's a pretty interesting point. It's a weird move to sweep under the rug. I guess you could argue that having a BMW is a choice, and it has associated stereotypes, which we can infer is sort of like joining a club.

race/gender are probabilistic and unalterable, one doesn't necessarily elect to inherit the stereotypes associated with race/gender. You're essentially being delegated expectations that may or may not be in alignment with personal values.

There are definitely double-standards in play though, a sort of socio-cognitive warfare, I suppose.

Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by artemonster on Sunday February 13, 2022 @02:00PM (#30324489)
I am unsure whether the (im)mutability of a qualifier plays a role. For example, religion is a choice, but making generalized derogatory statements about certain religious groups is not okay either. You can try it with the pattern of "civilized" user: """Everywhere you go, there will be _men hitting their wivers_. Disproportionately they will be ..." and say sorry afterwards. You will be making a statistically correct statement, but you will be flagged and IRL punched in the face for saying that. But somehow saying that about BMW drivers is still allright?
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by kube-system on Sunday February 13, 2022 @02:14PM (#30324613)
Religion is a choice in the same way citizenship is a choice. Sometimes it is a choice, often you’re born into it, and you often have to meet qualifications to change it, and some of those may be impossible to meet. And your social environment may impose some significant expectations on you.
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by artemonster on Sunday February 13, 2022 @03:14PM (#30325163)
now you're trying to argue about a specifics of the example I've given. Its tangent to the main question: whether stereotyping on something that is a choice or inherent is different? If you say that it is, can you please elaborate?
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by kube-system on Sunday February 13, 2022 @04:08PM (#30325705)
Yes, it is different, but not in a boolean sort of way. It is impolite to make fun of people for something that is not their fault... and generally speaking, the degree to which it wasn't a choice (and the degree to which it impacts someone's life experience) contributes to the degree of impoliteness.
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by artemonster on Sunday February 13, 2022 @06:00PM (#30326457)
making fun of a group != inferring generalizing statements about a group. I am completely with you about "making fun" part, but this concrete example is different
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by civilized on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:08PM (#30323947)
I take care not to violate society's statistical taboos.
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by artemonster on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:18PM (#30324058)
Ah, allright, I think I got the pattern. Next time someone wants to: """Everywhere you go, there will be {insert derogatory but also statistically backed pattern} Disproportionately they will be {insert your -ist qualifier}""" You just have to say sorry and it will be okay?
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by civilized on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:26PM (#30324139)
Have you considered what you personally believe is right?

Why go around being an enforcer for social rules you don't even know if you believe in?

Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by artemonster on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:51PM (#30324399)
I personally believe in statistics and I believe you cannot use them to make derogatory generalizations. I mean racists REALLY love to pull out crime statistics out of their pockets in justification of their views. And, frankly, its not about my beliefs right now and enforcing of societal rules, its about you making derogatory generalizations and thinking that its okay, because "statistics" and because you've said sorry.
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by civilized on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:57PM (#30324457)
Well, I don't believe what you believe. I think you have an overly general moral rule that you think is necessary for consistency, but it's not really, and it's just your personal belief.

Your belief implies it is improper to use statistics to describe morally salient human behavior in any way, unless the conclusion is that there is no variation. I think that's silly and intellectually impoverishing. Groups have different average behavior and I don't see the point in blinding myself to that.

We all know that averages don't determine an individual, and we all know that some generalizations should be avoided, but that doesn't imply some broad fatwa, completely irrespective of context, against noting broad variations in group behavior.

The prosecutor attitude is very entertaining though. Feel free to keep doing that.

Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by artemonster on Sunday February 13, 2022 @02:16PM (#30324638)
I personally dont require that consistency, I was merely asking WHY there is a difference in treatment of the same method (making generalized statements about group behaviour) when applied to different qualifiers. And yes, just as you've said, maintaining that consistency does imply that you suddenly can't use any statistics at all.

Point taken on "prosecutor attitude", sorry about that. riding "moral high horse" got to my head.

Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by civilized on Sunday February 13, 2022 @02:22PM (#30324700)
It sounds like you don't believe what you just said you did? I'm genuinely asking what you believe, as opposed to what you assert for the sake of argument.

For me, it's not an easy topic but I would say when negative generalizations escalate to exclusion and dehumanization, that's probably where to draw the line.

I know some people with Audis and I don't think worse of them or anything like that. It's just a funny thing that's hard to ignore after a while on the road.

Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by artemonster on Sunday February 13, 2022 @03:03PM (#30325061)
Thank you for the insight on where you draw the line, that explains a lot. Still, a hard terrain to navigate on when you can say something and when you can't, even if you make correct statements backed up by data. Just to be clear we're on the same page: I've made absolutely same observation about other bmw drivers. and we, humans, do exactly that: observe and generalize.

Regarding my personal beliefs, as I've stated above "I personally believe in statistics and I believe you cannot use* them to make derogatory* generalizations"

1. regarding "use": you cannot use specifically statistics/data to justify any *-ist remark. "I hate bmw drivers because most of them are assholes on the road", an example of that (not what you said!)

2. regarding "derogatory": you can(and should!) use statistics to do (just) generalizations, i.e. in a context of talking about group behaviour. "most of bmw drivers are agressive and dangerous drivers, as shown by this data" is a perfectly fine statement.

My problem is that you can say that sort of statements about certain group of drivers, but if you would have pulled up a similar argument and used (for example) PoC and crime rates, you would have been torn to pieces by everyone. And for me, on the surface, the statement and the structure would be absolutely the same (and it is STILL not escalated to exclusion and dehumanization). So whats the difference? And why different treatment? People above are arguing that buying BMW its a choice and using inherent (immutable) properties (i.e. race/gender) is different for the case of stereotyping, but I cannot see the key difference that makes okay to do one and not okay to do another.

Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by civilized on Sunday February 13, 2022 @03:48PM (#30325523)
On the difference between making these generalizations along racial lines vs other things - it mostly comes down to the fact that our ancestors ruined the fun. After humanity had used certain type of statements to justify mass dehumanization, slavery, Holocaust, etc., people don't want to see that happen again. Then it's just a question of how big a red circle we want to draw around that kind of talk. Most people found a simple ban on racial generalizations relatively intuitive and practical. I'd prefer a more freewheeling culture but it's above my pay grade at this point.

Side point - in general an important thing to remember here is the big, big difference between P(A|B) and P(B|A). It could be the case that all aggressive drivers I ever encounter are BMW drivers, and yet the rate of aggressive BMW drivers could be very low and of little practical predictive value on any individual BMW driver (e.g. 1% of BMW drivers versus 0% for non-BMW drivers).

People are already bad at distinguishing an implication and its converse, and they're quite a bit worse at the statistical version of the same.

Arguably this is a reason we should keep our generalizations to ourselves, even if they're accurate. A lot of people will take them to mean a lot more than they do.

It's not my style, but I do recognize the risk.

Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by artemonster on Sunday February 13, 2022 @04:19PM (#30325783)
thank you for your explanations
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by TheCoelacanth on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:41PM (#30324293)
There's a big difference between stereotyping based on something someone was born with and stereotyping based on something they chose to buy.
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by artemonster on Sunday February 13, 2022 @03:12PM (#30325145)
That is my problem: I don't see that difference. Its still stereotyping. Can you explain how it makes different to stereotype based on choice or some inherent immutable property? Its the majority of asshole careless drivers (inherent immutable property) that _choose_ to buy a BMW that make up a statistic. Still the stereotype selects that group, not by their choice but by and because of their property (being an asshole careless driver).
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by JKCalhoun on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:33PM (#30324209)
You can choose whether to buy a BMW or not?
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by artemonster on Sunday February 13, 2022 @02:05PM (#30324536)
but having one does not make you an asshole driver
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by rudasn on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:04PM (#30323904)
Re:Anyone else feel the constant urge to leave the field and... by civilized on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:11PM (#30323975)
Damn, I nailed it. I had no idea, this was purely based on personal experience.