News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by colesantiago on Sunday February 13, 2022 @10:19AM (#30322213)
This just proves how insecure the blockchain / web3 / cryptocurrency space is.

It's good to see white hat hackers in this space trying to fix what is already broken.

But sorry to be that person, just a timely reminder of the truth: All cryptocurrencies and 'DeFi projects' are ponzi scams including Orchid.

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by __MatrixMan__ on Sunday February 13, 2022 @10:38AM (#30322357)
Do you think that a bank or a government would've handled fixing such a flaw as well has optimism did?

All tokenization schemes are ponzi scams including USD, it's just that some use violence to stay relevant, and other use bug bounties.

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by skizm on Sunday February 13, 2022 @10:48AM (#30322499)
Banks or stock exchanges would just revert any bad transactions like they do with most scams, thefts, or accidents. It is built into the current system by design.
Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by __MatrixMan__ on Sunday February 13, 2022 @10:56AM (#30322571)
They revert the money (if they like you), but usually if money flows one way, something else flows the other way, and they can't revert that half of the fraudulent transactions without great expenditure. Often it's not worth it and they just write it off and the whole economy bears the cost.

I'm not saying it's a better or worse plan than whatever might happen under an alternative system, but just that it's not exactly a clean solution either.

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by encoderer on Sunday February 13, 2022 @11:57AM (#30323171)
Just imagine for a second if there was a bug in the US Treasury that let anybody order the treasury to print new money and deliver it to their bank account. That would rightly be seen as total incompetence by the treasury and cast doubts on the soundness of the entire monetary system.

But with ETH we have the community patting themselves on the back for it. It’s madness.

You are making a false equivalency when you compare crypto with usd.

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by solean on Sunday February 13, 2022 @02:38PM (#30324830)
Are you sure there doesn't exist such a bug in the US Treasury? They would never in a million years let the public know if an exploit occurred, there's zero transparency
Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by NovemberWhiskey on Sunday February 13, 2022 @11:49AM (#30323099)
I think your premise is fundamentally wrong there. Say I buy something my credit card but it's never delivered. My bank will reverse that transaction - exactly because half of the transaction never occurred.

The way that the credit card system works in the US is fundamentally biased towards consumer protection, because that's an explicit policy objective. The same with the Direct Debit guarantee in the UK, or the various laws which limit the maximum exposure due to fraudulent use of payment cards.

And when exchanges break trades, they undo the entire transaction - you don't end up with one party out cash or shares.

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by __MatrixMan__ on Sunday February 13, 2022 @12:18PM (#30323382)
The lack of agility shows up when I buy something with your credit card number. It gets delivered, and then the bank reverses the transaction because they later learn that I'm not you.

Now I get a bank-subsidized thing and you're not missing any money. It creates a drag on the whole economy, because instead of doing productive work to get the thing, it's often easier to play games with the system.

The fact that credit cards use a symmetric key to authorize spend is a glaring flaw. The technology to fix it (asymmetric key cryptography) has been around for decades. But instead of fixing it, the credit card companies just keep writing off the instances of fraud.

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by NovemberWhiskey on Sunday February 13, 2022 @12:43PM (#30323650)
In the situation you describe, the one who is "out" is the merchant. In the card-not-present situation, the merchant has the option to use tools like CVV and address validation to reduce the risk in the transaction, and always has the option to decline a transaction that seems risky.

That seems, to me, like a sensible risk balancing approach. In the cryptocurrency "all sales are final" world - you're the loser. I don't really see that the economic drag is larger one way or the other.

AFAIK the use of symmetric key cryptography in card capture and payment processing is not in any way a significant factor in payment card fraud - where do you get that information from?

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by __MatrixMan__ on Sunday February 13, 2022 @04:18PM (#30325762)
Whether it's the merchant or the bank that's left holding the bag often depends on the particulars like whether it was a chip or a magstripe transaction, but the larger point is that in card-not-present scenarios you can't pay once without also exposing secrets that allow whoever gets them to make subsequent transactions without your permission.

Better would be to have whatever secret authorizes spend (private key) be separate from the account identifier (public key) and to push money, rather than sharing a symmetric secret which authorizes whoever has it to pull money.

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by jollybean on Sunday February 13, 2022 @10:47AM (#30322485)
"Do you think that a bank or a government would've handled fixing such a flaw as well has optimism did?"

It's irrelevant. We don't use 'algorithms as ownership' in the real world. We use social agreements like contract law to undo problems.

"All tokenization schemes are ponzi scams including USD, it's just that some use violence to stay relevant, and other use bug bounties."

We use the law to maintain civil infrastructure. Yes, if someone wants to murder you or someone else, or launder billions, we'll use violence to stop them.

An algorithm that is effectively used as a Pyramid Scheme is not going to save your from anything.

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by __MatrixMan__ on Sunday February 13, 2022 @12:07PM (#30323270)
It can take years for contract law to get in front of a judge and be enforced, often the damage that can be done in that interval is significant. So I think they timeliness is indeed relevant.

As for your murder comment, I'm not saying that violence is strictly unnecessary, just that the coincidence of "we have the guns" with "we issue the ponzi tokens" is probably not the only way to enforce the law.

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by CRConrad on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @07:20PM (#30354815)
> the coincidence of "we have the guns" with "we issue the ponzi tokens" is probably not the only way to enforce the law.

Not "the only way", perhaps, but AFAICS the only way that makes sense. Sure, "the law is an ass" and "the querns of law grind exceedingly slow" and all that... But still, it's the worst alternative except for having no law, right?

So if you want the rule of law, the law needs to have the biggest guns. And why would anyone want anyone but the law to issue the tokens of lawful commerce?

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by colesantiago on Sunday February 13, 2022 @10:49AM (#30322507)
I have no problem with white hat hackers, I'm saying more power to them in the broken web3 space, which that is a complete scam.

However, I can use USD, GBP or any fiat currency in my local grocery store.

Can I use Bitcoin, Shib, Doge, or even Orchid at my grocery store without waiting hours in the queue for the transaction to complete and no huge fees?

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by __MatrixMan__ on Sunday February 13, 2022 @11:05AM (#30322655)
Not yet, but I don't think that we're too far away from using USD, GBP or any fiat currency as a unit of account at the POS and letting software handle ensuring that the buyer loses whatever assets they want to pay in and the seller receives whatever assets they want to be paid in.

But that's orthogonal to how quickly the maintainers of these tokens can make changes in response to threats.

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by colesantiago on Sunday February 13, 2022 @11:15AM (#30322742)
So no then?

Over a decade later and I still cannot use any of them at the restaurant or without waiting in the queue for the transaction to settle and paying more for the fees than the goods itself.

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by __MatrixMan__ on Sunday February 13, 2022 @11:26AM (#30322844)
It took 100 years for steam engines to start outperforming horses, why is it so damning that crypto isn't yet outperforming fiat after a decade and change?
Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by CRConrad on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @07:26PM (#30354863)
Please stop using "crypto" and "fiat" as if they were opposites. "Crypto" is just as "fiat" as any Royal Mint; it's just that the fiat-ers[1] are different people. They just want to muscle in on the "make the tokens that everyone else's transactions are counted in" business niche, because they reckon the makers can always somehow skim a bit off the top.

___

[1]: lit. "makers": "Fiat" is Latin for "let there be made", a form of the verb "to make". It's a cognate of modern French "faire", Italian "fare", etc. (Related words are "fact" and "factory".)

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by Aeolun on Sunday February 13, 2022 @12:05PM (#30323254)
> But that's orthogonal to how quickly the maintainers of these tokens can make changes in response to threats.

Never mind that the entire threat class doesn’t exist in traditional finance?

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by tenuousemphasis on Sunday February 13, 2022 @11:27AM (#30322857)
Bitcoin has a system built on top of it called Lightning, which allows for millions of cheap transactions per second inside of payment channels. Only the opening and closing of channels requires a transaction on the blockchain.
Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by colesantiago on Sunday February 13, 2022 @12:24PM (#30323451)
Lightning isn't really using Bitcoin is it?

The strike app (which uses Lightning) is not available worldwide which really doesn't give the image that Bitcoin lightning is decentralised at all.

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by tenuousemphasis on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @02:28PM (#30351415)
It is, all Lightning transactions are valid Bitcoin transactions. Strike merely uses the Lightning network, similar to how Coinbase uses the Bitcoin network. Coinbase and Strike aren't available everywhere, but Bitcoin and Lightning is.
Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by aspenmayer on Sunday February 13, 2022 @04:45PM (#30325987)
Anyone can run their own Bitcoin and/or Lightning node. Both Bitcoin and Lightning Network are totally decentralized.
Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by jokethrowaway on Sunday February 13, 2022 @12:06PM (#30323260)
I agree the government would be way worse at dealing with this flaw - but they probably would have just reversed whatever exploited transactions they needed. Or even just printed some more money to make everyone pay at the latest.
Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by Sparkyte on Sunday February 13, 2022 @02:22PM (#30324698)
To be fair we should be weary of both systems. Crypto isn't something sustainable in the long run. USD isn't a ponzi scheme, it is backed by commerce. Crypto isn't the multi sales and trades of goods are what dictate the value of the currency.
Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by birracerveza on Sunday February 13, 2022 @11:01AM (#30322619)
>But sorry to be that person, just a timely reminder of the truth: All cryptocurrencies and 'DeFi projects' are ponzi scams including Orchid.

Seems like just an opinion to me, and a poorly opinionated one at that.

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by NovemberWhiskey on Sunday February 13, 2022 @11:39AM (#30322992)
I think it's a bit pointless to argue about whether cryptocurrencies are Ponzi schemes or not.

What I would say is that most cryptocurrencies have no fundamental value, and are therefore bubbles. I don't know what the term is for when someone deliberately creates an asset bubble with the intention of profiting from it. It's something like a very long-form, deliberative pump-and-dump.

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by birracerveza on Sunday February 13, 2022 @12:17PM (#30323375)
I agree that the majority of cryptocurrencies are vaporware at best and deliberate scams at worst, but to claim that "All cryptocurrencies and 'DeFi projects' are ponzi scams including Orchid" is outright wrong.
Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by colesantiago on Sunday February 13, 2022 @11:07AM (#30322674)
Can you name any examples of cryptocurrencies being used that are not scams, ponzi schemes or for speculative purposes?

All I see are people holding coins and not using them at all for anything else other than 'I want coin to go up'.

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by birracerveza on Sunday February 13, 2022 @02:23PM (#30324709)
https://thegraph.com is one example.

Tokens are used to have a stake as an indexer (data provider) and to pay for query fees (data consumption), and if indexers tamper with the data they lose their stake.

It was released last year and has a long way ahead to mature, but it's an amazing product and tokens/blockchain is essential to its decentralized nature. Simply put, there is no way to accomplish this if the network didn't adopt its own cryptocurrency.

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by colesantiago on Sunday February 13, 2022 @02:58PM (#30325012)
Again, this can be done without using a blockchain.

Just like all the other coins, the only use case is burning up the planet by using Ethereum, BTC, etc, racking up high fees and being used by speculators while everyone else who invests in the ponzi scheme lose their money when it all crashes.

Nothing has changed.

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by birracerveza on Sunday February 13, 2022 @04:33PM (#30325903)
>Again, this can be done without using a blockchain.

How so?

I won't bother with the rest of the post as it's your usual crypto bad spiel that has absolutely nothing to do with the discussion we're currently having and has absolutely nothing to back up its claims (as do the rest of your posts, which I'm surprised aren't flagged/dead yet considering their low quality, but I guess HN is ok with them since they're anti crypto), but I'm curious to see how you would build a decentralized system that lets developers build data indexing programs, allows anyone to join the decentralized network as a data provider to run those programs, and lets consumers query that data from the network while also ensuring that the data is valid and hasn't been tampered with by the providers without blockchain/tokens.

Please, do enlighten me, I'm curious.

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by birracerveza on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @11:25AM (#30362001)
Yep, that's exactly what I thought.
Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by colesantiago on Sunday February 20, 2022 @12:02PM (#30407151)
You thought wrong, since nobody in this space actually cares about the technology.

Like all the others, most people are just speculating on the token price, asking if it is a good investment, etc. You would have to be lying to yourself to believe that people care about the technology.

Could you tell me why does this project needs a token attached? Even if we were to look at the price, the painful truth is that most (if not all) people who invested lost most of their money on this shitcoin, and this is excluding the punishing gas fees so it could be even worse. I hope this doesn't include you as well.

As I said, querying blockchains can be done without the need to attach a token to a project. BitQuery is an example of this without trying to burn up the planet with Proof of Waste.

If you are in support of the Graph you are also in support of the ponzi scheme.

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by pg5 on Sunday February 13, 2022 @11:10AM (#30322699)
Helium has practical uses - a cheaper alternative to cellular data for stuff like Lime scooters.
Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by colesantiago on Sunday February 13, 2022 @11:39AM (#30322991)
This can be done without the need for a blockchain.

Adding a new technology + blockchain + a coin still makes it ponzi scheme scam, even worse when the price of this coin comes crashing down.

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by vmception on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:53PM (#30324408)
Nobody wants a corporatecurrency

And there is no human coordination mechanism without the freely convertible currency

Blockchains provide the open source rails of all the account management and distribution, easing development costs. The infrastructure is already built compared to alternate ways of attempting to do this

have fun doing that without a blockchain

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by kristofferR on Sunday February 13, 2022 @12:22PM (#30323427)
Why would individuals buy relatively expensive equipment, set it up and manage it, without the potential for return on their investments?

The only reason Helium's LoRaWAN coverage is expanding rapidly is due to the crypto aspects of it.

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by colesantiago on Sunday February 13, 2022 @12:56PM (#30323796)
So basically a ponzi scheme that is expensive to join with guaranteed diminishing returns in mining.

If I would like to lose my money in style this would be it.

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by vmception on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:59PM (#30324480)
> If I would like to lose my money in style this would be it.

Well get in line, the backlog for receiving hotspots across all distributors is 6-9 months long.

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by pshc on Sunday February 13, 2022 @12:43PM (#30323654)
I was looking into Helium yesterday due to news coverage. "Proof of coverage" is a bunch of hot air, sorry. It's not resistant to Sybil attacks and GPS location is easily forged. Seems like a scheme to push hardware units that will topple once the token value runs out.
Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by vmception on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:51PM (#30324401)
Sort of, Helium no longer sells hardware and the community votes on third party manufacturers to be approved for authorization on the Helium network. This has helped distributed hardware delivery more than any single organization was prepared to do, with the semiconductor and supply chain issues.

There is definitely an opportunity to sell overpriced hardware into the community then.

There are some other antenna-blockchain systems out there that look more like "schemes to sell hardware", such as Match X. There is a big and burgeoning market for these "passive income" things, people install hardware to earn a cryptocurrency.

It is definitely worthwhile to sell the hardware if you can.

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by CRConrad on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @07:37PM (#30354946)
> antenna-blockchain systems

And earlier:

>>> GPS

So is this the Charlie Stross blockchain scheme?

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by CRConrad on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @07:34PM (#30354924)
The only practical uses of Helium are for weather balloons and for making your voice hilariously squeaky.
Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by tenuousemphasis on Sunday February 13, 2022 @11:28AM (#30322867)
Speculative investment is not the same as a Ponzi scheme. Not so subtle goalpost moving there.
Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by CRConrad on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @07:38PM (#30354956)
Isn't most speculative investment in the end a Ponzi scheme?
Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by colesantiago on Sunday February 13, 2022 @12:12PM (#30323326)
The are used for both.
Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by vmception on Sunday February 13, 2022 @01:49PM (#30324373)
It just proves that particular project had an exploit and a decent bug bounty program. Its nice that this person used the bug bounty program.

Other organization bounties should go higher. Especially Web2 ones.

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by whitepaint on Sunday February 13, 2022 @11:06AM (#30322671)
Tell me you don't know what DeFi is without telling me you don't know what DeFi is.
Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by colesantiago on Sunday February 13, 2022 @11:23AM (#30322809)
What is the process of getting your money back from a hacked DeFi project?

Why do I have to pay more fees to swap tokens on decentralised exchanges making them unusable, and how exactly is DeFi decentralised?

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by whitepaint on Sunday February 13, 2022 @11:33AM (#30322924)
> Why do I have to pay more fees to swap tokens on decentralised exchanges making them unusable

Wait for ETH 2.0. It's a really difficult problem to solve. In the meantime though, use Polygon (or other side chains). Swap tokens for a cent or two.

> how exactly is DeFi decentralised

Take a protocol like app.uniswap.org or pooltogether.com. If you have an internet connection, no one can stop you from using these protocols (and many other protocols). No arbitrary rules imposed by governments or companies. Your funds are your funds, there are no arbiters (just tens of thousands of Ethereum nodes which are responsible for settling transactions).

> What is the process of getting your money back from a hacked DeFi project?

Use protocols that have been around for a long time and have hundreds of millions, billions, or even tens of billions of dollars locked in. That decreases chances of you losing funds. But it is a problem, I agree, hopefully somehow we will make it better.

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by colesantiago on Sunday February 13, 2022 @12:06PM (#30323259)
> Why do I have to pay more fees to swap tokens on decentralised exchanges making them unusable

So I still have to wait at least 2023 (2025 or 2026 for a realistic possibility of merchant adoption) for ETH 2.0 to be used?

I don't think merchants would want to wait for something that is not complete and unregulated.

You do realise that ETH 2.0 has nothing to do with lowering fees? So all the DeFi apps using it will still be unusable anyway.

> If you have an internet connection, no one can stop you from using these protocols (and many other protocols)...(just tens of thousands of Ethereum nodes which are responsible for settling transactions).

Aren't most of these Ethereum nodes and DeFi exchanges on AWS like dydx? It went down a few months ago no? [0]

That doesn't sound decentralised to me.

> Use protocols that have been around for a long time...That decreases chances of you losing funds. But it is a problem

So I can't get my money back then? I see DeFi hacks everyday and not getting my money back doesn't help either.

Makes robbing a bank less attractive for criminals and instead target DeFi projects.

[0] https://twitter.com/dydxprotocol/status/1468293558360805381

Re:White hat hacker awarded $2M for fixing ETH-creation bug by SparkyMcUnicorn on Sunday February 13, 2022 @05:42PM (#30326360)
ETH is not the only chain out there. Transaction fees on Polygon and Harmony average between $0.001 - $0.02, and have all the things you'd expect from DeFi like Uniswap, Curve, and Aave.

The decentralized part of DeFi is the smart contracts. If you can interact with the contracts without any centralized help, then how exactly is it centralized in your opinion?