News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by dentemple on Friday February 11, 2022 @11:37AM (#30303466)
"Literary magazines are failing because people have wild takes these days" sounds like a huge leap of logic and embodies the sort of irrelevant dismissiveness that HN commenters tend to have regarding non-technical topics.

As someone else pointed out below, speculative fiction magazines are doing just fine, and you'd be hard-pressed to find ideas that WOULDN'T be considered "wild" in the field of SciFi or Fantasy.

Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by domador on Friday February 11, 2022 @11:51AM (#30303635)
I think you're confusing two different things:

1) Wild ideas INSIDE a given work of literature

2) Wild ideas ABOUT a given work of literature

Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by pcmoney on Friday February 11, 2022 @12:58PM (#30304713)
I am not talking about wild ideas in the literature but wild ideas in the interpretation of the literature. There is a pressure to interpret everything with the lens of partisan identity politics.

Eg. Most recently this surfaced outside of the literary community around Sam and Frodo's relationship in LOTR and whether or not they were gay.

Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by thebooktocome on Friday February 11, 2022 @01:08PM (#30304857)
People have been debating that since the sixties —- predating “identity politics” by several decades.
[dead]
Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by wolverine876 on Friday February 11, 2022 @05:22PM (#30307716)
> flagrantly infantile

Why do you feel the need to utterly dismiss other points of view, straining to leave no avenue for intellectual curiosity or discussion?

Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by pcmoney on Friday February 11, 2022 @07:29PM (#30308751)
Because it is. No claims are made now so nothing is provable/refutable. It is faux intellectualism, professional pedantry. We just debate narratives. It devolves into playground tribalism with moral relativism, theres not much to be curious about there.
Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by watwut on Friday February 11, 2022 @02:45PM (#30306129)
Yes, gender and race were immensly important to success and literally anything in the 60s. That decade started shortly after bus boycot and ended around the time MLK was killed.

Yale, Princeton and Cornell did not allowed women at all.

The identity ruled the lifes of people.

Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by thebooktocome on Friday February 11, 2022 @02:38PM (#30306039)
That may be your opinion, but C. S. Lewis was not participating in some discourse on identity politics, not by any stretch of the imagination. He wouldn’t have understood the term.

Your citation merely reinforces my point that queer readings of LOTR predate the current generation by several decades. It’s a historical fact.

Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by pcmoney on Friday February 11, 2022 @07:31PM (#30308764)
Maybe not the term but the practice: “The danger of mistaking our merely natural, though perhaps legitimate, enthusiasms for holy zeal, is always great. The demon inherent in every party is at all times ready enough to disguise himself as the Holy Ghost,”
Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by bigbillheck on Friday February 11, 2022 @03:25PM (#30306576)
> Eg. Most recently this surfaced outside of the literary community around Sam and Frodo's relationship in LOTR and whether or not they were gay.

This seems to me like a perfectly legitimate question.

Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by jimbob45 on Friday February 11, 2022 @04:27PM (#30307185)
>Some critics have detected in HAL's wheedling voice an undertone of homosexuality. Was that intended?

>No. I think it's become something of a parlor game for some people to read that kind of thing into everything they encounter. HAL was a "straight" computer.

From an interview with Kubrick in 1970[0]. The attempt to transform every male-male relationship in every piece of media to homosexuality has sadly killed the concept of friendship in media, just like it did to Xena and Gabrielle. It's okay for friendship to just be friendship.

[0]http://www.visual-memory.co.uk/amk/doc/0069.html

Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by wolverine876 on Friday February 11, 2022 @05:20PM (#30307703)
The artist doesn't decide the art's meaning to me (or you). Once the art is released into the wild, it's out of their hands. It's like an open source project, in a way, (or any software release): you release it and then everyone uses and modifies it in different ways, many of which you never imagined. It's not yours anymor; it belongs to the users.

I think what is interesting, and most valuable, is that people will find one way or another to attack any normalization of non-cisnormal sexuality. Why is that?

(Also, one example doesn't prove anything.)

Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by pcmoney on Friday February 11, 2022 @07:38PM (#30308804)
Cool, so lit critics can start publishing interpretations of clear expressions of the gay and trans experience and claiming the gay/trans characters are closeted or secretly wish to detransition? (I hope not)
Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by bigbillheck on Friday February 11, 2022 @06:23PM (#30308219)
I believe you'll find that this is from a different book by a different author.
Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by Nasrudith on Friday February 11, 2022 @05:00PM (#30307528)
I mean it is a complicated question based upon how you define gay in the first place with sex segregated family isolating education policies of the British schools. The whole reasons for that were the old chestnut of fighting decadence to justify brutality and worry that a mother's love would leave Britan with men too soft. Then there is the ever present situational sexuality evident in prisons and single sex schooling. It not only held there but was acknowledged. There is a homophobic by modern standards quote from his friend and contemporary C.S.Lewis about sodomy being a weed filled, stagnant oasis in the constant social struggle but an oasis nonetheless appears to be him "Saying what everyone knows but doesn't acknowledge out loud."

To sum it up in a snarky pithy phrase: the culture was so misogynistic that it became gay, because romance requires another person. It is reflected a bit in sheer rarity of female characters in LOTR.

Romantic friendships were a norm in the past largely forgotten in more open times where we are used to noticing obvious repression and "closet cases". In a way the real past manages to be even more alien than fantasy worlds with elves and dwarves.

Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by pcmoney on Friday February 11, 2022 @07:35PM (#30308788)
Or, and hear me out here, they just had experienced trench warfare in WWI (which Mordor is arguably inspired from and which Sam and Frodo had to experience together) and few things ever draw men closer together platonically than being in combat together.
Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by wolverine876 on Friday February 11, 2022 @05:15PM (#30307656)
> Eg. Most recently this surfaced outside of the literary community around Sam and Frodo's relationship in LOTR and whether or not they were gay.

I think the way to approach that is, what makes it necessarily 'wild', and why does that matter? Nonbinary sexuality is hardly political - it's been a natural part of the human race (and our ancestors and cousins) forever, long before current politics.

What makes it 'wild' is that it challenges norms to even ask the question. What makes it political is that anyone challenging norms tends to have their views politicized and suppressed - grab the torches and pitchforks. Later, when the same thing becomes normalized, it becomes something the next generation of conservatives defends.

The old saying is very true: 'First they laugh at you, then they say it violates the scripture, then they say they believed it all along.' (Except it omits the hatred and lynching.)

Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by bigbillheck on Friday February 11, 2022 @12:40PM (#30304392)
>speculative fiction magazines are doing just fine,

F&SF is down to six issues a year (they had 8 in 2009, and 11 from 1991-2008). Analog and Asimov's each dropped from 10 to 6 in 2017 (and each went from 11 to 10 in 2003).

That's not what I'd call 'just fine'.

Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by akuchling on Friday February 11, 2022 @02:29PM (#30305960)
Stories in the SF magazines have also pretty much disappeared from award-nominations like the Hugos and the Nebulas, replaced by publications that are free online like Uncanny or Tor.com. It makes sense: people are much more likely to read and nominate these stories, and the shrinking number of readers means a smaller pool of potential nominators. I think it's just a matter of time, maybe a decade or so, before the print magazines disappear.
Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by TheCoelacanth on Friday February 11, 2022 @12:48PM (#30304520)
Speculative fiction magazines are doing relatively well because the standing of speculative fiction in literary circles has risen so much.

50 years ago, it was largely considered pulp and not real literature (though I would argue that plenty of "real literature" was being written in the genre, it just wasn't widely accepted as such by contemporaries). Even the few works that were accepted, people often claimed that it wasn't really SF.

More recently, it is increasingly being accepted that being SF doesn't inherently reduce something's literary value, so SF magazines have had more room to grow.

Even with that, a lot of the traditional leaders among SF magazines have been struggling. What's doing well are the newer online-first magazines, most notably Tor.com, which has boatloads of money to throw around (by short fiction standards) and doesn't need to be financially self-sustaining because it is effectively a loss-leader for their novels.

Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by brimble on Friday February 11, 2022 @02:31PM (#30305972)
Mid-tier genre mags still pay. The pay may suck, but they do pay. Even some fairly low-tier ones pay.

Mid-tier literary journals generally don't, and their editors often act insulted if the topic is raised, so the issue doesn't seem to just be that they can't afford to pay. There's seemingly an expectation that until you've already "made it" you should be working for free.

Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by nonameiguess on Friday February 11, 2022 @02:17PM (#30305798)
It's amusing to see the responses to this about not reading the parent comment when, as far as I can tell, the parent comment may not have read the article. Literary review magazines publish short form literature, not literary criticism.
Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by thinkingemote on Friday February 11, 2022 @11:59AM (#30303746)
I believe that knowing about a topic is not a pre-requisite to gratify one's intellectual curiosity on this subject on HN.

Indeed, I would suggest that we encourage curiosity in others when we see it.

Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by chipotle_coyote on Friday February 11, 2022 @12:35PM (#30304297)
Sure, but I would suggest that we also encourage reading the linked articles before commenting. In this case, there is nothing in the CNN article that suggests the decline in literary magazines has a connection to "literary critique and interpretation in many Universities becoming more radical." It's awfully hard not to see this as the commenter just taking this as a stalking horse to bring up an opinion they already held.
Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by useragent86 on Friday February 11, 2022 @12:58PM (#30304717)
> It's awfully hard not to see this as the commenter just taking this as a stalking horse to bring up an opinion they already held.

Isn't this what happens on every HN thread, people expressing opinions relevant to the topic? Or is it only forbidden when criticizing descendants of the Frankfurt School?

Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by chipotle_coyote on Friday February 11, 2022 @02:14PM (#30305740)
I originally wrote a snarkier response to this in response to your snark, but I'm to just gently note that my contention was that the opinion was not relevant to the topic, and it seems to me you're demonstrating exactly what I was complaining about: you didn't actually respond to what I said, you just said, "Ooh, here's an opportunity to snark about something I consider snark-worthy." So, uh, go you.
Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by watwut on Friday February 11, 2022 @02:47PM (#30306164)
I think that issue is the claim not being relevant to topic in article, while pretending so to push for specific ideology.
Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by kevinventullo on Friday February 11, 2022 @11:57AM (#30303723)
SciFi and Fantasy are explicitly fiction.
Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by vorpalhex on Friday February 11, 2022 @11:49AM (#30303616)
Just out of question, do you read any literary magazines?
Re:Long-standing literary magazines are struggling to stay a... by oldsecondhand on Friday February 11, 2022 @12:00PM (#30303763)
He doesn't even read the comments he's replying to.