News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Scientific Virtues: Stupidity, Arrogance, Laziness by giantg2 on Friday February 11, 2022 @10:27AM (#30302501)
I'm dumb and ask stupid questions. My curiosity has only hurt me.
Re:The Scientific Virtues: Stupidity, Arrogance, Laziness by wongarsu on Friday February 11, 2022 @11:35AM (#30303439)
Nobody is born knowledgeable, and asking questions is almost always better in the long run than looking smart while staying ignorant.

There there are ways to make questions sound less dumb, mostly involving that you made an effort at finding a solution. "Why is the sky blue?" sounds like a dumb question, "I saw that liquid oxygen is blue, is that why the sky is blue?" sounds much better (even though the assumption is completely wrong)

Re:The Scientific Virtues: Stupidity, Arrogance, Laziness by giantg2 on Friday February 11, 2022 @11:56AM (#30303712)
Yeah, but most of success in today's world is built off of the perception that others have of you.

In fact, some of the feedback I have gotten throughout the years is that I have lots of potential, I'm smart (smarter than I really am), well spoken (for an IT guy), etc. It doesn't mean anything because they always seem to think that I should be driving every meeting or conversation. If there's another person in the meeting with more knowledge in that specific area and I agree with their direction, why would I take over? So their perception is that I'm smart, but that I lack some other quality. My perception is that I'm dumber than the other guy but just smart enough to know to defer to their expertise. It leaves me stuck and unsuccessful.

I'm stupid enough to ask certain questions... which I suppose makes them stupid questions. If we are a company notorious for value shopping, and the company says we're seeing deadlines or capacity slip due to not filling open positions, and is costing the company money, risk of tech debt not being addressed... it's stupid for someone like me to question that, but I do. If it were really costing the company money, then wouldn't we increase pay or not force people back to the office to increase headcount? There seems to be a contradiction here, and the people in power don't have an answer that makes sense (possibly because there are things they can't tell a peon me).

Re:The Scientific Virtues: Stupidity, Arrogance, Laziness by icegreentea2 on Friday February 11, 2022 @12:33PM (#30304262)
For your first part, you don't need to take over. But you should find a way to contribute. At the very least if there's an expectation that you drive meetings, but you want to defer because someone else has more knowledge in a specific area, you need to make it clear why you're deferring.

For your second part, it seems like the questions are you asking are not stupid in themselves. Rather they are uncomfortable and/or threatening to the audience. Like your question is driving at a real point which is that likely no one actually sat down and tried to rationalize (quantitatively or however) the cost and benefits of their course of action. The "stupid" part is poking at this sensitive topic in ways that don't give people a graceful way to interact with it. Most people do not want to admit that they're just autopiloting a decision that might have made sense as a quick heuristic based on assumptions (which are okay!) that have since provided to be wrong and have just been running with it ever since. Or that no, they've never actually sat down and quantified (ballpark) how much company the strategy is costing them, and that they're just making stuff up.

To back up to your original point, uncontrolled curiosity can definitely be harmful. You absolutely need to temper and control it, especially when interacting with human systems. That doesn't mean that curiosity is bad though. I do sympathize that the usual formulation of "there are no stupid questions here" is almost always misleading, and encodes a pile of unsaid assumptions.

Re:The Scientific Virtues: Stupidity, Arrogance, Laziness by giantg2 on Friday February 11, 2022 @01:45PM (#30305403)
There really shouldn't be a need to explain the deferral for each occurrence. I have explained it in general to my manager and participated, in my opinion, appropriately. They have not given concrete steps that they would like to see me take. For context, I'm only a midlevel dev.

"The "stupid" part is poking at this sensitive topic"

Exactly, but without bringing it up, that curiosity wouldn't be satisfied. They talk about being candid as a positive trait. It appears that isn't true - just typically corporate doublespeak.

Re:The Scientific Virtues: Stupidity, Arrogance, Laziness by lazide on Friday February 11, 2022 @08:33PM (#30309074)
Everything is contextual, and I think you may be missing a bit EQ bit?

You can drive a meeting while still deferring to experts by driving the meeting, and then bringing them in for their expertise when you know it is in their area - which you know when that is and who they are, because you would be an expert in knowing that.

You seem to be sitting back in the meeting and waiting for something to add, which… yeah doesn’t add much? That’s inherently passive.

And if they ask you to be candid, and then recoil when you are, that is potentially because you’re not wrapping up what you’re saying in a way they can process/handle - it could be overly abrasive, or verbose, or whatever.

The reason you may not be getting any actionable advice is they are giving you why they see as actionable advice. But you’re missing a connection here because you’re missing the EQ piece?

Re:The Scientific Virtues: Stupidity, Arrogance, Laziness by giantg2 on Friday February 11, 2022 @09:58PM (#30309512)
So everything is on me? I need to be the one wrapping my opinions in a way they can understand (which I do), and any (theortical) misunderstanding of their advice is also on me. Sounds like a bum deal. I don't think this is happening. Why else would they be saying that I'm well spoken and even diplomatic if these were the issues. They mostly don't like me to be candid when my opinion runs counter to theirs and I have points they don't want to counter.

Yes, I can and do facilitate meetings. That's not a problem. They just want me to be loud and talkative in meetings that could have been emails, or at least with a much smaller group.

Re:The Scientific Virtues: Stupidity, Arrogance, Laziness by lazide on Saturday February 12, 2022 @12:10AM (#30310132)
Then maybe find somewhere that does work for you?

If you always feel you’re crazy, then it doesn’t fit.

Re:The Scientific Virtues: Stupidity, Arrogance, Laziness by giantg2 on Saturday February 12, 2022 @07:42AM (#30312321)
I don't feel I'm crazy. It's the job of management to manipulate people and look out for themselves. It will be the same or even worse at other places.
Re:The Scientific Virtues: Stupidity, Arrogance, Laziness by lazide on Saturday February 12, 2022 @02:27PM (#30315507)
FYI - that mindset right there is a huge problem and red flag, especially if you’re staying.

I have never seen it be managements job to manipulate anyone anywhere. It is managements job to make the business work (manage it). In some places, the agreed upon way that management does this is by manipulating, lying, cheating, etc.

Those places are toxic.

It is also possible for people and workers to become toxic as a culture, and cause otherwise fine and well meaning behavior to be perceived as toxic and make a toxic workplace for everyone due to no/ineffective action from management.

I’ve never seen it be just one side for very long, unless both sides are feeding it it.

It builds a sick system, and like all systems, it has to be self reinforcing to continue to exist.

I’m not saying everyone is perfect - far from it. I’m saying that lack of trust and perceived negative intent from others (especially in positions of authority), lack of a feeling of agency in getting a different outcome or impacting current conditions are all, etc. are a dark place to be, and one that does not help oneself get better. If you’re not even considering finding somewhere else, that produces very very bad outcomes for everyone in the long run.

If you are not considering getting help in understanding or tackling the situation from your side, that also produces bad outcomes for you long term.

Re:The Scientific Virtues: Stupidity, Arrogance, Laziness by dfxm12 on Friday February 11, 2022 @02:15PM (#30305765)
You can drive a meeting among others who are more knowledgeable in certain fields. Leading meetings is a different, and in my experience, more unique, skill from expertise in a specific IT field; leadership is harder to replace than domain specific knowledge.
Re:The Scientific Virtues: Stupidity, Arrogance, Laziness by giantg2 on Friday February 11, 2022 @03:28PM (#30306618)
I guess what I mean, is they want you to talk... a lot. Apparently it's one of the ways they measure "engagement" - how loud is someone.
Re:The Scientific Virtues: Stupidity, Arrogance, Laziness by lazide on Friday February 11, 2022 @08:33PM (#30309077)
I very much doubt that is (actually) the case - but that you perceive it that way may be at the root of the problem.
Re:The Scientific Virtues: Stupidity, Arrogance, Laziness by giantg2 on Friday February 11, 2022 @09:59PM (#30309516)
It really isn't just me. Other people have also brought this up.
Re:The Scientific Virtues: Stupidity, Arrogance, Laziness by PaulDavisThe1st on Friday February 11, 2022 @01:06PM (#30304836)
You have to ask the stupid questions of the right people, unfortunately.
Re:The Scientific Virtues: Stupidity, Arrogance, Laziness by nanomonkey on Friday February 11, 2022 @11:09AM (#30303059)
"What doesn’t kill you, makes you stronger" -Nietzsche
Re:The Scientific Virtues: Stupidity, Arrogance, Laziness by giantg2 on Friday February 11, 2022 @11:27AM (#30303335)
Or leaves you chronically damaged/paralyzed/etc.
Re:The Scientific Virtues: Stupidity, Arrogance, Laziness by circlefavshape on Friday February 11, 2022 @12:25PM (#30304135)
Seriously? People are still quoting this as if it's true?
Re:The Scientific Virtues: Stupidity, Arrogance, Laziness by fallous on Friday February 11, 2022 @09:25PM (#30309346)
Hurt you in what way? Have you become less knowledgeable due to your curiosity?
Re:The Scientific Virtues: Stupidity, Arrogance, Laziness by giantg2 on Saturday February 12, 2022 @07:50AM (#30312372)
Any knowledge I do have is basically useless (Filenet, Neoxam, etc). In fact, some of the knowledge is harmful - I've learned more about the policies that are broken during performance evaluations, and of the lies the company tells.

I ask questions that the company would rather I don't ask. I was in a meeting once that I disagreed with something that was being said. I knew enough to keep my mouth shut. Then the manager called on me to share my thoughts. So I gave him my opinion, which included a question to validate my theory. I was yelled at, in front of everyone during that meeting. I don't think I ever did get an answer to that question, even in private.

I have 10 years of experience and a master degree. I've worked as a senior developer and a tech lead for a year each. Because I question things and am not a 'yes' man, I'm a midlevel dev with no future.