News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by scottiebarnes on Thursday February 10, 2022 @02:51PM (#30291527)
> but if the alternative is to have shrinking GDP and massive unemployment, I would rather have some inflation.

This is the general problem with central banking.

Politicians and governments will ALWAYS take action to "save the economy", whether that is a small downturn or a big one. There's too much pressure to not use the magic money printer. Short term election cycles incentivize everyone to just fix the problem as fast as we can, future consequences be damned.

You can get away with it in the short term, but over a long enough time horizon, you start to run out of bullets, as all the real value has already been plundered.

The US Federal debt is currently $30 trillion USD. This is never getting balanced, ever. There's only one possible eventual outcome with this system.

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by JackFr on Thursday February 10, 2022 @03:13PM (#30291808)
> The US Federal debt is currently $30 trillion USD. This is never getting balanced, ever. There's only one possible eventual outcome with this system.

The US debt to GDP ratio is currently slightly higher than it was at the end of WWII. It is significantly lower than that of Japan, who has a debt to GDP ration similar to those the UK ran during portions of the 19th century.

There are very good reasons for governments should be prudent in their spending and high levels of debt are to be avoided. But no, it will never be balanced, the national debt is permanent and exists by design.

> There's only one possible eventual outcome with this system.

I don't think that's true, and I'm really not even sure what you're ominously hining at.

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by foolinaround on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:04PM (#30292506)
> the national debt is permanent and exists by design.

Can you pls point me to something about its design?

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by tharne on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:18PM (#30292736)
If you read history books covering the time just before and after the American revolution, there was a lot of discussion of this topic at the time. A lot of the founder fathers, most notably Alexander Hamilton, believed a national debt was a good thing for the country.

The belief is/was that by carrying a substantial debt, you give the bank and financial institutions skin the game and make their success tied to the success of the country.

In the modern era it also gives individuals and other types of institutions a stake in the country's success. When people take about the U.S. national debt, much of the conversation goes to China and how much money we owe them. We owe them a lot, however, the biggest holders of U.S. debt are individual Americans with their 401ks and things like pension funds and university endowments.

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by JackFr on Thursday February 10, 2022 @05:31PM (#30293651)
The largest holder of treasury bonds by far is the Social Security Trust Fund. (Which is, of course, an accounting fiction.)
Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by imtringued on Thursday February 10, 2022 @06:41PM (#30294486)
Monetary savings = debt by definition. No debt no money. One should ask why money is taking a one way route though. It remains stuck in bank accounts.
Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by overtonwhy on Thursday February 10, 2022 @03:49PM (#30292292)
Disregard new accounts that claim the sky will be falling. The debt will always be going up and there will always be inflation. That's how fiat currencies work. Research the federal reserve and it's stated objectives to understand why.
Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by tharne on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:20PM (#30292759)
The only problem with that is that inflation is a like a fire. When it's very small it can serve you, but once it gets bigger and you lose control of it you're f*ked.
Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by imtringued on Thursday February 10, 2022 @06:43PM (#30294513)
There will always be inflation (temporary and permanently via mining) and debt goes up with a gold standard too. That's actually a general property of permanent money.
Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by colinmhayes on Thursday February 10, 2022 @07:23PM (#30294989)
Depends on your definition of inflation. If you're just talking about money supply, sure. If you're talking about prices, no. It is entirely conceivable that consumption increases faster than the speed at which we can mine, which would probably set off a deflationary spiral as wall st starts to hoard cash.
Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by scottiebarnes on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:06PM (#30292538)
If the way fiat currencies work is constant devaluation in the name of increased short term spending, then it makes the currency utterly terrible to invest and save in in the long term.

If this is how its supposed to work, then your money is a toxic asset which should be handed off as quickly as possible to someone else.

And so if no one actually wants this asset, then it makes it valueless.

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by dragonwriter on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:12PM (#30292620)
> then it makes the currency utterly terrible to invest and save in in the long term.

That's why it's called “current-sy” (only slightly joking) It's for current use as a medium of exchange. For investment/savings, you go to productive assets.

That's the whole point. Mixing those functions doesn't help anything.

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by scottiebarnes on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:20PM (#30292763)
No, money is supposed to be good at storing value as well. That's why gold evolved as the world currency over the last 8000 years, and that's why central banks still hoard it in bunkers. You can't easily devalue it by creating more of it.

You're failing to understand that treasury bond markets have an important function in the macro economy; ideally, a safe way to save and store value with low risk. And they are larger than stock markets.

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by ericmay on Thursday February 10, 2022 @05:54PM (#30293912)
> No, money is supposed to be good at storing value as well.

I think you’re confusing wealth/assets with mediums of exchange. Gold for example is a pretty decent store of value but a nightmare for exchange. Want to buy a pack of gum? Why don’t you shave a tenth of a gram off right here on the counter so I can measure it.. etc. You can see how crappy that is.

USD however have never been great stores of value but are great currency because they’re so liquid. Everybody accepts dollars. It’s easy to trade and convert to other assets. How much is that pack of gum? Oh it’s a dollar. Ok here you go. And that’s that.

The name of the game has always been converting dollars to productive assets.

Along comes Bitcoin and cryptocurrency and now crypto currencies in general have features. Bitcoin sucks as a currency for buying stuff but is great at storing deflationary value (or so it seems). Monero sucks as a currency compared to the dollar but has privacy features. Etc.

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by scottiebarnes on Thursday February 10, 2022 @07:20PM (#30294953)
3 functions of money:

1) Store of value

2) Unit of account

3) Medium of exchange

Go ahead and design a money that you intend to have last forever (because good design/engineering stands the test of time, right?)

Tell me which tradeoffs you make.

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by dragonwriter on Thursday February 10, 2022 @07:26PM (#30295013)
For #1, I want increase in value over time, but don't care much about volatitlity or ease of exchange.

For #2, I want low volatility (both in value and it's first derivative).

For #3, I want low volatitlity in value and logistical ease of exchange.

So, for #1, I want a different thing than for #2 & #3, for which I might want the same thing, since the needs are, though not identical, at least overlapping.

Productive investments serve #1 well, so I’d leave it to them, and leave the design of money to balance #2 & #3.

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by scottiebarnes on Thursday February 10, 2022 @07:40PM (#30295176)
Congratulations, you created the Argentine Peso. You ended up in a debt crisis and had to hyperinflate your currency.
Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by dragonwriter on Thursday February 10, 2022 @09:15PM (#30295994)
> Congratulations, you created the Argentine Peso

I’m pretty sure I didn't invent anything, you just picked a random currency that meets neither your implicit goals not my explicit ones, because it's convenient for a pre-canned argument you wanted to make.

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by scottiebarnes on Thursday February 10, 2022 @09:54PM (#30296294)
And you didn't design anything either. You basically said you wanted a super fast car that's super light and has a huge gas tank and is cheap.
Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by colinmhayes on Thursday February 10, 2022 @07:25PM (#30295008)
good store of value just means its value is predictable. Fiat currency actually make money a much better store of value, because monetary policy can be used to control inflation. Using intrinsically valuable goods as currency is horrible for store of value because people will always be worried that a new use or way to produce the good will be found.
Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by scottiebarnes on Thursday February 10, 2022 @07:53PM (#30295301)
Store of value means value is not easily eroded.

Fiat money is not a good store of value because it is the easiest to erode (central bank changes a digit in a database, and new money exists). Tell me which country's fiat currency you'd be willing to hold for 100 years, and how much buying power you expect it to retain.

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by colinmhayes on Thursday February 10, 2022 @08:01PM (#30295369)
Fiat money isn't supposed to be held for long periods of time. That's literally the point. The government is incentivizing you to invest/consume it, otherwise we're in a liquidity trap. It's just supposed to allow people to to make transactions and be confident that the thing they are selling won't be worth 20% more tomorrow.
Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by scottiebarnes on Thursday February 10, 2022 @08:24PM (#30295556)
> It's just supposed to allow people to to make transactions and be confident that the thing they are selling won't be worth 20% more tomorrow.

Huh. I'm pretty sure the things people are buying costs 7.5% more compared to last year.

Those stupid people shouldn't have been holding money for a year, they should have bought that stuff a year ago.

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by colinmhayes on Thursday February 10, 2022 @10:35PM (#30296585)
I mean yea, you shouldn't be holding cash for a year. Put it in short term bonds if you want it liquid.
Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by scottiebarnes on Friday February 11, 2022 @09:28AM (#30301831)
You realize the yield on a 1 yr US treasury bond is currently 1%, and the yield of it one year ago was 0.1%? And that bonds pay coupons denominated in dollars?

The savings rate at Bank of America is 0.01% APY.

A person has no risk-free ability to save, and is forced to speculate in asset markets just to keep up with inflation.

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by colinmhayes on Friday February 11, 2022 @10:15AM (#30302361)
> The savings rate at Bank of America is 0.01% APY.

The government doesn't want you holding large amounts of cash. It causes problems for everyone.

> A person has no risk-free ability to save

Nothing is risk free. Yes, the government wants to force people to invest their money in order for it to keep its value over long periods of time. Hoarding money is bad. If you don't think T-bonds pay enough you're free to buy other bonds, equities, real estate, even gold if you like it so much.

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by scottiebarnes on Friday February 11, 2022 @10:28AM (#30302519)
> The government doesn't want you holding large amounts of cash.

Government ownership of the interest rate is part of the problem. In a free market, an interest rate emerges naturally based on the supply of money from savers, and demand of money from consumers.

Any individual divides their wealth into either saving or consumption based on their individual time preferences. Some people like stuff now, some people are happy to wait and have more later. Presently, we are forced to consume, or take on riskier assets to save.

> Hoarding money is bad.

Bonds and savings accounts aren't hoarding money; you loan the money out for other people to use productively, and they pay you an interest rate.

> If you don't think T-bonds pay enough you're free to buy other bonds, equities, real estate, even gold if you like it so much.

Again, you're failing to see the consequences of t-bonds having a low interest rate and the US dollar being unable to store value. The consequence are volatile and speculative asset markets. If over time no one wants treasury bonds or USD, they become valueless.

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by int_19h on Friday February 11, 2022 @06:29PM (#30308280)
The end result is that everybody is an "investor" (mostly by proxy via 401k and pension funds), and that is then used as the trump card to shoot down any regulations that would reign in the insanity that is the modern stock market, by pointing out that any reduction in market profits hurts those "investors".
Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by imtringued on Thursday February 10, 2022 @06:44PM (#30294532)
Storing value in the bodies of other people without their consent is an absurd concept. Unemployed bodies starve and must be subsidized.
Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by ericmay on Thursday February 10, 2022 @03:14PM (#30291814)
A couple of thoughts (may be wrong, interested in the discussion)

When the government borrows money it borrows it at an interest rate. When rates are low, like close to 0% low like they are now, that's exactly when you want to borrow money. Want to fix bridges and invest in things? Now is the time to borrow money to do that. It also has the added benefit of making past debt cheaper. This scenario that we're in is made even more interesting by the fact that many governments also had to print tons and tons of money. While we're now over 100% debt-to-GDP, it's not unheard of and not so catastrophic that we can't recover from.

I'm also unsure about rising wages here. If they continue to rise won't prices continue to rise to reflect wages? I'm also of the opinion that slow sales from 2020/2021 + supply chain issues have caused companies to raise prices. I don't think cereal actually needs to be more expensive. Shareholders do though.

Re:Have we been thinking about inflation all wrong? by imtringued on Thursday February 10, 2022 @06:39PM (#30294454)
Have you ever wondered why the people that have the money that represents the government's debt isn't returning, ever?

When go the austerity route your economy collapses faster than you can pay your debts back, isn't there something odd with that? If money is supposedly cheap why does it refuse to show itself?