https://www.overcomingbias.com/2007/03/paternalism_is_.html
https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/PeSzc9JTBxhaYRp9b/policy-deb...
No matter what they've signed, that's still a million people who've gotten their money stolen and they'll be out for blood, communicating on forums, in-person, etc. Beyond the brute fact that a million people have had money stolen, which is bad, there's the secondary problem that if just another 1% of that million still complains to newspapers, there's no way that the government could arrest 10,000 people at once without major public backlash, especially if those people play their cards well and can spin a media story of "victims of financial fraud further being punished by the government." If you've got 10,000 examples to choose from, there are bound to be sympathetic stories which capture the public attention.
And then at that point, if the government chooses not to prosecute those cases, the floodgates are loose and the "Certificate of Dumb Investment" has lost most of its power and purpose.
The crucial point from the original proposal is the following:
> If an article ever appears in the Wall Street Journal in which you (or your lawyer) are quoted saying that you were just a simple dentist, didn’t understand what you were buying and were swindled by the seller’s flashy sales pitch, then you go to prison.
The implication (the WSJ is just a stand-in) being that if lawyers representing you even talk about this investment, let alone try to bring a court case, you go to jail. No law like this exists at the moment and I'm saying such a law would quickly become toothless because it would be nigh impossible for the government to enforce.
> As far as "the big problem", people win the lottery every day. It's still not a sound investment strategy (unless you have some sort of edge).
Yes and that's precisely why there's still a lot of people who buy lottery tickets. My point is telling people upfront that something is a losing proposition and then taking away the ability to complain if they do it and lose anyway isn't enough of a disincentive to prevent people from doing something if they are convinced that they're the lucky ones or that "this is the real deal," a slap in the face at your local SEO office be damned.
1. Anyone can invest all they want in a diversified portfolio of approved investments (non-penny-stock public companies, mutual funds and exchange-traded funds with modest fees, insured bank accounts, etc.).
2. Anyone can also invest in any other dumb investment; you just have to go to the local office of the SEC and get a Certificate of Dumb Investment. (Anyone who sells dumb non-approved investments without requiring this certificate from buyers goes to prison.)
3. To get that certificate, you sign a form. The form is one page with a lot of white space. It says in very large letters: “I want to buy a dumb investment. I understand that the person selling it will almost certainly steal all my money, and that I would almost certainly be better off just buying index funds, but I want to do this dumb thing anyway. I agree that I will never, under any circumstances, complain to anyone when this investment inevitably goes wrong. I understand that violating this agreement is a felony.”
4. Then you take the form to an SEC employee, who slaps you hard across the face and says “really???” And if you reply “yes really” then she gives you the certificate.
5. Then you bring the certificate to the seller and you can buy whatever dumb thing he is selling.
6. If an article ever appears in the Wall Street Journal in which you (or your lawyer) are quoted saying that you were just a simple dentist, didn’t understand what you were buying and were swindled by the seller’s flashy sales pitch, then you go to prison.