It would be if self driving Teslas were safer, but the evidence seems to suggest that they crash more often than regular drivers once you control for when it is used.
If Tesla’s approach ultimately succeeds in getting FSD working and into the mainstream, then for each year earlier that happens than it otherwise would, up to about 30,000 lives are saved, millions of injuries prevented, and roughly $1 trillion USD in total lifetime value is preserved as the worldwide accident rate goes to zero.
In that context, FSD should absolutely be civilization’s next moonshot.
That’s to say nothing of the other economic benefits besides simply killed and maiming fewer people and destroying less property.
The other, darker, possibility is that Tesla does so poorly in this moonshot that they poison the well for everyone else, some of whom might be more equipped to succeed.
If through their actions FSD is ultimately delayed a year, then they contributed to extended the carnage of human driven automobiles.
The point is the scale of the problem, and how valuable it is to solve it.
If Tesla's approach ultimately turns into a dead end (and that is the outcome of the overwhelming majority of very ambitious tech projects) then all the time and resources spent on Tesla's approach could be seen in hindsight to have been diverted away from potentially fruitful projects and are actually making mainstream FSD happen later than they otherwise would.
FSD being civilization's next moonshot doesn't mean Tesla should necessarily get a free pass to test beta FSD tech out on public roads without scrutiny.
What cost would be attributed to Covid, roughly?
That’s just the USA
Because I'm saying just because the goal is extremely worthwhile, it's not carte blanche to move fast and break things.
But lives killed by inaction should be counted!
The common pro Tesla argument of delaying self driving costing lives is absolutely valid. But it doesn't follow that allowing Tesla FSD to run red lights is the best way to accelerate the adoption as a whole.
If the whole industry was as cautious as Waymo, I think the risk of regulation would be minimal.
This is orthogonal to how well done the system is. I am extremely impressed it works as well as it does. But it's not good enough.