News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook loses users for the first time by bko on Thursday February 03, 2022 @12:11PM (#30195184)
How is that a joke? It's just looking down on someone because of where they live, eat and their politics (assuming very lose definition of "racist"). And when did the role of journalists start including dunking on random people?
Re:Facebook loses users for the first time by ubermonkey on Thursday February 03, 2022 @12:50PM (#30195864)
You seem fun.

It's funny because it's something many, many people identify with. A good chunk of Americans with the ability to do so leave small, provincial areas they grew up in for better opportunities in larger, more diverse cities. This leads to a pretty huge disconnect between them and those who, for whatever reason, stayed in their hometown.

It wasn't something that you noticed as much until Facebook exploded, and then everyone got re-connected with people from high school that, in some cases, you'd neither seen nor thought about in 20 years. And then the sort of post that prompted the joke happens, and you see it clearly.

And I assure you, as someone who grew up in and later left arguably the MOST racist state in the US south, the articles these archetypes are sharing are often quite explicit in their racism.

Re:Facebook loses users for the first time by bko on Thursday February 03, 2022 @01:06PM (#30196129)
Many people just want a normal life around family and friends and what they're familiar with. Having family around in particular is especially important when you have children or when your parents are approaching their end of life. Children get sick and having a relative around to help watch them is essential.

Many don't optimize their life their lives around "better opportunities" and "diverse cities". It sounds like you do, and good for you.

Re:Facebook loses users for the first time by ubermonkey on Thursday February 03, 2022 @02:26PM (#30197444)
I hesitate to respond to you again because I think you've dug your heels in here on finding the joke troublesome, but:

You DO realize that it's not at the expense of MERELY staying in a small, provincial, homogeneous place, right? It's ALSO continuing to embrace the blinkered worldview that growing up in such a place engenders. You need both for the joke to land.

You're reacting here as thought it's JUST about moving away (or not). It isn't.

I know educated, open-minded people who stayed in my hometown who have grown personally and intellectually and morally since youth. They stayed there for a handful of reasons, and some of them are as you state: an inability or unwillingness to be more than an hour from family, for example.

But I know of far more people who have not advanced in any meaningful way since they were 18 or 20. They often find the VERY IDEA of a world beyond the hometown to be fishy and untrustworthy. They are, uniformly, uncritical consumers of Fox News. They are the ones posting racist memes about, say, the Obamas, or proudly touting their COVID vax refusenik status.

This is who the joke is about.

Re:Facebook loses users for the first time by RustyConsul on Thursday February 03, 2022 @05:56PM (#30200249)
lol - thanks for this. Only on HN can you start with a joke and end with this.
Re:Facebook loses users for the first time by ubermonkey on Friday February 04, 2022 @08:35AM (#30206576)
Yeah, it's tedious.
Re:Facebook loses users for the first time by Charlie_26 on Friday February 04, 2022 @05:01AM (#30204847)
Solid explanation, but I think anyone can be forgiven for taking that tweet at face value and finding it disrespectful to small town people (good or bad) .
Re:Facebook loses users for the first time by jcon321 on Friday February 04, 2022 @08:37AM (#30206593)
wish I could report or downvote this
Re:Facebook loses users for the first time by shrimp_emoji on Friday February 04, 2022 @01:42PM (#30211101)
Reader, please take a moment to reflect on how hilarious this message is.
Re:Facebook loses users for the first time by ubermonkey on Friday February 04, 2022 @12:30PM (#30209796)
Why?
[dead]
Re:Facebook loses users for the first time by ubermonkey on Friday February 04, 2022 @08:36AM (#30206585)
Is your contention that there are no uncritical consumers of Fox News? If so, I have a huge swath of family in Mississippi I should introduce you to.
Re:Facebook loses users for the first time by tekknik on Friday February 04, 2022 @11:48AM (#30209225)
Um no. Tell me, what the point of that statement is other than to be a bigot and spreading hate? Could it have been left out, and less hate spread because of it, without changing the context they provided? So you see, it’s just there to spread hate.
Re:Facebook loses users for the first time by rmah on Thursday February 03, 2022 @01:30PM (#30196519)
KevinFarzad is not a journalist. WaPo was just reporting on such jokes.
Re:Facebook loses users for the first time by dgellow on Thursday February 03, 2022 @12:15PM (#30195268)
Journalist are normal people. Normal people write shitposts on Twitter. Presidents and CEOs can shitposts on Twitter but journalists cannot? What a weird assumption.
Re:Facebook loses users for the first time by bko on Thursday February 03, 2022 @12:23PM (#30195401)
Showing contempt for huge swaths of people doesn't really bode well for objectivity. It's in poor taste for anyone to just dunk on people who stay near their homes and eat at olive garden. Sure, journalists CAN shit post, and obviously they do. I guess I assume journalists that cover news for presumably everyone wouldn't have such open contempt for so many people. But hey, that's just me.
Re:Facebook loses users for the first time by ubermonkey on Thursday February 03, 2022 @01:20PM (#30196354)
I just realized you're basing your ire here on a misread of my post.

The joke is not from a journalist.

The joke was copied widely when originally posted, and it wasn't clear to me who wrote it in the first place -- but if I was going to reference it here, I wanted to give proper credit.

I found a story in the WaPo about online joke plagiarism, and it used this joke as an example -- and cited musician Kevin Farzad as the original author. Based on this, I credited him in my comment accordingly.

Re:Facebook loses users for the first time by xdavidliu on Thursday February 03, 2022 @02:08PM (#30197146)
I misread your post in exactly the same way and thought the joke was made by a journalist.
Re:Facebook loses users for the first time by browningstreet on Thursday February 03, 2022 @01:11PM (#30196220)
They’re not dunking on people who stay near home and eat at Olive Garden.
Re:Facebook loses users for the first time by meekmind on Thursday February 03, 2022 @01:27PM (#30196465)
It's different because I identify and agree with the virtue signaling of holier-than-thou social climbers who claim to do journalism. Their views represent mine, and since I am mostly without purpose or depth, I don't make petty distinctions about the definition of journalism: I only want them to validate my position that everyone I do not like is <insert adjective here> and incapable of critical thinking. The irony of this position is totally lost on me.