News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: I've built a tool for musicians using modular gear by eranation on Thursday February 03, 2022 @01:19AM (#30189315)
One tip - I'm a "musician" (hobbyist), I play the guitar, keyboard, dab with some Cubase, LogicPro, so I'm not a complete stranger to digital music. However nothing in the landing page explains to me what on earth is a patch, module, eurorack etc. Yes, I can google all that, but you have me as a "wider audience" that has a good chance in trying out the product if I had a clue what I need to do to use it. Do I need to buy hardware? You can upsell me an entry level synth (?), do I need to download / buy some software (e.g. a software synth) - a link to get a trial. You can basically open this from just people who know immediately exactly what you do and how it solves them a pain point, to a much wider audience, of people who didn't even know this is a thing, and now that you added a convenient feature to it, maybe the barrier of entry into this sub-genre of music making is lowered, and you gained an unplanned new customer that didn't even know they need it.
Re:Show HN: I've built a tool for musicians using modular gear by elevaet on Thursday February 03, 2022 @01:58AM (#30189538)
The modular synth heads who might use this are a niche audience, and they definitely would know what a patch is. If you don't know what a patch is, these aren't the droids you're looking for.

Hope that doesn't sound rude, its just that this tool doesn't really have any utility for a wider audience.

Re:Show HN: I've built a tool for musicians using modular gear by eranation on Friday February 04, 2022 @09:58AM (#30207515)
First, not rude at all, you make a good point, but my point is, if OP wants to monetize it / make it a business, my unsolicited tip (not that I am some startup guru or anything, just a armchair wannabe) is that even though you go for a niche, you can bring in verticals adjacent to your niche, instead of just fitting a product to the market, you can actually generate new demand by expanding the market. E.g. The chances to convert a keyboardist who can play into becoming a synth head and therefore potentially a paid user are higher than let's say a doctor, so if you already have a musician visit your niche synth website, give them a link, maybe they'll get hooked and you gained a new customer.
Re:Show HN: I've built a tool for musicians using modular gear by sackerhews on Thursday February 03, 2022 @10:16AM (#30193478)
>its just that

It's not just that. OP's title is "I've built a tool for musicians using mod..."

1. The title is highly inaccurate. It's not a tool for musicians, it's for a specific subset of musicians (like you say).

2. The OP got a front page listing on HN. He missed a golden opportunity explaining things. He probably got a lot of musician visitors that found it interesting, but just got confused and left.

Re:Show HN: I've built a tool for musicians using modular gear by polyterative on Thursday February 03, 2022 @06:17PM (#30200437)
Ok, can you please tell how you would have called this? I've been thinking about the tagline for a lot of time, wasn't able to come out with anything better than that.

"using modular gear" felt really concise to me