News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Starlink adds another 100Gbps connection to the SeattleIX by paul7986 on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @10:36PM (#30188264)
Musk is likable but im personally in no hurry to buy anything any of his especiialy his hyped up robot cars .. here's one almost killing a pedestrian (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lnp0VChf1_k) ... execute one algorithm to avoid car yet oops we forgot to program it executing additional ones in this situation .. let's ship out an update. Progress is going to be a killer!

Starlink seems to be more hype too like his HyperLoop.

Re:Starlink adds another 100Gbps connection to the SeattleIX by mlindner on Thursday February 03, 2022 @12:43AM (#30189116)
That's got nothing to do with "robot cars". That's just a bad driver. Why are you trying to spread FUD?

Even the video description is incorrect.

> Note the driver blows the horn as he enters the intersection. He obviously cannot stop the car. Probable FSD or Autopilot crash.

FSD/Autopilot does not stay on or prevent human interaction. Slamming on the brake turns it off, even assuming was on. This is a "unintended press of the accelerator pedal" type crash. Human error, and actually a good argument for why removing the human from the loop would be a good idea.

> Starlink seems to be more hype too like his HyperLoop.

Starlink is serving over 100,000 customers with good service all paying $100/month. Hardly hype.

Re:Starlink adds another 100Gbps connection to the SeattleIX by southerntofu on Thursday February 03, 2022 @07:51AM (#30191792)
> FSD/Autopilot does not stay on or prevent human interaction.

I'm not aware of Tesla specifics, but i've previously read several stories on HN of car computers who wouldn't let the driver be in control. As a computer person who has moderate understanding of mechanics/electronics, i believe unless you have a physical kill switch to take control back from the computer, there is literally no way software can be safe enough that even in a crash you can regain control.

I mean apparently you've been around for a while on these forums. You're surely educated that software can never be trusted, especially with life-endangering situations.

Re:Starlink adds another 100Gbps connection to the SeattleIX by mlindner on Friday February 04, 2022 @09:20PM (#30216407)
> I'm not aware of Tesla specifics, but i've previously read several stories on HN of car computers who wouldn't let the driver be in control.

That can't happen. People misremember things when they're in a panicked state. Or they're exaggerating to defend themselves. The instant you even slightly tug on the wheel autopilot and autosteer of any kind will disengage and revert to a traffic aware cruise control state (with an audible chime). And any application of the brake disengages autopilot/autosteer and also automatic cruise control with an audible chime.

> I mean apparently you've been around for a while on these forums. You're surely educated that software can never be trusted, especially with life-endangering situations.

I'm not sure what you're saying. People aren't "trusting" it yet which is why it's easy to disengage and override.

Re:Starlink adds another 100Gbps connection to the SeattleIX by southerntofu on Saturday February 05, 2022 @06:17AM (#30220060)
> That can't happen.

Yes yes i've heard that one before. I've had many bugs "that can't happen" over the course of my lifetime. Fortunately none of them involved a car so i'm still around to talk about it. A few years ago, somebody would have laughed at the idea of Boeing producing fallible equipment, especially since we as a species have decades of experience of air travel. Now would you still say it's unthinkable that Boeing could produce faulty hardware/software?

A link that gets posted on HN quite often contains many such bugs "can't happen" bugs, that aren't even caused by AI : https://beza1e1.tuxen.de/lore/index.html

I also remember some threads about high-range medical equipment (in actual hospitals) killing people due to software bugs.

> And any application of the brake disengages autopilot/autosteer and also automatic cruise control with an audible chime.

Is that a physical kill switch that triggers a sensor to produce an alert/chime? Or does the sensor ask politely the computer who actually controls the car to disable the autopilot? In the latter case, i know of no way to make this safe: for example what happens if the sensors requesting human control back die, short-circuit, or otherwise malfunctions? Or if the program enters certain kinds of memory violations? Or any other software/hardware fault?

> I'm not sure what you're saying.

I'm saying i've seen enough bad engineering (not always, but sometimes along with bad faith) across all fields i've been even remotely involved in. And i'm saying i don't even remotely trust the >100 micro-controllers you find in a modern car whose schematics and source-code we can't inspect. I mean i don't fully trust mechanical hardware either, but at least with it symptoms and failure modes can be easily reproduced and debugged.

And i'm definitely saying i would never ever trust a machine-learning algorithm with life-making decisions. More on this topic:

- James Mickens at Usenix on why AI is usually a terrible idea: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ajGX7odA87k

- jwz's blog (another HN favorite) is also full of examples of AI failures ; a fun harmless example: https://www.jwz.org/blog/2021/06/using-ritual-magic-to-trap-...

Re:Starlink adds another 100Gbps connection to the SeattleIX by dotancohen on Thursday February 03, 2022 @07:15AM (#30191473)
That video is amazing. Play it back at low speed, the airbags are fully deployed before the hood even begins to crumple.

Additionally, we see just how a real human reacts to a real present danger: confusion. After identifying the threat the pedestrian instinctively runs into the path of the vehicle, just to run.

Re:Starlink adds another 100Gbps connection to the SeattleIX by matt-attack on Thursday February 03, 2022 @09:31AM (#30192844)
Yep and they’re fully deployed within one frame of this video.
Re:Starlink adds another 100Gbps connection to the SeattleIX by paul7986 on Thursday February 03, 2022 @01:07AM (#30189242)
Autopilot crash so your saying autopilot (aka robot driver/car) is at fault and yet I'm spreading FUD?
Re:Starlink adds another 100Gbps connection to the SeattleIX by mlindner on Friday February 04, 2022 @09:17PM (#30216392)
It's not an autopilot crash. That's the FUD you're spreading.
Re:Starlink adds another 100Gbps connection to the SeattleIX by the_pwner224 on Wednesday February 02, 2022 @10:54PM (#30188403)
If anything Starlink is (along with SpaceX) the least hypey Musk project, it has some minor rough edges but seems to actually be doing a good job of fulfilling its goal. Comparing it to Hyperloop doesn't seem reasonable to me.
Re:Starlink adds another 100Gbps connection to the SeattleIX by _ph_ on Thursday February 03, 2022 @02:07AM (#30189581)
And it has to be remarked that Hyperloop was solely a concept Musk published to share it, as he personally had no plans of implementing it himself. The only other involvement of his with it is sponsoring a yearly event where universities can compete on a one-mile test track on the SpaceX site in Hawthorne.
Re:Starlink adds another 100Gbps connection to the SeattleIX by shaklee3 on Thursday February 03, 2022 @01:00AM (#30189205)
starlink is possibly the most hyped on the financial side. there are virtually no scenarios where they can make money and still maintain the plans they have now. I know people will disagree, but we'll have to see in a few years.