News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Despite the hype, iPhone security no match for NSO spywar... by badrabbit on Saturday January 29, 2022 @04:25PM (#30130645)
I don't understand why they can't compare android vs iOS. Can't people use Signal instead of iMessage? If they are criticizing iMessage then shouldn't the default messenger on android be used as a fair comparison?

My 0.2$ on this topic: prevention is nice but not good enough against a persistent or unknown threat. Mobile devices lack EDR coverage, even enterprises install an MDR and forget about it. I want every child process, network connection and interprocess call that falls out of baseline logged. Compromises happen, discovering them months later is the big issue at hand. If you're a journalist or dissident then you or your benefactors should be able to purchase a mobile endpoint security monitoring service that will actively monitor for exploitation and prevent known threats based on good intel. Crowdstrike is the only company that comes close to supporting this.

Re:Despite the hype, iPhone security no match for NSO spywar... by TheDong on Sunday January 30, 2022 @12:03AM (#30134204)
Even if you install Signal, you'll still have iMessage installed and processing messages sent to your apple ID.

iMessage on iOS is part of the OS, and does some message handling in kernelspace. Yes, it has blastdoor, but even since blastdoor sandboxing has been introduced, there have been multiple iMessage CVEs which lead to a full device compromise. See this project zero post for more about iMessage [0].

What I'm trying to say here, is that on an iPhone, no matter what messenger you use, some iMessage exploits can pwn that messenger anyway since iMessage cannot be disabled, and has privileged OS level access.

On the other hand, android does have "google messenger" or whatever the OEM installed, and it may not be uninstallable, but it's sandboxed away from the OS in the same way every other app is. There have been exploits based on kernel-space processing of media attachments on android too, but those actually did depend on the app being used, so if you switched SMS apps to one which rejected such an attachment, or otherwise processed it differently, you actually could be secure. Said another way, on android you actually can turn off the default messenger and use signal for SMS. On iOS, that's not so realistic.

[0]: https://googleprojectzero.blogspot.com/2021/01/a-look-at-ime...

Re:Despite the hype, iPhone security no match for NSO spywar... by YeBanKo on Sunday January 30, 2022 @01:12AM (#30134555)
iMessage can be disabled, but not uninstalled.
Re:Despite the hype, iPhone security no match for NSO spywar... by 369548684892826 on Saturday January 29, 2022 @06:32PM (#30131740)
> 0.2$

Do you mean 0.02 or is inflation really running that high?

Re:Despite the hype, iPhone security no match for NSO spywar... by giantrobot on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:34PM (#30133282)
Maybe they work for Verizon[0]?

[0] https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=MShv_74FNWU

Re:Despite the hype, iPhone security no match for NSO spywar... by neximo64 on Saturday January 29, 2022 @05:54PM (#30131439)
How can you be so sure NSO don't have an in into Signal? After all, it still takes an OS to run Signal.
Re:Despite the hype, iPhone security no match for NSO spywar... by artinmg on Saturday January 29, 2022 @06:16PM (#30131609)
Well you can’t necessarily, because who’s to say what various methods they’ve discovered. However, if we were to use the most famous recent example that relied on an unknown sender transmitting a GIF containing the compromise, Signal does have some additional protection in that it doesn’t receive messages from unknown senders by default. Rather the recipient must accept the message explicitly.
Re:Despite the hype, iPhone security no match for NSO spywar... by Sharlin on Saturday January 29, 2022 @06:27PM (#30131707)
Honestly, even after accepting the message there should be another confirmation step before viewing any and all non-textual content.
Re:Despite the hype, iPhone security no match for NSO spywar... by sorry_outta_gas on Saturday January 29, 2022 @06:04PM (#30131525)
Yeah if you can inject into the libraries on the system app isn't to important, just log whatever is sent to uitextfield or whatever and some info about the process; or be lazy and just take screenshots
Re:Despite the hype, iPhone security no match for NSO spywar... by badrabbit on Saturday January 29, 2022 @06:19PM (#30131643)
Yes. That would be a comparison I am interested in. Are there vulnerable and exploitable system libs and components on iOS? How does that fare compared to android?
Re:Despite the hype, iPhone security no match for NSO spywar... by badrabbit on Saturday January 29, 2022 @06:18PM (#30131629)
I don't but the article was saying iphone is less secure and signal has better restrictions on who can text you than imessage. So use signal on iphone? How does imessage reflect badly on the whole OS especially when compared to a non-default app like signal.
Re:Despite the hype, iPhone security no match for NSO spywar... by Tagbert on Saturday January 29, 2022 @06:42PM (#30131825)
Well, the article said that in their sample, fewer Android phones showed evidence of attack but they also said that Android does less event logging and they could not know if there were other attacks that they did not catch. Not really a definitive answer.
Re:Despite the hype, iPhone security no match for NSO spywar... by alphabettsy on Saturday January 29, 2022 @08:07PM (#30132544)
Could it also be that most of their potential targets use iPhones?
Re:Despite the hype, iPhone security no match for NSO spywar... by fsflover on Sunday January 30, 2022 @08:19AM (#30136932)
> After all, it still takes an OS to run Signal.

Which is why I find it suspicous that Signal do not provide the client for non-Android and non-iOS systems, both not very secure.

Re:Despite the hype, iPhone security no match for NSO spywar... by ignoramous on Sunday January 30, 2022 @02:00AM (#30134731)
> I don't understand why they can't compare android vs iOS.

Matthew Green et al already did: https://securephones.io

> If you're a journalist or dissident then you or your benefactors should be able to purchase a mobile endpoint security monitoring service that will actively monitor for exploitation and prevent known threats based on good intel.

I am actively building one such open source app (for Android). We are half-way there. One my friends was editor-in-chief at a big media company and his frustrations made it clear to me that they were sitting ducks. Though, securing folks in high risk profession is not easy, at all. But one ought to start somewhere. And it is clear, the eventual solution needs to be external to the phones themselves.

Re:Despite the hype, iPhone security no match for NSO spywar... by faeyanpiraat on Sunday January 30, 2022 @06:42AM (#30136157)
Why not make a phone which is secure by default?
Re:Despite the hype, iPhone security no match for NSO spywar... by ignoramous on Sunday January 30, 2022 @07:30AM (#30136580)
Easier said than done because of the attack surface, but I do think the industry will respond given Androids are the most widely-deployed, always-connected, computers in use out there.

I don't think just securing the hardware is enough (though, even that isn't fully done), the software itself remains hard to tame. Add to the fact that folks (including attackers) can "install" arbitrary things on their Androids, the problem gets only worse.

Then, there's the social and legislative aspects as well. For example, no one can raid your home without a search warrant, that's illegal. Similar thing needs to exist in the digital space. This at least thwarts illegal spyware, if not the law enforcement themselves from snooping about people's digital lives.

Re:Despite the hype, iPhone security no match for NSO spywar... by faeyanpiraat on Sunday January 30, 2022 @07:39AM (#30136641)
Okay so the real issue here is that people want convenience, which requires "N" number of features, which results in an attack surface of "too large to make it secure".
Re:Despite the hype, iPhone security no match for NSO spywar... by saagarjha on Sunday January 30, 2022 @01:31AM (#30134640)
> I want every child process, network connection and interprocess call that falls out of baseline logged.

This would be a nice thing to have, yeah

> If you're a journalist or dissident then you or your benefactors should be able to purchase a mobile endpoint security monitoring service that will actively monitor for exploitation and prevent known threats based on good intel. Crowdstrike is the only company that comes close to supporting this.

lol no. Commercial EDR software sucks whether it is Crowdstrike or Carbon Black or Cylance.

Re:Despite the hype, iPhone security no match for NSO spywar... by badrabbit on Sunday January 30, 2022 @03:51PM (#30140961)
> lol no. Commercial EDR software sucks whether it is Crowdstrike or Carbon Black or Cylance.

That's like saying commercial firewalls suck. Do you mean the UI perhaps? They all allow you to specify detection rules like with ids and fw but the out of the box stuff is good enough to catch APTs but obviously not perfect. Althougj out of those I can only recommend crowdstrike falcon, defender ATP is also decent. Red teamers have bypasses for some, it's a cat and mouse game but can you find one instance where an actual threat actor intentionally evaded an EDR?

Re:Despite the hype, iPhone security no match for NSO spywar... by lnxg33k1 on Saturday January 29, 2022 @07:35PM (#30132261)
I would quote myself from another thread where I said that Apple is only about design, but since we're talking security, I see always apple as exploiting having a very low market share for desktop and nil market share as server, but in terms of practical security I see posts like this: https://www.forbes.com/sites/adriankingsleyhughes/2012/04/25...

But I also like to share these kind of posts when I want to make example about like the absolute lack of knowledge in terms of security of apple, like having the guts to release to public a system where password files / shadow and sudoers are world writable just shows that they really have no idea what they're doing

And I wouldn't consider myself a fanboy or like justify this kind of posts like mine as "HN is notoriously against apple" I would more likely say that HN audience is a bit into tech, and if you are into tech and understand how systems work then you can't just ignore these kind of things when you see them so you forcefully end up just trying to dodge a system like apple

Re:Despite the hype, iPhone security no match for NSO spywar... by octoberfranklin on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:03PM (#30133885)
Because "we're a tiny bit better than the other half of the duopoly" is avoiding the issue.