If anything, that is an underestimate. I really can't understand what they are thinking. Since I am interested in both DVD and streaming, up to now I was completely locked into Netflix because of the integrated system - my "Instant" queue is just the subset of my DVD queue that is streamable.
If they break that link, and I derive no gain from being BOTH a Netflix-DVD and a Netflix-streaming customer, what is there to stop me switching to Amazon or other competing streaming service tomorrow? Absolutely nothing.
This is such a bad decision I actually can't even begin to understand how it made sense to the dude for the whole length of time it took him to write that announcement.
Edit: and another thing. Am I expected to believe that a technology company cannot figure out how to run two different business arms with a single customer-facing UI/website? This is something frigging clothing companies do every day.
Even worse, the technology company we're talking about already does that and has done it for years.
It's kind of a moot point to say "Well, Amazon has a crappier interface, so Netflix is safe", since Amazon can always update its interface to something more friendly. The important point is that Netflix has given up one of the major incentives to use its service -- the integration of DVD and streaming.
The quality of those services compared to Netflix.
Netflix realizes that they have to move quickly to cement their dominance in this field over the long term. If they are held back by their legacy business, they are going to die quickly. They would rather risk pissing off their biggest fans than jeopardize their stake in streaming.
Because it seems to me that this is a lose-lose proposition, for the reasons stated by the commenters above.
Quite a lot, actually, including the majority of new releases. And this will only become more evident in the eyes of streaming subscribers when they no longer see most of the new titles listed in searches. (Even the presence of those "Only available on DVD" titles in streaming-service SERPs lent a sort of subconscious, psychological indication of the robustness of Netflix's library).
Hard to see what Netflix stands to gain here. Streaming may be the future of media consumption, but there are still a few big hurdles to leap. Placing all the eggs in the streaming basket now feels a tiny bit premature. It's entirely possible now that streaming will win the day, but it'll be a competitor (or two) waving the victory flag.
Nor do those same people want to watch a movie or a TV show on their computer.
Those people request DVDs.
I don't see the issue with keeping everything under one brand.
Netflix became popular because of their DVD-in-the-mail service. It's a shame to spin that off into a sub-par seeming brand. Just keep it all under one house but emphasize the streaming service.
It's not like they can't design their one site to give users an option on what they want (streaming or DVD-in-the-mail).
Keep it simple, stupid.
If they are doing this because of the economics of the DVD and streaming service, then nevermind.
The main reason for the split is the realization that streaming service and DVD service are two completely different businesses that need to grow in completely different ways. For example, in case of streaming service, we've just expanded to Latin America and the Caribbean (to 43 new countries). In case of the DVD service, we're adding a new video games catalog.
DVD service is still growing - it probably won't grow at the same rate for very long, but right now, it's growing. Streaming, on the other hand, is growing at a phenomenal rate. Therefore it makes sense to not hold up the growth of one service for the other to catch up.
In the time (about 6 months) I've been at Netflix, the one thing I'll have to call out is the absolute, undeterred focus that the company has. Simply put, Netflix fundamentally believes that it's best to do one thing really, really, really well, than to do many things reasonably well.
Splitting the streaming and DVD service isn't so much due to lack of ability to design the website to suit both options, but really as an indication that they are turning out to be different businesses altogether.
Streaming is most valuable when DVD is (a) there as a backup, and (b) managed with the same system.
Netflix has seriously decreased the value of their streaming offering by separating out the DVD and de-integrating their systems.
There is basically no reason to pay for Kwikster now (terrible name BTW), and the streaming is now an extra cost. We'll have our kids use Amazon Prime, which we already pay for. They're much less choosy for content anyway, and it cuts off another monthly bill.
Someone inside of Netflix should have had the balls to tell your CEO this was a stupid idea and customers would hate it.
I joined Netflix because of streaming and I prefer to look at streaming only. When I joined netflix I got a DVD and didn't return it for a year. I didn't want to return it because I didn't want to get another DVD. In search results I never wanted to see the DVD results. I wanted to see what I could watch now. Content is such a key part of this. If the streaming service had the same or more content than the DVD business, nobody would care. But since they are still building that collection and struggling with content owners, people are freaking out.
Time will tell whether this was a stupid idea for the market at large. As a streaming customer, I'm indifferent. As a tech pundit, I think it was an important strategic move and I applaud Netflix.
To me the split has zero impact on my perception of the value of the streaming service.
I looked at Amazon about 6 months ago, and there was no content of interest there that was not also on Netflix.
I had previously thought that if I ever did want to order a DVD again (for something not available on streaming), I could just reinstate the DVD service and order it. Now, it appears, I would have to sign up with a totally different system to get the DVDs. I'm probably not going to bother doing that.
I am baffled as to why they would split the DVDs into a different business altogether. It's a different product, sure, but need it be a whole separate business? I trust it makes sense internally to Netflix, and I presume it is projected to be more profitable. And if so, then I can hardly blame them for doing it. But as a user, I don't get it.
With the split, Netflix gets to focus entirely on streaming - make it better for the customer. Which means, more (and better) content, faster and better streaming service, Netflix on more devices, providing Netflix outside US and Canada etc.
And Qwikster gets to focus entirely on DVD service - which means expanding the DVD catalog, getting video game rentals for Wii, PS3 and Xbox 360.
As a customer, you get a much better Netflix and/or Qwikster experience. As a Netflix employee, I get to focus entirely on making streaming better, faster, available on more devices, and in more regions than we have today, without having to worry about compatibility with the DVD service.
I don't want my experience dominated by picking between one medium and another.
I want to pick from a unified comprehensive content catalog, and get the content on whatever medium is available/convenient.
I want a single unified queue which I can append and rearrange with ease, not have to maintain 2+ queues of content separated only by medium.
I want to add title X with the intent of seeing it on pristine Blu-ray, and then on a whim watching it right now when streaming rights are negotiated - _without_ having to do a deliberate search on another site ("nope, not streaming yet").
FWIW: I was at Kodak when they decided that the distribution model was more important than the customer experience. You remember Kodak? used to make film for cameras? film? nevermind. Big name in the photography business, now bulldozing five miles of disused manufacturing buildings for tax reasons.
Splitting the delivery departments was smart, realizing streaming is the winning long-term move was smart, unifying the customer-facing content selection to cover all media would be smart. If I pick a title, I want the choice of media subordinate, not dominant.
If I buy a Macbook Pro it's from Apple and if I rent a movie from the iTunes store it's from Apple... They are completely different business units internally, but to the customer it's the same company and I can use the same account for either purchase.
http://abovethecrowd.com/2011/09/18/understanding-why-netfli...
An additional possibility that occurs to me is that the movie studios' well-publicized dislike and fear of the streaming business is hurting the physical DVD business. Netflix has had to accept some pretty bad terms from studios, like delaying their availability of new releases, in part because studios see Netflix as a long-term threat. Quickster, on the other hand, should be able to build better relationships with studios precisely because they're not a threat to the studios' long-term dominance.
Basically, it's true that this is not the most customer-friendly move in the short-term, but the movie studios' strategy in the medium-term was to kill Netflix. "Continue to grow in the same direction" was not an option because the studios hated it, and this way both pieces of Netflix have at least a chance to survive.
Depth of catalog is the most important feature for me. I especially like watching HBO shows without paying tons of money for cable. I also sometimes like watching really obscure films. Films which were released on DVD at one time, but where it may be hard to track down anyone to authorize licensing for streaming.
Which should I pick?
Before Netflix, I satisfied my tastes at the independent video stores around town. Netflix killed those. Naturally, I'm sensitive to any changes that might undermine the DVD service.
The best solution, as I've mentioned before, is to just allow obligatory licensing. Let Netflix convert its entire DVD catalog to streaming. Make it pay a fair statutory fee whenever it streams anything. If a content owner cannot be found, allow the fee to be collected by a designated rightsholder organization (something like ASCAP) until claimed by a verified owner of the content.
We had a few video stores that really specialized in the long tail. They sat right across the street from Blockbusters or Hollywood Videos. Stuck around a few decades, thrived on the indie image (sorted movies by director, that sort of thing). They made it through BB's reign, and passed away only recently.
But eh, that's my limited experience. I'd welcome more data. Call it a hunch for now, and an open question.
I'm surprised the reaction here is so negative. Working for large companies the theme is usually waste, and inept decision making. This is a result of the size of the decision apparatus. I would think a lot of people here are fleeing that kind of a work environment or are at least aware of it.
Wearing a customer hat this sucks in the short-term, but perhaps pays off in the long-term if the internal decisions made are substantially sharper. Now you don't have meetings where people are wondering why stupid decision X was made, and the answer comes back 'because of this Y interaction with our legacy mail service' which has no long-term role to play.
It's hard to see from afar the complexity of the decisions that goes on at Netflix HQ every day. I don't think that's going to be appreciated when people are wearing their customer hats. Clearly, the short-term customer perspective is poor.
The happiest face I can put on this is that they've decided to focus on a specific kind of customer (the undemanding kind who will take whatever turns up on streaming) and kiss off the more discerning sort (who really valued the breadth of catalog, and didn't care as much about the medium). Which may or may not be a good business decision, but it's unsurprising that those customers are pretty cranky about it.
Anecdotal, but I suspect this will be the least popular move the company ever makes.
For example, when Motorola split into mobile/home and public safety/enterprise divisions, this made quite a bit of sense (and they were desperate anyway) because there was little overlap between those. To a lesser extent you can understand HPs spinning off the PC business to focus on printers, but in this case, although the underlying delivery mechanisms and business cases are very different both are DVDs!
Think of companies going the other way, consolidating information to create user synergy, i.e. Google adding tweets to search results.
Some TVs and most Blu-Ray / DVD players these days play Netflix without extra anything hooked in. Netflix has done a really good job making its streaming offering available on a TV without additional hardware or tech skill.
What if Microsoft did something similar? What if the CEO in 1998 put all his efforts and attention into the Web? Results for Microsoft might have been much better.
Streaming has a unique disadvantage: you have to haggle with each individual content owner.
Yes, it's cheaper to move bits than stuff. Much. But licensing is a pricey hassle. It's a huge part of the comparison, and as content owners get savvy, it will only get more expensive over time.
This should be a signal of how much more right we got the law with physical media. We all want DVDs to be dead, sure. But DVDs would die tomorrow if we just set up an obligatory licensing scheme for this sort of content. If you distribute a movie, Netflix should be allowed to stream it, and pay you a fair statutory fee.
(This isn't some a radical new idea or some Communist scheme, it's basically how radio stations work.)
Until the law is fixed, DVDs will stick around, lingering on.
For my part, I still prefer DVDs because I actually like owning the disc. But more than that, I have a 25 Mbps FiOS connection and somehow at least once a week when I'm streaming something, Netflix dynamically changes the quality. It's more annoying than skipping due to scratch discs and the quality comes out terribly. I have no idea if Verizon's playing games, but as long as ISPs lose out with streaming media, I wouldn't want to bank on that business.
I'm not looking forward to a world without physical media where content providers and ISPs can dick us around with arbitrary pricing for content.
Again, Windows and Office are and always have been the lifeblood of Microsoft. You really think they should have decided to let someone else make all of that money in 1998 and retooled their whole business to keep only Hotmail? I think that would have been disastrous for MS.
Not to mention the diminished role MS has with developer mindshare.
Obviously, Windows is a great cash cow and I'm not saying they should have spun it off. I'm saying a VP should have taken responsibility for it and the CEO should have focused most of his/her energy on the Web.
Why did they lose Starz? Because they are too successful, and their suppliers are nervous about Netflix. Too many subscribers = too much cost.
To reduce their size they'll need to split the two services, and let each one compete directly.
To be honest, I would love to have Netflix's problems. Growing too fast and having to pivot your business model to keep your agility? Netflix is operating like a startup. Good for them.
3. It's not as if this HAS to be that way. In a blog comment Hastings said initially both sites would have all existing and current data. We're technologists here, is it hard for anybody here to imagine how sharing that data would work?
6. How will it be a distraction to now have a company that is solely focused on streaming -- which is the umbrella under which the original content is being created?
Wouldn't you agree that the economics of show-running fit a lot more acceptably into a business where the primary cost is content licensing vs a business where the primary cost is dozens of physical warehouses and massive USPS fees?
We like movies. I can't see how we're not a target customer, but I can't get most new releases on Netflix streaming. Now that streaming and DVD-by-mail are separate companies, how will Netflix convert customers? With completely separate websites, what opportunities will exist to inform me that the movie I'm about to receive in the mail is also available through their streaming plan? I'd like to know that, because the moment they lock up deals for the content I want, I'd be on board.
Netflix is a direct competitor to cable. I don't have cable and I use their streaming platform exclusively. I am their target customer.
They'll have a tough time convincing the older generation to ditch cable. They know that. So they're ditching you, instead. As things move along, you'll end up in the minority. At least, that's what Netflix is hoping will happen.
As it turns out, I've been using giving Netflix money to be a company they don't want to be. Silly me.
There's just no way the content creators are going to give Netflix better terms than they give cable operators. None. Won't happen.
And Netflix cannot afford to pay what cable pays, because it's all added cost to them.
Netflix is between a rock and hard place, they know it, and they did the absolutely worst thing they could do. They should have just let things ride, milk the cash cow they'd created, and see how it plays out. Instead, they shot the cow, spilled the milk, and seem oblivious to the overwhelmingly negative reaction from their customers. sigh
Your comment here is echoed all over HN and the Netflix blog.
Obviously being a separate website in no way prevents them from engaging in that sort of cross promotion. Strikes me as common sense. Comments like yours seem to imply an airgap between the two sites. I haven't read anything official that should suggest that.
You really think that the respective sites will have no integration? Not a single-sign-on user account? Not an "Available on Netflix" link? Why? It makes business sense for both units and it doesn't impede any of the objectives of the spinoff.
"A negative of the renaming and separation is that the Qwikster.com and Netflix.com websites will not be integrated."
http://blog.netflix.com/2011/09/explanation-and-some-reflect...
The problems, as I see them:
1. The two parts (DVD & streaming) had different characteristics (bigger collection vs. instant gratification) that balanced each other. This synergy is now gone.
2. The attack surface for other companies has just doubled. Netflix's DVD handling is super streamlined (they have special sorters in postal centers) but there are other strong players like Redbox here. The streaming biz is nothing unique, Amazon can easily get to that level of collection in a short time. Divide and conquer? They just did it to themselves!
3. As others have pointed out, the reviews, and user histories will be split. From a subscriber perspective this is most undesirable, now I have to deal with two sites.
4. The quality of recommendations will suffer with less data (they weren't great to start with) after the split.
5. How will this affect developers using the Netflix API?
6. What will happen to Netflix's original content creation efforts, this will be a huge distraction to those. And they are vital.
Overall, this has a heavy handedness to it that makes you wish for the comfort of the likes of Amazon.
EDIT: This also makes my suspicions that Amazon is gearing up to a massive upgrade of their offering soon. Netflix probably tried to focus on streaming and stay ahead in the game. How? I don't know.