Absolute percentiles are useful because they do show you where you stand in relation to the rest of society. Families making $250K may not be Scrooge McDuck-style super-rich, but they're indisputably in the top few percent of the nation in terms of income. It's hard for those folks to claim to be middle class when 90+ percent of their fellow citizens make less.
It's also worth noting that people's lifestyles and "necessities" expand to fit their income, particularly if their income goes up relatively gradually. I've literally heard people say, "Well, I make $400K a year but I'm not rich because it costs a lot of money to pay mortgage and taxes in Westchester County and send my kids to private school and drive a nice car." They think that "rich" means "disposable income I can spend a whim," when in fact living in Westchester and sending the kids to private school is part of being rich.
Of course this is a problem, because how can you expect people to abide by law they cannot understand? Worse, how can you communicate to people that they're incapable of understanding without being (or even just 'coming across as') condescending? I don't know, I don't have an answer. But when people like this: http://www.nytimes.com/2009/05/03/magazine/03european-t.html... show being absolutely oblivious to the mechanism (people who are for the rest presumably quite intelligent, and who - professionally - spend quite a bit of time on a piece like this), how can we expect the average citizen to really understand?
I guess it's a recent problem too - just 50 years ago people just listened to their banker about financial things and their doctor on medical things, and believed whatever they said, but we've long passed that point.
[1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pareto_distribution [2]Unless you look at the bottom end where you may find welfare trap effects http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Welfare_trap
I don't disagree with your first 2 statements. Here's my beef with "pay more taxes":
- The top 5% of earners already pay 53% of the nation's income tax revenue. The top 1% pay 33% of it. Exactly how much would you like it to be?
- Those in the top 5% are in a higher tax bracket already (usually 33 or 35%).
- 40-50% of americans pay no federal income tax (only payroll tax) and 10% receive more cash from the IRS than they contribute in federal income taxes and payroll taxes.
So, please, tell me what those in the top 1%/5% should be paying?
You miss this point because the mendacity is useful to the very rich, who pay their henchmen in Congress and the Murdoch media companies to repeat it endlessly.
Add the fact that most of the whales out there pay a much lower marginal rate than you or I makes it all the more impressive that they carry so much of the load. It's a stark sign of the disparity.
You should pay as much tax as is required to lift the rest of society to (or close to) your level (of lifestyle/income etc). (obviously "your level" will decrease as you pay more tax).
That's the IDEAL it is of course highly impractical. Most ideals are. :(
Just because you got given awesome opportunities (good school, good family, good race, good society, whatever) and even if you worked really hard, doesn't mean you deserve to hold disproportionate amounts of wealth compared to those that didn't get those things.
I have a friend who is roughly the same age as me, same race (white), parents were the same class, and we grew up < 3 miles from each other. Yet he is the laziest eff'ing slob I know. His wife works part-time, he collects unemployment and makes no attempt to train or find a job. They live in subsidized housing and make ends meet via welfare and taking advantage of others' charity.
I'm curious how you argue that all of society (including people like this) should have their lifestyle increase in perpetuity.
You can always find fringe cases where people are undeserving and insulting to a particular system. But the system shouldn't be defined by the few.
For every one person you find, who is a lazy slob, I bet I can find three people who want to work, want to make something of it but just don't have the means to get out of the rut they are in. (presumptuous I know, and I can't really back this up, but I'd like to believe it is true).
How about I flip that then, the wealthy robbed the people to generate their wealth, and then complain when they have to give (some of) it back.
It is very rare to find a company that isn't exploiting someone along the chain in order to generate that wealth. Of course capitalism renames it to "surplus value", but it is in fact exploitation (people being paid less than the value they add).
Do you really think an individual is responsible for all wealth they generate? So, if Steve Jobs was born in china, and lived through the cultural revolution, he would have still built Apple (or equivalent) and been the success he is today. Because society and the services around him had nothing to do with his success?
People don't generate wealth for themselves, they capitalise on opportunities provided to them. The U.S provided a lot of opportunities to a minority of people, who then capitalised on it. But their wealth wouldn't exist without the opportunities being available and thus they should pay tax (proportional to the amount of wealth they have generated) so that the U.S (government) can provide more opportunities to more people.
The good news for is that a standout non-lazy person will raise much more revenue than a stand-out leach will be able to take.
If you believe theologically, ideologically, or otherwise that "all men (and women!) are created equal" then it follows they should pay equally. I would argue equally means normalizing their income against their position on the income scale so the taxes "hurt" them the same as it they "hurt" everyone else.
It is well known that 10% of the income of someone below the poverty line is a serious hardship, but 10% in the top 1% of earners is not (although it still hurts). If you normalize the taxes based on the income distribution you can cause the amount of economic "hurt" to be equalized across society. This means that the top %1 will pay much more in taxes than perhaps the bottom 90% or even 95%. However, the "hurt" they endure will be equal.
(note that this is not a matter of argument - this is quite clearly settled. Of course you could question if it should be like this, and if we shouldn't change the meaning of 'equal' into more positive rights ('affirmative action' etc); I'm not so much interested in debating that. I'm just pointing out that for broadly-accepted definitions of the terms you use, your argument is flawed).
>> If you believe theologically, ideologically, or otherwise that "all men (and women!) are created equal" then it follows they should pay equally.
On this, I'm not sure how you can come to that conclusion. I'm assuming (possibly wrongly) that you're referring to the DOI, which states:
"We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness."
This seems to refer to equal starting points, equal liberties, and equal opportunities–not equal amounts of wealth or income throughout life. I think "pursuit" is a key word here. We should all be free to pursue what makes us happy, but there are no rights or guarantees that we will get it.
So you are saying all americans have equal starting points/liberties/opportunities?
When it comes to income, the top 1% includes an attorney making $250K and a hedge fund manager making $10M. I imagine its similar for wealth. My guess is that distribution curves spike somewhere past the 1% mark.
Maybe I'm biased because I barely make the cut and don't want to pay more taxes, but it seems odd to use such an arbitrary cutoff for reporting and (especially) policy decisions.
And please tell me if I'm wrong or off here–I'm geniunely interested in this.
EDIT: downvoted? Seriously?