Re:The Wealthiest 5% Grabbed Most of the America’s Gains
by jfruh on Sunday September 18, 2011 @10:29PM
(#3011979)
I should add that I'm not definitely not exempting myself from this set of attitudes. When I was in grad school in my early 20s (in the mid-late '90s, so it's not like inflation makes a huge difference here) I made less than $17K a year for several years, but I never felt particularly deprived and don't particularly recall not doing things I wanted to do because of money worries. Now my wife and I make more than $100K combined (putting us in the top 25 percent of US workers) and yet we are constantly bumping up against the limits of our income, particularly because we enjoy travelling. I don't feel rich but I know I'm better off than a significant majority of Americans.
Absolute percentiles are useful because they do show you where you stand in relation to the rest of society. Families making $250K may not be Scrooge McDuck-style super-rich, but they're indisputably in the top few percent of the nation in terms of income. It's hard for those folks to claim to be middle class when 90+ percent of their fellow citizens make less.
It's also worth noting that people's lifestyles and "necessities" expand to fit their income, particularly if their income goes up relatively gradually. I've literally heard people say, "Well, I make $400K a year but I'm not rich because it costs a lot of money to pay mortgage and taxes in Westchester County and send my kids to private school and drive a nice car." They think that "rich" means "disposable income I can spend a whim," when in fact living in Westchester and sending the kids to private school is part of being rich.