In the US.
And while I agree that anything nearing a de facto monopoly should be strictly regulated, I think any effort should be directed at any messaging app with a large user base, e.g. WhatsApp, Facebook Messenger.
So long as there is a near substitute for Apple smartphones, I fail to see what that is sufficient grounds for anti-trust action.
The messaging apps are not a good example of monopoly violations. They are all market options which have many many solutions. WhatsApp, FB Messenger, Signal, iOS Messages, SMS, Discord, Slack, Google Hangouts, MS Teams, Zoom, Skype, and a thousand web forums have similar capabilities. The comms market is remarkably healthy. What most people complain about is the contract they agree to which has lots of restrictive clauses (some which are very vague). Those general contract terms in SaaS services is what I would aim to regulate, rather than the biggest incumbents in the disparate comms apps.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usage_share_of_operating_syste...
Apple has not (in my recollection) sought to exert control over content of what is being said or shared among users. In fact, they seem to keep quite a distance from wanting to know or be responsible for that.
And you're claiming that iMessage is the "primary medium of communication of the citizens"? That is just a little overblown, don't you think?
I would argue, if you have that position, maybe you should spend your energy or concern on cable TV news and other media outlets, who do far worse, with far less share of their markets.
You may want to search for Telegram and Apple.
You can't expect Apple to allow apps which wilfully tolerate illegal content.
They also block apps that involve politically controversial content, or content that they disagree with (e.g. pornography).
Announced but not (yet) implemented.
> analyze your locally-stored photographs for child photography
Nope. Only the ones on iCloud.
> and upload questionable photos to the cloud for human review
Also a misrepresentation.
> or content that they disagree with (e.g. pornography).
True. And yes, I should have a wank to whatever I please. Legality permitting.
It is so easy to criticise Apple. So many angles to attack them on. So don't misconstrue facts. There's really no need.
> Nope. Only the ones on iCloud.
Nope. Only the ones your device intends to send to iCloud.
They’re already scanned on iCloud, this was on device scanning before upload. Likely it was a requirement for them to add encryption on the files they store and not have the unsealing keys.
Sort of a pre-emotive avoidance of certain political conversations.
From a practical perspective, for most everyone, "intending to send" and "on iCloud" is probably a 300ms delta in time.
It’s the motte and bailey.
If WhatsApp has the function for Facebook to read messages, then it’s not going to be a surprise when reversing the program to see that code; but if they claim that there is no capability to do that and you discover it then it’s much more damning.
Also; if functionality exists it’s easier to argue for a scope change… much easier than arguing for new functionality to exist.
They are not. Other file and photo hosting platforms do not encrypt the data, so they are able to scan server-side. The content is encrypted for iCloud, and the encryption keys are not known by the hosting infrastructure.
This means as an example that shared iCloud albums could be used as a distribution mechanism for child pornography, operating silently until one of the members' accounts gets subpoenaed or they confess and share the list.
Underlying cloud providers that Apple uses e.g. AWS may not have the key but Apple definitely does. And that key could be embedded in a CSAM detection app.
So unless you work for Apple and have definitive proof that they do not have such an app I think we should assume they do.
Do you have kids? Daughters? Would you like better control over what they're exposed to? Being given the tools to track screen time, purchases and control where possible exposure to objectionable content for immature minds isn't a bad thing.. provided it is opt-in. Which the feature always was before the news cycle chose their own narrative.
In addition to Google scanning everything in your Google account looking for child pornography for the last decade?
>a man [was] arrested on child pornography charges, after Google tipped off authorities about illegal images found in the Houston suspect's Gmail account
https://techcrunch.com/2014/08/06/why-the-gmail-scan-that-le...
In addition to Google scanning your online account looking for copyright violations?
And on the 2nd point, they like any company, have to obey the laws of the countries they operate in. Whether they should operate in countries that call for them to censor political content, that's a different question. I'm sure you would say that companies have to follow the local laws.
I think there are compelling arguments for making Apple open up which apps can access their SDKs natively, but I think most instances of its implementation will be driven by adversarial governments and bad for user freedoms.
How is that not a bigger monopoly?
Doesn't this imply that parents are the one purchasing it for them? Would be interesting to see how many stick with iPhone when they start earning for themselves.
And it's not Google.
Also please, that should probably be done by a company that is not Google.
Future concerns about what Apple might do in future are nothing by comparison.
But 90% of them will still be doing all of this on an Apple device. Yet you think Facebook is the company to worry about, not Apple?
So you just demonstrated that teens have so much choice. Why are you concerned that they're doing it on an Apple device then, if an iPhone is just the hardware on which all these apps operate, and has nothing to do with what's said within the apps?
Imagine it was Amazon in this situation. Or Microsoft. Or Google. Or, gasp, Facebook. Where 90% of teens were using a hardware and software platform made by one company. Seems like a problem, right?
Imagine how much people would be freaking out if Facebook came out with a phone and OS and had 90% of teens using it. The wailing and gnashing of teeth could be heard from the Moon.
The communication is not being done using software that Apple provides.
People have a vast array of choices for communications and Apple isn’t harming that.
In addition, there is nothing preventing Google or Facebook from executing on what Apple does other than their own lack of focus.
Except they do. They can choose to use Android like many non-teens do.
Where all of those apps except for one is available.
They control what messaging apps you are allowed to install on your iPhone.
Then there's the App Store being both a point of control, a burden on developers, and highway robbery with Apple's 30% cut.
And if you think the App Store is a burden you should try implementing customer acquisition and go-to market strategies which is what the store gives you for free.
I'd try but Apple doesn't let its customers willingly install my app from me or any other open-source repository they might choose.
If the only option is the App Store, it's not very surprising that the App Store is good for customer acquisition. You literally cannot acquire them any other way, you are artificially prevented by Apple's anti-competitive measures.
I do it all the time without having to go through the App Store.
They approve apps to be sold/distributed on their platform based on rules about what those apps do or are allowed to do, and whether they comply with local laws.
You're leaning towards making it sound like they decide what messaging apps you're allowed to use based on what you plan to say (content wise) on them.
Wow. Crazy! This has literally never happened before.
But objectively: monopoly is a bad thing. We’re still recovering from Microsoft’s dominance of desktop computing.
Once you have a near monopoly it’s practically impregnable to disintegrate. As you have a wealthy company which is actively harming those efforts.
Abuse of monopoly is a problem.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_antitrust_law#Mo...
IANAL, and I'm assuming USA since that's where Apple has 90% market share on the young, but this seems to imply that monopoly in and on itself is illegal.
You seem to be ignoring 130 years of law that happened since what you are quoting.
Courts quickly began struggling with the Sherman Act's broad and vague language, recognizing that interpreting it literally might make even simple business entities like partnerships illegal.[9] Federal judges began trying to develop legal principles for distinguishing between "naked" trade restraints between rivals that suppressed competition and other restraints that were only "ancillary" to other cooperation agreements that promoted competition.[9]
I assure you there was no malice.
It also goes without saying that the law trails ethics and morality; not the inverse.
Neither of these things crush competition in any way.
Security is not illegal, nor is anyone compelled by law to write compilers.
Being unable to use any other operating system on your PC was definitely seen as harming the user, and after lots of battles secureboot is optional on x86 windows PCs (but not arm)- in the same vain we managed to successfully argue that people other than Microsoft should have secureboot keys too, and thus redhat also have secureboot keys.
Not having a compiler though? That’s what put back computer science and education 10 years in the Microsoft era, the barrier to programming was a lot higher than it was prior to the late 90s and only recovered in the late 00s where we saw a resurgence of young people learning programming with the availability of WAMP and later django and rails.
You can thank Microsoft that less and less people each year understood native programming.
Microsoft hid their compiler suites behind complex systems, if they had been included or easy to access this would not be the case. But it was a choice on the side of Microsoft that only determined people really need a compiler anyway.
Apple is doing the same thing. But Apple at least ships with some interpreters of some languages like python or ruby. Windows didn’t even have those. Only vbscript (which is not a general purpose language)
This means we will soon enough have a situation where a corporation controls the primary medium of communication of the citizens. At this point a smart society would consider how to regulate this situation to safely prevent domination abuse, but I doubt it will happen.