You’re mistaken about the lack of “hard lines” distinguishing the sexes, though. The difference between male and female is unambiguous in biology. “Trans women” are, by definition, not women.
That is emphatically false. There are innumerable biological differences between men as a whole and women as a whole, and while these different factors largely correlate, they do not necessarily fit neatly into one box or the other. Is an XXY individual with a penis but undescended testes and low levels of blood testosterone and few androgen receptors "biologically" male or female? What about an XX individual with ambiguous external genitalia, high circulating testosterone, and a high number of androgen receptors? What do you make of the fact that females with congenital adrenal hyperplasia are far more likely to identify as LGBT? You are oversimplifying the biology.
That said, the right to create an exclusive space is a fundamental constitutional right. En plus, for socially marginalized groups, it is a societal benefit for them to have a space exclusive to them. I support the creators of this social media app.
It's appropriate to discuss generalities. It's appropriate to discuss individual cases. What is inappropriate is dismissing individual cases to come to a general conclusion, and then insist that it applies universally.
This is also in the context of trans people the vast majority are not biological outliers simply people identifying as something different to their unambiguous biological sex.
To make this claim, you would have had to find an exhaustive list of biological sex differences, and check a large representative random sample of transgender individuals to see whether all of those biological sex traits aligned "unambiguous[ly]" with their assigned birth sex.
Since I am quite confident that this work has not been done, may I suggest deferring to individual people to tell you what is going on in their bodies? While imperfect, self-reporting is still epistemologically far superior to you just pulling this claim out of your ass.
Women can be sexed at birth as female, male, intersex, neither; women can have genes for XX, XY, XXY, etc; women can have zero or more genitalia; women can have masculine, feminine, androgynous, mixed facial bone structures.
Each of these is a valid subgroup of women which can, if necessary, be described as a subgroup. Normally, just “women” should suffice, but the app linked by this post actively excludes at least one of those subgroups from the label “women”. So it becomes necessary to discuss those subgroups by name, such as “trans women” and “black women”, in order for discourse to occur.
They might be “male at birth” or “intersex at birth” on certain medical paperwork, and those physical sex characteristic will remain unchanged in subgroup “at birth” regardless of any shift in gender or medical alterations to their present-day sex characteristics.
(To avoid any possible confusion, I’m keeping in mind that “male” is sex and “man” is gender, as this is often confused in discussion of these topics. One’s sex is a physical characteristic like one’s eye color or skin tone; most people assume that everyone has just one and that it doesn’t change, neither of which are true. One’s gender is a behavioral characteristic like accent or musical tastes; it can’t be reliably guessed from any physical characteristic, and it can change at any time, either gradually over years or all at once at a coffee shop or anywhere in between.)
You’re attempting to redefine the gender characteristic “man” in terms of physical sex characteristics “male”, which isn’t valid; this invalidity is proven by the existence of both intersex men and intersex women.
You’re also using the invalid term “biological sex” to refer to “sex at birth”, which can be male, female, or intersex — but due to your imprecise phrasing, your use could also refer to “current sex”, which is a modifiable state that can be altered surgically and thus invalidates your point further.
Minor49er, I don’t think you’re participating in good faith here. You’ve presented a view that doesn’t stand up to the facts after repeatedly being confronted with them in multiple threads, your concluding question “Don’t you agree?” is a direct quote from the sealioning comic, and you’ve asked the mods to delete this post in a different thread while continuing to engage here. You’ll need to shop your anti-trans trolling elsewhere, as it’s not productive for me to engage with you further.
And yes, I asked the mods to delete the story because obviously a lot of posts have been getting flagged. The story appears to be causing a lot of strong responses either for or against Giggle, its community, and its owner. It's simply not resulting in constructive discussion. I mean, you're even accusing me of "ignoring facts" (?) and of being an "anti-trans troll".
Also, what's the sealioning comic?
If you’d like to register a complaint with the mods about my participation here, you can email them directly at the footer contact link.
> "Sex can be much more complicated than it at first seems. According to the simple scenario, the presence or absence of a Y chromosome is what counts: with it, you are male, and without it, you are female. But doctors have long known that some people straddle the boundary—their sex chromosomes say one thing, but their gonads (ovaries or testes) or sexual anatomy say another. Parents of children with these kinds of conditions—known as intersex conditions, or differences or disorders of sex development (DSDs)—often face difficult decisions about whether to bring up their child as a boy or a girl. Some researchers now say that as many as 1 person in 100 has some form of DSD."
1. https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-07238-8
2. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/sex-redefined-the...
So a city of 1,000,000 people has merely 180 intersex people in it, the rest conform to their sex assigned at birth.
Seems pretty flimsy to claim a 99.99% match rate is wrong because of extreme outliers. It's like claiming the coronavirus PCR tests are worthless because of their (much higher) rate of false negatives/positives.
Your single study isn't a debunking. Leonard Sax is a gender activist. He's also just one person who has no degree in genetics. I provided citations of actual research institutions with actual geneticists working for them.
> Seems pretty flimsy to claim a 99.99% match rate is wrong because of extreme outliers.
I didn't claim it was wrong. I claimed it wasn't "cut-and-dry". Nothing you said refutes that. In fact, pointing out any kind of controversy on this topic proves that I was right: there is no clear, undisputed genetic test for someone's sex.
Notably, testing for gender has an accuracy rate that is orders of magnitude more reliable than all conventional coronavirus tests, including multiple PCR tests back-to-back.
As for Eric Vilain, the physician who advocates for extremely harmful (UN's definition) sex assignment procedures on intersex people [1], his wishy-washy definition includes people who have minor genital deformities, according to his own paper. [2]
Just to be crystal clear to drive this point home, Vilain is an advocate of a procedure that causes "severe and life-long physical and mental pain and suffering and can amount to torture and ill-treatment" [1] and which is condemned by intersex advocacy groups. [1]
According to the UN, he is a vehement proponent of torture.
[1] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-spectrum-of-s...