News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You Don't Need the Cloud by samhw on Monday January 24, 2022 @10:35AM (#30058898)
This is why I think we need a 'simple cloud' where people can spin up a single server nearly instantly, with sane defaults which are configurable if needed, and a super simple flow to connect it to GitHub (maybe even "Go to your repo and `curl foo.sh/setup?id=ZnVjayB0ZXJyYWZvcm0K | sh`, then commit the result").

There's so much you could do from a UX point of view. Nobody wants to be fiddling around with IAM roles, trying to add the right ingress rules so their server can actually connect to the internet, configuring TCP_NODELAY, etc - and then constantly wondering if their server is secure. Just to run some CRUD React app whose requirements are the same as the other 99.99% of developers.

Re:You Don't Need the Cloud by eropple on Monday January 24, 2022 @10:38AM (#30058943)
You pretty much just described Render. https://render.com

It's not perfect, and there is probably a point in time for a project where you'll need to evaluate other options, but I haven't found much that's better for small-scale stuff if you don't want to think too hard.

Re:You Don't Need the Cloud by anurag on Monday January 24, 2022 @11:48AM (#30060173)
(Render founder) thanks for the mention. We have 50+ person companies running entirely on Render with zero devops engineers. The point at which you need to evaluate options is a lot further out than you'd expect (and continues to disappear into the distance).
Re:You Don't Need the Cloud by eropple on Monday January 24, 2022 @12:04PM (#30060463)
Hey dude. I've been very happy with the day-job stuff we run in Render, that's why I mentioned it. ;)

If (devops hat on) you want baseline compute/storage, I think I could see running on Render long-term. Where I (speaking personally) get off the ride is when I start needing external stuff, and that's usually pronounced "AWS services". Stuff like SQS and SNS are still The Killer App for AWS for me, and while I was poking at Render for my most recent personal project, it was easier to put compute and data storage into Fargate/RDS and not have to think about multiple control planes.

A seamless, please-not-Terraform way to cross-manage Render resources with other cloud options would be pretty killer. (Which is directly in tension with the discussions of simplicity here. Turns out cloud stuff is hard.)

Re:You Don't Need the Cloud by anurag on Monday January 24, 2022 @12:43PM (#30061079)
Completely agreed on building/offering higher-level services like SQS, SNS, S3. We're only at ~10% of where I want the platform to be, which is also why we're hiring quite aggressively!
Re:You Don't Need the Cloud by samhw on Sunday January 30, 2022 @02:50PM (#30140447)
Heya, sorry for the delayed response (naturally, this being HN, I didn't catch your reply, and you probably won't catch mine, haha).

Thanks very much for the personal message. I'll set up a personal account and give it a spin. My company is a bit more nonchalant about vendor lock-in than I am, and so we're relying on certain AWS services for certain things, but we're also flexible and I'd be very keen to move some stuff onto a service like this.

On a more general note, I really hope you succeed. I believe 95% of developers just want to be able to:

- sign up

- get a machine with an IP(v4) addr

- [wanted/needed but not expected] have some help setting up / hooking up DNS + TLS

- get their application onto it somehow (in order of sophistication: 1: drag-a-folder, 2: shell access to use scp/rsync, 3: GitOps w/ a helpful flow)

- get it running and keep it running

- have some basic monitoring and alerting capacities

- have a sense of assurance that it's 'secure' (I know, this word is as meaningless as 'performant' without further qualification, but that doesn't matter)

I think you could get so far with a "sane defaults, maximally configurable if you wish" model. You may not support computational genomics or FPGA-assisted currency trading, but you can win 100x on UX by not having to play Twister trying to accommodate the long tail of niche users.

The only other bit of vague and cloudy fortune cookie advice I have to offer is: an escape hatch is so important. It's somehow reassuring to know that, if I want to do [thing I can do on AWS but not on Render], that there's some way - however fiddly - for me to connect the two, or replicate that thing. (Being necessarily vague here because I don't have anything particular in mind.)

Anyway - really appreciate your reply, and really appreciate your serving this market. (And please don't offer any credits or anything like that - I know it's common in these threads, but I'm really not fishing for that. We have a fuck ton of VC cash to spend, and I believe in sampling the pricing in the exact same way that I'd be sampling the functionality.)

Re:You Don't Need the Cloud by snerual on Monday January 24, 2022 @12:09PM (#30060544)
Hi Founder,

I've been wanting to use render for a long time now at our startup, but last time I looked at your GDPR info it was lacking. We sell to public education institutes in the EU, so it is a make or break for us. We might not be your target customer in that case, but otherwise I would love to hear what is possible.

Re:You Don't Need the Cloud by anurag on Monday January 24, 2022 @12:44PM (#30061094)
We already sign DPAs, but expect to see more public information on GDPR later this year.
Re:You Don't Need the Cloud by samhw on Monday January 24, 2022 @10:40AM (#30058977)
That's fantastic! I'll have to take a look. Thanks for showing me. I was aware of Heroku, but this seems like the modern equivalent which I had in mind. (I do think you could likely go even simpler, though - there's a whole spectrum of complexity which could accommodate different services at each point.)

Edit: Apropos of "there's a point in time where you'll need to evaluate other options": I think a good selling point would be a well-designed flow for 'ejecting' to a self-hosted or AWS/GCP environment. Yeah, yeah, it's not good for lock-in, but by the exact same token it would be a strong selling point. Done well, you could assuage the "we may as well get it out of the way now" concerns by saying that you'll make it easier to set up shop on AWS.

Re:You Don't Need the Cloud by cldellow on Monday January 24, 2022 @11:11AM (#30059465)
I've been running a SaaS on Render for about a year now. In past lives, I managed ~$50k/mo of AWS spend for one company and $1k/mo of Heroku spend for another.

Render's great for letting us just focus on the app. There are things I want them to improve, but I'm confident they'll get there eventually.

Re:You Don't Need the Cloud by anurag on Monday January 24, 2022 @11:54AM (#30060275)
Lots of improvements and additions planned for the coming months. Thank you for sticking with us.
Re:You Don't Need the Cloud by eropple on Monday January 24, 2022 @10:50AM (#30059097)
You could go simpler than Render, and some folks do--but you go simpler at the cost of drastically reducing the value of a thing for whole categories of non-toy projects. For example, if you want to host a static thing there are a lot of pretty easy options, but the second you need something as foreign to the "JAMstack ideal" as "a datastore" like "for a blog with comments" now you're in multiple control panels and you're shuttling secrets around and you're confronted with paying multiple companies just to launch a blog and the whole thing physically hurts.

Some mild complexity in deploy (and it is mild, a render.yaml file in your repo's super easy) comes from having the options to actually do things, I think.

Re:You Don't Need the Cloud by TameAntelope on Monday January 24, 2022 @11:46AM (#30060154)
Once you understand how to deploy into AWS, it really is quite simple, and honestly not that expensive. It takes... a day or so of work to get those "IAM roles" and "ingress rules" right, and then you never have to mess with them again, and if you're using a tool like Terraform, you have a blueprint for yourself around how to riff on that concept as well, so future permissions changes are even easier.

In other words, nearly every complaint in this thread about the cloud is solved with some experience in the cloud. There's a reason it's so ubiquitous, and that's because it really is pretty damn simple once you get the hang of it.

Re:You Don't Need the Cloud by ryanjkirk on Monday January 24, 2022 @12:23PM (#30060760)
Our current CloudFormation pipeline template is over 5,000 lines of yaml. That's probably on the high-end, but based on your statements, it sounds like you haven't seen a corporate cloud footprint.
Re:You Don't Need the Cloud by TameAntelope on Monday January 24, 2022 @01:25PM (#30061698)
I recommend using a tool that lets you break that up, something like Terraform.
Re:You Don't Need the Cloud by baobabKoodaa on Monday January 24, 2022 @12:13PM (#30060602)
> Once you understand how to deploy into AWS, it really is quite simple

I've seen enough 500 line YAML files to disagree with you.

Re:You Don't Need the Cloud by TameAntelope on Monday January 24, 2022 @12:20PM (#30060709)
Yeah, I've avoided CloudFormation like the plague, Terraform is really so much better.
Re:You Don't Need the Cloud by gwbas1c on Monday January 24, 2022 @10:48AM (#30059075)
I thought that's Heroku?
Re:You Don't Need the Cloud by Shorel on Monday January 24, 2022 @02:08PM (#30062367)
In that case, the cloud is already simple.

I use it to spin a Windows server, then connect to Steam, download a game server, download some mods from S3 and start the service.

The rules are in security groups. I add one Steam security group, and then another group for each game, and the machine has both of them at the same time.

When the machine is running, everything is one PowerShell script.

Using a Linux dev instance can only be even more simple.

Re:You Don't Need the Cloud by vlovich123 on Monday January 24, 2022 @11:16AM (#30059577)
Have you tried Cloudflare pages + functions? Curious what you see as the big pieces that are missing from your ideal world?

Disclaimer: I work at Cloudflare.

Re:You Don't Need the Cloud by speedgoose on Monday January 24, 2022 @11:39AM (#30060020)
I’m not the same person, but for me to consider cloudfare functions I would need a standard solution that is not a vendor lock but something that I can run on developers machines and any server. I would also need a nice development environment. Right now I would rather develop using fastcgi than faas.
Re:You Don't Need the Cloud by vlovich123 on Tuesday January 25, 2022 @10:00AM (#30072484)
That’s fair. For what it’s worth you can run everything locally and on any server via miniflare. This is all integrated into Wrangler 2.0 which lets you trivially switch between running things locally and in prod.

The concept itself is generally portable with several services offering largely compatible implementations although there is more porting work than would be ideal.

As for standards/vendor lock-in concerns, I’m sure that will get resolved sooner rather than later.

Re:You Don't Need the Cloud by sam_lowry_ on Monday January 24, 2022 @10:39AM (#30058950)
Hetzner has its Cloud offering which is simple and configurable over API and cloud-init.
Re:You Don't Need the Cloud by sascha_sl on Monday January 24, 2022 @11:53AM (#30060261)
"Hetzner Cloud" is a VPS service, this entire conversation is about managed services vs unmanaged.

Running under QEMU doesn't mean a server is managed.

Re:You Don't Need the Cloud by sam_lowry_ on Monday January 24, 2022 @02:29PM (#30062679)
Er... There are different levels of managed services. I am totally OK with the cloud that manages storage, backup and networking as well as provisioning.

Every usage of RDS or Dynamo I saw until now did not need scaling nor DBA outsourcing that AWS provides.

For me, Hetzner Cloud hits the sweet spot for side projects. And I use their bare metal servers to run high-volume websites.

P.S. Surprisingly, non-tech businesses are often offset by Hetzner rather than by crooks with registered office in Suntec Tower, Singapore that run their "managed" services on Aquia that runs on AWS.

Re:You Don't Need the Cloud by aiisjustanif on Monday January 24, 2022 @01:34PM (#30061860)
Heroku?