Tons of heavy regulation everywhere limiting supplies of doctors, nurses, ability for folks to see pricing info, for pricing info to matter etc. Consumer of the service often is not the one paying. So you can do crazy stuff like make an insurance co pay $10,000 per pill for something that overseas no one would ever pay that because they'd be paying themselves.
I've been in third world countries, cash pay places, no insurance, no govt stuff. You can call and ask how much something will cost, they tell you, you go, pay and done.
My bills in California have like 10 pages of notices and warnings on them for each charge. So it's a 5 page document per copay. Its crazy.
Makes it hard to discuss because people use the same phrase to mean completely opposite things.
Yeah, the rent seeking in medicine is insane.
Just residency slots are so hard to get these days.
The problem with US healthcare is not that it's private, it's that it's more expensive than it has any right to be.
A private system with a good framework of regulation would be good.
I certainly disagree with you that it being a market is the problem, but I think one can consider downsides to that pretty straightforwardly: the lack of price elasticity when you’re dying makes markets price poorly, discouraging people from healthcare is a societal bad, etc.
The idea that there should be a market but that it should not be free is something I just find really problematic since it’s just a steal-from-everyone-to-enrich-medical-barons thing.
If you don’t want to have the freeness argument then perhaps choosing other phrases will help. If you do want to have that argument, obviously you’ll find yourself discussing whether or not the market is free.
DMV is quite good in my state. The Postal Service does an outstanding job of delivering packages. NIST and the Park Service provide great benefits to the nation. The U.S. military is government run and it does a great job at destroying organized state power. Should we privatize all of these organizations? How about privatizing the court system? Do you really want to live on Ferenginar?
Hollywood caricatures should never underpin your understanding of economics.
Plenty of agencies in numerous nations have proved this out, but folks continue to have onanistic John Galt fantasies instead.
There are many people in government trying to do a good job and many who aren't, just like private industry. I recently spent <15 mins at the DMV to get a vehicle title transferred and it was a very efficient process (granted I spent more time in the car as there aren't offices in every town).
---
Perhaps you should talk to your local representative about the DMV's funding. There was a recent post to HN about how the FDA only has 10 employees to do declassification of documents, of course they will be slow at doing that. I wonder how many employees/per capita works at your DMVs.
Strategic ambiguity around “freedom” “free market” etc is a useful tool to prevent change. It creates a self reinforcing mythology in peoples heads and enough confusion about reality that blaming the victims for being “unprepared” can exist in the broad/abstract while also still feeling empathy and dying “that’s bad” in individual cases.
Most people talk about ideas and politics without getting into the technical details of what's happening.
The Innovators Prescription[1] is written by 3 PhD's (2 in medical and running institutions and one in business) who provide an analysis as part of the book.
[1] https://www.amazon.com/Innovators-Prescription-Disruptive-So...
EDIT: I know the U.S. healthcare system isn’t a totally free market. We’ve designed a system that isn’t government run but has mandates like ERs having to see patients. Half the country labels anything that isn’t government run as free market and anything that is government run as communism. These are proxy words.
If you want a healthcare system that isn’t government run but that has a semblance of “free market” in it but that also “treats” most people this is what you get. Well, it’s what our system has morphed into.