News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by Hokusai on Monday January 24, 2022 @09:10AM (#30057717)
That's all the point of crypto-currencies, they need to go up and down to enable speculation. Pump and make it go up. Dump and it goes down. Someone is cashing the difference.

A stable crypto-currency will not attract so much speculative investment.

Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by dandare on Monday January 24, 2022 @09:28AM (#30057951)
A stable crypto-currency will not attract any investment. Crypto is useless for anything but money laundering and speculation.
Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by matheusmoreira on Monday January 24, 2022 @09:42AM (#30058123)
I've gotten paid for code in XMR. It's great and absolutely useful. I wish everyone used it.
Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by akvadrako on Monday January 24, 2022 @10:11AM (#30058556)
Monero (XMR) is indeed one of the few useful blockchains. Many darknet markets accept it, sometimes exclusively.
Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by schnebbau on Monday January 24, 2022 @09:48AM (#30058228)
What did you do with the XMR?
Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by matheusmoreira on Monday January 24, 2022 @09:58AM (#30058361)
I deposited most of it in a binance savings account. Left some in my mobile wallet. Unfortunately I had to cash it out in order to spend it. Wish I didn't have to but nothing else accepted it.

These things will not ever be real if we don't start using them as currencies. I came this close to proposing Monero transactions to a business partner after some banking problems but the market isn't looking good right now, too volatile.

Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by darkwater on Monday January 24, 2022 @10:02AM (#30058414)
Your "unfortunately" part is the whole point of what GGP was saying.
Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by matheusmoreira on Monday January 24, 2022 @10:16AM (#30058614)
It's not useless though. It works just fine as a currency. It's just that nobody is using it. Like how Signal is more trustworthy than WhatsApp but nobody I know uses it so it doesn't matter.
Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by darkwater on Monday January 24, 2022 @10:23AM (#30058733)
Sadly currencies rely on network effects even more than instant messengers to be really useful. The fact that most people look at cryptocurrencies just like they were stocks and comparing against a buying/selling price in USD should be pretty clear. I know that people also invest in currencies and gain money on exchange fluctuations but it's more a "side effect" than the main purpose. With cryptocurrencies is the other way round instead.
Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by immibis on Monday January 24, 2022 @12:39PM (#30060998)
All kinds of things rely on network effects, yet they managed to get started anyway. Reliance on network effects is not a reason to instantly dismiss something. Or else there would be no Hacker News.
Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by matheusmoreira on Monday January 24, 2022 @10:42AM (#30058997)
Which is why I decided to accept XMR. I thought maybe that'd start something. The system is literally right there just waiting for us to use it.

I also remember seeing at least one artist accepting XMR for cryptocurrency-related art. Plenty of people were spending XMR on that person.

Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by ashtonkem on Monday January 24, 2022 @09:33AM (#30058031)
The idea of a "currency"[0] attracting investment is kinda crazy in its own right. Normally currencies don't attract investment; you can bet on the difference between them, but you usually "invest" (buy) large amounts of it specifically to do business with the country or economic entity that issued it. You buy Euros to do business in the EU, not to "invest" in the currency itself.

0 - Which crypto currencies actually function as currencies is a matter of debate.

Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by msy on Monday January 24, 2022 @09:40AM (#30058109)
Betting on the difference between is done by buying and selling them. I'm no defender of cryptocurrencies but speculation and trading have been a major feature modern forex markets since their inception.
Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by oldsecondhand on Monday January 24, 2022 @10:24AM (#30058754)
Speculating on Forex is gambling, just like speculating on crypto.
Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by ashtonkem on Monday January 24, 2022 @11:41AM (#30060072)
Which is speculating on the relative difference in inflation rates, not actually investing in either currency per se.
Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by kasey_junk on Monday January 24, 2022 @09:36AM (#30058073)
Modern treasury operations for large cash holders absolutely “invest” in currencies. They do so in the form of what cash they hold outside of their immediate needs and in what cash “equivalents” they keep on their books.
Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by melenaboija on Monday January 24, 2022 @09:47AM (#30058206)
What’s the difference between “investing” and investing?

Maybe that will help me to better understand cryptocurrencies “investors”.

Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by mdavis6890 on Monday January 24, 2022 @10:14AM (#30058591)
Investing is when you buy something that creates enduring, repeated value over an indefinite period of time, which you can capture without selling the asset itself. Real estate, for example, creates value (a place to live) over a long time, which you can capture either by living there yourself or renting it to someone else - without selling the house.

Stock is ownership in a business which creates value over time (shoes, tweets, cars, etc) which is captured in a variety of ways, like selling through retail or ads or whatever - without selling the stock.

This is why currencies, gold and the like are not investments. They do not, in and of themselves, create value. They may be good to buy/hold anyway though!

Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by melenaboija on Monday January 24, 2022 @10:23AM (#30058746)
Agree. I personally don’t consider cryptocurrencies as currencies and the comment has few points where I disagree:

- Consider them currencies

- Describing the fact of holding positions on currencies for operational purposes as an investment

- Thinking that cryptocurrencies accomplish the second point

Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by kasey_junk on Monday January 24, 2022 @09:54AM (#30058300)
The only difference in investing in currency than other asset classes is that the value of currencies is entirely relative to other currencies in ways other asset classes aren’t.

In practice that doesn’t make a difference because all the mechanics are the same as any other form of investment decision.

Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by melenaboija on Monday January 24, 2022 @10:12AM (#30058567)
First of all I should be convinced that cryptocurrencies are currencies and secondly I don’t see how this asset can be used by treasury to hold any cash for operational purposes. Besides I am not sure that is investing per se.
Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by kasey_junk on Monday January 24, 2022 @10:43AM (#30059008)
I personally wouldn’t hold crypto as part of an forex portfolio mix for a corporate treasury largely because they are currently not really currency equivalents but there might be treasury groups that do & the mechanics of holding them isn’t much different than any other fx holding.

As far as whether treasury asset allocations are investing or not is largely in the eye of the beholder but companies very frequently prefer to hold “cash equivalents” beyond their immediate operational requirements. If a treasury buys us tbills that is both a traditional investment & a fx position (in that it’s a usd we are viewing preferentially over other currencies in our portfolio).

Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by soared on Monday January 24, 2022 @10:24AM (#30058751)
I’m no crypto fan but this is just incorrect. Stablecoins exist solely to be stable, look at tether.
Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by dandare on Monday January 24, 2022 @12:04PM (#30060462)
You are right. How are they useful?
Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by koonsolo on Monday January 24, 2022 @02:03PM (#30062295)
When you put money in the bank, it's backed by 1% real assets (go fractional reserve money!)

So let's say I don't want to put my money into something that is only 1% backed (See the Greek dept crisis). I could store cash under my mattress, but that also has some major risks.

With a stablecoin like UST, you 100% own it. Governments can't confiscate it. It's 100% backed by the asset behind it (not talking about Tether here ;)). I do agree that it comes with its own set of risks, but some people might prefer that risk over the ones above.

Or maybe I'm a foreigner and want to keep some of my personal value in dollars, but don't want to do that in cash or at some local bank.

It's basically another option at your disposal. And as the market cap of those stable coins prove, lots of people prefer that.

Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by dandare on Monday January 24, 2022 @08:03PM (#30066505)
So this stable coin is "100% backed by the asset behind it", like a dollar, which is "backed by 1% real assets (go fractional reserve money!)". What did I miss?
Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by koonsolo on Tuesday January 25, 2022 @06:50AM (#30070787)
1 dollar is backed by 1 dollar. 1 dollar in the bank is backed by 0.01 dollar.
Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by dandare on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @04:37AM (#30083515)
And 1 stable coin is backed by 1 dollar in the bank. That means one stable coin is backed by 0.01 real dollar.
Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by koonsolo on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @08:29AM (#30085119)
UST is not backed by dollars in any way, it's backed by assets that have a corresponding value in dollars.

So no, your statement is incorrect.

Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by Ekaros on Tuesday January 25, 2022 @05:49PM (#30079242)
How can't a government confiscate the currency hold by stable coin provider? They are the government, they can do any tyrannical move they want.
Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by koonsolo on Wednesday January 26, 2022 @08:39AM (#30085198)
Because the stable coin provider lives in web3, and so is distributed over the whole world.

So in case of UST, as long as the Terra network is up, your coins are there.

What would it take for a government to take down the Terra network? I guess more than what it takes to take down the BitTorrent network. And last time I checked, I can still download any movie on there.

So a government being able to confiscate a wallet on a blockchain, seems very unlikely if you protect it well.

Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by immibis on Monday January 24, 2022 @12:40PM (#30061020)
You can send them to people and/or exchange them for stuff. Which is exactly what you'd want to do with a currency.
Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by dandare on Monday January 24, 2022 @08:00PM (#30066485)
But why would you do that? When you can do exactly that with a traditional currency but much safer, much cheaper, much faster and much more conveniently.
Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by immibis on Tuesday January 25, 2022 @05:09PM (#30078828)
Sending traditional currencies has more roadblocks, in any form, whether you're talking physical or digital traditional currency.

The CBDC idea might bring the best of both worlds.

Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by iso1631 on Monday January 24, 2022 @10:39AM (#30058946)
How else will you get paid for your ransomware?
Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by koonsolo on Monday January 24, 2022 @01:51PM (#30062113)
Tether has a $69 billion dollar market cap

USD Coin has $42 billion, Binance USD has $12 billion, Terra USD $9 billion, Dai $8 billion, ...

you were saying?

Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by acdha on Monday January 24, 2022 @02:08PM (#30062360)
There's more to it than multiplying the current price by the number of coins in existence: you need to consider the questions of liquidity and what an attempt to sell a non-trivial amount would do to those exchange rates as people start questioning whether they want to put more hard currency in. Cryptocurrencies are the weakest form of fiat currency and that means that there's a very real chance you simply cannot find enough buyers at the price you want to pay.

This can technically happen with other currencies, of course, but they're so much larger and more stable that it's orders of magnitude less likely. You need a world-shaking catastrophe not to find someone willing to take USD because so many contracts are written in USD, and there's plenty of need to pay taxes or interact with government contracts and employees.

Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by shane_b on Monday January 24, 2022 @11:14AM (#30059526)
Stables just need a fixed income vehicle similar to bonds. Luna and UST is this and is taking off.
Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by tootie on Monday January 24, 2022 @09:48AM (#30058218)
That isn't the point. They're supposed to be stable to be usable as currency. Using them as an investment class is a very off-label use that has emerged.
Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by smaryjerry on Monday January 24, 2022 @12:20PM (#30060711)
This sentiment is exactly why it hasn’t worked yet. Yes bitcoin is a currency hence the “coin” in its name but a lot of crypto is not. This is a failure in education in the community and also a failure by the US government to correctly classify the different types of crypto, and essentially label every blockchain as securities when only a few even approach being securities. In their desire to collect tax, they have completely mistaken one thing for another. In the same way the US hasn’t figured out that “tech” isn’t one sector of the economy but actually has 100s of new industries each of which are extremely unique. Facebook and YouTube are not two competitors just because they both are software with ads, they each exist in their own industry and monopolize their industry. You wouldn’t consider TV broadcasting and radio the same industry even though they are both forms of media. Crypto is the same, there is just so much unique software that is being miscategorized.
Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by tootie on Monday January 24, 2022 @01:09PM (#30061455)
I don't see how any of that is relevant. Bitcoin has failed as a currency because owners are hoarding instead of spending. But the fundamental elements of all crypto, namely anonymous transactions over decentralized Blockchain, is the only element that is giving regulators heartburn.
Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by ashtonkem on Monday January 24, 2022 @03:34PM (#30063628)
> But the fundamental elements of all crypto, namely anonymous transactions over decentralized Blockchain, is the only element that is giving regulators heartburn.

No, it's not. See wave after wave of stories about people thinking that crypto was anonymous only to be arrested for drug crimes and tax evasion.

I think the thing that's giving the regulators heartburn is the fear that this is looking like a massive bubble.

Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by smaryjerry on Monday January 24, 2022 @03:01PM (#30063161)
It matters because if it is just a currency then you shouldn’t be taxed on its appreciation. Right now if you say sold $100 in product and now have $100 worth of bitcoin, but then the price of bitcoin doubles and you have $200 in USD of bitcoin, then you have to pay taxes on the $100 appreciation if it is a security. The way it gets taxed will make it a currency or not.
Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by ashtonkem on Monday January 24, 2022 @03:33PM (#30063612)
It might not be what the inventor imagined, but this is hardly an unexpected outcome. BTC in particular was doomed to either be a forgotten novelty, or the wild speculation instrument we see today. It doesn't really have a good mix of features for a usable currency, and its appeal as a currency is largely limited to those ideologically pre-disposed to value anti-inflation over other limitations.

The limited throughput of the blockchain was always going to be a particularly bad problem.

Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by immibis on Monday January 24, 2022 @12:41PM (#30061038)
Wait until you learn about MakerDAO
Re:$130B wiped off crypto markets in 24 hours by JoeAltmaier on Monday January 24, 2022 @09:37AM (#30058082)
So now the critical deficiencies of Crypto as a currency, become it's selling points? I guess for the con-men and shysters that makes a sensible point of view. Fleece the sheep!