News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Internet disrupted in Burkina Faso amid military uprising by cuteboy19 on Monday January 24, 2022 @07:12AM (#30056675)
Modern liberal democracy could not have existed without Napoleon. Yet you don't see liberals venerating him as a saint or anything. It's puzzling why communists insist on canonizing every dictator that happens to use a red flag.
Re:Internet disrupted in Burkina Faso amid military uprising by baud147258 on Monday January 24, 2022 @07:49AM (#30056977)
> Modern liberal democracy could not have existed without Napoleon.

Maybe I've got a few blind spots there, but didn't Napoleon took power by a military coup against a nominal democracy? And I don't really see what he did that would lead to the creation of modern democracy: after his defeat France went back to a monarchy and I don't think any of the countries he invaded became democracies either during or after the French occupation.

Re:Internet disrupted in Burkina Faso amid military uprising by ABoredBirb on Monday January 24, 2022 @10:40AM (#30058964)
See Code Napoleon: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Napoleonic_Code He ruled like a monarch, but he reformed and liberalized the society itself and spread those ideas throughout Europe during his conquests. His rule was ended, but the reforms could not be undone by any monarch.
Re:Internet disrupted in Burkina Faso amid military uprising by sofixa on Monday January 24, 2022 @07:31PM (#30066245)
> Maybe I've got a few blind spots there, but didn't Napoleon took power by a military coup against a nominal democracy

Coup yes, military kind of ( based on his military successes, but it wasn't executed by troops), against a nominal democracy - not at all.

However the Napoleonic Code Civil and the many reforms he enacted in France ( administrative, educative) which were also spread, alongside the revolutionary ideals, abroad wherever he conquered, significantly impacted Europe. It's generally accepted that the French Revolutionary and Napoleonic wars ushered the new era of nationalism, liberalism and political thinking ( including Marxism, because Karl Marx was inspired by the French Revolution and this type of event figured prominently in his thinking).

Pinning it all on Napoleon would be falling for the Great Man fallacy, but he certainly contributed a lot.

Re:Internet disrupted in Burkina Faso amid military uprising by dragonwriter on Monday January 24, 2022 @07:43PM (#30066340)
> Coup yes, military kind of ( based on his military successes, but it wasn't executed by troops), against a nominal democracy - not at all.

The Directory was a multimember executive of a nominal democracy, so, no, the upthread description was entirely accurate.

(The Directory wasn't itself directly elected, but then neither are a number of executives, individual or group, in democratic republics.)

Re:Internet disrupted in Burkina Faso amid military uprising by sofixa on Tuesday January 25, 2022 @12:40AM (#30068531)
As you said, the Directory wasn't elected and they had the executive power. The Directory itself was installed by a coup. They were in no shape or form a democracy.

That's not really comparable to a prime minister elected in a two-stage election like the UK.

Re:Internet disrupted in Burkina Faso amid military uprising by dragonwriter on Tuesday January 25, 2022 @01:23AM (#30068798)
> As you said, the Directory wasn't elected

I did not say that.

I said they weren't directly elected.

They were elected by the Council of Ancients (upper house of the national legislature, which was itself elected) from a list sent by the Council of 500 (lower house of the national legislature, also elected.)

> The Directory itself was installed by a coup.

No, it wasn't. After the Constitution of Year III was adopted, the two councils were elected under it and then the Directory elected by the councils.

Re:Internet disrupted in Burkina Faso amid military uprising by lucian1900 on Monday January 24, 2022 @07:28AM (#30056813)
We don't. Stalin and Mao both made mistakes, the common assessment is ~70/30. Sankara and Castro made fewer mistakes. All led movements that drastically improved the lives of millions of workers and that is why they are held in high regard.

The problem is that most of us live under the dictatorship of the bourgeoisie, otherwise called liberal democracy. It's hard to have an objective assessment in the face of constant and pervasive anti-communist propaganda. Even you used the term "dictator", which is simply not supported by historical fact. On the other hand, there's not much point to propaganda for or against Napoleon.

Re:Internet disrupted in Burkina Faso amid military uprising by kodah on Monday January 24, 2022 @04:43PM (#30064475)
"Made mistakes" is some very careful language on your part. To then follow that up with "the dictatorship of the bourgeoisie, otherwise called liberal democracy" is fairly deceptive.

Personally speaking, I don't think capitalism, socialism, or communism are inherently good. The only way any of them work is by mixing traits of others and regulation. Given that, they're all pretty arbitrary.

Re:Internet disrupted in Burkina Faso amid military uprising by thematrixturtle on Monday January 24, 2022 @07:37AM (#30056888)
"Three parts bad, seven parts good" is the official Chinese Communist Party line on Mao's legacy. A neutral assessment would not be so positive.
Re:Internet disrupted in Burkina Faso amid military uprising by lucian1900 on Monday January 24, 2022 @08:23AM (#30057270)
Considering liberalism (and thus capitalism) is currently dominant, who would make such a neutral assessment?

[edit] Also, it's Communist Party of China.

Re:Internet disrupted in Burkina Faso amid military uprising by nradov on Monday January 24, 2022 @09:04AM (#30057636)
In theory tenured academic historians are supposed to be able to make neutral assessments regardless of which political theory is currently dominant. Whether that's true in practice is a matter of opinion.
Re:Internet disrupted in Burkina Faso amid military uprising by thematrixturtle on Monday January 24, 2022 @10:01AM (#30058405)
You're welcome to examine pretty much any economic or health metric for China during and after the Great Leap Forward and the Cultural Revolution and draw your own conclusions.

My own unscientific view was that while Mao did an OK job unifying the country and (to some extent) fighting off the Japanese, pretty much everything he did after the founding of the PRC was varying levels of disastrous.

Re:Internet disrupted in Burkina Faso amid military uprising by snowgrove on Monday January 24, 2022 @09:14AM (#30057776)
Subjecting your population to multiple genocidal events seems worse than 70/30 to me. Many leaders who we hold in middling esteem have managed not to murder tens of millions of their own people.
Re:Internet disrupted in Burkina Faso amid military uprising by lucian1900 on Monday January 24, 2022 @10:13AM (#30058587)
That's the dominant liberal propaganda, yes. It doesn't necessarily match the historical record, especially in different countries.

The same propaganda holds Churchill in high esteem despite the Bengal Famine and his general enthusiasm for imperialism and sympathy for fascism. There's a reason there are people with the first name "Stalin" in India, but Churchill is overwhelmingly hated.

Re:Internet disrupted in Burkina Faso amid military uprising by cuteboy19 on Monday January 24, 2022 @09:56AM (#30058334)
I think it's pretty insane how communists refer to any contradictory fact as propaganda.
Re:Internet disrupted in Burkina Faso amid military uprising by lucian1900 on Monday January 24, 2022 @10:33AM (#30058865)
We don't, we just use the term accurately: information spread with the purpose of convincing. It doesn't have to be incorrect, lots of propaganda is entirely accurate. We label our own efforts as propaganda, too.

The dominance of capitalism in most countries is not disputed. Is it far-fetched that capitalists would like to maintain their rule through ideology as well? The effects are readily apparent when comparing newspapers, school curriculum, public announcements, etc. from countries that disagree even slightly.