There is no need to tie this to base load power generation. In fact, quite the opposite: A lot of the electrolysis projects and the funding happening right now is targetted at using electrolysis as a compensation for fluctuating renewables.
This makes sense: We have cheap, green electricity, however having it in constant supply is expensive. So the smart thing is to shift the demand where that's possible.
You can solve the intermittency problem by building plant that acts as a hydrogen buffer to smooth out irregularities in hydrogen production. This substantially increases Capex/Opex that must be added to the cost of hydrogen that is already significantly more expensive than methane reformation. At some point, insisting that every step of the industrial chemistry process be done in a dis-economic way accumulates untenable product costs.
People need to be realistic about what is achievable at scale and the influence of economics.
The economic balance of running an electrolyseur only part of the time is something to be worked out. Still the balance is almost certainly not "we need baseload".
It’s to the point where even running 1/3 the time at the cost of 3x the equipment is likely a cost savings at scale assuming the local grid has a lot of wind/solar.
But overall it's going to be the cheapest way to make hydrogen and then ammonia very soon. And the market has already seen that inevitable future, lots of right-wing Australian mining billionaires have jumped into the market hard for example.
The main saving is avoided carbon, which isn't priced in everywhere. But the sheer scale of ammonia production means it's easy to gradually introduce this as long as you spread the initial upfron cost across all the users (which is basically everyone).
It's a very mutually beneficial arrangement for renewables so the two things reinforce each other strongly and I think it'll be one of those things that moves faster than they expect.
This analysis is 5 years old and it was already the case back then: https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/engineering/hydrogen-pr...
> In case of PtG applications, electrolyzer utilization becomes a key parameter. To illustrate the resulting utilization of electrolyzers when run on “surplus” electricity alone it is helpful to plot the residual load duration curves for different penetration levels of intermittent renewables.21Figure 11.4 depicts two typical residual load duration curves for a 30% and 80% share of generation from intermittent renewables of total electricity demand.
“High electrolyzer utilization reduces the specific share of electrolyzer capital costs in hydrogen production costs; on the other hand, a higher utilization increases electricity costs, as hours of expensive electricity will increasingly be included. Hence, in order to minimize hydrogen costs, electrolyzer utilization has to be balanced with the electricity price.”
Of course the specific utilization percentage varies based on how expensive the equipment, it’s overall efficiency, and grid spot prices. We don’t actually know how expensive it is at scale so picking exact percentages is impossible.
However, the grid is expected to have a lot of unused capacity. California is already at the point where 5% of all solar power produced is wasted and people are still constantly adding solar because the current economic break even is ~50% of all solar produced being wasted. That would average around 4-5 hours a day of basically “free” electricity which isn’t quite enough, but at scale at scale electrolysis equipment is almost that cheap and will probably hit that point.
This becomes more likely when you consider efficiency as a useful tradeoff. 40% efficiency at 2c/kWh or 20% efficiency at 1c/kWh potentially spend the same amount on electricity per kg of hydrogen but the second is likely much cheaper to build. You could potentially have several designs that get turned on or off depending on the current spot price.
Also, the continuous supply of power is exactly what the grid is designed to do. Availability of cheap nuclear or geothermal could change the economics. But the power is exactly the same if it comes from nuclear, renewables or battery storage.
But still I think there is a mistake in assuming that everything needs to be tightly coupled. The benefit of an electricity grid and storable fuels is that you have flexibility.
Why should someone who wants hydrogen buy expensive nuclear electricity when they can use much cheaper renewable electricity?
Using "hot" hydrogen would mean that you have to build ammonia and steel plants right near nuclear reactors, which can be somewhat difficult, but potential efficiency benefits could be big enough to offset it.
You can also produce hydrogen at the point of generation if water is available, and store it using the now obsolete natural gas distribution network.
The cheapest power is solar and wind. If you build an ammonia plant, the cheapest way to get the power you need is to build solar and wind.
You can sell some excess to other grid users when you have too much, and you can stop production on very short timescales to help balance the grid during peaks but overall you'll be able to predict energy production years in advance and know upfront how much it'll cost you. Those financing benefits are a strong driver of the move away from fossil fuels.
This is already happening with actual plants, they build the renewables and the plant at the same time. It just makes sense.
So, green hydrogen will overall be a source of cheap 'excess' renewables power on the grid, not mopping up excess from other providers.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_production#Methane_py...
Is the scale of the nuclear pollution really different from the scale of infrastructure-construction pollution for e.g. solar or wind? Because AFAIK either option is much, much cleaner than fossil fuel.
Finally, part of this teeth-gnashing seems to be centered on old fears. For instance, we have international treaties banning nuclear waste dumping in the ocean, but that's kind of absurd, considering that the amount is so low, and the ocean is so much larger than land, that water is quite good at absorbing and diluting residual radiation, and that any specific spot on the oceanic plate appears to be some of the least valuable ecosystem habitat on the planet. Why not just dump it in small containers somewhere in the middle of nowhere?
I believe valid concerns surrounding nuclear are primarily those of cost and delay. But this isn't some competition with e.g. wind and solar; it's a potential addition to replace e.g. coal, which is still a major power source all over the world. Comparing nuclear to solar is a distraction - if we manage to replace nuclear with e.g. solar+storage many decades down the line, that's great - but decarbonizing is extremely urgent, and we should therefore not be shutting down any routes to do so without extremely solid reasons.
The name comes from the combination of "green hydrogen" (electrolysis using non-fossil electricity) and "blue hydrogen" (methane reforming that avoids CO2 emission by capture and sequestration of the CO2).
An obvious challenge is that we don't have available green base load power -- nuclear, hydro, or geothermal -- at anything remotely resembling the necessary scale. The requirement for base load power follows from the economics of industrial chemistry, which becomes much more expensive if you can't run your process in a continuous steady-state equilibrium. If we tried to produce ammonia via micro-batching chemistry or similar, those economics may not be practical.
The other unfortunate reality is that ammonia production is often a way to extract value from excess methane that might otherwise be vented or burned. It is a better use than the alternative. It isn't a coincidence that ammonia is primarily produced in countries with a persistent surplus of methane. As long as we have vast amounts of methane lying around, and we will for the foreseeable future, conversion into ammonia is a pretty reasonable choice since that carbon will often end up in the atmosphere regardless.