News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by jandrewrogers on Saturday January 22, 2022 @02:08AM (#30034430)
Yes, this is the case due to the enormous scale of production. Replacing the hydrogen source at similar scales with electrolysis is plausible with base load power generation. The cost increase is a small integer factor, and in the bigger scheme of things is likely something we can adapt to at least for agriculture.

An obvious challenge is that we don't have available green base load power -- nuclear, hydro, or geothermal -- at anything remotely resembling the necessary scale. The requirement for base load power follows from the economics of industrial chemistry, which becomes much more expensive if you can't run your process in a continuous steady-state equilibrium. If we tried to produce ammonia via micro-batching chemistry or similar, those economics may not be practical.

The other unfortunate reality is that ammonia production is often a way to extract value from excess methane that might otherwise be vented or burned. It is a better use than the alternative. It isn't a coincidence that ammonia is primarily produced in countries with a persistent surplus of methane. As long as we have vast amounts of methane lying around, and we will for the foreseeable future, conversion into ammonia is a pretty reasonable choice since that carbon will often end up in the atmosphere regardless.

Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by hannob on Saturday January 22, 2022 @03:05AM (#30034690)
> Replacing the hydrogen source at similar scales with electrolysis is plausible with base load power generation.

There is no need to tie this to base load power generation. In fact, quite the opposite: A lot of the electrolysis projects and the funding happening right now is targetted at using electrolysis as a compensation for fluctuating renewables.

This makes sense: We have cheap, green electricity, however having it in constant supply is expensive. So the smart thing is to shift the demand where that's possible.

Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by jandrewrogers on Saturday January 22, 2022 @12:24PM (#30038696)
There is significant downstream cost associated with intermittent hydrogen production. Just because it is possible to produce hydrogen from irregular power sources does not imply that the downstream process chemistry can efficiently operate that way. As a rule, you want to run a continuous process for cost/waste reasons. Ammonia isn't craft beer. You really don't want to micro-batch a 100 million tons of industrial chemical production unless you are okay with being extremely wasteful of materials and energy.

You can solve the intermittency problem by building plant that acts as a hydrogen buffer to smooth out irregularities in hydrogen production. This substantially increases Capex/Opex that must be added to the cost of hydrogen that is already significantly more expensive than methane reformation. At some point, insisting that every step of the industrial chemistry process be done in a dis-economic way accumulates untenable product costs.

People need to be realistic about what is achievable at scale and the influence of economics.

Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by freemint on Saturday January 22, 2022 @03:48AM (#30034915)
This works because electrolysis equipment is cheap, so shutting it down half time barely increases total cost of ownership compared to the input electricity.
Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by hannob on Saturday January 22, 2022 @05:06AM (#30035314)
Unfortunately that's not the case. Electrolyseurs are expensive (though hopes are they're gonna get cheaper quickly, as there's a lot of investment in this sector right now).

The economic balance of running an electrolyseur only part of the time is something to be worked out. Still the balance is almost certainly not "we need baseload".

Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by Retric on Saturday January 22, 2022 @05:57AM (#30035590)
The cost of electricity is already vastly more import than the cost of an electrolyzer at scale. https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Economics-of-convertin...

It’s to the point where even running 1/3 the time at the cost of 3x the equipment is likely a cost savings at scale assuming the local grid has a lot of wind/solar.

Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by ZeroGravitas on Saturday January 22, 2022 @04:11AM (#30035040)
I don't think electrolysis equipment is particularly cheap, there's some excitement about cheaper alternatives coming to market and mass production that use cheaper materials.

But overall it's going to be the cheapest way to make hydrogen and then ammonia very soon. And the market has already seen that inevitable future, lots of right-wing Australian mining billionaires have jumped into the market hard for example.

The main saving is avoided carbon, which isn't priced in everywhere. But the sheer scale of ammonia production means it's easy to gradually introduce this as long as you spread the initial upfron cost across all the users (which is basically everyone).

It's a very mutually beneficial arrangement for renewables so the two things reinforce each other strongly and I think it'll be one of those things that moves faster than they expect.

Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by Retric on Saturday January 22, 2022 @06:04AM (#30035631)
The equipment is cheap relative to the cost of electricity to run it.

This analysis is 5 years old and it was already the case back then: https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/engineering/hydrogen-pr...

Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by ZeroGravitas on Saturday January 22, 2022 @07:23AM (#30036067)
I'm not sure exactly what you're referencing, as that seems a general topic you've linked to, but one of the articles I see at that link says that basically electrolizers are expensive enough that you need to be utilizing them at a high rate in order for it to make sense, and I think that's still true.

> In case of PtG applications, electrolyzer utilization becomes a key parameter. To illustrate the resulting utilization of electrolyzers when run on “surplus” electricity alone it is helpful to plot the residual load duration curves for different penetration levels of intermittent renewables.21Figure 11.4 depicts two typical residual load duration curves for a 30% and 80% share of generation from intermittent renewables of total electricity demand.

Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by Retric on Saturday January 22, 2022 @07:36AM (#30036153)
As I said, it’s an outdated analysis the point was theses things are a long way from 24/7 operations and have been for a long time.

“High electrolyzer utilization reduces the specific share of electrolyzer capital costs in hydrogen production costs; on the other hand, a higher utilization increases electricity costs, as hours of expensive electricity will increasingly be included. Hence, in order to minimize hydrogen costs, electrolyzer utilization has to be balanced with the electricity price.”

Of course the specific utilization percentage varies based on how expensive the equipment, it’s overall efficiency, and grid spot prices. We don’t actually know how expensive it is at scale so picking exact percentages is impossible.

Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by ZeroGravitas on Saturday January 22, 2022 @08:02AM (#30036279)
Okay, there's a gap between requiring 24/7 usage, and "only exist for the purposes of using excess power that would otherwise go to waste" and I think we agree that electrolysis is somewhere in the middle of those two extremes.
Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by Retric on Saturday January 22, 2022 @09:56AM (#30037183)
If we are talking today then absolutely.

However, the grid is expected to have a lot of unused capacity. California is already at the point where 5% of all solar power produced is wasted and people are still constantly adding solar because the current economic break even is ~50% of all solar produced being wasted. That would average around 4-5 hours a day of basically “free” electricity which isn’t quite enough, but at scale at scale electrolysis equipment is almost that cheap and will probably hit that point.

This becomes more likely when you consider efficiency as a useful tradeoff. 40% efficiency at 2c/kWh or 20% efficiency at 1c/kWh potentially spend the same amount on electricity per kg of hydrogen but the second is likely much cheaper to build. You could potentially have several designs that get turned on or off depending on the current spot price.

Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by 7952 on Saturday January 22, 2022 @03:10AM (#30034716)
Surely the hydrogen could be stored to allow for intermittent power supply? Make hydrogen when power is cheaper and there is spare.

Also, the continuous supply of power is exactly what the grid is designed to do. Availability of cheap nuclear or geothermal could change the economics. But the power is exactly the same if it comes from nuclear, renewables or battery storage.

Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by fuoqi on Saturday January 22, 2022 @04:10AM (#30035032)
With very-high-temperature reactors (one of potential paths for Generation IV reactors) you can produce hydrogen using reactor heat directly, bypassing the electricity conversion step, thus significantly improving efficiency of the process. And with sufficiently cheap hydrogen you would not be able to produce fertilizers, but also steel, another dominant CO2 source.
Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by 7952 on Saturday January 22, 2022 @04:38AM (#30035177)
Oh I absolutely agree that nuclear is a brilliant choice for hydrogen production. And presumably it would allow nuclear to adjust electricity output whilst maintaining high utilisation and profitability.

But still I think there is a mistake in assuming that everything needs to be tightly coupled. The benefit of an electricity grid and storable fuels is that you have flexibility.

Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by pfdietz on Saturday January 22, 2022 @05:32AM (#30035466)
How is nuclear a brilliant choice for hydrogen production? Hydrogen provides inherent storage, so energy sources will (aside from cost of electrolysers) be competing based on levelized cost -- and levelized cost of new nuclear sucks. High temperature electrolysis doesn't change this: it reduces the electrical power needed by maybe 25%, at the cost of a nuclear reactor that has to operate at 1000 C with all the material problems that implies (there's a reason LWRs won and HTGC reactors did not.)
Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by 7952 on Saturday January 22, 2022 @05:45AM (#30035532)
I don't have the expertise to answer that at a technical level. I think it could be a good choice because it would help balance out intermittent sources like wind and solar. And give alternative revenue streams for nuclear power.
Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by pfdietz on Saturday January 22, 2022 @05:47AM (#30035544)
If it balances out renewables, it also then pushes new nuclear entirely out of the picture.
Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by 7952 on Saturday January 22, 2022 @07:07AM (#30035957)
I don't see why. Currently you would subsidise a nuclear power station because it provides reliable capacity that you may not need. The customer is created artificially by the market. But if you can link nuclear with hydrogen production the customer is not artificial anymore. You could provide guarantees about future hydrogen prices instead and still get the capacity. You then get a product that helps to decarbonise other parts of the economy.
Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by pfdietz on Saturday January 22, 2022 @08:32AM (#30036439)
It pushes out new nuclear because the levelized cost of new nuclear is much higher than the levelized cost of wind/solar. And with highly dispatchable demand, levelized cost is what matters.

Why should someone who wants hydrogen buy expensive nuclear electricity when they can use much cheaper renewable electricity?

Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by taubek on Saturday January 22, 2022 @05:14AM (#30035356)
Is then hydrogen liquefied? I remember reading somewhere that hydrogen requires pretty heavy/thick containers for storage. Does it need to be kept at low temperatures?
Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by fuoqi on Saturday January 22, 2022 @05:27AM (#30035426)
The Haber-Bosch process used in ammonia production is done at high temperatures (400-500 °C), so you can use "hot" hydrogen to power it (i.e. to heat input nitrogen) and maybe even extract some of leftover energy in produced ammonia heat to generate electricity. Same with steel production, you don't need to cool hydrogen before using it, on the contrary, high temperatures are useful in such cases.

Using "hot" hydrogen would mean that you have to build ammonia and steel plants right near nuclear reactors, which can be somewhat difficult, but potential efficiency benefits could be big enough to offset it.

Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by pfdietz on Saturday January 22, 2022 @05:34AM (#30035477)
HB consumes energy in its compressors, but releases that energy as heat on the catalyst. Hot hydrogen doesn't compress well, so you'd cool it beforehand.
Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by fuoqi on Saturday January 22, 2022 @05:49AM (#30035549)
For HB you need pressure of 250-350 bars, while existing PWRs routinely work with 150 bars of coolant pressure. I assume it's possible to produce hydrogen with the necessary pressure using VHTRs, i.e. you would get hydrogen already pressurized and hot. You would still need to run compressors on input water, but it's much easier than working with hydrogen later.
Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by pfdietz on Saturday January 22, 2022 @05:58AM (#30035595)
Producing hydrogen at pressure doesn't eliminate the energy needed, it just forces the electrolyser to act as the compressor (the voltage goes up).
Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by fuoqi on Saturday January 22, 2022 @06:11AM (#30035665)
Please, read the thread carefully. The point is that with VHTRs you don't need the usual electrolysis to split water into hydrogen and oxygen. Instead you can use high temperatures produced by a reactor to power conversion directly, thus improving the process efficiency. The most common option is the sulfur–iodine cycle. Granted, it's not so suitable for producing hot pressurized hydrogen (though it may be possible to separate iodine and hydrogen without condensation), but there are other options for thermochemical water splitting like high temperature electrolysis, which requires less electricity than electrolysis under STP.
Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by pfdietz on Saturday January 22, 2022 @06:15AM (#30035693)
Thermochemical cycles like that have been explored for decades and have gotten nowhere. For some wonderous reason, systems that involve vaporized high temperature sulfuric acid and the like have not proved to be practical. Falling cost of electrolysers and electrical power make that approach even more of a nonstarter.
Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by theropost on Saturday January 22, 2022 @05:43AM (#30035521)
I for one am all for building green energy infrastructure at scale. However, at this point, I believe the push for green energy at the expense of nuclear, and even hydro projects at this point, has retarded the reduction of green house gases. It's a bit ironic that those wholly supporting wind/solar, have at the same time forced increased bureaucracy, and cost in other base load energy sources that could have helped in an overall reduction of emissions. So by fighting against climate change, they may have indeed made it worse.
Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by otherotherchris on Saturday January 22, 2022 @03:15AM (#30034749)
If electrolysis can be made cheaper (E-TAC looks promising) you can run it at a reduced duty cycle on excess solar and wind power whenever they are available.

You can also produce hydrogen at the point of generation if water is available, and store it using the now obsolete natural gas distribution network.

Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by ZeroGravitas on Saturday January 22, 2022 @04:20AM (#30035076)
People need to flip this excess electricity idea.

The cheapest power is solar and wind. If you build an ammonia plant, the cheapest way to get the power you need is to build solar and wind.

You can sell some excess to other grid users when you have too much, and you can stop production on very short timescales to help balance the grid during peaks but overall you'll be able to predict energy production years in advance and know upfront how much it'll cost you. Those financing benefits are a strong driver of the move away from fossil fuels.

This is already happening with actual plants, they build the renewables and the plant at the same time. It just makes sense.

So, green hydrogen will overall be a source of cheap 'excess' renewables power on the grid, not mopping up excess from other providers.

Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by pfdietz on Saturday January 22, 2022 @06:07AM (#30035644)
Green hydrogen becomes a source of more dispatchable excess power on the grid. This is more valuable than just randomly available power on the grid. Those renewables powering the ammonia plant can be diverted to sell to the grid when prices there are high.
Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by otherotherchris on Saturday January 22, 2022 @11:26PM (#30043624)
Ammonia burns fine in a diesel engine with almost no modification, just swap the fuel pumps and injectors.
Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by the8472 on Saturday January 22, 2022 @07:02AM (#30035933)
Or, until we have enough excess electricity, we could replace methane steam reformation with pyrolysis.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_production#Methane_py...

Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by peterburkimsher on Saturday January 22, 2022 @04:20AM (#30035078)
Let's make ammonia in Siberia to catch the methane from the melting tundra!
Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by DonHopkins on Saturday January 22, 2022 @05:49AM (#30035550)
Waiting for the Ammonia Shills to chime in that producing enormous amounts of ammonia that nobody actually needs will drive the development of green energy infrastructure.
Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by mtsr on Saturday January 22, 2022 @03:02AM (#30034682)
While nuclear has different pollution than fossil fuels, one can hardly call it green with the everlasting poison it produces.
Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by emn13 on Saturday January 22, 2022 @04:53AM (#30035250)
As far as I know - but please correct me if I'm wrong - the amount of waste is small enough that this is irrelevant. Additionally, having radioactive isotopes around is the natural state of affairs; after all, that's the input too.

Is the scale of the nuclear pollution really different from the scale of infrastructure-construction pollution for e.g. solar or wind? Because AFAIK either option is much, much cleaner than fossil fuel.

Finally, part of this teeth-gnashing seems to be centered on old fears. For instance, we have international treaties banning nuclear waste dumping in the ocean, but that's kind of absurd, considering that the amount is so low, and the ocean is so much larger than land, that water is quite good at absorbing and diluting residual radiation, and that any specific spot on the oceanic plate appears to be some of the least valuable ecosystem habitat on the planet. Why not just dump it in small containers somewhere in the middle of nowhere?

I believe valid concerns surrounding nuclear are primarily those of cost and delay. But this isn't some competition with e.g. wind and solar; it's a potential addition to replace e.g. coal, which is still a major power source all over the world. Comparing nuclear to solar is a distraction - if we manage to replace nuclear with e.g. solar+storage many decades down the line, that's great - but decarbonizing is extremely urgent, and we should therefore not be shutting down any routes to do so without extremely solid reasons.

Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by fuoqi on Saturday January 22, 2022 @03:53AM (#30034940)
With a proper breeder system we would not only significantly reduce amount of required Uranium mining (and thus its environmental impact), but also amount of produced waste and time at which it will be radioactively dangerous (from several hundred thousand years to several hundred). But, unfortunately, only the Russian government currently seriously invests into development of this area. Everyone else is fine with simply storing nuclear waste (with varying levels of finality and recycling), especially considering that it takes a minuscule amount of space as far as industrial processes go.
Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by adrianN on Saturday January 22, 2022 @03:06AM (#30034696)
At least the poison is very concentrated and easy to store. CO2 in the atmosphere is "forever" too, and much harder to deal with.
Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by mtsr on Saturday January 22, 2022 @05:27AM (#30035428)
Not really, the most abundant life forms on earth consume CO2 to grow. Of course not at the rate we would like (especially with current coverage and that we’re still freeing more carbon daily by chopping down more forests).
Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by adrianN on Saturday January 22, 2022 @11:46PM (#30043718)
Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by stavros on Saturday January 22, 2022 @05:31AM (#30035460)
They don't consume it, they store it temporarily.
Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by hnhg on Saturday January 22, 2022 @03:07AM (#30034702)
Green is an unhelpful umbrella term IMO. We need to be specific. Even "low carbon" is vague and prone to abuse.
Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by pfdietz on Saturday January 22, 2022 @05:51AM (#30035561)
I was amused by other color coding for hydrogen, especially "turquoise hydrogen": hydrogen that is produced by pyrolysis of methane to hydrogen and carbon. This requires considerably less energy than conversion of water to hydrogen and oxygen. The carbon can then be buried so it doesn't oxidize.

The name comes from the combination of "green hydrogen" (electrolysis using non-fossil electricity) and "blue hydrogen" (methane reforming that avoids CO2 emission by capture and sequestration of the CO2).

Re:Industrial ammonia emits more CO2 than other chemical-mak... by mtsr on Saturday January 22, 2022 @05:29AM (#30035442)
Absolutely. But it is also helpful to for example subsidize low carbon energy, rather than solar and hydro specifically, because it allows for innovations outside of those specific options.