I appreciate how antivax people love to share this fact like this is the ULTIMATE argument as to why the vaccine is actually BAD.
That question applies in literally every case and therefore doesn't change change the optimal strategy.
> What if it requires some domain expertise to detect a reasonable-sounding, but actually false claim?
That question applies just as much to links from "sciencebasedmedicine.org" as it does to the OP.
Sure, which is why being aware of both is valuable.
Sure, which is why I find it useful to know about the source, and criticism of their past work, when evaluating an op-ed just published in a field that requires substantial domain knowledge to fairly evaluate claims. I linked an article not very charitable towards the author because I consider it valuable in exactly this sort of determination.
> You don't need an expert to tell you transparency is good.
You don't need an expert to tell you complete transparency can have downsides, especially where patients' medical data is involved.
HN usually takes a dim view of "if you have nothing to hide you have nothing to worry about", but the rapid release of raw medical records is the sort of scenario where people may have lots to hide.
If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful.