News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by BobbyJo on Thursday January 20, 2022 @02:20PM (#30013392)
> When people talk about defunding or abolishing the police, they refer to razing systems like this (or parts like this in larger departments) to the ground, rethinking and rebuilding based on the needs of the community.

Some sure. Certainly not all. I don't even think most. If I'm wrong, then the meme itself needs better phrasing.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by helen___keller on Thursday January 20, 2022 @02:28PM (#30013524)
> Some sure. Certainly not all. I don't even think most. If I'm wrong, then the meme itself needs better phrasing.

The meme lives in the gray space of non-specifism, where every person for or against imposes their preferred meaning

If you go to a somewhat authoritative source such as https://blacklivesmatter.com/defundthepolice/ then you get

> We call for a national defunding of police. We demand investment in our communities and the resources to ensure Black people not only survive, but thrive.

But what does it mean to have “resources to … survive [and] thrive”? I would argue it implies a rethinking and rebuilding of policing based on the needs of the community, like GP claims. Another leftist might think it’s the anarchical approach. It’s vague, more or less intentionally

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by snomad on Thursday January 20, 2022 @02:36PM (#30013628)
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by gknoy on Thursday January 20, 2022 @02:46PM (#30013760)
I think you mean https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motte-and-bailey_fallacy :

    An arguer conflates two positions that share similarities, 
    one modest and easy to defend.. and one much more controversial....
    The arguer advances the controversial position, but when challenged, 
    they insist that they are only advancing the more modest position.
Thank you for pointing out this argument fallacy. I've certainly seen it and been unable to articulate what is going on and why it feels like an argument in bad faith, and now I have a name for it.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by helen___keller on Thursday January 20, 2022 @02:43PM (#30013721)
Not exactly. Motte and Bailey is a fallacy as an argument, but memes are not arguments. You can think of it as a distributed version of Motte and Bailey: someone out there surely is trying to actually abolish policing, but if you fish the internet for arguments in favor you only get people looking to reform

The answer, like to most of these kinds of issues, is to avoid arguing against internet memes. Have a debate with a singular person on an agreed upon position, or don’t debate at all.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by GordonS on Thursday January 20, 2022 @02:32PM (#30013586)
I should think that the number of people who want to completely do away with the police is vanishingly small. Actually, it's probably about 3 people.

It seems like the right in the USA are being deliberately pedantic about the phrase "defund the police", to make it sound like those on the left are crazy.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by throwaway894345 on Thursday January 20, 2022 @02:47PM (#30013772)
It was originally “abolish the police” and it was a pretty widespread slogan in summer of 2020 for those of us who visited the BLM protests.

Perhaps they didn’t literally mean “do away with all police”, but no one was very explicit about what the slogan actually meant. And when the media tried to rationalize it as a metaphor (because it was so damaging to Democrats), many leftists corrected them, clarifying that they literally wanted police abolished.

In whichever case, we’re presently suffering the effects of these anti-police protests as homicides have surged to levels not seen in 30 years (whether due to official “depolicing” policies or soft pressure for police to minimize proactive policing or due to reduced cooperation from the community or so on). Whether they literally meant “no police” or some other policy, it’s pretty clear that all of this leads to more crime, and the communities who pay are predominantly poor and/or minorities.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by giraffe_lady on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:01PM (#30013921)
Since virtually no police departments were "defunded" in any sense to any significant extent, it's not clear to me at all how that slogan or those protests contributed to any rising violence.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by throwaway894345 on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:03PM (#30013957)
I refer you to the parenthetical in my third paragraph.

> whether due to official “depolicing” policies or soft pressure for police to minimize proactive policing or due to reduced cooperation from the community or so on

Note these findings regarding the St. Louis police department following the shooting of Michael Brown:

> In the immediate aftermath of Brown’s death, self-initiated arrests fell 62 percent. Similar declines are seen across nine out of 11 categories of self-initiated activities, including foot patrol (down 82 percent) and pedestrian checks (76 percent). Notably, the decline in arrests is concentrated among misdemeanor arrests (more discretionary than felonies) and among arrests of blacks (rather than whites). This reduction in police activity persisted for at least the next two years. In the same period, the city experienced a significant rise in homicide and aggravated assault.

https://www.city-journal.org/new-evidence-connects-police-pr...

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by giraffe_lady on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:09PM (#30014033)
Again I don't see how you're making the connection that any of these things are "due to" any others.

Crime does rise and fall over time and the reasons are notoriously complex and difficult to understand as it's happening. The police are certainly confident that anti-police sentiment leads to rising crime, but I don't have any reason to accept that evaluation right now.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by throwaway894345 on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:53PM (#30014803)
There’s a lot of literature, some of which is touched on in the link I shared. In general:

1. Crime rarely surges so dramatically as it has in the last 6 years. Note that before 2014, crime had been trending down consistently for decades.

2. Homicides spiked all over the country following major BLM protests.

3. The counties with the largest BLM activity saw the largest decreases in proactive policing and commensurate increases in homicides.

How much more evidence is required (and how many additional thousands need to die) before we get folks on board to reverse these trends?

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by KerrAvon on Saturday January 22, 2022 @11:32PM (#30043646)
You got nonpartisan citations for those assertions? I’ve been unable to find anything to back 2 and 3.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by BobbyJo on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:54PM (#30015662)
By that same argument you have no reason to believe that pro-police sentiment causes an erosion of rights and safety.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by BobbyJo on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:55PM (#30015678)
These slogans we're indeed acted upon in several districts, which are indeed feeling the effects. See Portland for a prime example.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by KittenInABox on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:01PM (#30013932)
> whether due to official “depolicing” policies

My recollection is that there have been almost no depolicing policies actually made in effect. Not even the Minneapolis complete dissolution of the police by whatever whatever time. Several big cities even increased their police funding. The argument that homicides have surged because of depolicing first needs to prove that depolicing actually happened.

I would instead argue that an increase in homicides might be caused by an decrease in the general wellbeing of people when dealing with a pandemic. We're getting to the point where many people either know someone who has died or knows someone who knows someone who has died.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by throwaway894345 on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:59PM (#30014893)
This is pretty well-established.

> In the immediate aftermath of Brown’s death, self-initiated arrests fell 62 percent. Similar declines are seen across nine out of 11 categories of self-initiated activities, including foot patrol (down 82 percent) and pedestrian checks (76 percent). Notably, the decline in arrests is concentrated among misdemeanor arrests (more discretionary than felonies) and among arrests of blacks (rather than whites). This reduction in police activity persisted for at least the next two years. In the same period, the city experienced a significant rise in homicide and aggravated assault.

> The multicity analysis shows a similar pattern. Cheng and Long assume that a Ferguson Effect will be more common in cities with higher black population shares, so they compare those in the top quartile of black population against the other cities as a control. They identify the same phenomenon as in St. Louis: the blackest cities saw larger declines in arrests relative to those with smaller black populations, driven by a decline in misdemeanor arrests, and a simultaneous large (10 percent) increase in homicide.

> Both studies not only identify a decline in police activity and an increase in homicide after a high-profile incident but also argue that the nature of the decline in activity supports a “public scrutiny” mechanism for the effect. In particular, a drop in police activity for minor offenses drives the overall policing pullback. This fact supports a theory (as articulated by Premkumar) whereby officers reduce arrests that they deem “less important” in order to minimize public contact. That differs from a competing theory under which a loss of police “legitimacy”—which, in turn, reduces community engagement with the cops—drives the Ferguson Effect. If the competing theory were borne out, the study should have found reductions in arrests for offenses of all kinds.

https://www.city-journal.org/new-evidence-connects-police-pr...

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by KittenInABox on Thursday January 20, 2022 @05:13PM (#30015912)
But I just pointed out there's no evidence that policies are in effect. Your provided study is alarming but not at all supporting the specific language of your claim. Potentially the intention, but not the language.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by throwaway894345 on Thursday January 20, 2022 @06:09PM (#30016708)
My claim was about a combination of policies, pressure, and loss of trust, not policies alone. I don't purport to know the coefficients, but the cited studies do support my claim. I suspect the most damaging policies are unofficial--top down pressure from politicians to avoid an embarrassing incident and district attorneys who don't prosecute (why should officers risk a confrontation with a dangerous criminal if they can't trust prosecutors to keep them off the streets?).
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by KarlKemp on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:00PM (#30013913)
How do protests against police violence lead to more crime? Not a single police budget was actually cut.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by rufus_foreman on Thursday January 20, 2022 @07:04PM (#30017279)
>> Not a single police budget was actually cut

"In fiscal 2020-2021, the Austin police budget was $292.9 million, down from $434.5 million the previous year. The City Council slashed $31.5 million directly from the police budget last year.

It also put $121.7 million in a reserve fund that was intended to 'decouple or reimagine some public-safety functions' from the police department but which ended up funding police operations, says Alicia Dean, a spokesperson for the city. The City Council also canceled three cadet classes and cut 150 officers from the budget last year, says City Councilor Mackenzie Kelly, an outspoken supporter of the police."

- https://www.wsj.com/articles/austin-texas-defund-the-police-...

The homicide rate went from 4.7 to 6.2. Yes, I know that doesn't prove causation. But if the homicide rate is going up 32% year over year I want more cops on the street not fewer.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by throwaway894345 on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:57PM (#30014856)
> Both studies not only identify a decline in police activity and an increase in homicide after a high-profile incident but also argue that the nature of the decline in activity supports a “public scrutiny” mechanism for the effect. In particular, a drop in police activity for minor offenses drives the overall policing pullback. This fact supports a theory (as articulated by Premkumar) whereby officers reduce arrests that they deem “less important” in order to minimize public contact. That differs from a competing theory under which a loss of police “legitimacy”—which, in turn, reduces community engagement with the cops—drives the Ferguson Effect. If the competing theory were borne out, the study should have found reductions in arrests for offenses of all kinds.

https://www.city-journal.org/new-evidence-connects-police-pr...

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by polski-g on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:30PM (#30014402)
If you can expect a murder charge for doing your job, don't expect many people to do said job: https://nypost.com/2020/06/13/unarmed-black-man-shot-dead-by...
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by SauciestGNU on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:49PM (#30014727)
I'm sure that if I killed someone while at work I would face criminal charges. And yet I still do this job. I think the key thing here is to not kill people, and definitely don't make it somebody's job to kill people.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by throwaway894345 on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:03PM (#30014970)
Unless your job requires you to forcibly intervene between armed, violent offenders and their victims, I don’t see how this is relevant.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by monocasa on Thursday January 20, 2022 @05:27PM (#30016126)
Police's job doesn't force them to intervene either.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warren_v._District_of_Columbia

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by throwaway894345 on Thursday January 20, 2022 @06:11PM (#30016722)
You're confusing "forcibly intervene" with "forced to intervene".
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by monocasa on Thursday January 20, 2022 @06:13PM (#30016747)
> requires you to forcibly intervene

They are under no such requirement as shown by the citation.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by throwaway894345 on Thursday January 20, 2022 @06:48PM (#30017131)
They have the right to opt out of any given encounter, but the gist of law enforcement is intervening as you well know. Anyway, word lawyering is dreadfully boring and it seems that’s all you have to offer so I’m ducking out.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by monocasa on Thursday January 20, 2022 @07:26PM (#30017495)
I disagree that addressing the core argument of your claim is "word lawyering".

Your original full claim

> Unless your job requires you to forcibly intervene between armed, violent offenders and their victims, I don’t see how this is relevant.

doesn't hold water when police are also not required to forcibly intervene between armed, violent offenders and their victims.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by BobbyJo on Sunday January 23, 2022 @05:01AM (#30044976)
I'm sorry, but the point you're trying to make here is just bad. If some is running around with a knife stabbing everyone and the police just watched because 'they don't want to have to kill anyone's do you think that'd be ok?

That is the kind of thing the police force was designed to handle. Sometimes killing someone is the right thing to do when your job is dealing with situations like that.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by rufus_foreman on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:28PM (#30014358)
In June of 2020, as I'm sure you recall, The New York Times published an opinion piece titled "Yes, We Mean Literally Abolish the Police".

Why do you think the New York Times was publishing opinions that you believe were only held by 3 people?

You of course also remember that when the New York Times published the opinion piece titled "Tom Cotton: Send In the Troops" arguing that the military should be sent in to stop riots and looting, there was a massive backlash and the editor for the opinion page resigned. This even though the opinion expressed by Tom Cotton was fairly popular.

I would think if the New York Times was publishing opinions that had no popular support at all, there would have been a backlash about that, wouldn't you?

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by selimthegrim on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:06PM (#30015018)
One of these things is of doubtful constitutionality, the other is not. If Cotton suggested suspending habeas corpus would you want the Times to print that too?
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by rufus_foreman on Thursday January 20, 2022 @05:49PM (#30016447)
From Cotton's opinion column itself:

"For instance, during the 1950s and 1960s, Presidents Dwight Eisenhower, John Kennedy and Lyndon Johnson called out the military to disperse mobs that prevented school desegregation or threatened innocent lives and property. This happened in my own state. Gov. Orval Faubus, a racist Democrat, mobilized our National Guard in 1957 to obstruct desegregation at Little Rock Central High School. President Eisenhower federalized the Guard and called in the 101st Airborne in response. The failure to do so, he said, 'would be tantamount to acquiescence in anarchy.'

More recently, President George H.W. Bush ordered the Army’s Seventh Infantry and 1,500 Marines to protect Los Angeles during race riots in 1992."

What Cotton suggested is expressly permitted by an act of Congress and that act has been invoked many times over more than two centuries. It's been used half a dozen times to suppress riots since the 1960's. Not one of those actions has ever been found to be unconstitutional.

Second, if Tom Cotton and only two other people in the entire US want habeas corpus suspended, than no, I would not want the Times to print an opinion column suggesting that. A poll had 52% of Americans agreeing with sending in troops to stop the riots. If Tom Cotton and 52% of Americans want habeas corpus suspended, then I think a paper that calls itself the "paper of record" is exactly where that case should be made.

Just as it would have been appropriate to make the case in those opinion pages for why we would send the 101st Airborne into Little Rock and Detroit, the 197th Infantry into Baltimore, the 1st Marines Division into Los Angeles, and military police to the Virgin Islands.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by bandushrew on Thursday January 20, 2022 @02:42PM (#30013694)
Its a social problem, largely driven by the FPP political system in the US.

The left hold up the opinions of the far right/right lunatics and say "see? this is how insane everyone on the right is"

The right hold up the opinions of the far left/left lunatics and say "see? this is how insane everyone on the left is"

The moderate left and the moderate right have far more in common with each other than they do with the extremes at either end, yet somehow each is convinced that the other is represented most accurately by the extreme edge.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by bee_rider on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:00PM (#30013918)
I would like to believe this, but legislative outcomes on things that you'd expect to be bipartisan (like dealing with the pandemic) have been fairly poor, right? If there really was this large moderate population, you'd expect us to elect moderate elected officials, who'd find each other and pass some moderate legislation, right?
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by dantheman on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:19PM (#30014183)
The primary process is not well attended my the normal voter, only those on the extremes. So to win the primary you have to go more extreme, then to win the general you have go more moderate. So we ended up having to choose between more extreme candidates that don't reflect the majority. In fact the majority of people don't identify as republican or democrat.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by bandushrew on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:58PM (#30015707)
The extremes always vote, many moderates only bother to vote if you can convince them the other side are totally insane/evil/stupid and life as they know it is going to be over if the other side get into/remain in power.

So politicians in particular get very good at making the other side look extremely insane, evil and stupid.

The better they are at that (lying) the better they do in elections.

So...the politicians who would be good for us tend to have integrity and strong personal beliefs about lying, and so tend to do poorly in elections.

Which leaves us with everyone else.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by vkou on Thursday January 20, 2022 @02:46PM (#30013759)
The 'moderate' right and the 'moderate' right are both pretty insane when it comes to the police, because they largely support their current status quo, and their current status quo is insane. Pants-on-head insane.

Just because you're a centrist on <an arbitrary political spectrum, that spans a single country's politics> doesn't mean that the things you believe in aren't crazy or horrifying.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by throwaway894345 on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:02PM (#30013949)
I think we get different facts about the characterization of US policing. If you look at extreme cherry-picked examples one way or the other, you tend to end up at the extremes. If you accept that reality is more nuanced and the good and evil police aren’t evenly distributed (and that the trite policies offered up by extremists do much more harm than good a la the current surge in homicides), etc then you’re probably much more likely to be a moderate on the issue.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by vkou on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:13PM (#30014094)
The issue isn't that particular police officers are 'good' and 'evil', the issue is that systemically, the police, the justice department, and prosecutors collude to protect gang-like behaviour in police forces.

We give them absolute power over life and death, and zero accountability. The justice system is in theory, supposed to be a leash on that dog, but in practice, it's the other way around.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by throwaway894345 on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:44PM (#30014637)
Sure, there’s a certain amount of injustice in policing. 90% of Americans agree that some form of police reform is necessary. Leftists lose the rest of us when they argue for depolicing reforms rather than reforms which increase accountability while keeping policing levels.

In particular, it stands to reason that increasing spending for social services isn’t going to pay dividends for many years, but following policing reductions, crime surges immediately and significantly. So again, the rest of us are puzzled by the folks who emphasize “depolicing” rather than some more reasonable policy of “increase social spending while also maintaining a robust police element, at least for the short term”.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by monocasa on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:17PM (#30014154)
> a la the current surge in homicides

How do police prevent homicides? Are people really out there thinking "the police department is 10% smaller than last year (but has a larger budget), I bet I could off my neighbor and get away with it"?

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by throwaway894345 on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:35PM (#30014480)
My understanding is that police have reduced their preventative policing activities either by policy or soft pressure. Criminals aren’t idiots—they can tell when police pressure goes up or down.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by monocasa on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:45PM (#30014648)
But like, what kind of preventative policing reduces homicides? Who's that person that's out murdering because they saw 10% less cop cars drive by?

A better explanation is that underlying social safety nets have been ripped out from under people for the past couple of years putting way more people in rough, quasi legal situations to get by that make them trend towards extralegal forms of dispute resolution like personal application of violence. Additionally suicides count as a homicide (it's technically a person killing a person), which has made the numbers go up over the past couple years.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by throwaway894345 on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:08PM (#30015033)
> But like, what kind of preventative policing reduces homicides?

Misdemeanor arrests, searches, and foot patrols, etc. See my various other comments for more details and links.

> A better explanation is that underlying social safety nets have been ripped out from under people for the past couple of years

These effects predate the pandemic and correlate with the BLM protests in time and space (crime surges immediately after and in the vicinity of BLM protests). That said, I don’t doubt the pandemic contributed since 2020.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by monocasa on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:32PM (#30015371)
> Misdemeanor arrests, searches, and foot patrols, etc. See my various other comments for more details and links.

That doesn't track though. _Why_ would misdemeanor arrests result in less murders. I don't agree with Charles Fain Lehman's analysis in your post, and believe that while he thinks that because violent crime arrests when misdemeanors dropped that somehow proves that police aren't to blame I see the opposite in that data. As I argued above, that says to me that a drop in public acceptance of the role of police and the justice system leads to self directed dispute resolution, which more often turns violent. His gotcha that's supposed to be a nail in the coffin of this argument appears to me to actually be a point in favor of it.

> These effects predate the pandemic and correlate with the BLM protests in time and space (crime surges immediately after and in the vicinity of BLM protests). That said, I don’t doubt the pandemic contributed since 2020.

The idea that cities reaching a boiling point in distrust of the justice system, followed by no meaningful reform continue down the road of self directed and often violent dispute resolution is consistent with the model I've presented.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by throwaway894345 on Thursday January 20, 2022 @05:45PM (#30016394)
> Why_ would misdemeanor arrests result in less murders.

That's an unanswered question (crime is complicated), but there are probably many factors, not least of all that people get arrested for misdemeanors and then they're found with felony amounts of drugs or weapons and thus removed from the street.

> I don't agree with Charles Fain Lehman's analysis in your post

It's not his analysis, he's reporting on the findings of studies.

> while he thinks that because violent crime arrests when misdemeanors dropped that somehow proves that police aren't to blame I see the opposite in that data.

He doesn't profess that belief in the article.

> As I argued above, that says to me that a drop in public acceptance of the role of police and the justice system leads to self directed dispute resolution, which more often turns violent.

The article posits that as a factor as well (specifically that loss of trust in policing leads to less cooperation from the community).

> The idea that cities reaching a boiling point in distrust of the justice system, followed by no meaningful reform continue down the road of self directed and often violent dispute resolution is consistent with the model I've presented.

"Your" model also requires us to believe that the evidence of decreased proactive policing is merely a coincidence, which is hard for me to stomach. I don't doubt that the loss of trust contributed, but I only think this is the "fault" of policing as an institution to the extent that the activist and media narrative is accurate (which is to say, "not very").

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by monocasa on Thursday January 20, 2022 @06:14PM (#30016751)
> That's an unanswered question (crime is complicated), but there are probably many factors, not least of all that people get arrested for misdemeanors and then they're found with felony amounts of drugs or weapons and thus removed from the street.

Being in jail doesn't stop homicides. In fact they have more homicides than the general population.

> It's not his analysis, he's reporting on the findings of studies.

It's both. If you read the studies, while in the abstract they purport to establish a causal link, they don't back that up in their methodology. Lehman combines this into a greater analysis.

> He doesn't profess that belief in the article.

He professes a causal link between police _protests_ and increased homicides, finishing his article with "But it does give support to those who propose a relationship between 2020’s wave of anti-police protests and the ensuing homicide wave still sweeping the country—and to those who believe that continued hostility to the police will lead to more bloodshed."

> The article posits that as a factor as well (specifically that loss of trust in policing leads to less cooperation from the community).

While calling out protests specifically as being causal wrt to homicide rate.

> "Your" model also requires us to believe that the evidence of decreased proactive policing is merely a coincidence, which is hard for me to stomach. I don't doubt that the loss of trust contributed, but I only think this is the "fault" of policing as an institution to the extent that the activist and media narrative is accurate (which is to say, "not very").

No, police not doing the basics of their job while still overall increasing their budgets, and particularly arbitrarily and capriciously enforcing the law would be a major factor in loss of confidence in the justice system. I'm not saying that it's a coincidence; I'm saying that it's part of the model. If you can't rely on police to respond reported crime, then you start handling disputes person to person. Meanwhile with budgets continuing to increase _and_ police not doing their jobs, any semblance of social safety nets disappear. That's the point of "defund the police", noticing that they refuse to do the basics of their job, and in fact the goal of using them as a catchall for all sorts of social services failed, so put that portion of the budget back into more productive uses.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by vkou on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:19PM (#30014181)
> How do police prevent homicides?

They don't, they clean up after the fact, and convict someone for ~50% of them. Unless it's one of their own that's responsible, then the entire country needs to riot for a week, before anyone even thinks of pressing charges.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by beepbooptheory on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:30PM (#30014405)
It's so weird we talk about it like this, to say an entire swath of social research and theorists are "crazy," because they have the audacity to think a less-than-150-year state institution is maybe not perfect.

Like, do any research at all into the history of criminal justice, you will find we live in a very contingent situation now, one that has other options.

Like, do you all really think that police have been around forever? Do you really all think we would be violent state-of-nature monsters without them? That civilization is assured by them? Are we really so historically shortsighted that we see the existence of police as exactly corollary to law and order?

Can we imagine for a second that just because something is sufficient doesn't mean that it is necessary? Can we think about this rationally at all?

And then look at cost of the status quo... I don't know, its just so sad this is how we talk about it: the police (specifically, its unions/fraternities) truly have won the cultural battle. Doesn't even matter if there are some radicals out there, because the only way we can talk about these things means they will always win.

Call those people naive if you like, but "crazy" is just disheartening to hear for people who are mostly just angry and wanting it to stop.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by BobbyJo on Sunday January 23, 2022 @11:51AM (#30047686)
I mean, it is nothing short of crazy to think that solutions that worked 150 years ago would work better than the system that has evolved along side our society now. It is also crazy to think that we should throw out something that mostly works in favor of something entirely different when the ramifications of the new thing not working are very very serious.

Also, you're throwing up a lot of extreme straw man arguments like that's what is being said.

> Like, do you all really think that police have been around forever?

I believe in dinosaurs, so no.

> Do you really all think we would be violent state-of-nature monsters without them?

No. I think more people would be without them than with them. Even if the difference between the two is 1%, that's a pretty serious change for the worse.

> That civilization is assured by them?

No, it's assured by faith in the system. Much like money. If everyone decided the law didn't matter there is very little the police force could do about that.

> Are we really so historically shortsighted that we see the existence of police as exactly corollary to law and order?

No. I certainly don't believe that. It's a component, but a small piece of the pie.

> Can we imagine for a second that just because something is sufficient doesn't mean that it is necessary?

Sure. Totally on board for that. It is sufficient to drive a monster truck to get where I want to go, but certainly not necessary. Not really a hard thing to imagine.

I can run counter to basically every argument you lay and still believe that a police force is necessary without there being any logical inconsistency in my beliefs...

> And then look at cost of the status quo

Look at the cost of social security. Look at the cost of public school. There is so much tangible and intangible value locked up on those institutions that if anyone said "we can do better" you'd be hesitant to throw them out whether or not you agreed.

> the police (specifically, its unions/fraternities) truly have won the cultural battle

it's not a culture battle. We're in an equilibrium, and people are rightfully hesitant to leave it behind for promises of utopian glory. It's fine to think there is a better way, and it's fine to test that out. Looking at the places running such tests, the 'better ways' so far proposed are far short of actually better.

> Call those people naive if you like

It's a good term for how I see it.

> but "crazy" is just disheartening to hear for people who are mostly just angry and wanting it to stop.

It's subjective. If I saw someone saw off their own foot, I'd call them crazy. If I see someone do something, or advocate doing something, that I think would be extremely damaging, I call that crazy. It's not crazy to want to do better, it's not crazy to be upset that things aren't getting better fast enough. Only another set of crazies are calling that crazy.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by kbelder on Thursday January 20, 2022 @02:54PM (#30013846)
I think it's more than that. I've seen at multiple people on national television advocating for exactly that.

I'll concede that it's a small minority, though.

The problem is that it's a really stupid slogan. A natural, unbiased reading of it says something that 95% of the supporters don't mean. That's not the fault of the people interpreting it, it's the fault of those saying it.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by nitwit005 on Thursday January 20, 2022 @02:53PM (#30013833)
Some of the protestors are/were openly anarchists, and eliminating police is central to what they want. There are certainly more than 3 anarchists around.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by dfxm12 on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:12PM (#30014067)
I should think that the number of people who want to completely do away with the police is vanishingly small. Actually, it's probably about 3 people.

Importantly, and I do think this is worth pointing out, those people have zero political power & zero input on any budgets, legislation, etc. Situations like those described in the article are actually happening.

It seems like the right in the USA are being deliberately pedantic about the phrase "defund the police", to make it sound like those on the left are crazy.

Conservatives have been gaslighting the electorate for as long as I've been a voter. This is no different.

Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac... by ryguytilidie on Thursday January 20, 2022 @02:25PM (#30013487)
So you're dismissing the defund the police movement based on the phrasing and not knowing anything about it? What would be so harmful with learning about the thing you're speaking about with authority before doing so...?