Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac...
by snomad on Thursday January 20, 2022 @02:36PM
(#30013628)
Its a Motte and Bailey https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motte-and-bailey_castle
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac...
by gknoy on Thursday January 20, 2022 @02:46PM
(#30013760)
I think you mean https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motte-and-bailey_fallacy :
An arguer conflates two positions that share similarities,
one modest and easy to defend.. and one much more controversial....
The arguer advances the controversial position, but when challenged,
they insist that they are only advancing the more modest position.
Thank you for pointing out this argument fallacy. I've certainly seen it and been unable to articulate what is going on and why it feels like an argument in bad faith, and now I have a name for it.
Re:Police in tiny Alabama town suck drivers into legal ‘blac...
by helen___keller on Thursday January 20, 2022 @02:43PM
(#30013721)
Not exactly. Motte and Bailey is a fallacy as an argument, but memes are not arguments. You can think of it as a distributed version of Motte and Bailey: someone out there surely is trying to actually abolish policing, but if you fish the internet for arguments in favor you only get people looking to reform
The answer, like to most of these kinds of issues, is to avoid arguing against internet memes. Have a debate with a singular person on an agreed upon position, or don’t debate at all.
The meme lives in the gray space of non-specifism, where every person for or against imposes their preferred meaning
If you go to a somewhat authoritative source such as https://blacklivesmatter.com/defundthepolice/ then you get
> We call for a national defunding of police. We demand investment in our communities and the resources to ensure Black people not only survive, but thrive.
But what does it mean to have “resources to … survive [and] thrive”? I would argue it implies a rethinking and rebuilding of policing based on the needs of the community, like GP claims. Another leftist might think it’s the anarchical approach. It’s vague, more or less intentionally