[1] http://www.linusakesson.net/scene/a-mind-is-born/nft.php [2] https://opensea.io/assets/0xa7702e0769c5d408ebf2b056d7c3cc0a...
But the reason why this is such a great example for me is because the token actually contains something substantial. This song is now permanently a part of the blockchain, as opposed to just some link to an image host that might not exist in a decade.
Now of course, if there's a contract that says "whoever owns this baseball card owns this baseball player" then you get an ownership, but that's unlikely. Same with NFT, unless there's recognition and contract in place that designates ownership of actual work, you won't own the work itself.
It's an overly simple example of course, but now carry that out to trade secrets, future stock prices, gambling picks, private videos etc. The "art" on the outside isn't really relevant. It's just an indication of what it is you're owning. It might be just that art, or it might be something else depending on the contract. You're seeing the box, not what is in the box. You have to own it to get the contents of the box.
The use of NFTs for tracking subscriptions, memberships, or other credentials is an interesting idea in its own right, but let's not confuse the issue by claiming that these external services keyed to NFT ownership are somehow "inside" the NFT. They're a hybrid of centralized services with decentralized access control. Everything "inside" an NFT is a matter of public record on some blockchain; the nature of the system precludes storing any hidden information. Ownership of an NFT can serve as credentials for accessing information on some other server, but then you're forever dependent on whoever runs that server.
Of course if you're dependent on a particular centralized server for the content anyway then that server could just keep track of the ownership itself and avoid the overhead of a blockchain, but there could be cases where multiple services want to share the same access control in a decentralized, market-oriented way.
I have no idea if any NFT is encoded this way though.
Sure, but that just moves the problem around; instead of secret data you have a secret private key to manage. The cyphertext can be stored anywhere—on the blockchain, in IPFS—but the private key to decrypt it remains separate from the NFT: If you put it in the NFT then everyone would have it.
> Selling such piece of data would mean decrypting it with old owner's private key and re-encrypting it with new owner's public key.
Any protocol such as this would require out-of-band communication and carry counterparty risk. What happens if someone sells the NFT but refuses to hand over the data, or claims not to have it? The smart contract can't deal with this as that would require making the key public. I'm not seeing any way that an NFT improves the process over simply paying someone to give you a copy of the secret.
> NFTs can be resold on-chain, whereas unlockable content are items that live off-chain, and therefore cannot carry on to future owners on the blockchain.
That pretty much says all you need to know about "unlockable content". Simply put, if you buy the NFT through their platform they'll give you something extra. This bonus content isn't actually part of the NFT at all and is indistinguishable from any paid digital download, apart from being bundled with the purchase of an NFT.
This is just as multiple baseball cards pointing to the single baseball player.
Thing is, what’s “non-fungible” here is (arguably) the token itself, not the thing it points to.
> For more information on NFTs and the terminology used in this article, the OpenSea NFT Bible is the current de-facto document for NFT knowledge
The reality is that NFTs are vehicles for money laundering and gambling. They really have nothing to do with the art.
Like buying the rights of an old album; an album for which the original is lost. I might receive some piece of paper that says the songs are now mine. Of course, there are already thousands of copies of the songs, but (somehow) now the songs are mine, and I can certify it.
> but at the end of the day, they are digital tokens
I can simplify everything up to the point of saying that the 10 bucks bill you have in your pockets is just a piece of paper, but we all know it's more complicated than that.
Would be really interesting to actually see that challenged in a court.
But if the problem is legal (and not technological) then it may be just a matter of time, given enough adoption. Much like Bitcoins (now running as an official currency of El Salvador).
Perhaps it's a matter of establishing we run on this or that blockchain to make NFTs completely traceable?
I simply do not agree with this characterization. At a minimum, the vast majority of NFT transactions do not allow people to buy and sell ownership of digital art. They allow people to buy and sell ownership of the NFT itself. Unless you consider the token itself art, this is a very different proposition.
People come up with all sorts of complicated metaphors for what NFTs are, but at the end of the day, they are digital tokens. That's it. An NFT is not the digital art that it may be notionally connected to.